Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-04-339/2 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2004:3.04.339.577 AI generated

3-04-339/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-04-339/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

 ! " +*# !+!$*"#$# +*#   *-22 &+# "#3$-2+" ,"$  $  2#"  -#"* +& -#  +-""*2##7      #$! " 2 ##*+ *"#" *"  *&"# 2-$* *" $#  *# 2#   0/1" #3$ - % +### "#"##"-,=7 2  " # ,=.!!$**##" *#"$ # -+" "# !$ ,=7 2*,=./!!$* *! 2-$* $+ ! -2- "" "$  2##*+!+""*- """  # "#*# + ##"-,=/"#$"" $ !& ""!#+&"+-#" *# !$  ,=7!&"$  2 3 !" "#

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-04-339/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:  ! " +*# !+!$*"#$# +*#   *-22 &+# "#3$-2+" ,"$  $  2#"  -#"* +& -#  +-""*2##7      #$! " 2 ##*+ *"#" *"  *&"# 2-$* *" $#  *# 2#   0/1" #3$ - % +### "#"##"-,=7 2  " # ,=.!!$**##" *#"$ # -+" "# !$ ,=7 2*,=./!!$* *! 2-$* $+ ! -2- "" "$  2##*+!+""*- """  # "#*# + ##"-,=/"#$"" $ !& ""!#+&"+-#" *# !$  ,=7!&"$  2 3 !" "#

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                 

     ! "#$"#$ "% " "&  " ! ' ( )* #"* "*%% *& +*," *#(!! ,""" *% #+- +""#$  

 !  %%"," * #(!! ,""" "#

 

 ../*"$  # ""#  #!+  *#  "#$"$*   0 

1&#  ##"#!! * $  . &  "*#   #0.1 3$4  ," *#(!! ,""" "#

 

 ../5 *  -+""$ # 4  "$ +& "*$!++ +*# !$* !! *!5  +*+& 6"+*$$2-$-  "*""#$2-$* 2"*"#  #



 " "!#+* 5  +& +*+"* +  *!""#3$ /7 "      2 "#$"+*"   $ ,"2##" *   &"#$%% "$  *"+-"-"2##...* $ +!*"#"  #  ,"2##"##" *  89"#  # +*#*"#$  !! "! +"* +      ,"2## +*# "#

  633"+-* %%$ +*# "#$ "*#" +* -"#  #"  "#$""#$"-"* 2+#" *+*   "#$0 1   ,"2## +*# "#

  633"+-* %%$ +*# "#$...* "*#"  +*-"#  #"  "#$""#$ "-"*2+#" *+*   "#$0 1   %%) ,"  "#

 ./*.

  "#

  7!+...& & " +*# -2+ *" +*# -22+

  %%&"#$8  "-"#" * &2++-*2 "# #"  $&"  ##" * +""#$0 1   ,"2##"#

+ "# ""# " "#633"+-*%%"*#" + "#  #2 ##..."  0 /1    $," *#(!! ,"""2##%%)"# 

/8&"#$%%! +"* +      ," *##   $%%+/  "#  /8++"# "$"*"  ++  ##"(!! ,"""01  $," *#(!! ,"""2##%%)"#

 

  ../ "*#" "#

"#  # *!"%%2##" +*-3*+$" ..."  

  "#$"-""#  #+*+$"" "!+#" *""#$&#+!$""#  # "#$071  "#$"$ 



" *"*2##...  #$ "#  ##6    

 $ +*#  #+6 &-22/ "#*! +" !! % ##  /7 73$  "++"#

*!" "*" +*"#  # 2 ##..."  

 * "++"#

"#$"$ "-" ..."  #" *""#$&#+!$" "#  #"#$*+!"++"#

&  *-"!+"*# :;  "  +*#  +-633"2$!++#+-& +*# #*"" #++-'$&""$ ##+"#  #"&2 !+3""*$"#  #*+!"++"#

&  "$ $!+*$  #   # &  -"*! ** #-*"#$#   + *$  #"++"#

-"#  #+&# #+    -+ "#$# "#  #2  # "-&$#    +*# """#  #&""#-2  "*  & *!""*$  #"#

  -"4 -# 2 #2# #  &   #+-" !*+! -"$ #" &! "#$""#$2#  -#" &# * *+!#  "$  -"# 33#"  "&# ! 3$ "  "$ # -++"#"  !+&+!"*&



"#

"#  #"*$& 9$*$  # 2"* "#  #   2-$* *-+   "## +#"*+"$

+*# !+!$ 

*" *+!"#$2



$ "#

 2"*$#+" +*# &+ "#

#$#9 !+" +*#  *":;$ #" +*#   "#

 ./ *... #.

 "#

  7# +" " !! "#  #+# *! "*#+  /7  +#2 &+! "#  #*!"++"#

 "* +*# *!"*$+"# 2 ""#  #"+*" #" "&#"*"# + -#" &#   "*# #" *"   +"""&# "* - "$ 2##6  !2*$  # "++"#

  +*#+  *#"#$   ""$  # *+!"#$"*"633""#  # 

 <+*# "#$# ++-"#

 ./* 7& "*+ #(-22+""*   "* "#

! +#"   ##"  !$*3"""$"#/ & "$" /7   +## "++  +$2$"&+ + 22$"!  *"#- *$# #+!+" "# # - & + "++"#

*"#$  $""*2$$""++* #   +*#  "#

#++-  &2 "$ "#

 ! " +*# !+!$*"#$# +*#   *-22 &+# "#3$-2+" ,"$  $  2#"  -#"* +& -#  +-""*2##7      #$! " 2 ##*+ *"#" *"  *&"# 2-$* *" $#  *# 2#   0/1" #3$ - % +### "#"##"-,=7 2  " # ,=.!!$**##" *#"$ # -+" "# !$ ,=7 2*,=./!!$* *! 2-$* $+ ! -2- "" "$  2##*+!+""*- """  # "#*# + ##"-,=/"#$"" $ !& ""!#+&"+-#" *# !$  ,=7!&"$  2 3 !" "#

&#*$","$ $" &* "$" *$ "$ !&""!#+ +-"# !$     # "##"-,= $#  +!! +-$"  &# ## +-$2 -    

# "$ 2##"  +*# $"# $"       ,"2## +*# "#

 ./633"+-* %%$ +*# "#$ "*#" +* -"#  #"  .    ,"2##

+*# "#

  7633"+-*%%$ +*# "#$ ...* "*#" +*- "#  #" 7/  %%) ,"  "#

 ./*.

  "#

  7!+...& & " +*# -2+ *" +*# -22+<+*# -22+# ,=8  + +*# -2 + 2##""#$+- *!++ +#"$ 2##2##+ +*# "#



+*# -2+<+*# $/ ," *#(!!  ,"""2##%%)"#  /8&"#$%% ! +"* +          (!$,=  2-2$"  $" +"         ,"#"#$#%%)2#!$,=/ "* +/ 01&#$*""2!+"$"+" $  +2##+!*+*#-22/ "#

 /8+" +*# "#

   ./*.

   7 !+"  ,"$ +!"#$# "++"#

++- +*# "#

    ./*.

   7* + "+# -22 & "## *- 0.1  # +""++"#

&"#  ! >?," *#"""&*!""#  #%% " +*-32 ##..."  

> ,=..2 "#$2"!!  "# +*"" *$-2"$ *-  ,*, !$ *+-" 0 + 1 2"#++-$""#+ "!#+*"++"#

++- +    +*#  2*+-*!"#"# + ," *# /7 +# ### 2 "#$#4@ "  ++  ##"(!! """> (!$,=8# +$ "#

# "$ -4 1 $+* $""!"+-#"$"   "- +$"6"*! *5  1 $"&## # +-$* #5  1$$"  " *$" "&#  ## "+-*#"5 1#   #"# +-$3 "#  ##  5 /1*!+ $        

 "$ +#+$ &+# ### $  $ 0+-+!+*!"1-" ,= /- ##"-,= /$ $" "+-#  ## "41#$#  5 1$#   + $  #+ 5 1$#   + $  #$ # ##     #"##"-,=$#  2##  ###- "#$  # *##"++#++-"              "++## ," *#2## "#

 

 ../++-$ $#   +!$, = /  ,=/.  +# "$ -"#  #"-"""#$ *  +-"+  ""#$2##"# #" &$"2& **+   $AA*#   +  *3--#  #* 4 13""*$"#  #"0= 7B 15  13"#  #"$" +*# "0=  B81 ,"""+!"#$#"*+"#  #  +*#  &   "#

 ./*.

 "#

  70 71 % +2##+*#"#$&/ "#  /8 +"#  +*# "#

   ./*.

   7 " !+  ,=/&"#$2"$  +*#  *!!  +*# "#

&#""#$ "!&# ++"#

++-" "!! "#  # ! "*+#            ,=/ !&"$ 2##++-"#

 +*# * !! "#$&"! ""!#+= 7!"#  #+"& "2 ##& +*# !$   +*# !++ "   #- "#$#"$  "++"#

++- , =/ -++"#

&#"++"#

!!  +*#  !$            # "$ # & "*$!++ +*# !$* !! *!&-+   "$ 2!+3""*$"#  #*3"#  #!+& 3""*$"#  #*3"#  #!+! "*&"#  #!+  ""   & +"#  #+# # ""#$   +-*"#$&# "#$$  "!#+*$"#  #+# & !$**! "" "*!# ",! -"#  #!+"    #  ,"2##"##" *  8 9 #"  "#3$ ...* " +*"  - "#  #"

. #  ,"2##"##" *   9*$ "%%)#" "#9*+$  ..8-  2 



$ ,"2##" *   &"#$%% "$  *"+-"-"2##...* $ +!*"#" 08 1 " * +*#" *# "#$" * 2-$*"%%"9*$"2##"$ #3$ *6 +$ - 2  ( 2 "#$#  *"! %%& "# 6 2 "# #" *-""""" *"#$# 6 2## $+!*" * """633"$%%)  " * +*#" **$" *4@?+- ""-"2##...* $+!*"#" ># -  +*+!"#$&"!" *# $%%)" *     ,"2## +*# "#

 ./633" +-*%%$ +*# "#$ "*#"  +*-"#  #"0 1 .    ,"2## +*# "#

  7633"+-* %%$ +*# "#$...* "*#"  +*-"#  #"0 1 7/  %% ,"  "#

 ./*.

  "#

  7!+...& & " +*# -2+ *" +*# -22+071 7   %%&"#$8  "-"#" * &2++-*2 "# #"  $&"  ##" * +""#$0 1 / $," *#(!! ,"""2##%%)"# 

/8&"#$%%! +"* +    +### "*"633"+-*# +*#       +*# #-2+7/   % +##3 3""*+!"#$&"*""#$#  "#  #



  / $," *#(!! ,"""2##%%)"# 

/8&"#$%%! +"* +  

/7 ," *##   $%%+/  "#  /8++"# "$"*"  ++  ##"(!! ,"""01 (!$,=/# ""#$+- #&"- +  "&-2AA $"#$ "!  *"#

"$"#$  +## "++&# -" " !++ *! ##&"""#$ "!!$**##" "-+-0"!#+*$"  7 1 (!$2##+*#," *# "#





 ../++-" +*$- + *+$"2 ## 7 "  # "*2!+  +*+$"* ++*"#$  + 2 ##"#$& *+$"""#$$  "!$"+   ++"#

# "#$"*"$ #"  "#33"#$&" # 33"#$& # 33"#$071%% # 7     ,"&"#$8  

"$ "-"@?#" " #"#$% +""#$?> 0 1," *# /7 #  # "!"*" ##+!"++"##  $ "$ 2##"# - &$"+&  +&%%# *! ! ""#$&# " "$  # ##  % +###  *"*+!"#$&"$  -+#" ## &"#- "#$2-$  "$  -"#33&" # 33"#$"* 2##   * *"#$#"* #7   +#" "$   *#  "#$#$3+2##" "#$"#$" " *# "* " -+"#"" " ## &- ""##*"*"#$ ##"#8 7" ## & # ++""#

  "" $#&"#$"+!*-2 #2# #  " $  % +##**$ ,= 72&2 &27&= */&, =. &. * & "#$  %4  <$%%#*3$," *#(!! ,"""  "#

 

 ../  <$%%#* -+""$ # &  "*$!++ +*# !$*!! *!  '! $%%# -+""$ # 4   "*""#$2-$* 2"*"#  #



" "!#+* 5   +*+"* + *!" "#3$ /7 "    !*-," *#(!! ,"""& "## ."C$2-" / ! &0 $3" "3 1" ## %%""  #$#+-2## " < "# "#$ !  "#$" 2!+*##" +#+"  

 %2## ""#$2!+*##" +# +"              % " "         #$ "