Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/579/2007 • CJ GE DCSO/579/2007 Généré par l'IA

Property Covenant and Guarantee Enforceability Dispute

Numéro de cause DCSO/579/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involved a dispute concerning the enforceability of various agreements and covenants related to property rights and obligations between multiple parties, including a principal party, an occupying tenant, and guarantors. The court determined that certain agreements, such as a guarantee and a covenant to pay property costs, were valid and binding despite claims of misrepresentation or invalid contractual formation regarding other related agreements. Specifically, the court reasoned that the agreements in question were clear, unambiguous, and supported by independent consideration, concluding that the principal party was liable for the agreed-upon obligations, while rejecting arguments attempting to void these obligations based on the status or validity of separate, associated undertakings.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Commandement de payer. Abus de droit. | En l'espèce, des circonstances exceptionnelles permettent de conclure à l'existence d'une poursuite abusive sont établies. Sauf à protéger un comportement contraire à la bonne foi, l'on ne saurait admettre qu'un prétendu créancier utilise la procédure de poursuite aux fins manifestes d'exercer des pressions sur le mandataire de sa partie adverse dont il désapprouve l'activité déployée sur instructions de son mandant. | CC.2.2

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
obligations contractuelles droits du locataire garantie indépendante contrat de mariage règlement du litige déclaration d'exécution

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 93 LTF
The appeal is declared inadmissible because it concerns a final decision regarding the admissibility of the main claim, which is insufficient for the admissibility of the main appeal.
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The losing party (Appellant) is ordered to pay the court fees.
Généré par l'IA
A/4500/2006
Property Rights and Contractual Obligations Dispute
A/809/2007
Restrictive Covenant Enforceability Dispute
A/2217/2006
Contractual Obligations and Property Rights Dispute
A/1474/2001
Contract Enforcement and Property Interests Dispute
A/1701/2002
Contractual Dispute and Breach of Agreement Enforcement

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 93 LTF

The appeal is declared inadmissible because it concerns a final decision regarding the admissibility of the main claim, which is insufficient for the admissibility of the main appeal.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The losing party (Appellant) is ordered to pay the court fees.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

     

DCSO/579/07 



                        

 >0?(5>$#32(#&'?%$#2@"ABBBBBB"



'4'CD  

 

  

 !!"#$%&'()%("*%

 !"#$"$"  %&' '  (#) $+ , -. / (#0"((*1    ' 2 2     && 2 &34'   22 &,"+5"061" 7 '2'  %&' '3((83  9)4& :92'  2 2' ',"("($" -1 4) 22&& ;<,"("0" -1" 7' <'  <&&3 434:4' = 237<',"8$ -1"  

" 47 @"ABBBBBB3!&& 2,E2D!&&1&'3  (+ F $#3     2=3 2 G*# 9999?0  C @BBBBBB      2=3 2 G*# 9999?8  C @"HBBBBBB32'''2) 2   0::&"2'7C+I (0%$5  J   ,1                                                      K"

''&22' !22"

"  (5F$#3@BBBBBB@"HBBBBBB&'!&& 42'! 2 42  @"ABBBBBB34!!)<C2C4 @" HBBBBBB ' !  4    !L   & 2 @BBBBBB3!) @"ABBBBBB" 92' 4  2 <' C   !  &  ) 4  '4  4!  7  ''  %3 MCC'2C9 2   @BBBBBB"4 !&&3C23   2 4 C @" ABBBBBB !92 J'K    2= 222C  3 223 !     2=3 2 *#9999?0*#9999?83% 3 @"ABBBBBB  )&   2'  ' &' C !" #0 "( 3 ! !%2' 2     3   '  ' ' 22''"

  $* F $#3 !&&  ' ' !  C @" ABBBBBB  92 J'K     2=   4    '' %&'3 22C 2 *#9999?0*#9999?8)4!C4! '& ! %& 23 !@"ABBBBBBC2  =  2 &&' C  '    C     %&    2 )4!C !92  ' 2 2 2   = 2"

"  $0F$#3@BBBBBB@"HBBBBBB2'2     '3 3 2'%3 C  2  !   2 )4!C  '  !&&3 C 

23     '  !&&  $* F $# 3 223C! 2*#9999?0*#9999?8"

   $8F$#3  '&'3C  23 ' !&& $*F$# 22 2  '' C      2  !    )4!C  '  !&&    %&    2"

"    8 2% $#3 @" ABBBBBB   4' C !&& 4  2*#9999?0*#9999?8''2&4    ! 2'  2' '   2 J     ND&& &O ,1!" # $ !     %&     ,1!     '     &           ,1   & (       K3  4 J                NO   &  ) *!&     )      NO        NO !  & NO       '    K" @" ABBBBBB   92' 4   '' 2  J   & NO    NO  NO +     )  '&, -     K  4!  '< 2 @"HBBBBBB    & 4!@ BBBBBB ! 2 J       ( K4!<22 !L  HBBBBBBP '"

@" ABBBBBB   ) C   2  9 3 '  $Q  (# ) $#3     )< !  ;<   2' 2'>(580#>$8"

  2  2''3 !  @" ABBBBBB  2   ! 4 2 @ BBBBBB       2'  2' 2''34J ,     ,  &       !,     )   ./ 0         &         (       1       (&        K"  !' 2  2 4  )< ! J    NO  &          N@ ABBBBBBO!       !         !            2 3   !                 & K"224 ;% !'4' 2 @ABBBBBB <   !%  & =   C !2  @" ABBBBBB 

$8 $5   4 J       K 2     2'   2'9 ! 2 2'  @" ABBBBBB"  < & 4 J       K  ' J          K3 3 3 4  & %"ABBBBBB/ 'C2'   2' C !  @" ABBBBBB3 4  @ ABBBBBB3   '4' &!' '3''    34' & '''< '''2'44!   &2 4' 2"

 92''3! @"ABBBBBB 44!2 2      &  % "ABBBBBB / 3   24&!%2') 43 23  4'  2   7 '"     7 ! '' BBBBBB/ 3'' @ABBBBBB!= '4 44& '2  & %  "ABBBBBB/ "

"  82%$#3R(*3@"ABBBBBB2'2  '  !&&  $* F $#3 ' 2   2   2    '  $8 F $#" / 23 @"ABBBBBB 4'4 82%$#2  %&' '! 2''4!&23 ';'3 ' !&&"

-"  '  $# 2% $#3 &'   '3 !&&  ''     &&  2  *# 9999?0   *# 9999?8  <'3 23@BBBBBB@"HBBBBBB"

 !&& ''3%342 <'@BBBBBB 2'  ' @"ABBBBBB !9 2C3 2'' '  !2%'  ' 4! %  <  @ BBBBBB 2 7  2 2%" /!<   2 <'  @" HBBBBBB3 !&&   '' 4  & 4' 2 @"ABBBBBB 2  2    @ BBBBBB ' J' &    K  4  2 2'  '<   ' !9  2   @" HBBBBBB" !&& 3  3 42 ''' !%  "

   '3@BBBBBB@"HBBBBBB'24!  '2'$0F$#''=' S2   $%$#"

"    ? % $#3 @" ABBBBBB  &' 2   '  !&& $#2%$#34! 4R$%$#    !"

  !22   23 @" ABBBBBB 22     )2   % &' '      ' , -((+  (?   />+##>*513  4     9 2 %.   4 ' !&& &' ' 7C '"@"ABBBBBB24 2&4!2 <'     2 2   J       K 4! '; !%'29"/2''3 J  ,  K 4!2 <C2    3J    &      !         K3 !2"

/!<  ' 23@"ABBBBBB'2 4! ! ')C 4' C!&& +2%$#3C 4!2;C@BBBBBB !;')< !;<   2'  2' >(580#>$8 <'    & 4  '  '     &  % "ABBBBBB /   ''  '4!!=2 234 !C2 22C '<" &  2 '4  2  ! 2'3  %<   2 %   9   ;  BBBBBB3      2;2 2  &"

A"   %  $$ % $#3 @ BBBBBB  @" HBBBBBB ) 2C&  ' !&&  $#2%$#"

 < '22'22''2E2 2 4 %"

!&&!'&''9&  ' $#2%$#"

" @"ABBBBBB292' D

E 2'  2' >(580#>$83  4   '' 2' !4 ," (85 13  < '= ," (+? 13   &&  !&  2')   ' ," (58 13  < & ," (5+ 13  '   2     ) ,"(5Q 13 !& C !" 5(      4  !<<  '3 !4 ," (85 13  &9   

,"$+( 1  ! ," (+# 13  2    )< !"       2' 3 @ BBBBBB 2' @ABBBBBB39E'2 @"ABBBBBB34!&& &  T<"

 2E%9 !2 2     >0588>$# , />+$Q>$#1C4@"ABBBBBB'24' 2<3 '4 ''2' ;&2''D

E J  ! &  NO        4555  % 6   7  8$ 91   6   :!     NO     N!O                NO          /   8          6   !     & 6        4.'  4554!   N!O     !           ,  1   6                 !           &  +   6   !       ,     !           6                !                   &                  N4! !O   6   !   '  &            6         1!              NE 7O ; <  $9=4 =>:!  !   N4!O  NO        6   !    , & !,   ,                       NE 7O   !    !   !  6     &        & ?         6    

7 8$ @=>@5?9=A:!      B  ;      !      &       6   !      ,NO    & &               6   !        !     ! ,         6   !       * 8$!             &!     ' NO !   '  ,!& 6   !  ,       !       N4!O NO  *8$ C    ),*         &          !                          , NO !    

                ,        6                          &  , NO     !            &      6               )   8,             &       K3

E J       ,         6$*;$0C;D  N% "ABBBBBB / O        @..A,4554!                      &                  B !         &E      /< FG@E.AA!.A     ,         6       ,           &  /C$           /< >=EF.A5A &                 6$*;$0C;DK"

E 2'  >0*(Q+>(QQ?  &&     '29 ABBBBBB3  2 " @ ABBBBBB  2''   2' 2@BBBBBB"

E 2'  >$+Q*>$82 <'2@"ABBBBBBC!  @ ABBBBBB3 2  !   2" @ ABBBBBB  2'' 2' 2@BBBBBB"

E 2'  >(?5+?>$5  2  %<  2 %  @ ABBBBBB3  2 " @ABBBBBB2'' 2' 2@BBBBBB"

6"  < !&& 224@"ABBBBBB3'  '%(Q+03 ' @ABBBBBB3 2%$$"! 'C@BBBBBB$8"

 /<  3& ; BBBBBB / 3 2'  ? ) $$3  '' S'    ''  '  2%  (5  $#" 64! ) $3 4!  ''  '  <  3 @" ABBBBBB '    3  <   "  2   3 @ ABBBBBB    <  "

/<  T<3& %"ABBBBBB/   '' 2'  $Q ) $$" @ ABBBBBB   %   ! 4 <  "

 

("  2' 2  '' &'  2  2  !' 2' )C222=4'2 <2 ,"(#."(*"((0."+5"061"

 %"

$"" /  )2   % &' ' ,&"  - #"05>$5  (5$5 "$"(.#"8+>$5 $?)$5 "0"(.#"$(Q>$5  #"$$*>$5  (5  $#  " 8"$   7 '13  2'   2  !" (#   2 2 !%3  4 !" $ 3 !   2'   2    M  <& !%  4'C! 2'<. '2 '')< , -((0$36 (Q?Q($*1"' ! 2 2 %   2 & 7      92D34!&4'< %    22   2'   23  2 2 '%''2, -((+(?36 (QQ(#51" '<   ' 4 2    <'' 2   2   2        % '2   2 4    !&&   2 E7 4!!<2 '%&&&,771"

$"%"  !23   92 2   C !9 !2%'%"

  &  '  && 4  2<    2'   2C & '' %"&& 224    !9' &' 2 C  E  '  2  2'  '%   ! 2'   2 !9   3 ! ! <  !9' &' 4 C  & 2 '< C  2 4   '' 2' 2'  % &  3 4 ! 2 2'<' 2   ,"$ " $ . 2 9"  />(0(>*#  $$  $#  "$   '&'1"

 3!32<!4C!;<  '&  '7   9E'2      2 2'  

2    4    2 2"   3  %3 4      '  <      !9'    &' 2  9E'2     ! 2'  2' 2   " /  2 !&& 4 J             %    K32;C  !;')< !  ;<   2'  2' >(580#>$8  & 4  '  '     &  % "ABBBBBB /   ''  '4!!=2 234 !C2 22C '<"

 /&C2'<2C%&3!  4! 2'  '   2'   2 9 & & !9 2  2   '22 !' '2='  "  !2)&' 4!2 <'UC2&4! ! 24  !2U2V  ' '4 '2,4 2 3".&" /;H(QQ(32"((( "+14 242&,2%' !%' <3 %3"1342< <"

   !)3    C )   '3   % !    !    C !  !9E'2  2<3C3D

E 2  23<  4' 2  2<   '4  23 3  23      2    C    ' 2  )< !;< !2' 2' <'3'2'' 4  2< ! 2     ;  BBBBBB /  2)$3 9&  2;3 42' 2'4'22<'''$8 22'$5.

E % 2C! @ABBBBBB3 @BBBBBB V  'C    !9'  '& '7 2' !222<.

E    ! '  !L   4 @ BBBBBB  2='34 !)44 2<!)  '22''"

$""  42' 3  ' 4!C%  4!&& ''2 '' &&2 !%  "2 '47)'"

0" '&,"$*"$;"+."5("$"1"

WWWWW

  +

           ,

-.!'),

' %  2 &'  ? % $# 2     ' !&& 2 $#2%$# ' &&  2  *# 9999?0   *# 9999?8  <'3 23   "

(!'/$,

(" )"

$" '%2 "

"01./*D @" '<= X3 2' . @"  H//E /3 )< .@"X   3)<22'"

   D 

@ /  '<=X &&D ' D 



    2' '4'2 C!&&'2  '922<&&