Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-04-458/2 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2005:3.04.458.658 AI generated

3-04-458/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-04-458/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                           

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-04-458/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:                            

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                           

                 ! " # !!! !  $"! #         %%  

       & "   !    '  " !   "   "  (" !!  )     

   ' !!     ! (*+, %-)   .!- "#!   - ! &  /  !  !    - "   ! " ! ! ! " !    " ! - " ! " !  .! " ! ! ! " !  - "    

 0- !  ! ! !  !!  ! !! !  $- " ! " ! ! ! " !   " !- " ! " ! 0- ! "#!  $! ! !    & !   "   !    ! ! !  ! !    ! !  - !     ! "#! $%"&'  1 %% %2 %

"#!!* / &3& !"!" !!-!    $ !  4 *  (!   %1%)  3   $! !    #  #!!       "     %221

      !$! ! * -  /  &3 & !"!1 %% %2 %

!1%  #!-! "  (!  ) 

     %2 

! -! !" !! !*5'(2  %2

)   "  5    % #!!!     " !5    ! $! -!  ! #" !!5   #6* -  537&* ,  !" "   $  (!   )   %  %21

 # 8  9     / !$$ - 5   !   / ! $$ ! * - 5 #!  " "   " 5- 61 !$  - !  (!  % 2)    + !  %221

! !" ! !4 !5 !'7* 7 ($  *5  ) "#! % % %2

 " ! 7 * (  *) -  "  5   % #!!!   *   # !  "    6 " !   " !5  !"   ! " !  ! 65#" !! !-  !! (!  %%) 8 !!" ! !"5# !!!  4      + !2  %222

! !" ! !4 !5 !7($ *) "#!!-   '* 2  %2

(* )" ! ! 

 -  "  :#  5!5#   '*!  ! -  "  5 %#!!!   " !*   #  6(!  )   *   " !  % 

     61% !! ! !! ! !   7  * 5  #  " ! ! (!  ) -   6 6   +  !!! !  -#   " !  4   ,     -  (  "  !" ) ;! !! ! !   #!  " "  -!!7 (!  6)   *   " !  % %

      ! #   !#    !   /<  .!#    ! ! "          !    # !  5 !          * -  &3& !"!%  %2

!(!   )      "   6  %

     2 !! ! $$   #  "    4 , % ,% %  # " /<(!   %)   ! !  #! !$$ -   %

(!   )   6 6 %

  7   !  * * "       - #  !!5 !  !" ! % % %22

7"  =#!! $ =#!!     "    - #  !!  ! # ! ! !  ## !# " ! !"##  ! ! ! "#-"   5  * 5 # "!5-  6 6  #6 "!5-  (!  %)    % 

   1 % 

 !    (   )     (     )  !*  " !   "  ! " !#!!!! ! $"! #(!  %6  1)  

 

  !  % 

    % 

 

!   ! "   !     ! 5!! -!   !  "    " !!  (!  %%2% )  

  ! %  

   %  

 

!    !    ! "  !  ! 5  -!  "   !   " !   ! !    -  !! !   $"!  5  -  " !!  *  " !(!  % % )  

  ! %  

 

  ! "   !   $! !  !     $  !  (!   %%1)     !    ! ! !    ! $"! # #   !$  !    !   5   "     !   #  % #!!    !5      ! ! !"  $    ; #!! -!! !  ! "   !-!%1 ($  !! !"  "$)     ('!  "  ! 7    *!! !   -   : ! 5 -# ! !  !$   !$ " !5!!-  5   * 5 #!  " 6: "   - 5"   ' *>57*>  7>(  )     %22

 $$! ! 7    !    *$$!  4! $ "  5!!   * / &3& !"!1 %% %2 %

 !   1% !  #!!!    !  # !   45  -! "   3! ! ! -! !$! !    "     %221

      2  %2

'*--*      %2 

  * -    / 3!  ! !    * "   " !!5 !'*>-  "   " "    $ 7 "   !!    " ! 5 ! ' 7  *< -    !   - "  2  %2

 ! !$!7 >-!" !"#!   %  %262

 7   !!   % %22%

 !  7   *   " ! " # " ! !"##  !"  ! !  -5#   #! -!   7 % % %22

7  !  &!>-!  %22

"   !!#  !! -  5-  !$! ! #   ! "   "   -  &", %  !  -  " !"#! ' !  "   !% # !"     !         %

 ! #! " !  !5! /  *!   !  !$ " !  !$   5        "     "  # &! !  # " #!! 

  (%) ! -!   !!-! !-  ! $    *!    0? 7   *  @$ -!  !  !" !1 %1  !  !   * "   " !!#   ! ! ! ! " ! "! !  #     A " !   5 !  /> !!  #    & !/! !  "     %               "    /!  4 ,1#% 5!# ! !!-    ! !  -!   ! "# !   !#     7 ! 7    7 ! %% %22



 1! ! !#   !   -!%  -!%5-!%  -!5! ! !!! " ! "!!  (!  %% )    !   " !!   !!5 *   " !  % %

  !        "   " ! " !  !  2   "    !   6 6 

5  !!"  #   ! !    ! !    ! !$! - " ! !     BB 0"     ! !#  5!! !  !!" ! (!  % ) 0"!   !   # -   ! -! 5      /5     !     ! !    (!   6)  *     "#  ! !    !  ! !   ! !5 !    #"  -#  0 "#  # ! !!   $"! ! !(!  % )   

 ! '    " #!! !    0"    " 5 ! !      !#    ! !  #  %     #  " !  !5   !#   !  $  !#  * / &3&*1 %% %2 %

! 1%! !$!" !-!  "     $!   !5 !   " !    $ !  #!!!    #   ! (!   )    %2 

 " !!!  !5 !    $ " "   %#!!!  #6  " !  %2  !  $  #   " !"     * - &9"! @$%6 2 %262

 !%1(!  6) !5!  #     *  &3 &* 1 %% %2 %

 !   1% $ !  #   4 &#"  ! !  +- /   0"   ! !   - # !!!(6 6 %

) !5!  #  " ! "#! -  "  5   ## !  #  "  # " ! !"##  ! ! ! "#-"     !#" 5! "      # - !    #6 !#   ! !! !5!* -  &3&* %  %2

 !    (- %)   ! 8 9 "    0  !    " ! ! !" !  " !:0 5  6  # 



(!  %)   !!! !5!/    "  %  %21

 !$$ -  89(!  % 2)   /%2  %221

!  ! "  #  !      &  !       ! %  

 !#  2%  !   #     /5       -  !5 %  

 - #  !!   (!   % )  0"     !   ! /-!%  

(!  % )   0!!# !5!/ #  # "  ! #  5- ! 0A,2 !! "     0"   -! !# !5! #    ! ! !"#!  !#   !      !    !  #      4  !! ! !   !   !!!! ! 5 ! 5!-        !5 !!!!   + 4 , %  !  5 ! ! !  4          ,    %  !  ! !        !#     !  " 5! 4 ,1 % !*   " ! "#    !   -  !   !!-  "         -- #  ! !! #  !     !    !    #  !     " 5 !    ! !!   !  -%  !! !!  " ! "!! #     !7   " !! !  $"!  ! +  !  #      ! #     #   4    !! ! 7 !!  - "#  ! -!! !   !!        !  !  & !     5 ! "        "  " ! "#/ # ! #!  "  "      "    !  %221

  #6  " ! # !!  (!  % )    )*!%##  / " !!   , 1   %  ! "# 5  #   "  "#    # " !  ! "  " #  ! !5 #  !  !! !   $"! !  " !   !!  5 !   $"!    "  "#    # " !  ! "        $"!  #! $ -##!    ! !  ! 5     "#  " !!   ! "  #  !" #    0"    " !  ! !   #  !#!!5 !  #  "  !$  ! !/<  ! ! !(!  % ) !#!!! !$ "              /    0"     !   !$ !  %#!!!  !(!  % )  

  0"!   5! !" ! 4 , !%    ! !  " 5!  "    " ! ! $"! #  "     * !   5! ! !7   7 ! %% %22

 

 1! !C+ !#   !  D !! !! - " !! !!" ! "!! #     7 !!   5!  !  # !#    #  4   ! " !!  5!"   -    "# ! !!  !             !!     !  !  7 !      / "# -BB  !   #     ! ! (!! -!5!  %65)   /%2  %221

!  ! "  #  !      (!   % 5 -BB)  7 !!   "!  " *  /  &3 &* 1 %% %2 %

 !   1% ! ! $!" ! -!  "    5 !  !5!  " ! !$#!!!  # !(!  )    %2 

 " !! (!    )5   !    " "    $  % #!!!    # 6   " !   !  5 ! %2  !  #   " !"   $          ! %  

 !#  2%  !   #   /5  - !(!  % ) 0"   !  ! !  / -! %  

(!   % )  ! ! "      " ! %  %21

 !$$ -  (!   % 2)5     /     #    " 8 9 .!$$ - !    !" !! !! #!  "   ! " !       " ! !! (!# !5 !   %65 #-)  !- " !!# ! #     !     !#! " !!  5!! ! ! !" !" "#  - ! + 4 , % !! # !#     !  *  " ! % %

    !# /   !#    !   +       " ! * -  &3& !"!%  %2

!   ! ! ! - !!!   "  6  %

  2 $$  # "    4 , % ,% %  # " /<(!   %) ! !  #!  %

  !$$ - (!   )    !  !!$! ! !!!! !  ! !   " #   7 !!  !#!   5! "   !" !  # !%  # " ! !5!    !#!  0"   ! -! ! !     - #  !!! (!   %) !5!# " !"#!-  "  5## ! #  "  # " ! ! "##  !   ! !  "# - "   ! !5! "        !!   !!# -! !" !" ! !   !    5 !   $"!  #!   !  "# 

 1    5 !  "   ! " # " ! ! !#    ! ! "    $$/<!" ! !   *!$  *+,2 % !! 5!-5 ! !!5#!! "  !  -! !! * "    !"  #!5! " !!   !! !!!         *!