Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/733/2005 • CJ GE DCSO/733/2005 Généré par l'IA

Defective Service of Process Invalidates Enforcement Order

Numéro de cause DCSO/733/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The situation involved a dispute over the validity of service of process for an enforcement order regarding outstanding financial obligations, with the service allegedly being defective due to an improper address. The court determined that the service was invalid because the process server failed to strictly adhere to the mandatory statutory requirements regarding the address for service, concluding that strict compliance with the rules governing service is essential for jurisdiction and that any deviation from the prescribed method invalidates the service.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Defective Service of Process Invalidates Enforcement Order: The court determined that the service was invalid because the process server failed to strictly adhere to the mandatory statutory requirements regarding the address for service, concluding that strict compliance with the rules governing service is essential for jurisdiction and that any deviation from the prescribed method invalidates the service.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
notification d'actes autorisation d'exécution condition de validité validité de la poursuite service financier violation d'obligation d'entretien LP.89, LP.159, LP.39, LP.43, LP.22, LP.206

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive section to allocate court costs.
Art. 68 al. 2 LTF
Cited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of compensation for the respondent's legal costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/2333/2011
Defective Service of Payment Order Nullifies Enforcement Proceedings
A/499/2015
Service of Process Nullity in Enforcement Proceedings
A/376/2016
Defective Service of Payment Order Nullifies Enforcement Proceedings
A/3554/2019
Defective Service of Payment Order and Annulment of Enforcement Proceedings
A/1956/2017
Invalid Service of Payment Order Nullifies Enforcement Actions

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section to allocate court costs.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of compensation for the respondent's legal costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

     

DCSO/733/05 



                         

 9,--090..:& !# "$  , #( 0..:            !#6!"!$ #  !#   $5!!!##!# !#;.+'''<8=#=>>>>>>? 7



$!!##!5$@       3#$3!#?!#  (# $A/  B<:  /../##  *  !"#$ #%   ?#+B   0.-  /0//#1(-  *  &''%  !#=!/,   /-:B  /00< 3

      !  "!!  !# "$$ ! % "$  $!&$ $#!' ! !!#(!#""! !  "!! ) !*!# +&   ,-+.& /0// #1( ,2&  3#$ 4# ' $!!#$!!#5$&#!'61#!"!!# $#$!!# )7/87/2!#56#!1 ! ""#3)70.27  ! !#!5  !#  5 # !"!!#   $!!# 5$  #$#!##!1(#13!"$$5!#(!$ $!!# #5!#!(!!#7   

7 0+0..:&C    ?    ?D 5! #!#!# !#;.+'''<8=!!3$#=>>>>>>? & # ##  004,-<&-."7  $!#  ,4.++"7   :4..."7 E$  !(#/8$0..0/<#(0..,7

 F""!  ! )!* 1@ F""!2  !$  5% # %  5#$5!!!#"$# !!!3$ #=>>>>>>? 7

 F""!  ""$& # 6#(!  6! 0..:& ! 3  !13  =>>>>>>? &!>>>&G>>>>>> 3&H!##$# E$ #!17   ##$  !!  !! FE (#& F!# # (  $!!#&!'!3$#1 !#F# !!$&F#!#& F# $  I&  % 5   # $$ #!5 ! (  !=>>>>>>? 7

 F$!#F###!#F!#!=>>>>>>?  #F ## $$"'7

 (!###!!$##(E$'#5 #J 0..:#F# ## !$(!#!!7

7 =>>>>>>? $$$$#"!!/8 0..:7

7  , #( 0..:& $# # #(  ! ##$   $5!!!# $!$&  C     ?     ?D    !!  !!#$#F# !# !#6!"!$#!# $5!!!##!# !#;.+'''<8=#=>>>>>>? 7

7 # #   $  /- #( 0..: ! $  0: #( 0..:& F""!$$#!##$5F!(!""$ ! !""$#$5!!!##!# !!!3$#=>>>>>>?  "!#!#"!!#!17

 

/7  !!#  $#   $#  ##K  !# !!3$ #   !   3#  F'$!# "$ 5! # #  5 (!6!!! !#"#$# $#$#! 6!!#6!"!$)7/<L7/.7/7//70L7:B 7, M27  ! "  ! #  ##$#& !#$ ##   !#&  #!$   #!   ! !!# $!$ #

F!#$% !  # F!#$%  ## 5! # #  !   $)7007/27

# !# $#!6!!#6!"!$ %"$#  )7/<7,27

# # 5 !(#&  !3##  5!$   !# F#  !#6!"!$#!#$5!!!##!# !7

? !# !"! ' '!3#  "   ## !   ! )7/,7/027

#(7

07  #  F7 -8 & 5  $!  6   !  (!  !!&F""!& 1$ !#$5!!!##!# !& 1 !!E"! $ F""!!H(#!#!!7 ?#F7/:8&F!6 ! (!"!!&F""!!! #!"!#!#!#"!!1$ !#$5!!!##!# !7

F""! ! 3! # & !  ! #  ' 7 #  (!# #$!$(!!#/B$/88+#$#(!3/6#(!/88<& F7-8 $!!5F""!(!##!$5!!!##!#  ! # # $!  ! 67 ?!  $! F  $$  $  F'!3#F#!#N#O&#F !#3F#     55 6 # 5F! " 63  F'!#  ## F# !#6!"!$)P 7?""&!F'$!#&Q,#;:<LR ##9 C!!# P& #!& <1 $7 0..,& Q// #;:& Q00 #;,<& Q,B #;+L !* !!$#& #!&  7-8 #;+7L #$ 7 & !# ?R&  7-8 #;0& ,.  ,,L " ##& !# ?R&  7/:8 #;/.L  M39 S# ! P9  =7 R9 =!# R##& ?R&+1$7/88<&7-8#;/7/:8#;//.27

 $ F'$!# "$ ! % #$ ( !!3#  ""!!$7 5F! E! !&$3!F $(!*%&#!## $!!$"'!#F!#&$! !#0. 6 #!"!!### E)7B87070& 7--7/LP ?""&!F'$!#&Q,#;B.27

!&F!" ## !""!$ !55F""!  ##  '$  !!&  F#  $! )!* !!$#& #!&  7-8 #;:2&  # $($  $5!!!#  #!#  ! 5 F""!   ! # ! # (#  (! ##K    !   ! )"7  !!5 !$ !# ?R 0..+ 7/0&"!#$ 8:4+<:!!'$$#1(#0..,27  #

""  (!  ##     ! !!#  F""!  E# #$!  5  '!3# $3  $ !# %  $& F""!$##T$!3$F3#!"U#!# "! !   !   ! !!# ) C //8/L  ?9<0B9.: #!707  08 #( 0..:L  ?9,-09.+ #!70   0. 6! 0..+L ?9,0:9.,/,J0..,L!*!!$#& #!& 5!#!('7/*,.#;,27

,7 # F 1& F""! #F   $$ !#!"& !5F!  ""$ ! 3  !13   !$$ !(!&  '!3$  !#  # (#!  #!!# !#!!$$$!!& $!###!"!!#(!3!# 1#5 7

 #'5 $# !#!"#$##5 !#   !#6!"!$7  C#!# !3## !   #!3#  1  F""! (#  " !#&  (! 5 ! (! $$ ##$   $5!!!#7

+7 5!#F(1"!## !###F 17#""&F""!F  $  (!  #!#  ! #!$$& #  #  # #!#!#  (!  !!  5  $!!  # !$$ ##E 6 ! (!"!!)7,87/7-25$# "!# F6   ! #!$$ #F     5  ! (!"!!')7+,7/27

#!!# $(E##F7B.!"$$ $(E# "!##(!!& (!(#  !#(!!$ ) * ? -,/7+.2& $$ # (  F7:+  ! !&  C     ?     ?D  (%"6!!5F#"#!#! !($#7-. 7#F #! !5#F7+,7/&! C#!# (! ! !#   $! #  $5!!!#  #!#  !    6! # F $6 $!$ ) C //- /,L !* !!$#& #!&7+,#;+-727

$ !#$5!!!##!# !#!$$&F""!! # J $!  #!"! #  # !#!#  "!!   !$$ !(!)7/:827

,77    ! $# $( # F!#$% !&   # !  F""! # F# # ( F'$ # !! # # )!* !!$#& !  & "!!  #& +1 $7 0..:& #;-:.L P 7?""&!F'$!#&Q8#;0<27

  #FE"! !&#F#&##!$$ 5 F""!  # ! # ( F'$ # !!&  5 ! #F  $7

,77 # ""& !  ( 5  !$$ !(!  $$ $$ # "!!  /8  0..:7

 &#F70.B7/& !!!3$##"!!F$!3##7 $#C#!# !(#!#% !#"!! !(!& # !#!   F!#!!!(   C#!# !3##7  $# $!!##$#!##!5$!F""!"!!7

 E!#F""!F'!#!# !#;.+'''<8= E $#T7

:7  $  !#  3! )70. 7/ 7/ L 7B/ 70 7  27# %$#$ #)7B07027



VVVVV



  (            )



'&"$*)

/7 $ (  !# 9,--090..: "$  , #( 0..:            !#6!"!$ #  !#   $5!!!#  #!#  ! #; .+ '''<8 = # =>>>>>>? 7

#"+)

07 # F'!#!#   ! #; .+ '''<8 =        "!!=>>>>>>? 7

,7 ET7



,-&+%@ =7  W =   & $!#L ==7 !! ??   !!# S  X&637



# !!#(!#@

 #E   W=     !*3""!1@  $!#@ 



      $#$!!##!5$ ! F""!##$  !3#' ! 3""!1