DCSO/61/2007 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

DCSO/61/2007 · Statutory Service Requirements and Default Judgment Validity (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appeal concerned the application of a statute requiring service of a subpoena to be executed by a specified authorized official, where the petitioner argued that service performed by an individual lacking the requisite certification was invalid, leading to a default judgment against them. The court reasoned that because the statute explicitly designated the authorized officials for service and prescribed specific execution requirements, service attempted by an uncertified party was fundamentally defective and could not confer jurisdiction, thus invalidating the resulting judgment and requiring the matter to be remanded for proper service and further proceedings.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Suspension de l'instruction. Saisie provisoire. | Le montant de la créance qui doit être énoncé dans le procès-verbal de saisie est celui indiqué dans la réquisition de poursuite, respectivement celui retenu dans la décision de mainlevée. | LaLP.13.5; LPA.14.1; LP.83; LP.112

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

validité de la notification condition légale incompétence ratione materiae défaut d'une partie manquement aux devoirs de magistrat subrogation de la collectivité publique

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order imposing the costs of the federal procedure.

Généré par l'IA

A/3085/2007

Statutory Service Requirements and Personal Jurisdiction

A/2637/2005

Service of Process Statutory Interpretation and Default Judgment

C/29500/2018

Improper Service Renders Judgment Void

C/14009/2020

Appeal Admitted Due to Void Judgment Based on Invalid Service and Right to Be Heard Violation

C/15687/2018

Appellant's Challenge to Default Judgment Due to Improper Service and Pending Related Action

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order imposing the costs of the federal procedure.

Texte complet

DCSO/61/07

:++;2:511*% " 0< $! 0; "/ 511* " % ! #! = 7> ?%%@(

!&!@A

!A = 7> ?% 02% "210 050005

!" # $%& & %'(%!#%)*)*)!#% !A =8= B% C!!0; 051) C ++%* ! &$)(&(%# &

! " " #$$ " $%&! "" $'()*(+,-( . !"! /$! !%011102% 34&$ #3"! " "! !'(011(05( 6- &4 ""$$ 78'(011(+( 6-( .! 8! 8$$% &%&#&! 9 "%.8!'(25 6-(

( >DDDDDD> ""! " EC C= F%+% GDDDDDD@(33 !"H "%&!!@=( DDDDDD% I" 8! /J% 3"! 4& @ % !! ! !! 90K;K% DDDDDD> 8!! I"(

51 0KK;% / " ! @ DDDDDD > 8!! I" 4&I0;"/0KK;%"% ;/0KK;%"8! !4&I0;$!0KKK%% 554 0KKK%78! "/ I$""!" DDDDDD> 8!! I"% DDDDDD > 8!! I"& (

00KK;%=( DDDDDDC!%C/% !"H /3 " "!! >DDDDDD > @ DDDDDD > 8!! I" ( @ C !! 2 0KKK =( DDDDDD DDDDDD > 8!! I" %"!!" =(DDDDDD=(BDDDDDD%!& I DDDDDD> 8!! I"& (

( DDDDDD> 8!! I"& I""9! 9 $$! @ "! 4 5111 @ !/ 5115% " 5)5#0)5%)1$(% ! & C/ =( DDDDDD ! !;/5115@/%>DDDDDD> ( & "/! ! DDDDDD > 8!! I" & /& ! L"$% ! & L(

* !/5115%"C CC DDDDDD> 8!! I" & !8 % >DDDDDD > & @ " M153333<+ " 5)5#0)5%)1$( !. @ ) N ) !/ 5115( " I "!!% $ & >DDDDDD > I " " !7 4 ! @ $ I"" $! "9(

0K 4 5112% !& >DDDDDD > @ "M120K01)*""!! 5)5#0)5%)1$(!.@ )N 0)O5110%I$$ "'C"AI$$-$$ "9 @ DDDDDD > 8!! I" & %&H$""(

48 50/5112% / " !/! >DDDDDD> $ &. !"( $% 0< $! 511) "" >DDDDDD > % 4 ! 48% "! ! I"" I DDDDDD > 8!! I" & "9 M123333)* ! 3$ "! " )11$( !"$ >DDDDDD> (

!"!01511) /39% !!!@I 524511) 2 4 511) / /3 9% DDDDDD > 8!! I" & 8! >DDDDDD > /! (

48 51 $! 511*% / /3 9 " I /! I DDDDDD > 8!! I" & %!& @>DDDDDD> 5+K#052%01$("!.@)N 045110 0#521$( " !. @ ) N 0; 4 5115% "! ! !$ "9M123333)*@7 % &"M123333)*@ (

( 00/511)%>DDDDDD> &"@I I DDDDDD> 8!! I"& @ 5)5#0)5%)1$("!.@)N 0)O5110(

* !/511)%I$$9!@ DDDDDD> 8!! I" & I $3! 0* !/511)%" +1;#1)+%5)$(9"!.$(

( 0) !/ 511)% DDDDDD > 8!! I" & ! I " % $ &I " . " & " $%" /""3"@ "%&I /! (

! >:0*5:1* K 511*% ! 4! " # DDDDDD > 8!! I" & !#$$@"! @" !$%&48 / /39 51$!511* !$$% / (

( 0<511*%#$$! >DDDDDD> $ A '- @ $$% # " !$P'-@(

5< 511*% >DDDDDD > $! #$$ & 48 / /39#!" !$$ &#$ "! @" / # DDDDDD> 8!! I" & " 5)5#0)5$()1!.@)N 0)O5110(

6( 5 511*% #$$ !/ "C/ M 12 3333)*( @ &A'-@#!@5KK#+2K$(21P'-! !" # A)1)#)12$(21 !.@)N 00KK; ! '-0+0#5*2$(;1 !.@)N 5+0KKK '/-0+5#5;0$())!.@)N 5240KK; $( "C/!!Q">DDDDDD> ;"/511*(

( !"!0;"/511*%>DDDDDD> !"!" "C/ %!M123333)*((>DDDDDD> "#$$ "C/ !( #"" "%""&# #(+;%""" !. !! " ! & " " !!"!"&#!"!"! !"( "C/ &( #"%>DDDDDD> &###"""/ ! "#$$ "C/!!.!4 !" &. '0</511)-4 "$$'5511*-( &#% & " "@&#!!"& 4 !!" 0<$!511)( +1)#;+1$(*1 !" &. % " +00#)*) $( K1 4 " $$( >DDDDDD > & #$$ O " DDDDDD > 8!! I" & 4 (!&@&# !@#$$ $ "C/ ! @ 5511*(

?( / 5;"/511*% DDDDDD> 8!! I" & &"/4% "!!( 3" & 8$ $ #!. " #$$ !&% R " & !7! " !$ $! ! #. 4 !( DDDDDD > 8!! I" & "" $$ & / /3 9 ! @ 5+K#052 $( 01 " !. @ )N # 0 4 5110 @ 0#521 $( " !.@)N# 0;45115! >DDDDDD> &

"! #"" 48 # " !! !">DDDDDD> %C#!/!@@$ 48 "( DDDDDD > 8!! I" & %"!/%@" # " 4&#@ 48!" 4#""$!48 / /3 9 51 $! 511* % !7!% 4&#@ ! " !$("% DDDDDD > 8!! I" & !/ >DDDDDD> (

( "" 0< / 511*% #$$ 3" &# # $ ! .! " / /3 9 48 51$!511*" !@%" !.( #$$ S $ & $ & 48 "!! $ #/4 # "" & # "! # "% &# O"C/ "& / "'A 4-"!!% 5)5#0)5$()1"!.@)N 0)O5110(#$$3"&# O $ $8 "C/% @ ! "% +00#<);$(+)'!T!.-"$ "( # "" @ 4 & @ #""! $ "C / !" #. 4(

,( ! +/511*& " # "! "% >DDDDDD > ! #"" @ "( "" & " " " !% & " $$ "!$& ! !"(& " !/.3!! !$ & 3 . &! "C/ "( . &! 48 !% # /! #! " " " 3! "( >DDDDDD> !&&"C/ $! &# &&"" +00#<); $( +) " $ "% & # #$$ "" 0</ 511*( $ " # " " " " $! " 0;"/511*(

0( "! " !! $! " " I! "! 4@"""9&!" 8" '(0<P(01(00+-(

/(

5( >#(0+()%"! 05"/ 0K;)' P)01-#""&3"! 3"" !(

3 #(02(0 %& #"! !" # & % "! "! # ! $ #/4 # "! " !%" "! "% !7!%."!4&#@ &(

>4" %L (L '. / $ 02(1K(0KK+ :5;5:0KK+C -(

#"%$ # &@ @&@ ! " "8 !" " # /! "($$%# #/! #"/@ "#".7 "" &!"'$( (+((C -( ""@ ! #" !$&#$$ 3!! "$!@4$&# @ # # "! /! ( " @" # "! " .4!(

+(( I(;+(0%&!"!! !% !"%"! ! "&! !/%&! " 48 &I "! ! @ I "" I( 0*5 ( H!% !/ "% 51 4 @ " !%$ "/! '(;+(5-(

! ! "% ! $ 7 48!% " "! $!& "%

&! "% @ " I 'U (>$$% I3!%V2M01)-(

$% $$ "% & / ! "% I @ I$$ " !& " 48@!&48 !"(>48 3!&"I94""&I/! I " !! !% &I !! ! &I !! 4! " 48 "! $ '7( 5 3" $8 $( M0-% I$$ " 3! @ "( " I"/ "!&I&"' 6K5 )*%, 0K*<%, 0K*<2-(

"&! " 4&#@ 48! # /! ($$ I I/! % & I " / @ "% I " I/! "3 " !" &!!(>"$"8 "/!# !/! %! !$'(;+ ( + - 'C/ !% % ( ;+ M 0; P ! >7 % C (;+M)P 600<0<%, 0KK+ (5-(

"$$"!$& ! !" ' 6015; (5%, 0K<<;*- .3!! .$Q & !$' !>7 % C (;+MK-( # & ! & . !! "C/ '(005(0- &! !& "'(*<(0 7(+-%" ! !(

+(/( I"%"%". 4 0<$!511)% / ! " #"" @ 5)5#0)5 $( )1 " !. @ )N # 0) O 5110( #. ! !$$ 3! & ! & "(#/! !""" ""%I@/ &I$$&! "(

7% $ # "8 &% $! 3 "" ""!% &! "C/ &! (!& O. !& "'5)5#0)5$()1-P !.%&@3% O . ! 4 #!/ "C/ % % #"%5511*(#$$ 3"! "" 0</511*(9 # " # #$$@ $"C/ "! !(

2( "! " 8 '(51 (5 7( ) P (*0 (5 ( -(".! !"'(*5(5-(

WWWWW

, -

+). -

! / " :++;2:511* $! 0; "/ 511* " >DDDDDD> "C/ %!M123333)*((

$ " # " :++;2:511*(

(+)!-

0( " :++;2:511* $! 0; "/ 511* " >DDDDDD> "C/ %!M123333)*((

5( @ #$$ " $ "C/ % ! M12 3333)*( ! @ 5511*(

+( !/" (

% #A =(!89G%"! P=6 > =(7"" X %48CC(

A

9 !89G C8$$A ! A

"! !&!" @I$$!" 83""8$$

Statutory Service Requirements and Default Judgment Validity

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet