Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-05-782/1 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2005:3.05.782.1078 AI generated

3-05-782/1 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-05-782/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                    

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-05-782/1 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:                     

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                    

                 !"#$ %& !''(    )*+,-.!''(  

   & /%  0  * 1 2 +-#'"#!''( -+3 * $4%5$4 &46 # *       ++#$ %& !''(        &4 4 % 4$7  %/ $4 2 4%%   ! "  7 8!-2+6-/8)+2942(/8:) 2+0  7%  &1 2  +-#'"#!''(-+#  7%  1$% #         $5& 6  & 

2 )'6 $ 4$   $ 2 % !"# $ %&!''(# 6  &  %  &  4 +'6 $4$    $ 2 % #  # $ 

  !:#',#!''($ %$$  2     $2  +!#)'6%1% ;+9<# !:#',#!''(  26     6% 6 52 % !:#',#!''(#  6  ':#'"#!''( ;:/+'<# '+#'"#!''(   2   /% %6   !:#',#!''(%;++*+!<# '!#'"#!''($5  =  !,#'9#!''(%1% ;+(*+-<# ')#'"#!''(   %!:#',#!''(%1% $  ;+)<# +-#'"#!''(6%   62%6 $ 6$ = ;-*"< +-#'"#!''( 2 426 $ = 6% 2;(<# 4   52 %   / !:#',#!''(4$ % +!#)(+)#''  6 $  %5   >%/ 

$26 4$ %$$$&  >    &  /  $5%/ % %&6 $ $ #7 %$2%  6 /4 6  6  411  & 1% #   "  ! ! $   &4$   $2??4    1  /  &44   %# &426 &4%  61 %  %% $$%2%  2$5& 6 /% 2 %6  % 5 2/ %4% 2# &4 /    2  %5    64% # &4 &/   %% 6&  4112 5  6  % 52 2 $$ &1# &42       %%$64% 4 2  %% 6%   &$%   # 

4  & # 424& $2??4    1  /  &4    #

4 2  6 $ &$    >/% $2$  #6 $ %      &  /  % 46 &$2%  $ %/   >&4  > %% % 6 $ &5 6  /% $4$5%&/% $5%& %$4#  >4%&  / 6 $1  /$2%    & 2 56 &  >  %%#% 2&$2%   4/ 6    6$ %/6 $   6  4%# 4 /  &4 $&  > &  / $2%   $5%/   6 $ &2$%$  5%   $2 %    # 4$  4$2% 1%

   &4 2 2  4% /% 6  %  5 # 4$       5 $    %%6%   % 4 11 % 6 2 5    # &4$5   26%    6$% 4    &4  5  % #     %&#"$$   &4+-#':#!''(   1+-#'"#!''($$5  #  58-2!6+28:2+  44# $    &&$#   $$4 6 &4% 52 % /%     / !:#'+#!''(   +!#)(*+)#''  >%/  6 $ 6 =4$ %$$ = 6 $ $&  >&  /  $5%/  % %&6 $$ #   /   $2% $ 2 46 =6  211 6   & 1% #  2$>  &46% 652 %  $2  8-,2+4 26* -#+#+#/-#+#(46*  +!#+4+!#)42#

2 8-,2+ &/ 42  2% $26 $ %$2  44%$2%        #  26* -#+#+#/-#+#( 6 &6 $% $2 / 2/%$2%  4@ 4       4% $2 4$2  $%  2 $52 / %$$2 4 2/$21$   22  6 $  2# 6* +!#+4+!#) 6 $6 $4$2??4 26 $  % 6%1 %4 5 6% / % &$ 52 $/26$4$ $# %  %&A  B$%#6 $6 $$$ %%%     # 

2 8!"2! &/ 4$ 4  >% %& 6 $#  26 &$2%   %$5%/  >%  %&6 $$ #  62$2)  4$  4  >%  6%  % 2 / %$ 4  %  2/ %42# 7 6 $  >5 42%% 2%/$2%  $5&  >%42/% 26 $5 # 2

  %6 & %$5%52 %$55 /  &6$/ 6 $$5&6% 52 % # 25   $ 2%   >5 $5%     >& %$ 42#  >  2&/  >& 2 $ %/%$2# 4    5  /%11%& $4$ 44 1    / & %$4%  $5%$/  > % %&6 $#  4 1  >% % /  >% 24 >;-)/-9</  654  $4   44 1   /  2$ $2%  26 $  >%   &  >& %$ 42 #     / 4 1     $4  >&$#   $ 6$4 2  $2%   /% %22$&  >& 2$2  8!"2! % % #   &4 $/ $2%  &45 6 2  $ %5 # &4$   /% $2%  1 #   &4    / $2% .6    >5 &$/ 4/$2$$ &45 /6  &4%$2%  5 4  6# 4 $4 1 4 &4'+#'"#!''( 2    4 4 4;++*+!</%   $$ %  % # =     %5 2   &4 / $&/    &#%  %2& &4/ $ 5 %$ AC#4%??%5 %/$% 6#C 4   #% 45 6 2$% #B   6$41%& 1 &4$   /  /%%  %5.1#    4  = 4#=1 /%    &4   >6 5$ 4$&&# 7 &4 /% 4%  %2 /   &46$ %611%$6  %  ;  1 < 2$2%  $ $%% 654 #   $ 4425  &4 /  &4    >22  >& $2%  $/& $&%    &4  2 #

6#=6  4% 5 #=4 2 1 246%   25  2;:/+'/+9<#  245  &46$2%   %4%  4$2% 6  4% #      /4 1    &4     >5 #   $4%/ 25    25  % 5&% /% 5 5 6 $%&  #

    6$4/424 5  4 4 4 = 11%& 1 &4$   /  $2%   2 $  %2 &46  >% 5  6 % 4.$5 % 2$2  8!"2)  $ 52 6% #   &4$  6%   &$% $2  2  5 #  &42$2  8-92!/%   >%  6 $ 6% /%  11 # 6 $52 2#  $2 8-)2+$5&  $  /$2   4 $5% 52 5  11 %   6 $ 6#

2  8-9 &6%   &$%  #   2+ $&6%   &26% 4  2&$4$2 $5 %6  $$2% # 7 4/%1%  4 4 $4 26%   2/&6 $  6% % 6 %  66%    % %# 25   !:#',#!''(%1%  $2%      4 4 $4 2%  26%  '+#'"#!''(;)'<#   $   &4$   /  &4   66%  %  6   % 566!:#',#!''(# 

2  8-92) 6 6%   #  4&6%   &$$2% # $%4   $%   $2  4 #

2  48:, &6 $#6 $ 11 6% / 6%   6#   $62$2! %2 642% % 0 64 *46  %4$5  6%  16 $3$ 6 $$5     36%  243 6% 4 4$ 52  /%3  6  6 34 % 36%  236 $2% %4% % # 4&   $2% #  46%   6$&6    5   ;-*"<#  $2  48:" 6%   6  4    36% $%    3 6 $  44% 635 6 $  $ 6 35   62% #

 46%   6 5 % 4#25    &4   62/ 45 # +-#'"#!''(6%   6$ = ;)!<# &4 6 4% /%   &4 5 

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

2  8++2+ &/   $  4     %     %      / $    $   #  8-'2! $ $21  /  2*422  # $2 %$524$#8-+2+  &    $ 2 % $5 % %  /      % %%#25     2 +)#'(#!''(+*9.((- &4  $  ;9+/:+<# 62$2!  &   % / $4566 % /252 56   % $5 % /    #   $  2 +)#'(#!''(+*9.((-  $$ $$5% 4 $2 24     4$% #   25  2%4$   2  $4 $4 /  5 %  &4$   /  6%$ #

   $$$ 52   $/6$44 / 2 & 44 $    $ &4  $#   &4   1$ %6#  8:!2+&6/  4 #  2 & &4 1$% 5 4%#