Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-05-317/2 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2005:3.05.317.745 AI generated

3-05-317/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-05-317/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                           

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-05-317/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:                            

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                           

               ! " #$% !  &' ( #(

# )#'     ' ($*! ( ! & ((& #  

 #(( ##((#!(#+ ,,(*(  #-#         , . 

       /(# # !      #' % ! &' ( #( (( ! "#  ! & '( # ')#0  

   

((  #$   ( %&01,'+2,"   3(#2# # -$#(   2# ( #$#4  )' (#  (    2 #  ! (# ( (# ( (#'### ! '# ( 2 # (  (#  3(# ( (# ( (#'## 2 #     

 2# ( #$# #( #( (#$ ! ((  (#! ((# (  *#2 # !(# ( (# ( (#'###! '# (2 # (  (#    ! "#! $%"&'   . +55

  $   & / #( 6 $ ' 0 (  ! ( (   # #(# 6  #' $#( ( #'-22#+  +55

6( ( (  ( #! (  /(  ,"    2  ! #((**#(#2## /# 2# ( 6( #$##! (  /(  +" 

     

(#'% ! &' ( #(

# )#'     ' ($*! ( ! ##(( ##((#!(#+ ,, ( (   (/(  ," ## (( (  ! (#  ( 

(#2((  ."   5  

 #(   !   #$#  (# ###( ( #((#!(#  + ,,(*( #-# 7( #(   !  #$## '#-' (#( (# ( (#((#!(#( (#2# ( #(  +"  

 (+  



#' 2# ( (# '#-' (#  ( (  #((#!(#  + ,, ( (# (   +." !  + , 

 

#'  -#(  #$##(#(  "     ('!  "  % #$# #( !   $ #(#  . +55

 #( 6 $ '   #( #'   , +55

  + +55

" # $#'   2 #   2   !  $ #( ##(  '  !# ( ( (   (/     # *## !  #((/# #2# (     !   #(  %  !  &' ( #(# #   ( (/  # $ ## (   #((  # #((#!(#'  # #  !  -  -(  ((#!( ( (  / #( # (( - !  !   #(  ( / #( #( #    !  -' $  (   &' ($* #(## #( ( !  # #( #  (  2  # 

 (#(/#(   6##   0  ##  ! #( ( #(##( /#(( #6##     ! ' #'#'( /#((  2$ -   #  6## # 0 (( /#(## (## #$  6##     %  #   '# 48#(8##  -! /   ( 2#( &  6 #   (-#/(# !#-(##-# # (   % #$##( ! #(#(#'### (#'# #' !   2# (( (/ # 2 #  (#  9# !  2 ! (# !  # # #((#!(# ( #  ## -#(   !  $ (    !2 ' -'(! #(   (  ( (# 0###(#( (/# ' #2#!     '  2* (      ( ( ##(( # $  ! / #( %  !  &' ( #(#(( ##((#!(### ! (#(*(    

 ! '     $  '  6## ( #(# %  22(    , +55

 6   #(  ! '   , +55

 :  + +55

 !  $ ! '   2 #  6 ( (   ('(##2  #((!# ( . +55

  ! -# (  ##(-((  (/#(6## (# #  

    #((  ( ( $ #( #  (  6##  ;<# (  

2  !  ( .  +55

 48 88 6 $ '" #  #( 2*#(# (#2# +  +55

 !#( 9  22(    % ! &' ( #(2( $ 

(###(# ' (  ! / #(# (#'#(6## #/# #  -(( (-## /#(6##  2  # #(6 $ '9  ! 6##;<# (= '22(2*#((#2 (-# /#(  !  +  +55

6## #   #(# #  ( ' 2<<# (  2# #  ( +  +55

 2*#((# #$  # #'(##( # #   #( #   ### ( #$ #  2*#(( $#6-*  (#,  +55

/ (  ( /#( +  +55

#(# $( #$ # (   % #$# #( !  # -( ( # (#( #((#!(#' /  # ( !  *(#' -'/ #'  (    ((#-(( -'( 2-!# $ #'  -'/ # ( % ! &' ( #(##   % #$#  #/ #(  !  # # 6##  ;<# (  /   (  2$ #( ( ' #(  #(  6 #  #/ #( #( #$ # ( $ 

  # (  2  6##  ;<# (   #( #  (  2 ( %2 (  /#( # '(6##   ! 2$* #( ('#( 2 /  ###( (*(#'#(/( (#  6##   #( $( - ##  -((  0  (#$   / #( ##( #-22##' # (  (   % #$##( ! ###( ''#(-## ##( /#((# # -(#  -  ! '#' 6## :48#(8##-  ' +55

/  $ #2# (#6## / #((# #! (# #   )   ##-'#2--(#(# #(' '-'((     (# ###/ ## #  $# !  '( !  (# *#  -#  #  

  ##2--'(!

 #(#  #(#    ( # 2  ## #   / #( #((#!(# (*( #'  #  #  ! ##  (' $#    ( (##((2 $ (( ! ! ((  #$#   (    )*!%##  6   (## #1+'+ #(2# $#    ##(# $#!  #( $##   0  # #! 2  '   #(   ##( $# #  # # $ /  / 2   *(##     '2 #  (#2( (( ' -  / #2'((## -'#( $ / -' $ ' ( (6 $ '6 (#2((#(  -#($#(#( '# #(/( #( -  (((## -' -(  



6 ! -(#! #-### #1'+ (#( $/#( #  #( # -   #' $    #( # ! /#(  ' #((# ( $ #'-22#!  #$##( ! ## ' $## #  (/(#'% ! &' ( #(

#  )#'     ' ($* ! ( !  ( # #((#!(# #( 6 $ '(  #!# (+  

% ##   ! ## (##/#( #$# #( !  # # #( $# #  (/   !  # # #(  ##(#! ( 2# $6## # ((   0##' (#$( /   !  #$###( (#   # ( (   ((*( #   6 ! -(# !  #-## # # 1 . ' +  (#( ( #/ #( $ #( 

  ##(# ##((#!(#(( # ((#!(#( ( ( ! (#   -  ( (#  0    ###( ( 2  '   -#  ( 2( (/ #(

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

##  ( !   !  !$  ( (# # $  #(/  (('#(  (( ! # !   ! #(/#( ($/#(++ . 

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

   #((#!(#( ((-! 2-!#   '## &-! 2-!# #  * $ #( (###(##/(#(##!(# -$!

  #((#!(# ( (#    (  6 (( !  # !  ( (('/ #( ( (#-($ ! #(! -! 2-!#/( (##2<< (# ((('2(/( "  ' '  ( (  (( (#( 

#'  2# ( (/ ## #($   ##   # !-(# !  ##'    !  - 2 ' $(###((# ( # (    %(#*  %&015'+ (#( $/#(2##/## ( #(#(/-(#( # ! (#  2(  ( (  % ##  ! ( ! -(## # / #( %  !  &' ( #(  (( ! " # # (# * ( # ( (( #(        %(