Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-05-94/2 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2005:3.05.94.712 AI generated

3-05-94/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-05-94/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

  +&'* * # "*&"  " %*  "#, *   (     &*" &&, *   (!  "" &7 *&"# +&'","*  * "" &* #**    "&' $   %  &' *"'  &&* *& 6"    * "" * *" *" &"&&   " 1  &*" ( 8 )   *"* *   !  *#, "* "&* &"&  "&" "" "&"&* * $ + &"* ""3 &&"*&","*((   "&' "& "  *  * &"&   &*""" * * ""' "&"+&*  * " "3&'&   $   %   &*" '&   "# +&'" 6" 3+ ", "* " * 7 & "&*&" "   *""&    "   *   " * *     3&&&" '"&" ""3 " %   &* &#" *"& ,"* &" * &* *" '&*  6"* #*"'"&"" *,& +& &" *  ,*"# * ** &"*&    * , "" "", "* "'&*      #      1  *""+&'"'  " * &"   "# "" " * &"    *&&" &  *& ((  "* 3" #  &  &*&"*   "*&+&' &,"* #3&&&"'"&"""3 "   .'&"&"  * ""* *" *"&"& &&* &"""&"+&'3  "  " * &"""*&&'*"*"'" *  *&","* "7&" "2&'"" " "*"* *&&'&  * "" &" &&'& " * "" &" * &"#, "*  * " "3&'*" +&&" ** &" #   "  3 ""  . *" *"&"& &&* &* # &*" ""  *&   * "" &" 3*"&,&"""&* '  *  *""3&'*"+&&*  

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-05-94/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja: *" *"&"& &&* &* # &*" ""  *&   * "" &" 3*"&,&"""&* '  *  *""3&'*"+&&*  

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                                            ! "#$  %  &' (  ) *"() &"*+&' * "* &* &",$  %   &*"( (  *&&'

&&,&"& #"  ""&* &"+"!+&

' * "*&* &"&'$  %   &*""  *  ""& *"*"'"&"+","*  *   *""+&'"' " * &"""**""""  ** * "' "           (-            *"&&'"./ "&  / 

     "# $   %  &' (  )  *"  ()  &"*! +&' * " *&* &"+"   * $12 '(3 !   .&*  $  %   &*"( (  *&&'&&!"&" *"*"  " "&* &"+" +&' * "$12 '(3!   ." $  %   &*""""& * * * *" *""+&'"' " * &" ""**"""" ** * "' "  $12 '(3!   *"3" "+&#"&*   3" *& "#". & 4&' *"  *    3 "   *"  &* *" *  *"'"&"" '" * 3 " *  *"  *"  &* *" *  *"'"&" 3 "      53" *& "#" "&* &"* *"#   **   *" & &* *" *   6" "    53" *& "#" +&# "&*   6" *" *" "&*  &&  ." "* "& "   "&*   & *" *""&* &"* *  "&* * " 3" *& "# 

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

 *()   

"'  "*& "# &'* ,"** 3*  +"**  - 8!   (( )  "&* #    3"* 3*","&","*+&" * &""*"  #&&&&" & "   &*"""&* *  !  

 *- )  

"' +"*&    "#""*"*  !     ('!  "  (  )    " ,$       ""7 &"&*&"   5    *  " "* *"" * +&'*  "&*  (  )  $   %   &*"" * *" "&*&"'  3&&"    *""+&'"'  " * &"  & "*  "* &  *"   ) "&*    """ " * &* *"* 3*",&""&& * * 3" 3   *6&"*, &   &* " *    * &  *  * +"  "#" "&* "  *  * *+"&*  "  *+*&" *  "&  * *   *""+&'"' " * &" 38! ""**"" * &  """*"+*&" "' 7&""& *   "&* " * &  "* 3*"'  *" #"+",&""$  %   &*  *   - ) , "*  *6&""   (,  ,        $   %  &' (  ) *"' ()" * *  6"

 *6&" **&* *

  +&'* * # "*&"  " %*  "#, *   (     &*" &&, *   (!  "" &7 *&"# +&'","*  * "" &* #**    "&' $   %  &' *"'  &&* *& 6"    * "" * *" *" &"&&   " 1  &*" ( 8 )   *"* *   !  *#, "* "&* &"&  "&" "" "&"&* * $ + &"* ""3 &&"*&","*((   "&' "& "  *  * &"&   &*""" * * ""' "&"+&*  * " "3&'&   $   %   &*" '&   "# +&'" 6" 3+ ", "* " * 7 & "&*&" "   *""&    "   *   " * *     3&&&" '"&" ""3 " %   &* &#" *"& ,"* &" * &* *" '&*  6"* #*"'"&"" *,& +& &" *  ,*"# * ** &"*&    * , "" "", "* "'&*      #      1  *""+&'"'  " * &"   "# "" " * &"    *&&" &  *& ((  "* 3" #  &  &*&"*   "*&+&' &,"* #3&&&"'"&"""3 "   .'&"&"  * ""* *" *"&"& &&* &"""&"+&'3  "  " * &"""*&&'*"*"'" *  *&","* "7&" "2&'"" " "*"* *&&'&  * "" &" &&'& " * "" &" * &"#, "*  * " "3&'*" +&&" ** &" #   "  3 ""  . *" *"&"& &&* &* # &*" ""  *&   * "" &" 3*"&,&"""&* '  *  *""3&'*"+&&*  

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

#  &"** * *,&"  &6"" * &  * "&*   ," * &  "&'&3 * * ""&* ,+" "  ""&* &"+&' * "   $+""&* #    "#"$  %  &'(  ) *"() &"* +&' * " *&* &", $   %   &*" ( (   *&&' &&, &" & # "  " "&* &" +"! +&' * " *&* &" &' $   %   &*"" *  ""& *"*"'"&"+","*  *  *""+&'"'  " * &"""**"""" ** * "' "    

 )

 ! ' #  $  %  &' $  %   &* ** ! "#*"&*&* ""*"*    - )!   5* &"" 6&'*&$       ""7 &     (  )  "" &$  %  &'+*(  )  **"(),&"' &&* *&  # 3+   * ""* *" *"&"&& ""&"& * &""&  & +  ""   ", "* 7& * "& "&*""&  ""'  "&       * *"# "*&  * "&"  *&'*" &* &","*""'  "&&* "#""&* +&'&"' 3&& **"  # &   %&'*"&3*  ""7 &*""& ,&

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

7 &"&*&&6#&*"  " * &"""*&&'*"*"* &"*"'""* % **  "& ,"* "#3+ "  * 3   ""   *    )*!%##  % &""  $ ""     ""&* *"&" *+"* :"&* " *""*    3*   * "&*&" 7 ! " *""+&'"'    " * &" * *" ""*"&"' ,   '   #  3+    * "" * *" *" &"&  &&* &"' , &" +&#    " +  *""+&'"'  " * *     +& &   &' " *"  $+&'"3" *  ** #"  & *    &' *" +&'3  " 6&* &' "" " &"*  * &&&*"* *"" * * &+"*   &* * *&&'* &&!   *""+&'"'  " * &" 3*"&  %&& *&&"* * +"  &'& 

  "*  "&"* *"# "&  &*"       3* "&* * * **" " &" 

   %&'*" &* &"  5   &* $  %  &'3*(  )  *+"**"() " 3&&  &* *  *+&  *!,&"' &&* *& # 3+    * ""* *" *"&"&&*  ((!   $ "#" "&* * &*  *"  *6&"  * "" * *"&"   *   &"&  &&* &""*# ""  6   +&'*"' ,&  *& *+*&"  (  ) !"& 6&'"&*&*7 !""   """*""& ""  *" +&'&&   *&+&'3  "6&*& * "6 "" &" "*" "&'  % &* *   *  *  * *  "7& " " " 3&& ; 14!2* # 3+   * "" &"! "&"* *" " 

3  ' & "   +&"  "* * #  &   &*  #  3+    * ""* *" *"&"& :&"&&3  "    &**&" ." " &"&   &  3 "&'"" '" "*"*    * "  ""     3  ' & &&"  +&"   *"* *, "*   &'  " # &* * &&*"  "#",&&* #&"&  "&* #""  " " % &" * ""3&'*"& +& ""' "&"" &""   &'3 ""  #&&&*&&'& ""* 3& *&&* *&"& "&  ' *&*  +&' * " &6&3+ ","*& "   *  " "'& "& * "  &"&  &&* &" * *"* "3&'*" +&&* $&"3&'

&'&'*"3+ *"+& *  "" "&"   &*,&&+& & *  & *6"*""+&'"' " * &*3*  * *"  " &" "" +  % *   3+ "" *""+&'"'  " * *      *" *  3" &  *  "" ***", & +"* "  *   *""+&'"'  " * &"3*"&   "&"* * 3+ *"     "#   &' *"  &* &" 6&"   &"""& ."&*"+"*" "&" ** &""   &' &    &* "",&    &*& &'**   ""    +*  *6&    * "" &*   ;  *"&" 6&  "& + *    &'(  ) *"+&'3  *   *""+&'"' " * &"* * "&"""* 

1 "7& " "  2  '   *"* #, "* "" 3  ' & " &"* ' * *    *""+&'"'  " * *    , " '  "&*&" *""& &"  &   "  3&&&

 # * "3 ""&'   "+"*"' &  &  &* % # &&'&% &*""*"* *  % # &&'&% &*" "#&( 

"'    -&&* * *""+&'"' " * &" " 3&&;*""+&'"' " * &" +&" * &"!3*&) "**""# &  &* *""+&'"'  " * &"" "   " * &"  *"* *""*&&'&    * &" 3*&8 "* ' # *""+&'"' " * &"""*  " "&* &"' " * *     '"" &"  &*"" % "&3"     3*"&* ** **6"*",& * *&  "*"*  ""&* &"7 *&  &&& &*"&"   *""+&'"'  " * &"   3* (  *"* #, "*  &   &*  * * *"*   +&   *""+&'"'  " * &" ""*&&'     



*""+&'"'  " * &"  " "&* &" 3 " *  *"  " &*   *&&' +3"   * *&6" * &" *&& "&* &"'  &&'&   * *& 3& "  *""+&'"'  " * &" *&& "&* &"'  " * &"   "  "&"* *  &** * "' "&" &  &* '&  

1  *""+&'"'  " * &"    "*  " * *     "  3&&&" & 

 &"6"""*&&'&' *  *   3*&"((3" # &   &* &"*   *""+&'"'  " * *     "  3&&&" & 

 &" "*&+&' &,""+&'*  " * *   3&&&" '"&"""3 "*     *" &"*"& *,"* "&"* &&+& ' &, " 3"  *   3&&&" '"&" ""3 "  &&&" '"&" ""3 "'  &"+*&"   " * *"  +&' (3 "   ""3 "  &"*  *" "&*  & &*  *&""&* * &*" $&""3 "* 3" # * &*"& 3+ " *,* #* "3&&&"'"&"""3 " $& * &*"&"&"+& & "*  ,&7""&#""3 "* ""** *" *& &*, & *"  3+ ", & * &*"&"&"+& & "*   $ ""   &"3"&" " * &"' "" ' '* '" " +*  ""'  *"#    3* "&* * * &+" *""+&'"'  " * &" ""*"

* &"     $&    "&* *, && *&# " &" " * &3*"  ' & &&*& *&&&   * &"   3*& (   *"* *, "* & ""*&&'*" +3"&&&"&&#&# &*  &*"*+* **"3+ *",&&3&""# *  *  *&&'*"*"* &"* * "' "" ' "" #&&#&&"3+ *""'"*7&""&&*   ""*" " " 2 ( ' (   *"* * 3+&+*", &"  "* +* #  '  * *"  * "" *  "" 3*"*  $&  **  "& #, "*    3&, && *"# 3" +   , & "

# & '& '"* "&* * * *  5*  "& "   " * &"*" +& * 3**" "&* &" * * "'  

 *   6&'"&"*&&'+"!6* &  &* &'&& *"#   '  +* , "*   "&   * *" " "" & *  , &&" "    *""+&'"'  " * *  *   * *"   * *        &'& " "  &* # * *"  ."'"& +& " 3" & "'   *   ""*"  &'  "&"* * 3+ *" *"#  **  ( (   *&&' &&! "&"   *"* "  " "&* &" +"+&' * "*&*   $+" %  &'*"+&' * "*&* &"+"

#   * ,&   &*"  * "&* * * * &  * &+" *"#     %   &* 3"  *     *""+&'"'  " * &" ""** "" "" * * * "' "    " ""&*  $&* **"&"+& &&* *"   ,&&*"# ""     &"   , & ""* &""""* "& 3"  ""*+ 3" *  $&  6&'* *" * *" * &" 3*&"*( ((&&&3&,&&   3"" ""*"* && *   * *"  3" # * " * * *   3" +    1& 3*# "&*&" *""& &"  &   

 &", && "" "" *   &&* * % # &&'& % &*"   (8  

"'   ())  "&"* *   3*&   "*  "&*&" *""& &"  &   

 &" "   * ' * &", *""+&'"'  " * &", &&'&  &" *&" +&   &*&3 &""&&" * *   * *      3*&* ( +&# "&*&" *""& &"  &   

 &"  *" &      &   &*" 3*  *+"*    

 - *""+&'"' " * &"*"   "" #""+&""" *""**&' "&  +  *" *&"**& $""*"*" *6&" *  3&&"

 *  "& ,6 ' *&  *  *" "#*"3, 6&" " &" '&*  & "*  &,  "33*& ", *"*&'+ "*&  +&'"'   $*"6&  $12'( *"* #,"*3"","" * "*"*&,+&*"* "  *"  3*  * *  $ ""      "& " 3*"& &" *" 6&* &"* **"&*       

$*&