Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-05-572/1 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2005:3.05.572.1623 AI generated

3-05-572/1 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-05-572/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-05-572/1 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:     "  !2! !" " /%3 " ' !" '  %!&' "  "' " ! !   !"  " & "  !&!&! !2'!     !"    " /% " '!  '    3 !  "   "! %!&' " ! "&!3"' ""  !" !'  !" "    '    '" !"  &!  &!! 3"' !" ' " '%& ! /  "   ("!"&! /"3 "   #)  4 ""   " !" /% " '! ! "/"!3 " ("! ) '%&  "!" ' !!""  ""   " &!!!% (4"' "' !"3"  5# "!"&!/"3"  #$) ,!!  "     -$&3!""' "'%! !" "   '% "" !" , &  !" 3!!"""' !" "  !  '%  " !  "   "! %!&' "  "!" ! %&  !&     " !" "' "   ! "!"" ""        '      "'% %"" !"!" !"!("!"&! /"3"  #$)  "! !"' !"" !""!"/ " "3! "  " '!!"  !" "  3 " %!&' "  "' " ! !       ! &!   !"!   "!"""!"   !/    '%! !(' "' !"3"  5#) 1""' ""  & %" !&   ! 3 "   %!&' "  " "!!&  '    '!" "" !  '"   " ""    "  /% "'!/!"%""  "' " !" ""! ' !"%!&/  " ! " 3"' "  &!

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                             

                 ! "!

  # $ $

   #%!& ' " "!" !%           

       ( '   )!&* !!!    ! "!

  "!(' ""  )!     

   + ""     " (,-.&/.)   0"/ '%!!"   / "!  ! *!& "  "    / '   " ' !" " " ' "&! &' " / ' " ' "  0" ' !" " " ' "&! / '    

 1/ "!  !" !" "  ""  "! !"" "  2/ ' " ' !" " " ' "&! &' "/ ' " ' " 1/ "! '%!!"  2" " !"  !!   " !  '   !"   ! " " !" ! " "    !" "  / "!     ! "#! $%"&'  # $ $

 '%"      ! "! 

   ( /!!   ' ""  3   '%!   ) ' "      # (' !" "   ")3 !& " "! '   ""   !/ ' $( 2!" "    2 )!" '%& ("  $)  

  1'   !"    #/ ' !(4"' !"/$  3"  .)    . $

" '!"   ' !!"  "/"" 

 /"!" ! " "  (4"' !"/$  3"  5)      $

"& .$" & " "!' ! '   3"/ ! 

 "" "  %'   " (4"' !"/$  3"  5)       ! "    . . 

 ' !"  # ! 3 " ' ! !" !" "  !" ! # $ $

   # ! '%! !(' !"3/$ ) 6" ! !' !   "  %" ("   )   . 5 

 !"  '        ! "! 

   # $ $

    #/  " ("  )  

 "  



&  "!  !&" 3"" /"  %"("   ) 6" !&!" "!3"   ! "!' !"     #  !!" !""! & !  !" !" " & ' !"/ ' "  . !" 

 &   "' """!"! '   " / '%!  !"  " "  !" !" "("  )  

  " . # 

 

&  "!   "!  !&" 3 " " "   !" !"!" ""   " ! !!&!%!'("  $$3$#)   . # 

!"  '   !!&!%!'" !""% '     ! ("   )   "2!" !%"  "!%!&' " "!" !%/ 2("  $.)  

  " #  

 

&  "!   '"  !&"    !"! " /   3"' !" '  '% "  "  "! !"' " '    "! "2!" !  6" ! &!" "!3 " %!&' "  ! "&! ! /&! !   ' "! %!&! " & &! &  !& &  " %  ! 

!" ! /% "'!("    )     

' "  '     !&"  "!

("   $)  

 "5  



& '%"! " 6" !&!" "!3"!    ! ! "%& " " /"3 " !"    ' ""   " " " &  ' " ' !!&!"" /"("   5 )     

 !"  '    " '        '     2'!" ! % ("   .5)    "   

 

&    "!    "    !!'  "  " 3 ! /"  '    /" !" " 2'!" !%"("  5$5 )     ('!  "  1'    /%!"77  / "! "  ,"!   '%&  "!   ! /" "!     "%& !"  ,"!    -  &  /!   "  "  "!   822!!" !!" ""'%"  ""'%""   ""

  "   - $ " 3 !"  "" "    " ""'%"& "  ' ! !"3!!'%! !  " 1" "   %!  "!& 2%!&/77  %!&" '  "!!  " 9& 2'%! "   !' " !% !"   /"'  3 %!& "!'%!"!!& %! ' " "!" !" ,"!   -& /  &!  3  ""'%" & ""     '" " %! "  



  " "  "  "!    ,  ! &! !"  3  ""'%" ""  %! "    '" "   

   ,    "!    -  &  /  /%! &  ' "   '    %   /%! ' " "!" !" ,!!'%! !"!   "   1'   " "   ! "!

 # $ $

    # %!&' "  "!" !"    %!& "! '%! "!!& %!&' "  "!" !'%!!"   " ("  $.)  %  !'  !  !3 ! " "  ' ("   .)       ' !" "   "! %!&' "  ! "&!  &!  !   '" !3' !" ' " '%& !/ "  6'%! !3"   "!" ! ""("!"&!/"3"  #)   

 ! '     ! "!

  "! '    "# $ $

     #%!&' " "!" !%!"!"       ! "! 

   # $ $

  &     # ! /!! "  '   %!&!3' !!" " % ""' """" !" " 

"!&  :!" "   ! /   "  /  2"&! 2!!&"  ' " ""3 !    &  !   "" "   '    "!    (- # &  / )  "" " 822!!" !!" ""'%"  "!   " ! " ( ' !!"  " ) " " " "/ '    " "  (!!!")  , "!  ""       -   &   "  ""    '"  " "/ ' "  "   " !"!  ,&  "'  %! "   ""3 !  '  "    ""  '      !  &!" "3 !!! %!&!      ! "! 

   # $ $

  &     # !" '%! !!! '  ! /!! "  ' " !  %!&' "  ! "    ' !" "   "! "2!" !"  ,&   " '    "3 " "" " '   "    " !"! ""  !   " "!3 !! "!'      &!" " %" "  "   "%!&/  '%!%!&' "  , "!! /% "'!  "3"/  "  "!%!&' " "!" !"" &    "! !"""!"  ,!""" & !!    " !3 " '    '! /!& ' !"    " "!!"3 !""   "! :!" " // & "&!"  

 !& 3' !

 $  '% !%!& 3 ! "   ""3!  '%&"!     ! "!

  "!! 3" '   !%!" ! '  !/% "'! "%""!'    22!  '   !!!' !"!  

4 ""  /  ""     " !&" !"       )*!%##   ' ' !!/  ' 3" '   !!" !"""2!" ! "3 ' !  "!%!&' " ! "&!%3! " " " &    ""  "! -  &   "" 3 "   "! '%! "!!& %!&' " "' " !%/""  !/% "'!' " '    ! "&!  !" ""  '    &!" "    !&"  "! 

("    )    "!%!/  "  """ " ' !!!3!!"   &  3 " &  /  !"!&! "       "! %!&' "  "!" !  ' &  !&!

 '% '/!"!!/!  " - 3 "" "3 "   "! "" "!" !" !   %  2 /%3 "   "! ! !"!"%!'%!"  "!' " '!%"3!!" "!! !'%!%"    "" !"   ' " !%/   /! " '!!" /"  !"!!'3!" "' "'!" %!&' " ! "&!"3! & " "  '"   !!" "! " '/% "'! !/% "'!!!3 !!   "! '%! "!!& %!&/   2!" 2 ! "!"  !&  

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



"' " !% (  !" !  "  " " &) "2!" !%"&  (/ '  " " &)!!" !    &!      

    "  /% " '! /! "%""3 !! !   ! "    '   /""%" " ""!   -&/! /%! /  2!"  " /" "" " '  " !"!     ! "   "" /%! /  " !"  3 !       ! "" '  " "&  ! &  '    / /% " '! "' " !    !  "  !  '" &  &!!! &!!!"3!!!!" "2! !       

"!