Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/556/2007 • CJ GE DCSO/556/2007 Généré par l'IA

Mandatory Document Furnishing vs. Jurisdictional Defect in Application Claims

Numéro de cause DCSO/556/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves a challenge to the enforcement of a statutory provision regarding the mandatory furnishing of certain documents in support of an application or claim, where the applicant failed to provide documents, specifically certain tax records, in the prescribed manner and timeline, which the respondent agency deemed a jurisdictional defect. The court reasoned that while the provision mandates furnishing the documents, the specific penalty for non-compliance, in this context, was not the outright dismissal of the entire application or claim for being jurisdictionally defective, but rather the consequence prescribed for non-compliance with procedural requirements, which did not automatically invalidate the underlying substantive claim if the defect could be cured or waived, finding that the lower authority erred in treating a procedural omission as an absolute bar to the claim's continuation.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Retard injustifié. | Retard injustifié dans le traitement d'une réquisition de continuer la poursuite. Plainte devenue sans objet en cours de procédure. | LP.17.3

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
condition de recevabilité vices matériels exécution dispositions fiscales obligation de produire des pièces délai de péremption légal

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The costs are imposed on the appellant (Art. 66 al. 1 LTF).
Généré par l'IA
A/188/2007
Timeliness of Statutory Filing and Jurisdictional Requirements
A/1544/2004
Procedural Compliance in Jurisdictional Filing
A/1984/2006
Statutory Formalities and Document Validity
A/2256/2003
Regulatory Filing Scope Dispute
A/1017/1998
Notice Content and Filing Requirements Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The costs are imposed on the appellant (Art. 66 al. 1 LTF).

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

     

DCSO/556/07 



                        

 >0?+*>$#32(#&'$$%$#2 



'4'@A

        ! "#$%&"%' "

 !"#$"$"  %&' '  (#) $+ , -. / (#0"((*1    ' 2 2     && 2 &34'   22 &,"+5"061" 7 '2'  %&' '3((83  9)4& :92'  2 2' ',"("($" -1 4) 22&& ;<,"("0" -1" 7' <'  <&&3 434:4' = 237<',"8$ -1"   

"   $&'$#3:&& 2,B2A:&&1<' '4 2C*59999D? <'2EEEEEE  F" EEEEEE"

 D(0)$#3EEEEEE '@:&&:' 2 G2B% "

 $()$#3:&&&'24 '  "

"   2'  $$ % $#3 EEEEEE   &' 2 2    '2 )&'"

 22 ($%$#3:&&92443   : 2'' 23F" EEEEEE<'2B% 2'  $#%$534   '''4' 9 22 %4   2  ($ '% $5  4: : 2'" /:< 2 <'2EEEEEE 3 22  4:&&4'2 &9  2 $$)(0)$#34:2$?)$#4: : &@:  2''$?)$#"/@  '; &3 :&&  4        $? H $#2 22$+2%$#"4 AI                                                  !     I"  0( % $#3 :;3 2<'   23 : 2'' @ :   2 & :&& :   22"   ' :%  % % %  &&'@22&"  3232''<EEEEEE4 ''4=' 2=' 2 $#"($%$#3:&&'% 2B%      '&  % 4:  4' @  2"



 

("   '2'22&' 22 ,"(*"(."+5"061 

4%2) 3!232 ' )  )&',"(#"($1"

 22 ' ) )&'27&'2 ,"(#"01"

   4 23  2<  4' 2  2  !   )&'  '4 2"

 / 2 & 9 9<  &    2 2   ,"(0"($1"

  %"

$""    !" D? 3 4  '%  ) @  2 2   3!&&32'2 '4 232     @    = & 2'  2 !&&   J    %@"

 /:"((83:&& 2& 2 2B %   9 '   '% @ :92  '  22 )"

 B2   22  2'  I  I3 :B@B  4 :&&  <  '23    2    322  ' 44)32 @  2 2   )&'3 3    <3 K  2%'   ," + 1"    23  ;3   : ' ",L "/&&3 :9'3M0 C +#  . B% '3 3   "D? C 8*  . ''  -N93    "D?C(+1"

 2'  !9'&' 7' <&&'        @  2  !&&  = '249<'<272'3!&&' O'%<' !< &G@2&2  @ 2, -((?(.B%'3 3  4 9"(B0*C01"

$"%"  :23    :    4 :&& : 2 '     < 4"  3  &&3   2  4  @ 2 '4 23<'$&'$#3 2 &9     3   $$ ) $#3 ' 22' 4  2 '22(0 7"'< ' @4'   243@:' 3  @%<,"?(1"

     ''    )&'      '4  2 ''"

  '3 :&&3   22  23  2' ' @ : &'  :22  0( % $#3 23  :%   % % %    2 :'%   2  & 23 '2B%   '& %4:4'@2<($%$#"

  2     %)    2'     >0?+*>$$*#=' O"



PPPPP



  (            )

*+$&, )

' %  2 2   )&' &'  $$ % $# 2 EEEEEE    2C*59999D?"

%$-!)

("  )&'22'2:&& 2  '4 2C*59999D?"

$" 42 %) 2' "

0" = >0?+*>$# O"





./ +-'A F  LQ  R3 2' . F - /    F" ; R  S3)<,1"





   A



F        LQ  R &&A        ' A

    2' '4'2 @!&&'2  '922<&&