Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/560/2007 • CJ GE DCSO/560/2007 Généré par l'IA

Contractual Breach and Performance Dispute

Numéro de cause DCSO/560/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on multiple contractual obligations and alleged breaches concerning the delivery and acceptance of specified goods and services, with claims involving issues of quality, timing, and associated penalties or remedies. The court reasoned that the evidence and contractual terms established clear requirements for performance by the defendant, and that the defendant failed to meet those standards in several instances, justifying the remedies sought by the claimant, including specific financial adjustments and enforcement of penalty clauses where appropriate, while also considering and dismissing certain cross-claims based on insufficient proof or correct interpretation of the governing agreements.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Cession des droits de la masse. | Condition de validité de la cession. La demande de cession des droits de la masse formée par l'intimé (créancier) est tardive. | LP.34; LP.260

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
inexécution d'une obligation contractuelle exécution en nature différend commercial exécution garantie d'exécution qualification du contrat

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs for the federal court proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/2303/2003
Contract Breach and Performance Dispute
A/1781/2002
Contractual Breach and Performance Dispute
A/374/2007
Contract Dispute Over Performance and Financial Obligations
A/3733/2005
Contract Breach and Specific Performance Dispute
A/952/2007
Contractual Performance and Breach Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs for the federal court proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

     

DCSO/560/07 



                        

 >05*?>$#3 2 (#  &'  $8 2% $# 2   ! "######3 '   :'   @ ;2; AB3 3 C "



'4'CD

$  !"###### 'D   @ ;2;AB3  -E  20#?(  ($((0  $ "%###### 'D   @6F ;/@@3 <(5  208*#  ($((0    $ &''( &))*######   !"#$"$"  %&' '  (#) $+ , -. / (#0"((*1    ' 2 2     && 2 &34'   22 &,"+5"061" 7 '2'  %&' '3((83  9)4& :92'  2 2' ',"("($" -1 4) 22&& ;<,"("0" -1" 7' <'  <&&3 434:4' = 237<',"8$ -1"   

"  )<  #  $03  %  2   2'  & /GGGGGG/ 3=<999999C.(E)$83 7 % '4  &"

 ''2'C:3+3((3 9'3 (#:&"  (#:+&"3C: @"HGGGGGG33I53' +:&"C :  @" JGGGGGG3 2'    K 2  2'' 2  %' 2F &"/I?3''2'  2  @"JGGGGGG3C:& % &2+#:0?*&"E*"

 -< '< C :3   ($ C (#3  2' < C : @" GGGGGG3- LGGGGGG/ 3@"HGGGGGG3@GGGGGG3 @" JGGGGGG  @ GGGGGG3 2    (85: &" 2'    < % 2  ' , ' 2'%1 2  2%'    4' :< 2%   '' & ," #+8  13   3   4 2'93   2'' 92'''"

"  ' 2  2   '' &9'  +  $8   & !%) ! 2% -   8&'$8"

 !' '' '2'#$832C+$8" ! &  '&& 4!  !7     6  (?%$+& '& ' !&& !' '4 !' '' '2'"

  ;  & @" MGGGGGG  2   '  ?+:0(( &" $+ 4  ''  0"

 @" HGGGGGG  ''   C :'     : ' 22' : (E:8#8&"5*"

"  $5&'$#3!&&&''4!   '  2  C :  @" HGGGGGG 4  @" JGGGGGG  22  '4   C < F7  ;   '%" '($$#'22 ' 22"

    #  $#3 !&&  &'  ' 4 :    & : 2  '' &&   &  ' 2  )   2'   @" GGGGGG3 -  LGGGGGG / 3 @" HGGGGGG3 @ GGGGGG3 @" JGGGGGG 

@GGGGGG  22  '4   C &   2' " '(E$#'22  '22"

  93:&&2'4'4'2  2 '22':% ''22  22"  '3 2 3  4' 43    N  )'  '<2' :&&3' : ')C&&    :"$5*3   7 ' 2'C:&&  '2''"

  ' ($$#3; &@"MGGGGGG4  ''  $5&'# $#"

 $0  $#3 !    &  ' ' C  ;  & @"MGGGGGG  C! @"HGGGGGG @"JGGGGGG 2'C!+353?(("

7)3!  &' 'C; &@"MGGGGGG     3 2' C !   ($ C (#3 C !  @" GGGGGG3- LGGGGGG/ 3@"HGGGGGG3@GGGGGG3@"JGGGGGG @GGGGGG"

"   2   '  (0 ) $#  ' C @" HGGGGGG3 9999C3; &@"MGGGGGG32: 3 !&'4!%   C"  )< 2  '    $0  $#   @"HGGGGGGC :<'"

/ ', OP 1 32 ''' %' C@"HGGGGGG(#)$#"

$8)$#3@6F ;/@@3&'&'C   3'2 4!'''2@"HGGGGGG4!' ;<'  '& '7"

 0K$#32'''C: ; &@"MGGGGGG 4:C $* 7"

"    '  $ K $#3 @ 6F ; /  ' C :&&4:'4:222'    "

!&&'2 ?K$#4!2'&3'4 22   3 ' #$#3 '' 'CC999999C42  '' ' 2    ($  $#    Q       R" 2     #  $# ' )C43C  =&<3''S2  EK$#,&"2I03;<' @"HGGGGGG1"

   '  0* K $#3 " HGGGGGG3 2 :   3!''4!2'9'& (*$#  'C999999C24 # $#92' 'C7 !232'4  2'999999#$C"4' ' &3          3    &3   C !&&   '     2     C   '"

02%$#3!&&&'C@"HGGGGGG4  #  $# 4 ! 2' 9 '  (*  $#   '' ='C999999C34'''C!&&    Q       R  4! !'22%  "!&&&'4  '   "

(*2%$#3@"HGGGGGG'''  "

 '3 2    $0  $#  92' '  ($ 2% $#3   2S    $0  $#3 !    &  ' ' C  ;  & @" MGGGGGG  C @" HGGGGGG      2' C !   ($ C (#3 C !  @" GGGGGG3 -  LGGGGGG / 3 @" HGGGGGG3 @ GGGGGG3 @" JGGGGGG  @"GGGGGG"

-"  $82%$#3; &@"MGGGGGG2'2C  ' '    4 ''&'(02%$#C"

 &4@"HGGGGGG 2 :&&2 4'       3 2%% 2 4: : 2'(0)$# ;; :<'34 472% ! "

   43   )2 3   &  ' '3 4 @" HGGGGGG & !< )    2%'9F< /GGGGGG/ 3 &234!   !  2='"  ) 4 @" HGGGGGG  '< '% &C; 08:&"2 C%' 2 234!2% 2=3722  +&"24!! 2= 2"

 &3)4!  %4'    '&   @"HGGGGGG3!< 2'2%'<  &32%4    2''  2 && !  22   '    &  < '"

 223!&&924@"HGGGGGG!24     '22 #$# '9 '" '3T4@"HGGGGGG!2S 3    = '  2      Q       R"  2' & 4    3 '<  '3 4!   ' C @" HGGGGGG C   9999999C2"

 !&&2 4!C 2 22 3 224@"HGGGGGG !9 C'2  ;@"MGGGGGG (0)$#34!&  $ K $# 2 2 !&&3 4!   '<    4  4'' '' 7'"2'434 @"HGGGGGG '$K$#'' ''2 C  '3 '' ''%  &' 2  9 ) 2    !9   " !&&!22&C!22'   '"

 /  & 3 !&& 22 4   )2 3  ' 2     2< <3 F 7&23C 4 ''4  <  4! !22  C !    &  C   ' !27;!9' 2'& '  '  &  ' !     4!    7'4'2"

'C '23@"HGGGGGG '3%34!'' &' '% K $# 4 !&&         '' ='9'4$K$#2  !&&" @" HGGGGGG   )   2    '2" /% 3   4 !  &9   ' & <2' "



 

(" /&    N   2   ) 3  2 7 2' 2 C !' 4! !&&C

2T2)&'&"2 7 '2'  9)  N2< ,"(#"($"+5"0 6."(*"(3"(01"

    '  2' 2 '&   ' !  2'' !"$5*, -((0(0+.6 (EE*E*1    ) C 2"   4 '   &3  2<  4'2<2"32''&'2 2  & 22"

  %"

$""   7  (E % $# ,+ G08#>$#13  % &' '  22' 4::'%4&C ' 3 :FCF  )' '3 C<F74:  72&& , -((?+# "036 (EE8 +5. -((0(0# "0%36 (EE*E*1" :=3 <3 2 :%' ' 4 ,"$0("0;" ( 13  '   3  223 24' 2      2% 9 '"  &3   3  2  ' 4 2 7 ' :&&    2 2  '  3 C':  '4C ' :&&  <94   7 2'  &S 92 , 6> 3  3 "$5*I#3(0(81"

$"%"   4   3  ' 4   %   3  2  2'23     2     9 )     %'  ' ," 8? " (  -13 &  2' )&  '2U       %' ,"8?"$ -1" 4 37 '2 9 '    23    ' &  7 2 4   '2U  :'   ," 8E  - . F %'3 3 "$5*I$E1"

$"" :23& /GGGGGG/ '4 '2 2'  3 :&& 3 2   #  $#3 ' 9 ' :  '4C'C< '  (E  $#   '' 2 2  &"   7 '3  '''C       :"$5*"

  '  $0  $#3 :    &3 & 4  )'  '3  C  22 2     #  $#3'C&F7 '($C(# ' 'C2<4&    '2"  2' &'499<22'F "

0""  &&&2'.&&'2  '  2    S C  4   ! 2 ,"081"

2 '2 S  2  &  !&& ! &   2  2 , -($(((.6 (EE#(?51"

!<  !9' &' C 4    2  ' Q2R32 < 2 C  2  3      ! 2 %C, -+*(?836 (E$+?81"

    '<   '&  3       ' 4 &  ! 4'   ) N !'' 2  &&   ! , - (*8  ($3 6  (E#E  ($0   7'. -((*E36 (E?#$?. -($*((836 (EE#+*1"  && 2 4!   9    22 !93   2  2   '; 4 ! 2     2  %, -((($?$F$?0 "$%.F%'3 3 "0(I$?1" 22 %&3!''  <!9  '3 4!2  2S !9 V C '&  4  4    22 !%' 2  ', -(*##$36 (E?0 0$#. -(*$%E(36 (E#?58E1"

0"%"  !23 !   2  2 !'% 4    #$#'' 'C@"HGGGGGGC999999C3 <   &3 2 2  '3  C    5  $#  ' C !&&    Q         R"2''! 2S"

  '3  22 4:  '' &'          & ; &@"MGGGGGGC'2  '4      '  (0 ) $#3 4!  S  (#) $#3  4 ' )      $0  $#"    : 2  S  23 4   3 & 92' '&' 9 3  '2   $8 ) $#"  ! & 4  $K$#3W)2 34:! 'C!&&2!& 4!4' ' &3!' 2S !&&    " 2 43   '2 4 3C 3@"HGGGGGG  2  '; 4 ! 2      4!    !9 " !&&3&&3C2  #$# !222  ?K$#34 S  3) EK$#3:=&< X  X,&"2I03;<' @"HGGGGGG1" ! C  4  2''       9     # $#"3!40*K$#3<)2 34!!  ' C!&&2      &      4!   4'3 4!C '&3    7  '' 2"

-  4          43 7  !&&      0* K $# C    '3  2  K '' '' %  '2' 2  9)2 !4'"

! C4!&&  ' 32   $0  $#  4'  (0 2% $#3   2S $0$#"

   '  2'2   4'"

8" '& '2,"$*"$;"+."5($"1"



YYYYY



  +            ,

)& -,

' %  2 &'  $8 2% $# 2  .  ! "######   '       3 '  $0  $#4'($2%$#3 & /GGGGGG/ "

! (,

(" ! "

$"        3 2    $0  $#  4'($2%$#32S $0 $#"

0" '%2 "



/0&(*D @  BL  M3 2' . @ - /    @" ; M  A3)<,1"





   D



@        BL  M &&D        ' D

 "   2' '4'2 C!&&'2  '922<&&