Financial Transaction Dispute and Liability Determination
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case involves claims related to various financial transactions occurring in the early 2000s, with the court considering multiple sets of dates and amounts as evidence, including submissions referencing events in 2000, 2001, and 2002, and involving several distinct transactional periods. The court reasoned by analyzing the presented evidence, which included numerous referenced schedules and exhibits, to determine the liability and appropriate financial adjustments among the parties, ultimately making specific findings regarding the established timelines and respective entitlements related to the contested transactions.
Regeste Legislator
OfficielAbus de droit. Cession des droits de la masse. Procédé téméraire. | La poursuite dirigée contre la plaignante en vertu d'une cession des droits de la masse n'est pas abusive. La plaignante et son avocat sont condamnés solidairement à une amende. | CC.2.2 ; LP.20a.1
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAApplied to order the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Texte complet
DCSO/683/06
;./.:;200<( "#% 1= $& 2. 200< " ( &#%!##%6&!!>> (*(%3*9
&##%%#7&?
!##&? !!>> (* 11(!% 120<%3*
!##&? !!>#@AB (* 22(!C% 2-00 , !"#$%&'#& (#
! "# $## ! # % $&!& !# ' $& " &#(!&"&%#)"# ##%!*#%!$$#!"# ! $## + #,#% -( " ./-0( 1211 %3* .4( "5%& !6% )"&!##%!!&##%7&(!%!#)8!3%#$##%!"&%!&##% +91:914#%78%#3!"#"$$!%5+92049 !# #%!#7 "#% 7 % !#$##% ! !&##% 7& !%!&%#%% #3*%35!!#$&!&7#%*#&"!&##% %7#%#*##%9
9 85% ! 1= # 1:::( # % ! "#3 #%% "%%& $##!)D#5E9
/%* 200F(6$$#!$##&#>BGGGGGG"6#%$ !$#76&##%#!& ##!%#*" "% !1F62/.$9:0#6'%!" !6""%#3! )H!:!& 2002##"##%!&#!!#)8" 67#!9
' !( 6$$# ! $## $# *# > BGGGGGG 76 !%!!6%&%##*##%*%#&%%"&%#%%"#% !!2F-62.<$92."&%%%%!!5 #" &%# +!&* "&*## 4 " "% ##& % % 7#& !65%"% !%I!#&&$## &9=F- 96#%*###$#%%J!6##1/%* 200F!7%#3 %%!## &!"&%#%9
9 "# %!& ! 1/ 8%*# 200<( 6$$# ! $## &!& GGGGGGE ( &%#3 ! $## !# 6& ! #% " % %% ! 2262F= $9 -F( !# ! ( % "## !# #%*%#& %K F <( *# % "&%#% % "% ##& % 5%!#&&!%>BGGGGGG+%%765%!$#4 %&%%*"&#&!1F62/.$9:09 %!6!#%(% !&#!!)%!3&"#%(&##"#GGGGGGE "$#*# !#9
# ! = 8#% 200<( 6$$# ! $## &# > > ( %#!>BGGGGGG(7!1F62/.$9:0&&%!% #%#7!"&%#%%"% ##&*#%&&#%*%#&&!&9
9 10 8# 200<( 6$$# ! "# +#,"3? 6$$#4 %5#& % &7###% ! "# !##5& " GGGGGGE % > BGGGGGG % *%!11F62/-$9:0"#%&'FL!31:8%*#200<(% !#%!6$$#!$##!1/8%*#200<9
1- 200<( 6$$# %#$#& > BGGGGGG % %!% ! "H("#%K0<MMMM1-7!%#3$&""##%9
9 "&2. 200<(>BGGGGGG!&"&"#%%9 %%%%#%9 % %(3576'! !6"" % #3 ! ) H ! : !& 2002 && %! )#*%% &%&$#(#&&$##%6&%""#"&!( 76""7!%#3*#$#*#%&%!$! !&##%8!###("&%#%%#'"&#%%"7 #%#%*%(#1F62/.$9:0%%11F62/.$9:09 $$#76# 65##!6%!6$$#!"#*%(#!6%*%&! "&#& ! # %# % N N9 > BGGGGGG !& 7 "# %#!&& %6 %#$% %$%!%!%O$#&!6%%%7#%&" !#%!!#!("%76%##*!6% ! !#9
% % ""( 6$$# !& 7 %% #%!#7& !% &7###% ! "##$#5%%!%!"H76%&#%6 " "&% ! "%% 7#% ! *# # %% % "#%!%%(%"#%(""#*#% 8!"#%9
%*#& !&#%( GGGGGGE ( 7# "" 76 5# % 7#& ! #%%#!!#!(%(*#!!&"%( 8! "#%9"&#&$#*#7&5#%!"#5%%%!&"* !"3!&#)"#%*#$%##!&&#&9
199 ##%!&%"&%""#%% #3 !P)&#%$&+91=Q91091Q9F<9.R49
*#!!# #!##*#8!###+91=91 49E# P)% ! 7#% ! !# &# ! ! 85 !#%# + C 11.2( !# #% R! 1:/:1204( 5#$ 7P% "# "&%# % %#$ ! !#( "#%#" )"#& P9 2 9 2 * !% P% ! P! 8#!#7( %&%#% * !*% P#& ! *#%%%7P#!##5&%P###%'!H%7P$$ !# ! P)&#% $&( %% % "&%#% ##5# ,' +C*# ( #% EA( ! 91= %K2=Q #, ##&%( %#( ! 91= %K//Q C% %!#( # %5# S!%!##5@#(A%T!% #@%1.U.0EA(2000( ! 91= %K2=-49 % 5#$ " ' *& %% P%% ! %#$##%!P%%!%!"H(7#!#P"#%!P$$#! !%%#&7###%!"#%###% 8"#%+91=9149
!&#"""#%!!#)8"!#O"#5%% %%#% ! 7& +91= 92 49 P#& ! *#% !# % !P$$#( #%!&"%!% ' ! "#% +922 4( %#& ! %# ! !#"##% &!#& !% P#%&' " # !% P#%&' ! "%% %% "# "&!(
##% ! &% % % #3 5#$ ! %#& *& ' !#*%(#%#%!*#!&%%&(""&$%!&(&#! #%!% %#&!7#%%"&%!%$$&9
19 9 %P"3("#%&&!&"&%"#!%$"# "3! ##%!*#%%%%!%!"H(# %8"#%(""#*#7#7#&"5#"*# +91=912Q91.49
!%!&&* 9
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
#%# % ! !# 7&% 7#( ! &*#!%( %%! "#* % "%% " ! "&%#% #%)#% "$3 ! &5#%#%8#&7###%!"#!%!P%*# ! &7###% +EA 1::1 "9111( #& " #, ##&%( %#(!7#%!#*)9./,-F%K-0 49 %# &5%% %#$!!#(%#%%"%#&!"#( $#!P#%%%"#!% !"#%&"#% &!# ! "%% "#*# +ER 1:/= "91F<Q CR 2001 "9..1Q B%# %); ,B%# E#%( %% "H#7 ( % 2001( %KFF/ 4(#!%% %PH%"#%!""*"&!, '(%"##"%!&# &&%"#*#9%#$##%! %!% ! "H #$ %% " %# ! &% # " ##"#*#"#%!#"%# ##&! #%%H%! *!%%#"%(%!%!#%*&!6""##% ##85!#%#(#"# !%#% !!#+ C
11F1/( !# ER 1:/: "9 -00 R! 1::1=<Q E;=F;200< ! : $&*#200<Q E;F==;200<!F 200<Q'! # %%%" #&! 1< # 200<( =9.<;200<Q $9 #, ##&%( %#( ! 9/ %K.<(!91=%K2.(!7#%!#*)9./,-F%K.FQA XY#;E(#%EA(!9<:%K1F49
H"3%"*%'!#7P)"#%%%(6$$#! "##&!*#%%!*% #%%$Z% 85!#%#(P5!!P% !#%%! 7P#$)#%#P#%##%!!#!P)&#%$& %##*( !% % "##( !P %#$ ! !#9 $#%( %# P$$# %# ##% ! &% %P% "%!% "&! % %H ""$%!#!!##%%9!#*%%"*%!P)#% !P% %#$ ! !# 7 !P&&% !P% % !P#%!# %*5% !&%% ! $Z% "% 7 !# #%##% !&%&!$#%#&9
P8 7 %#$##% !P% %!% ! "H "&% % H%&5!P#%""#"#%+91.F92 49%&7###%! "# " !% "#* %#7% $#%( 7# % 35 5&%& &5## ( H "# 7 &%# % !#" !P% # ! #%*& + E;1/0;0. %#!9.9 ! 22 # 200.Q E;F2-;200- %#!9299 !2/ 200-49
29 9 %6"3("#*% %(%!!1/8%*#200<(#%! !#!(#(%"##(#%!6%"&%#%%"% ##& %5%!#&&!%"#*#+%%765%! $#4,&%""&7%%!!5 #"&%#(*# %%!!&*"&*## (!2F-62.<$92.,!6%&%%* "&#&!1F62/.$9:09#!##!*7 &%&$###!%$! !# !6#% #% "3 #7 "&# % % "" % 76% %"# # 7# % !# ! "&$&% 5#% ! "3( % %7* %*#%!&#%&876%%! %% ! &#% % "#( #%&' $# 7 6&*% )&!% *& +R%, H( 7 &$)#% "" ! #%!!#!%!692<0( R! 1:::"9-.,--49
6%#7"&%#%( 8!"#7&(!&!#% !!#!%$*!"#*%9
#%#(%#%7#%"#5%%%*##%!35! %%$#+$9%#!9.99.9 94("#%6%#%#$%#%$%!&( %# % & !6% !6% *%& ! %# ! "#*%( %6 !%"%##*!6% !!#9
%$%!&("#%8&9 .99 %$&%)92091(<1929<292 (#%PH" #!"*#!P&%!8#(%#!P!!&"%9 $#(% P9 20 91 "9 2 ( "# % "&%% 7# ! "&!& &&#!*#$#"'%!%&%%!!16F00$9 )##%#7P"#%!&%!!& 9
E"!$Z%&&#!*#$#(%!692091( #7#(%*##%!!*#!65#% %%$#($%% *# !6#%&' % !#5% ! "#% #% 7 ##% % $# % !# # #( *% " %# "&! + C 12= 1=/ &$&%49 !#"##% " ! %#%% % ) #%##% 8!### *& 6&( 7# # $# ! $#% "% !## % *##% ! 35 ! %% $# +#, ##&%( %#( ! 920%K1:Q C*# (#%EA (! 920%K11Q C% %!#( "9#9!920%K1.Q A %%;C#!#%X(%!#( =3 &!9 200.( [1. %K1-49 P % ! % ! 3 ! "#% !# P8 !#% !P5# ! %#3 &&# +#% !( #% ,( ! 920%K--49
.9 9 % "##( # "" 7 %# "#5%%( %# % %# 7# "!# !%%5&#%!!#!!1/8%*#200<+"#3%KF4 ! 6$$# ! $## ! = 8#% 200< +$9 %#!9 9 %! "5"4(%"*#%#5%7#%6%%!"&#&(!%# $# )"&% %#% !% %!% ! "H( "# %% %%&%!1F62/.$9:0#&5%%"&%#%% "% ##& % 5% ! #&&9 #( $ ,# ! %76#%$#"*!*#$#!&&#&%&5%7 "#$##&!6%%%7#%&#%#$%"!#% %#!&&9 %$&%692091"92(#%%%&7% %!%&#!#%"#%!6%%!(!%%%'& .00$9
\\\\\
) *
+,%'*
& * "#% $& 2. 200< " % %!%!"H("#%K0<MMMM1-9
&%-"*
19 89
29 %!%#!#%>BGGGGGG> %%!!.00 $9
.9 & "#!%#%9
./,-(?> #% X ] B( "&#!% Q >> #!# EE ##"" ^(859
%! ##%!*#%?
C##""#%> #%X ] B $$#3? &#!%?
"&%!&##%%#7&"# P$$#%%&" #5%)"#"5$$#3