Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-05-532/2 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2005:3.05.532.814 AI generated

3-05-532/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-05-532/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                                               ! "#$  %& "'&"  "" (   "  ) '*&' &"+"          ,         $  %& "'&"  '&"" "& "&" 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-05-532/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:                                                ! "#$  %& "'&"  "" (   "  ) '*&' &"+"          ,         $  %& "'&"  '&"" "& "&" 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                                               ! "#$  %& "'&"  "" (   "  ) '*&' &"+"          ,         $  %& "'&"  '&"" "& "&" 

    -''  "#   ' .$/0(12(!   3'"2" "+&#"&'   2" '& "#"% & 4&1 '"  '    2"   '"  &' '" '  '"1"&"" 1" ' 2" '  '"  3'"  &' '" '  '"1"&" 2"      2" '& "#" "&' &"' '"#  ''  '"& &''" '  *"2"  '"  &' '" '  '"1"&"" 1" '2" '  '" 2" '& "#"+&#"&'  *"'" '" "&'  &&  %" "' "& "   "&'   & '" '" "&' &" ''   "&' ' " 2" '& "#    ! "#! $%"&'  ,    & $   %& "'& "  "  "   (5 &"1  ' '&   ' '   (   ,) &  '" '&     & '"&'"&!&' +1 '  ! . "'' ''&1& "" &"  5"' ' ""&'&'  "" "0 +&" '"' ''' '  '" "' &" 

       "&'     ""&"' '  "   ( 2" " $   %& "'&" &"'   !   $  %& "'&    &"'""&'&5"'    +1'&    &" 2"&& ( ,,, &   '&  ''"& " /""1 '&' '& &' ' "'"'&1 """'"'&*" "   + ' &"'  '   !    (   & $   %& "'& "  "  +  ' &"  "  ) &' '  '!5&"1 ' '&   ''   , ) &  '" '&    ) &  '" &'"&! & '  +1 '  ()!    (  "&' $  %& "'&" "" (   "   )2" " "#" '"'  !  

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

  '&  '!   ' " '"&#  +1 '&   '&"  &&'" "'" "" ' " "' '"1""'   $ ' '" "1&'& "'" " 2&&   '"&  '"" ' '&    &&'" "'"'  '  '&"'&"' +1"'&     1" '8     '  '&    &&'"  "'" '  '  '&" '+'' '&   +15 &&"' &"'' "1&     '   &&'"'&  " 9    '  '&    &&'"  "'" '  '  '&" '+'' '&   +15 &&"' &"'' "1&     '   &&'"'&  " 9    '  '&    &&'"  "'" '  '  '&" '+'' '&   +15 &&"' &"'' "1&     '   &&'"'&  "    %"" ''&  " "0,1(2'&1  "" "01'    &' '  :"+"'" " '" " 5    ' ""' '  ' +  "&""""'&    &&'" "'" '  '  '&"1   2"  ""   ' &" 2" 5 &    "& "   " '" '"& '      2' &&"&"1  )    "&' ' "  '&&     '' "& " 5"'" "''"1"'"''"+'  "&'&5&'+''2#  & +&1&   '" '" &&"   ' &" +& &1""&&" &1 ""' '"" ' + &"+&"2" " ' &"'' "1   7 &' '  '#'&   ""' ' '&'"&' &"2"&&     &     '*&' &""'&  " "0,1(2&    "" "01 "    '" )  "'&   "" "01 "'6&&"'&&' "''"+' 5    &"1&'&"  ' 6&&"' &&' "''"+'  +&1 $   %& "'& 2&&&"  """   '"1"" 2" ' &"' "''" '" '  5 &"  "  "&5& "''"+'2" ' ' "   $ "&&'     & 1 '   !5"'  &"1&'& "'" '" &'  ,  ""'5"'' "&'"1"""''"+'"1 .&1&& '"&"15  '" ' 5 "' "& '"1"" "''"+'"1  &1&  "& +& "&   '" *" "''"+'"1  '"1""   ' 5&"' '6 '&&&&'"'   &'" &' &" "''"+'"1  &''"'"1""&"' /"" """   "'&'&  " " "'& '&  1   ' &" # "'& " "  '"1"5 &''" "''"+'   "1&'""&&"      '" '    &" "''"+'"1  &''"'"1""&"'  ""1  "& "'   '  ' &2"&&   &    ' &""& '6&&"' &&'"''"+'  /""'+"&+&#1"    5"'  "&" '  ""2 &"' ' 2"&&   " +"'" '  '" "' "1  +'  &&& *"''" &'  '"& + '     "&+'$  %& "'&"& 1 5"' ""'"" "0 1 " # 2&&&   '& '& '&& 2+ &""  7 '2&&5     ' '



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

 ! '  $  %& "'&"$  '&"" 2&&; "! "#'"& '&'   $ ""&+'   "& 1  &&'"1   "" "0,1"5 "' '&'&" &"+&"    '  ""&"' ' " " 0  1 5 &"  "'  +  '&'&" "1&'' "1  "&'" ' '  "1&'' "1 1 # ''" '&'&" ''2"   #&" ' " 1"  '     &'5 ""1    +  "1&'' "1  '"   '"&'" ' '   '"&+"'&'&"'' "1'"' '  "" "015&"  "'  &'"&+" '&'&" "1&'' "1 * ' 5  '" "" "&' &" ' " 1"  '    &' .   ) '&  (  5""1  &'"&+"'&'&" "1&'' "1 1 #  '"  ( &1"' "+22"   )   .""     &&'"  "'" &&&' '"' ' " "1  &1 2+ "5 "'  ' " "& "&'  +&1" "1"'  "  '&" ,,,  &  "  '&&)   !5"& ""+& ' " &""



 & &  '  &1""1 "&2+ ' " &"" '"  "'  '" '"& '    $ """ "& '"" '&  " " *"'& ''"' ''  '   &  '" '"&  $ " +'#  "#" "&'  "& 1 5 "' <2" "   '&  '"1"&' ' &""    '"1 = &1 ""2 '   "  '  ' ""    '  &&"   '&  +  ' &"  -" &""        ""' *#" "' &1 " &""   #&"  & 5& ' " " ""& '   '"  '&&""&' &')   !"&" "  '    "  '" "' 2+ "5 "'  "#" "&'   "&'  "  '&&  /""1  "&  2+ '  & *#" "'      ' " 2& " &""  5  ' ""'5& " &"") &5 & 2+ "5 "'  ' " "&'  "  '&& &&"&"1 5 "&    "  '     " " " 0  1  "&""  '"&"  "  ' '" "'&1""'+''#  &""  "" "0'"&"+&""   "5&" "'  &+&1 '   '" " 2 '"  '&& "&' &" ''2"  "&' ' "  '&& " ' '    ' 5 &    ' ' ""  '&&"&' ' ""'"2+  /""'""#  '5"'  ""& '&' " "''"" ' 2"'''5&" '+'"  ' "'&&1'"'5&  ' ""&"+&1" "1"''&'   $ "  "& 5 "'  '"    &'   "'& '&  " " + '&' #4&&1&' "&)''+1""5"'6&&"'&&' "''"+'   ''"&# *""''"+'' &"+&" " '"1""     /'&  " "0,1 '"' #6&&"'&&'"''"+' "+& ""   '&    &&'"  "'"  &" ' '" ' '&1&'" "   '&'&"  &'" 2" # "  '"1"&' "''"+'" 2" ' &"1  +& '&" +&  &" "''"+'"1 5 &" 1  +222"  $   %& "'& 2&&&"  """6&&"'&&'"''"+' 2''" ' ' %"&"'"''"'" ' &" 5&"'"' #  ""    . "#" "&'   "1&'""&'  ( ,,,  &"1&'& 6&&"' &&' "''"+'  "&' '  " " %" 2#  &""'&  " "01 2  1 (5 &"  "' 6&&"' &&' "''"+'    # '&   22'& "' 6&&"'&&'"''"+'  "1&'""&'" 1 4"1&'& "'""&& 1"'5 "' 6&&"' &&' "''"+'  '"1" "  &" +& '&"  . "#"  "'  6&&"' &&' "''"+'  "1&'""&&" 2+ "  " " ' &"5 &''" 1   '"1""  "''"+'"1  .&     "&   " '" &  "#" "&'  6&&"'&&'"''"+'  "1&'""&&"'"1"&"'2+ '"'   $ "" "1&'&'" & # 1"5 "'  "#" "&'    ,   '" &'  &"'   &' "''"+'"1  &''"'"1""&"'5 &&' &6 '&&   "    & 1 '   !&&' 5&"''"+'"+2"' &""" #   & '&&1& 2" " &" '" &' &"  /"&'" '&&1'"  &"1&'&' "1&'& "'' &"5'"  '&&"&' &" " /   '' "& 5 "'  """ &"' '"1"" +2"' &" '  &6 '&& &" "& " '"'5"'  "" "01 "  ' "&"' ''  " "

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

 , $& 2'# &"'"" " '   '& '&""&&"  &'"& "' &" "'& 1 5&&"'&   '&*& '"&"'  "&& '  "" &  " " &'"& "'""  " ""!    '&  '&""&' 2&&  '  ' '  ""'" " " 0'  "&     +    '& "'"' '&' &'*"2+ "5"'  '& &"&'&""'+"&+&"'  ' "&  '  &+"'""5 & ""&"' ' &&" "& +& + '     '' &'  .+''"'"#  "& "5"' &' '  '+&12 "   .'"*& .$/0,1'"' #5"'2""5"" ' "'"'&5+&'"' " '"  2' '' ' ' +&'&"""&5"' '' "& ""&'' ''"&'      .'&