Legislator Case Law & Legislation
EVGENIOU ν. POLICE (1981) 2 CLR 213 AI generated

Court dismisses appeal for attempted illegal departure but delays sentence execution due to youth and lack of counsel.

Case Number EVGENIOU ν. POLICE (1981) 2 CLR 213
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Cyprus (CY)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Supreme Court dismissed Andreas Evgeniou's appeal against concurrent two and six-month prison sentences for attempting to leave Cyprus illegally. Although the appellant, an 18-year-old with prior convictions, argued the punishment was excessive, the court affirmed the seriousness of the offenses under relevant departure laws. The court declined to order the sentence to run immediately from the dismissal date, citing the appellant's very young age and the fact that he filed the appeal without legal assistance.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Sections 3 and 5 of the Departure from the Republic (Regulation) Law, Cap. 107; Section 3 of the Citizens of the Republic (Temporary Provisions on Exit) Law, 1974; Section 147(1) of the Criminal Procedure Law, Cap. 155: Appeals against serious offenses must be dismissed, but immediate execution of sentence may be withheld for young appellants who acted without legal counsel.

Keywords

AI generated
attempted illegal departure concurrent imprisonment sentences youth mitigation in sentencing lack of legal assistance Criminal Procedure Law Cap 155 dismissal of criminal appeal execution of sentence delay

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Sections 3 and 5 of the Departure from the Republic (Regulation) Law, Cap. 107
107 and on one count of the offence of attempting to depart from the Republic without the permission of the Minister of Interior, contrary to section 3 of the Citizens of the Republic (Temporary Provisions on Exit) Law, 1974 (Law 49/74) and was sentenced by Eleftheriou, D.J.
Section 3 of the Citizens of the Republic (Temporary Provisions on Exit) Law, 1974 (Law 49/74)
107 and on one count of the offence of attempting to depart from the Republic without the permission of the Minister of Interior, contrary to section 3 of the Citizens of the Republic (Temporary Provisions on Exit) Law, 1974 (Law 49/74) and was sentenced by Eleftheriou, D.J.
Section 147(1) of the Criminal Procedure Law, Cap. 155
Criminal Procedure—Appeals against sentence—Groundless appeals—Whether to be discouraged by ordering that the sentence should run as from the date of dismissal of the appeal—Section 147(1) of the Criminal Procedure Law, Cap. 155 (as amended by Law 12/75).
Criminal Procedure (Amendment) (No. 2) Law, 1975 (Law 12/75)
AI generated

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

ΑΝΑΦΟΡΕΣ:

Δεν έχει εντοπιστεί νομοθεσία ή απόφαση ή δικονομικός θεσμός στον οποίο να κάνει αναφορά η απόφαση αυτή

Μεταγενέστερη νομολογία η οποία κάνει αναφορά στην απόφαση αυτή:

Δεν έχει εντοπιστεί απόφαση η οποία να κάνει αναφορά στην απόφαση αυτή

ΚΕΙΜΕΝΟ ΑΠΟΦΑΣΗΣ:

(1981) 2 CLR 213

[*213] 1981 September 2

[TRIANTAFYLLIDES, P., MALACHTOS, SAVVIDES, JJ.]

ANDREAS EVGENIOU,

Appellant,

v.

THE POLICE,

Respondents.

(Criminal Appeal No. 4238).

Criminal Law—Sentence—Attempting to depart from the Republic by sea, without a passage ticket and without the permission of the Minister of Interior—Concurrent sentences of two months' and six months' imprisonment—Appellant’s young age and two similar previous convictions—Sentence not excessive in view of the seriousness of the offence and object of the relevant legislative provisions—Not made to run from date of dismissal of appeal in view of very young age of appellant and because he made the appeal without legal assistance.

Criminal Procedure—Appeals against sentence—Groundless appeals—Whether to be discouraged by ordering that the sentence should run as from the date of dismissal of the appeal—Section 147(1) of the Criminal Procedure Law, Cap. 155 (as amended by Law 12/75).

This was an appeal against the concurrent sentences of two and six months’ imprisonment which have been imposed on the appellant for the offence of attempting to depart from the Republic by sea, without possessing a passage ticket and for the offence of attempting to depart from the Republic without the permission of the Minister of Interior. The appellant was eighteen years old and he had two previous convictions for similar offences.

Held, that the offences in question arc, indeed, serious, in view of the object of the relevant legislative provisions especially when such object is looked at against the background of the anomalous situation prevailing at present in this Country; [*214] that, therefore, the appeal must be dismissed but in view of the young age of the appellant and as he has made this appeal without legal assistance no order that the sentence should run from to-day will be made.

Appeal dismissed.

Appeal against sentence.

Appeal against sentence by Andreas Evgeniou who was convicted on the 25th June, 1981 at the District Court of Limassol (Criminal Case No. 9738/81) on one count of the offence of attempting to depart from the Republic by sea without possessing a passage ticket, contrary to sections 3 and 5 of the Departure from the Republic (Regulation) Law, Cap. 107 and on one count of the offence of attempting to depart from the Republic without the permission of the Minister of Interior, contrary to section 3 of the Citizens of the Republic (Temporary Provisions on Exit) Law, 1974 (Law 49/74) and was sentenced by Eleftheriou, D.J. to two months and six months’ imprisonment respectively, the terms of imprisonment to run concurrently.

Appellant appeared in person.

A. Vladimirou, for the respondents.

TRIANTAFYLLIDES P. gave the following judgment of the Court. The appellant pleaded guilty to the offence of attempting to depart from the Republic by sea, for the purpose of proceeding to Greece, without possessing a passage ticket, contrary to sections 3 and 5 of the Departure from the Republic (Regulation) Law, Cap. 107, and, also, to the offence of attempting to depart from the Republic without the permission of the Minister of Interior, contrary to section 3 of the Citizens of the Republic (Temporary Restrictions on Exit) Law, 1974 (Law 49/74).

He was sentenced, respectively, to periods of two months, and six months’ imprisonment, both terms to run concurrently.

While being in prison he appealed, without the benefit of the assistance of counsel; and today he appears in person and has not requested to be afforded legal assistance.

He has contended that the sentences which have been passed upon him are manifestly excessive.

He is eighteen years old but, unfortunately, he has two previous [*215] convictions for offences of exactly the same kind in respect of which he was sent to prison for three months.

We agree with the learned trial Judge that the offences in question are, indeed, serious, in view of the object of the relevant legislative provisions which the appellant has infringed in committing such offences and, especially, when such object is looked at against the background of the at present prevailing in our country anomalous situation.

We have, therefore, no difficulty in dismissing this appeal.

What we have had to consider with some anxiety was whether this was a proper case in which to demonstrate that groundless appeals are to be discouraged by ordering under section 147(1) of the Criminal Procedure Law, Cap.155, as amended by the Criminal Procedure (Amendment) (No. 2) Law, 1975 (Law 12/75), that the sentences imposed on the appellant should run as from today. In the end, we have agreed that we should not do so in the present instance, in view of his very young age and as he has made this appeal without legal assistance.

Appeal dismissed.

cylaw.org: Από το ΚΙΝOΠ/CyLii για τον Παγκύπριο Δικηγορικό Σύλλογο