Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/557/2007 • CJ GE DCSO/557/2007 Généré par l'IA

Tax Statute Retroactivity Challenge

Numéro de cause DCSO/557/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerned a challenge to a statute concerning tax liabilities, with the challenging party asserting that the legislation violated constitutional guarantees by imposing taxes retroactively and retroactively altering pre-existing rights or obligations, particularly relating to assessment and collection procedures. The court reasoned that while a statute may generally impact future conduct, the challenged provisions did not impose new taxes or substantially impair vested rights but rather constituted procedural amendments to an existing tax scheme; therefore, the retroactive application of these procedural changes to assessments covering prior periods was permissible under the constitution because it did not impose an unexpected financial burden but merely streamlined the administration of a validly enacted tax.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Minimum vital. | La poursuite se continue par voie de saisie s'agissant d'impôts et de cotisations AVS. Pas d'atteinte au minimum vital de la plaignante. | LP:39; LP.93

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
législation rétroactive assujettissement à l'impôt taxations fiscales constitution perception de l'impôt droits procéduraux

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/2809/2007
Tax Amendment Retroactivity and Vested Rights Challenge
A/3090/2006
Retroactive Tax Statute Violates Constitutional Prohibition Against Retrospective Laws
A/2735/2006
Property Rights Challenge to Retroactive Statute
A/1500/2005
Tax Amendments Retroactive Application Overruling Judicial Judgments
A/1169/2007
Retroactive Tax Application and Legal Certainty

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

     

DCSO/557/07 



                        

 >05($>$#32(#&'$+2%$#2



'4'?@      !"#"$%&' ('))*#'+')' #,%    * %'))#-. )%&'    !!'-#).($)('&)

 !"#$"$"  %&' '  (#) $+ , -. / (#0"((*1    ' 2 2     && 2 &34'   22 &,"+5"061" 7 '2'  %&' '3((83  9)4& :92'  2 2' ',"("($" -1 4) 22&& ;<,"("0" -1" 7' <'  <&&3 434:4' = 237<',"8$ -1"   

" 47  &' '/3  9)' ,2  *5 9999AA   *5 9999A+ B1   CCCCCC ,2 *59999D( 3*59999(DE*59999*$13:&& 2,F2@ :&&19'' ?: GCCCCCC3?;  0!($* &" 2 3    ' ?  2=3 ECCCCCC / 3  (*2%$#"

   2F%   ' H *5 9999AA   2 !&&3 4GCCCCCC' 8:+(5&"5+4;<  (:0D*&",% :@(:(&".& 2@$$*&"& 2@ #*&"1"!&&!2  ! 32 '2='"/!< =3 4'4G"CCCCCC3&   '%3  &'    )&&  2 3 4! !%   3   ' '   2 2   2  ;<"

"    $+ 2% $#3 G CCCCCC  2' 2 2    '!  &'?2= ($2%$#"

 '4!< )?2 2 &"

 32;?!&& 223   3  ="

    ?    ' !  !&& 2& ?   )4!? )<'%F& '"

"   ' 4'2?  2 24!($%$#"

     3 G CCCCCC   4' 4 G" CCCCCC !'3 ?   3 ?!&&22' !9' 3 4!   &&' )< 4!  3     '   2 4   3  2 4  )&& 2 =!''2 "

   '' 43 2  F&' $#3  ;%   BCCCCCCC3  4    &< 2   %I 9   4! ! 2 &&'  ;< !  2  !&&    22   <  4! ' '  ; JCCCCCC"

    ?    '     ;< $# 4! ;&& ? 0:08D &" 2  ,@ (:$ &". &  2@ A* &".  @8*&".=@D#*&"./@#*&". @88D &"8*.2K@0+*&".@#*&".<@($*&"+*1"/!< 2  3   2'' 4! !<  !   2 F 7   ;   ! '<"  ?  2 !  3    4' 4!  2= 4      ="   '< 2   2 !   &   2 H*5999905 / <' ?  3 &'    G" CCCCCC3  (#2%$#"

 GCCCCCC2''4!  3 &  )'3   ;;  9 ;L      ;L43;4! ?M32   = 22%"

!  3  '2?GCCCCCC '  (D % $# 2 2   2    %  !22 BCCCCCC 2 ! 4 )&& 2  9;<3  ?2%$#"

   ' 23 G CCCCCC  2   2 !   %  (8&'$#222  92 BCCCCCC  F7  4 GG" CCCCCC  CCCCCC  '<'  N  O    = !' ? D &"3 2 #* &"  ;<.  2 ! & '   / 2  2'   $D  $#  8 ) $# 5D&"+* '?G"CCCCCC3>GCCCCCC3ECCCCCCP / 3 GCCCCCC?34! 'N    O  (*&' $# '% 2 QEE / !   88D &" 8* R 2  2'  (0($#"

"     $0 % $#3    '  &' !&& 2& ?  2  2 ? !&&3 ? CCCCCC  ?  &' ' /3  9)' '2 ' 2"

   ' 23 CCCCCC  '' 4! !  % ? &" !&&   &' ' /3    9    )'!2'2 "

" GCCCCCC<    2 (+$+"

 < 2 2  QEE /3  22 4  2 !  ,1 GCCCCCC 8$8&"8*2423? !92   &'$#32='"



 

(""    '  2' 2 I  2 <'    2 2  <  !9' &' 4   2 4%2)  2& '2'  '  ) )&',"(#."(*"("(("$."+5 "061"

("%"        ) ? 2   2  4'2<2"

(""  2  7 '2'   9 )   S  2<    ,"(#"$1"

  :23  22 4  2<       2    !     ?  2=  ($ 2% $#"  22I  4  23 &'  $+ 2% $#3   " '3  2'2 !'72%  !'7  2  2 ?  2'  !9' &' 2 3  22'4'<32 !"0D3& '3? !&&2 ," $$ . F% '3 3   "0D H(A.  3  /;E3   "0D H+. 4 <3  F3   "0D HA. > -  T;3  3 # ' " $03 UD H(5"1"  7342 234 7' !&&2, -((8 #A "036 (DD*  (5$. 3 F "$$H$$.- 3/;E3  "$$H(0.< GV;3/;E3 "D0H5+"1"

   ''424 229< & 22" $""  2   2   & 4  '%    < !! 4''''?!"0D3 2  4'  N;& !     ,"D08  D0+ 1O ,"0D;"(1"

 !"802' 92?!)?22  &3   '      2' ? 3  2 2   !2K3 %3 '3 3  2  2% ?2%4? &,"80;"(1"

 22 &94')  2%422%)'& ' 2%"

$"%" !23'%) 2' 2F% 'H*59999AA2 ? 2K  /"  !<  ' & '    2%   '3  &' ' /  CCCCCC3   )   2%"   2 2   &  9 2  '" !&&   2' 2 ?! 2<"

 <&'2  & '"

0""    !" D0 " ( 3     3  &   2 3   <3  7 4  % !3  2  2    4  ' ?   2  <2' '   !32   '  2 4   2 %    !" D$ 3 273 ' & 42'2' 2%2 !  '% &"

2722?2 !9'  " /3   '3 !&&   !  & ' 2     3   2 !2    9 ,"D0"01"

0"%"  ! '%34 7&9'&  &9 !9' , -#"$>$0 ((% $0  " 8 , 2%' 9 - (0*  8+1. - ((+  (*0  " (3

6 (DD((*A13 ''%   !%'' ' 2! ' 2 3<   3  !   2 !' $# ,/>  0 5*"*81"   !)?%,;"1=&&&  <  '%& ;&&<,;""(1"-'<2       !    % ,;" "013  '2 2%?!9 !'2&34& 22 ;  ,$$22?AF(*&"1&  '2'2 32 <''   :% 9 2 2%4 ,G; ;3 F3   "D0H($813!)&'?;<  '%,;""8"%1"

 ;3  & 2 !3  7   <3  & !'<3   '4   <L  3    & !3 %  2 722"232K3&'3 3 3 &     F   ''2;    

 %3"342 !%<& 2 2    ,/6$  $(0. -W  3  /6 $#A83AA1"

/  ;< && 2='  7 2  2      '%, -($( $*36 (DD#(501" 2 '72 ;<4!2''2='2    2''   3   '% ' 4!  !  ! 4 '<  ! 2 4!  &&'  2  ,/6$$(0. />$$>*0 $0)$0 "$. />0D>$8  (+)$8 "$1" 0"" !232<2;?!&& 2 2%'   ;<     =  D#* &" 2 "  ! & 2 22'2 2 ;<"3!=2 ! 2  "

/!<  '2  ;< $# 4  2<  2    !  ($%$#3  '224&   ,(:$ &"1    '4 ,#* &"1     % ! (:(&"222"3 4 !&&  '< 2%'   ;<   2<   $$*&"2& 24!2 ?!9'"

2<'<  & 2,A*&"1 &  ,#*&"1"3 !  ($%$#32'' 4' 4!';2;;9;L  ;L4!2 ?=  2 2%" 3   7 2%'   ;<3 ?   &  23    #* &" 2   R  !%922%"

 2   ,8* &"13 2  ?   2' , >'<132K,0+*&"1<F  F F,($*&"+*1& 2 2   ! '%    !%'   27 ;< 2<"

 &2 ! '2='3!?)4!&& !22  ;< 2<"

 -  4!&&'   2<3 4   (:0D* &"   2   % !  (:(&"3 & 2 #*&" & 2 $$*&"

8" 2'2 )'3  %'"

XXXXX



  *            /



(" )3      %'3  2 >05($>$# &'  $+2% $# 2      9'' ?  3 &!%) 2F% 'H*59999AA"

$" '%2 "







'"0% &@ G  TJ  Y3 2' . G - /    G" ; Y  Z3)<,1"





   @



G        TJ  Y &&@        ' @

   2' '4'2 ?!&&'2  '922<&&