Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-05-4/2 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2005:3.05.4.662 AI generated

3-05-4/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-05-4/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                            

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-05-4/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:                             

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                            

               !  "  #$ $ %

  $ &  %

 '( )"   " #  *#+ #  ,           %

       ) "  - *.# -   #  #  #  # &  -  /  -. !  "  #)" ## - *  -  "  " #012 #- /   &      3#  " / - 

   + #   !  "  #$ $ %

 $)/45(&3*   + #   !  "  #  %

 '()/45(&3*   /, #  !  "  ##)  6* " - # 3# ## % ) # # #  +* )/45$&*   #3 ",  #   3 #     7 & #  #    3 "  - # "  # # # " #&  - &" # 3 " # " #  # "  # # # " #&  3 "    

 83 #    #  # # - ##  # -  ## #  +3 " -# "  # # # " #& - &" #3 " # " # 83 #  ",  #  +# #  #      #    " -   #     # #  #   # # -  -  # #  3 #     

  ! "#! $%"&'    %

 #  !  "  # "  #, &&  #     ## "   &   & ##  #)#  *    !  "  #% ( %

 & ''

 #  , 8(  " # #   &, &" # #",,  # , &# #-# /.

- # & # # "  - 3  33,  # # -  $ %

)#   *    !  "  #$ $ %

 & $)" # #  #*

 #   "  +  "  -  & # ##-#, &&  # # "    &  #  #)#  *   8"  -  #  # # 3  !  "  #"     !  "  #  %

 & '(- # "    # )#  ( *     

 #  "  -   #  !  "  #$ $ %

  $-   %

 '(#+ #  ,)#  %*  

 #  



& - #  "  -   &# .## 3#  ,#

- " #" #  # " #)#  (*     

  #  "  -   3 # 3#  9#   ##     # -    " #" #  -  -

 )#  '$*  

 #  



& ",#  "  -  #)#  '*     ('!  "  $ $ %

 & $- ##  !  "  #   #  "  #   #, && #  # # "   - ," #- 8"  -   #   # #   3  " .     !  "  # - ##      %

  &   '(    #  !  "  #    $  #  " ## -    .# # # "     . #  #   #, &&  # ## "    , &" # # ",,  #   .   ,  (8  +.& $.'#  #.  # ## & #  # #  

" -+ #" #"   " - 3# & # # " #  -  # #   - &  # , &# # -#   &        #, &&   #   -# "    #   #+ & +&# 2 #    #+.   "   #  4&        #  & &  #  #  # +&"  #+  "   -# # "   #     !  "  #   .# :  5$&       &  +&" #  +#   - # # "    #   " #  !  "  #   %

   3,-  # 3    -  

   #  # # "  #   -&     & -    -. #+&" # # # +#    #  " # 4      7 & /  # & #   8"  -  .# :  5$& # "#,&  " #  ,##& 8"  -   #  #, &&  #-  &   #   

 .  :   # #  # 8"  -  #  .##  " # & # # "  . #  #    # -   ;; . # + #" # "    .   "#    #      #    #.  4   -  :  5$& ## #.#      3 " #  " #  "    .# , &# & # # "   # "# #  #  " # #  #3-

"  .  ##. -

  , &# #-#  !  3 " # 3 - & #  , &# # -# -    " ",   #",# .-     , &#, . #  #  4&  "  - , & #   3 # & # " #",,  # #     # - ;; .# #",    #  # & # # "   # "# #% #  #.  #+.  +&   & . #     -  % #  #  .    #      # #  #      4#,##     # -  , 3   % #      #  &  &  ,   #    #  #.     ",   !  "  #   #   # #   #" # :  5$, - 5,  ##&  # )!# # 3#.#  $*   

 ! '   !  "  # # # # - " " #     !  "  #  #  # #&  - &" #  #  8"  -       -   - "   #    %

  3 &&    -   #    %

 !  "  # #, &&  #   " .# #2  #    #  #   8"  - "  # 3 "  #+ . + ## <7+# "#&  $'.     #& . 8   #& . 8 "    #&   & =,   #&    - "   #+  .(%%  9 #"  #+    #  # : -   # # & # # & #  #  # 4&  "   3 "    3"    # #     - #   !  "  #    % '(# " "   &   "  -   #  4&  "  "  #    '(       #   "  # ,# " # "- 3     # -    "     !  "  # 

    % ( %

  &   ''   ,  8(   " # #    #, &&   # # "  -  , &" # # ",,  #   , &# # -#  # & # # "     -  3   33 ,   # # -   $ %

 3# 

 # # # -    , # -  "  "  # 

     &  - 3    $  #  #   .    # 3  # # # "  ,3 ,, #  #-  # # +#  # 

 % 8#  #"  "  # :  5$, # !  "  # & . #  :      "  -     # - # -    # & #   , &# # -# ",  33  #  # .   ##   &   "  #  # # #  #   33  #      "  #     ",##    , &# #-# "  # #  -   & ## " # #   8#" 3 - #.(%% : # " # . #  .# "  -       #        #. # "   3 "    3"     , 8( .   - .   # #+.   #   #   #+  9-

 ,  8(   # & # #  , &# # -#      " # " #   .   , &# # -#      33  #  #   " ### "  "  #.#$ $ %

 $-   %

    '(        # -  -# "  , &   & 3  - ##       #    "$ %# ''' #  /  "  -   #   ##   &  . # "  -     # & #  #  " # 3,-#" #  4 #  / # !  "  # #, &3  # &

3 - ##     #   -   " #,#"  & . #-# -

 # & #    ( #  # -  #,##       #   # # -#  , &   # & #      )*!%##   !  "  #$ $ %

 & $

 #  "  -  & # # #-#, &&  # # "   &  #  #)#  *   4.# "  - , & -#, &&   #  <3#   # " " #  !  # # "  &   / :    ) 3     < /74* 5 $ &    ",     #       "  3 " #  " #  #      3 " #   "  #   "     #  #  .  #  , &  #    #  # 3-

"      # & # # "    # "#.    ## .   -

 , &# # -#   4   3  & "  -  ,   # # "   3 " #   3 

- &     , &# # -#  -       "  ",   # ",#  . -    , &#,  #  #  4-# "#  .#  ## #  - &&   # # #, &#  "   , &  

" " 3,# "  -  - & .#" - 3# & # # " ## #   ) , (8 +.& $.'#  #* "  + #" #  - 

  &  3  # & # # "    # "#     #    % #  #   &   ##+&"  #+ #    )!# "  - # 3#.#  '*   ! ## - #   #+ & 3 "    -  .#+    #    &    #  #        " #   ##.   # # +

3     7+# "# # # #& ''>>$)#  * 43  # & - # #.#/74 5$& ",    -# & #  #    #  .  & " ##3 "  #+ - & +&"  #+ "  #   "#) 7+# "#* 4  #,#+ . /745$& "  #  # # #,&    #. #  +# )  ##*   "  # 3    &  

     #  ##    # # - # /74 5 $ &  , ##    #      4    ,   ,##& /  #   ##&   :  5 = # #

3  & "  #  ,   & # #, &  "   #    ##    #, & # ",   #   # & #    & "   -

" #      #   . # & . #   # # #    -  & &     #  #  #, &#  "    , &  4    3# " -   "     - # # "    # , ##   # # 3  & "  -  ,   .    # ",   #    # # +& " ##+&" ## # # +##.  "   3 ", #   "#.- .-,& . 3  +#   & #  "", #",- < - # #   

3#3#  -# # "   #",    ##- #    " #   # #"  #    ##  = # # 3, ,#  + # "   "    .  #  #. # "  -  # #       ## /745$&# /745&"  #   3  & " $- # 3# #.# #, &&  ",   #     &    3  & "  $  ## #  #.     # 3  & " #   # #  #   # ## # "#      #    # ## .  ## &    #   " #  # # +#  # " ,##. " # #.    "    3 . #. - . -,& .  & #  " ",  #",    , ,#.    # # ",   & #  "  &     ##   ##"  #.+#  &     8"  - & #,# .#" # # $ 3  " #3,- #.        #         #  #  /  3#   ",   # ",#   - &   3 # 3  )/78 5 $ &     *.            #   8"#  #  "

##. " " #   #-   -    4 ,##   3  " ## -  "  -  # ## # &  #      ",     #    .   #  #    " # "      #  -  3,-    !  "  #$ $ %

 $#  # &# #       #" # ### "  -     -  #+ #    8"#  - .#  %

" #) *#  &  # &    # +# #" . #  ## #,&  # " #   #+ #      # #    4  #     . #     #+ &  +&" #  #+    ",   #   3& # #,##. #   "   #    " #  & # #" &  

 (  # # 3,-        #  #  - ##     #  #  - #     3,- .   #    #   #  . # # &    # # "  /  # & #   ",   #   - # "#    " #  # " ",   #  # #- -  " #   # #3, ,### 4   "  # 3 "   ##  #+  #  -  3  

 #     . + &  #   " # " #  # 3.   +       - & #     # "  .  33#  . ## &, # " , &&   #+   /45$& ## .#3. # ## ., ## " - #  3# ##  "   -  #  "  - , &  - # ## #  & , "  & %     , &   " - , # # &  %  )  # # #  +* ! ## - # 3# "  " #" #    # )# #& 3#.#   (*  .#3,- #- "  " ## - # "  -  " - , #        #