Legislator Case Law & Legislation
3-04-166/2 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2005:3.04.166.701 AI generated

3-04-166/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-04-166/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated



Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-04-166/2 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja: 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text













          

 

  













 



 

  

!!"#



 

$%&$'(!))*





 +,

%



- )*")$"&... &!*

/0 1

#

 +,

%0- 0!.")2"&... 

&34&%0/0 5

%0- 0!.")2"&... 

&34&%067- 5

%0- 0-60-

!.")2"&... &34&%0  

0 "







  

)3"#!))*

  

 

 +#  #





-# 

-  #

 



-#0- 0 #

 



0 



  ! "

8 9!27&:219$&74#7*193'

7!19.!7&,



80  

- 

)*")$"&... &!*/0 6 



80 ,

0- 0!.")2"&... &34&%0

/0 1



80 0- 0

-60-!.")2"&... &34&%0

  0 "



80 # 

/-0 "



80 

- #

67+ /-0 "





 

 

  -6+ :  + 

7 $): -

#-   - 7 0 !!"#

!))*"

:  +  0  +

 # &): -#- 

  - 7 0 "









# $



$)"&&"&..*;

00# 7 67

+# <0 --    %$&&0

 "

   %$&&0 0 /"=/1

-660 #   /> # ?" 0

/- >  ?#>  0 ?@!'1!.A"

#  -  / 1 />  ?#>  0 ?-60

767+#  "

)$")."&..2 7!$!000 00  

 +#6  <0"":731!4" B 1   <0""

 67+# 1-  00:  "

!&"&&"&..2  - 070 "

)*")$"&... 

-  7&!*6  # 

0/ 21.* 67 7 0 "

!.")2"&...0- 0 &34&%0 -

 00 / # 0/  67 7 0@$%3*(!))*'A"



!&")2"!))4   +  

- )*")$"&... &!*

/0 "

 +# 7 67 0 #$%&$'(!))4

 !3")2"!))40 7@0$2%$'A"

!."&&"!))40 7: 0  #$%&$'(!))4

  0    -#0- 0!.")2"&...

  &34&%01 0 -0 7@$%&$'(!))4&&!A"

!4")*"!))*0 70  #$%&$'(!))4 

@$%&$'(!))4&&*%&&2A"



&4"&)"!))4   + 10  0- 0!.")2"&...

 &34&%0/010- 0 67- 

0-60- 0-60- 0 

  0 @$%3*(!))*2A"

&2"&&"!))40 76: 0  /0 @$%3*(!))*

$)%$!A"

&2"&!"!))4

70 7/&2"&&"!))40@$%

3*(!))*4$A"

&&")*"!))*

7 700 7/&2"&!"!))4

70#&2"&&"!))407 

/0 +  7 @$%3*(!))*44A"



)3")2"!))*: 0 7 $%3*(!))*#

$%&$'(!))4# @$%&$'(!))4&42A"





"  ! ! $



      +# 

-  -0 

6 0  - 070  07 7"0/

 # 1--660      %$&& 10+

0 67 7 0 " # /  0//

!.")4"&..' B " 0#-  7  +#  0

 67 10 +# -"  - 

0# '0 0 7 -- 76 

0 0 "

 +#7+ -- +#677    

%$&&0" +#-  -## +# # B  7 0

 :  # / #-60 +# 0/ 

7-0: 7 0 " +#7-#

  - --60 1  +#67  # 

0/ 70"7   -6600 

/1   067+#   - 

  #77 6  - --  1

0   B676/   #  0 / 

70" +# 7   + B  0#  !#

/ # 0 -+ 0 - 7 +# 7

41.*  # 0/ " +#-  + # / 

#7 60 6  71706 0 0/ 

# :- "

 +# +



 @$%&$'(!))4*!%A" + 

    +#  - # 0/ #70 

 : 7    -+0 / #70  -

0" +#-  -- -- /0 

 7 0  " # 0/ 7 

 +# 1   +#676  0/ 707

 " +#-  --00 +# #

0  #: :: 600 "

 + 0- 0   + +#1 0- 0

67 - #+ +#677 # 0/ "

0  -- 67 - 1

 +#  0 67 7 0 : 1 

67: 0- 0" +# 7    

-- +# #67- -660- 00 

0 77-# -0 ::  #60 "

-+: -0 # /0+   1 +0#7 +##

00- -60-6   "

 +# 7  0- 0 9247!67

 0  67  "

 +#





 07" + : 

 +# # 0/ 7 0 :#: -7

-   #    +#-7

 # 0/"



% 

-  + @$%&$'(!))44!%4*A"

#-6+67  +#-   1   

- 0 0 0   1-#7    -

# 7 0  0 710 -- 

/0 1  -- 70 -#"

# 7   +#67731!4"

#

7  -#  7-0 70 

+#  -" +# 70701: +

7-0 0- 031!4"

 /  # 

 21.*" 0 - ' 0 "



  0067 0*)70#70 

0 #70 67+#  -  + 6

/ "  -#  0 / 31!4

10-607" 0 + 21.*C 7

0  0+70  "

# 

  





  @$%&$'(!))42&%2$A

 :+ +# + 671  -- /0  

070  067   "

#7

 ---7  // # 

0  -7 6" --  +#671 

--6 6

9.7!"



%0- 0   +"- 07 

06 0  1 0- 0 -- 7

  # 0/  0 /0 @$%3*(!))*&2A"

# 

  





  @$%3*(!))**'1*3A

   - -  0# -0 0 "

0+67- -66010/  67+#  

 06 67 0:  #  67+# 1 1 +0

70"

927!:$ 0 7 -6 -1

  -    - "

9.7!  0

067 7--  !)0"0

0+-+ : - 0 -  - 0!)10 

 0#+067+#  ";7- -66&2143

 0  21.*1 7- 0:

 0:" 0 -0 /10 

/ - - "- 0 1 -- :

 -0#:06 -  7"

#70  +-   71 7- + 6

 / "- 06+1 070 -

 +0 0 : 1  -# -

0  6 0  +67 1 0  

  0 0 --6"









   + @$%&$'(!))442%43A"0

-    +#  7070 

- 031!470/  + " 0

067-+ : - 0 :0  70  

-0!)1 +# # 0/  0 7

 :6# 1 -+: -0/ 7 : "

0: 

  



@$%&$'(!))4'2%''A

--   +070 1 0

0 /0"0-   ----6 

6

9.7!1  7 +#67"



  &'#"$$



 +#!&")2"!))4   + )*")$"&...

/0 " +    -- -$&")*"!))4"

 +# 7   # -   1 

  + 07 7 --  "



- 7 +  7 @$%&$'(!))4

44A1  +#:01  067---6 

7: 0-# 00  1   -

  "0-     -- 00"

)3"&)"!))407: 0 7-1 

 + 

- )*")$"&...  &!*  7 

@$%&$'(!))432A"

 +#&4"&)"!))4  + !.")2"&...0- 0 

&34&/0 -60 -#0 0 

  0 @$%3*(!))*!A"

7 70&&")*"!))*0 7-1  +

 7 @$%3*(!))*44%4'A"

927!:& -6+ + 7 -6  

/07  - :#  +  

 7 "

/0 76067- -0 1 +

-0 60/0 7"

927!:! -6+ + 7 -#0# 

-#0"

-    + +-"





9!!7& - 67 70 1  

670  0"



9!!"&"7& +1  67 7-6+0   -

  :7- '131.1&)#!&  1  -

:7-    "

 !!")*"&..'  

-  -  

 67 7 0    000 /-   

# '0@ # /  0 04A"

#  -  / 1  - -     %$&&

01/  # "

 7- 0  0 0 0

70 "



9.7! +167- -660- 00

-+0 0!#67+# -+0707

 #60-  ::  0- 0#1

  00 -+ : - 0 - *)"

76   - 0/7-+0 : "

   #7 -+ : - 0 :0 0

67+# # 00- -60-6   1# 

00  676 0!)0"

# -   @0+ +#:7 

 +    - -#7-0#70   - 

-60  0  A

9.7! >-60

-6   ?-  -#7-0:7"

   %$&&0;

00#$)"&&"&..*

 7&$!67+#   # 0+< "

 7-0   67- -660 #

&2143@&!A"

  - 67- -66006 067

+# 6  31!4"

 00:  01 070@&'A" B 

0:  0:731!4@&$1&4A"

76   / >  ?#>  0 ?31!410

-607"0  -0/21.*"

 7 7 0  -0&1!.-6- 0 +#

6  "

  0#70 67+# # 00- 

: 

9.7! #70 :606 "



 +#-   + > # ?/  !7/ #

  /7#--    +-   

/ 7-"

 D0  9.7"!0 06  E7-E

6  / 10 7   @%A/10 

    - 0+"

76   -6067+#  707

6 67  "

0 D067+#   67      7 0

#  070- ";7- -660

 70  00 -  

927%4"





9!$7! +1 67- -660/ 01-#

- 67 7 0 1 :67- -66

070 0"

  -  +070 67+#  

10-  7: 0 67 7

-0#:1   6+1:#-600

7#:# +70 -60 60:  "

 7+  067  -#/ 070 

67+# 67 767- -660"

 0   -6  -  70 71 

0  0# 7  7    670-

67"

#76   0  # 0/ B -

0# @ # /  0 021&&A7 0   

 670-67 "

 +#-   1  # 0/#+70 61  

00:  1#6 0  "



 D067+#  +0 0 : 

9%.

6 ! -"

- : : 7 0   : @: 7 0  0A

0 0   ::

9%.7".  -#7-0

 #: 00 : "

76   67+#  0:   "

9*3    06/ :6# 1

0 0  6 -6  -

-06   "



9!$7!  0 67  0 

00    670-67"= 7-  7

6   1  # 0/  0    7 671

#   "

  : 

 ##76  1 -

#10  -- :: 7 0   : 

 7 0  06##0"

 7 -60 67 7- 0   0 : 7 0 

 :  7 0#0 06##07/  :6# 

/ "



 +# # /-0#  

0 #@.3%&)$A"

 9.!7&+:1  # "

 7 + +# /-0 6 #0"





-)3"&)"!))407 #

67+ /-0"



- #= 7 ;7+/- $)")2"!))460

67+ :7--  0   + @&)*13*A"#

&!"&&"!))4 # 0 #1- #006 -

0 @&)4%&)2A"

--60-#06 - 67+ -# #

:6#  0  +/# 1   /0 

 : +0  0  000  

1067+-#:"

7 +  0 -  -61   -#

 7-- : +#0#0 0 0 

: "0 0 #70 07-- 

: -  

 0 7 -  0# 1

 7:6# -- :67+0 "

-    + 

- 67+ /-0 

 93'7!#0"





























((