Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/544/2007 • CJ GE DCSO/544/2007 Généré par l'IA

Enforceability of Arbitration Clause Omitted from Final Contract

Numéro de cause DCSO/544/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involved a dispute over the enforceability of an arbitration clause within various documents exchanged during complex contractual negotiations, where the ultimate agreement did not explicitly contain the clause but related preceding drafts and correspondence did. The court reasoned that the parties' conduct, specifically their engagement with and reliance upon documents containing the arbitration agreement during the negotiation process, demonstrated a clear intent to be bound by those terms, even if the final written contract omitted the specific clause, thus upholding the obligation to arbitrate.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

For de la poursuite. | La plaignante, qui a conservé une adresse à Genève, est domiciliée en France. L'Office des poursuites est incompétent ratione loci. | LP.22.1; LP.46

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
clause compromissoire partie au contrat clause d'effectivité contrat d'échange nullité des ententes procédure arbitrale

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to regulate the court costs (costs of the Federal Tribunal).
Généré par l'IA
A/1424/1996
Arbitration Clause Enforceability
A/4858/2006
Contractual Incorporation and Mandatory Arbitration Enforcement
A/1350/2004
Arbitration Clause Enforceability Under State Contract Law
A/592/2006
Contractual Incorporation of Arbitration Clause Dispute
A/2377/2004
Arbitration Clause Enforceability Due to Alleged Unconscionability

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to regulate the court costs (costs of the Federal Tribunal).

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

     

DCSO/544/07 



                        

 >0(?8>$#32(#&'(5@$#2



'4'AB

-  A  

-  -  

-  !"#$ $%&$' ($%)*) ' *



- &+, - "&$* 

 !"#$"$"  %&' '  (#) $+ , -. / (#0"((*1    ' 2 2     && 2 &34'   22 &,"+5"061" 7 '2'  %&' '3((83  9)4& :92'  2 2' ',"("($" -1 4) 22&& ;<,"("0" -1" 7' <'  <&&3 434:4' = 237<',"8$ -1" -  .%%' &   

 -  (($))',"&  '  $,/    - (($)%0',&%,$%

 

"   2&'C*59999($ <' D EEEEEE3:&& 2,F2B:&&19''3   0( ) $#3    < A :   2''3 A ;  (:??*&"

 :&&4DEEEEEE%34&A;<3 '$G '%$832323 8:0#(&" G* 0:??0&"5+4;<2'8:+80&"?*"

 /%4HH 2F% 2' <'2 D EEEEEEE  (* ) $#3 &< 9  3 3  EEEEEE3 A <32EEEEEEADEEEEEE,-1"323  4= < #5*- G$(&"/"

" 2'(5@$#3DEEEEEE2'2  4:2''  A4:'A(:&" 2 ' 22  ' =A/F 63 D"EEEEEE32EEEEEEADEEEEEE32  )$#3 :,21 #5* & D"DEEEEEE3 9 2 -2 :3)$#34&<2 ' 3  :    G$(&"  &   '< EEEEEE / 3 4''2',3)$#1 2 :  EEEEEE3 DEEEEEE32EEEEEEADEEEEEE" 2'''<2 4: 'A:&&$+) $#49 4;<323 & :2 '22&A; $G*&"23 ($*I2)"

 22 ((2%$#3:&& '' '"

 2'''A '"

"    '   '  2 2  23  2 ' 2'  2J3  4 :   D EEEEEE3 K  D EEEEEEE3   %  F3 D"EEEEEEE"

     3 4 : ''  0 % $#3 D EEEEEE  ''4% :22,21EEEEEE3'  D EEEEEE4=&342==3  4:F7   D" EEEEEE A DEEEEEE3 LF/ ,-13 2 :@$0"924'43A'2 : '293&(???3:''A/EEEEEEE3AEEEEEE34: 4' $0';M 43 2)D"EEEEEE-")'43  '2  /3 'A:&& 22:  K 24:2 A:'<4:   2=324'H   HA" DEEEEEE&'4: A <:'4:%J9 4:       22 4 2   K "  2'' 2''4 '-3N %&3'$G '%$834 '< '2 4'  <"

 <') ' -4:2 A    :&& 2 )&  2  =  :22  <3 DEEEEEE'2 4::< ' 2 3     '  3 3 2 3  :    &   2    N3   :  4'3    2 A <2== 22"

 DEEEEEEA  '4: ' A:&&(0)$#3 4&&&O )&A: 22'F "

  A <3D"EEEEEE&'4:-3A : 2''3DEEEEEE" ''2::' '%$0$8:'F)$0$84 DEEEEEE:)"

 2' A  )3 D EEEEEE  '' 4 :' % :' $03  4::';M%3:'2 & 4'$G '%$8"

 D" EEEEEE3;2':&&3&&'43  N D EEEEEE ' )  2  :&&    223A:9 :& 2A" :  : 3   &  4'3 4:   '   2''3  224:'% '-4: A <' &"

 2 2F% : ''92&4:  '"/ 9 :9 '3:2:22A )3 : 2  4:     2 <'  DEEEEEE"

" /  '  :&&    223 D EEEEEE ' ' /EEEEEEAEEEEEE (%(???()$53

23   3  EEEEEE A <" /  %4 H<H  ' D EEEEEE"/'< 'A   3D EEEEEE3 2$5&'$(3I EEEEEE3  2<3 2(%$+"



 

("    '  2' 2 J  2 <'    2 2  <  !9' &' 4   2 4%2)  2& '2'  '  ) )&',"(#."(*"("(("$."+5 "061"

  2  7 '2'   9 )   N  2<    ,"(#"$1" $"    A  2 ' '  !'7 2%   !'7  2 4   2 2 A  2'     !'   !&&'37 '  2 '2',"$$"(1"

  2&,"851  2%  2'&3 ' 22' 4      2= &' 2  && 2'2%  ' 2  9),"(#"$ 13 2A &2' 3;37'2'% 22 !&&323!  &, -GGG  " 03 6  (?5$  08. - ?5  0(  " $3 6  (?#0  $#   )2 '. />5$$>$5 $%$5 "(%"1"

  ! 3 !%  <   &  ' &&'! 2"

  2' ! !3  !       &3 <&J'3 N  !< ! 4  &    '%"  '  7 ' !&&   2   '2  ! 2 ," $$ . F% '3 3 4     " 85F++3 C001";34 &2'%  '%4!%"   2=43! ''%&' 3!2"/ '%&2    '  23  2 2   !&& 2'   ',P "/&&3 !9'3Q03

C ?8"3 2" ##   )2  '. &" '<" F% '3 34  "85F++3C0$)2  '.LF%/;R2%;3 F3  "85F++3C$( )2 '. -G$50 "836 (?+5??1" !4 '% 4 ! 2 2' 2   9 )   &    2= 4 !'  2'22!&& 22'   3 4   ,F% '3 3 4   "85F++3C001"

0"" !<<   ' ! 2'  !9' &' 22 !9 ! &   23 4 '< !<  2  2' A 4  '  !  2    2"   '&  &   2 223 22' &   ,"85134!%' &2'9,"8GA+$13  '   A 2 4  ;<    '&' !& 22',"+01"

 &9&2'&" & 2 7 '' 2 '  &  23 92  3 ! 23 ' &2'  '% 'A!'<'  !9'/,"+*"$.P "/&&3 !9'3Q0 C?(. F% '3 3 4     "85F++ C0*.    ;%  2  &  % &' ' (0&'(?G8!'  22 & '3/6(?G82"$851"

0"%"  '42' 3:43%44!2'' '22<3  ' 3 !&&3 '! 9& 2A!&&'2'   29'2'"

8" &  2   '%,"85"(1"

   ''2'2!"$0"( 3 ';'3 2 !"$* 3 4   7   "  22;=4  !N'  ! !='%34224!& 4 '722&"4  ! 22;=43&2 !%   3    9   A ! 3   2=3 N  &  9 !''232&3  4!' !29 ! .! 2' 2 !72 3& &O%)%2

, -#"$8(>$0 G)$8 "8. -($+( "03

6  (???  (##. - ($*  #  "$3 6  (??5  #0. - ((?  58  "$%36 (??5$$(1"

  ! 2  2% 4! 2  !   )  22 '' 3&&4!22 &        93    2  2&3 &OA A')%'34 % 7! 22   N A &, -5?? "$36 (?80 8*?. -5?$## "$36 (?88(#$1"

 2 4 ') A !'< 2     / 4!/ 93 3 '7  '9'3  43!'% &)A '< S2, -#"$8(>$0 G)$8 "81"

  '2S  22 ! '3     2  '<3  ' &    3       2  3  2      2% &&     '9  !9     4    4  &  7 A  '<   2'2  &3 4 2 2&, -($+  ( "0  '&' '1"    & 2 ' A 9 3    N   !< 4 !  , - #"$8(>$0  G ) $8  "8. />(50>*+ $$$+ "8"1"

+"  :23 '%<'2 :&& 22= AEEEEEEA < 2 ()$5" '3&':&&32 (0)$#34:   -   2<   '   " :&&3 43 A '2 '4 23 '&2'   3 : & 2  '; 2 '&  &3     A :      < N   2  43   22   23   K F4    %  : 4  '  :&&    22F      234:& FA":323'3  )&& 2 = :22A 3 :'  2  '' '3''42< ' :2' 2 2 2 :=3  :423222 42"

   2    '3  2<  &&' 4:   -2 & 2 :@$034  /3;MK3:'4:%J94::'A

:&&    22 4:  4' /3 2 4:  && 2=4:  "

 / '  '' &' 2  % F4 :4  =  :22   - 2  '%   2 %F3  & 4   2 '%'F)$0 $8 '    2 ;  2' 3  '4  2&' ''  :'$#"

+"  ' 22' F 3 4    '   2%3 22 3& 42 4'  /3  2    '' $83 2      -3A: 2EEEEEEADEEEEEE"

    < 9''  0( ) $#   '4 7 '' 24:' :&&42'  "

   '':&&AA 2<2  "

5" 2' '='ADEEEEEEA - 4!A A <3& &%'2"



TTTTT



  #            1

*('&1

'%2&'(5@$#2DEEEEEE  < 9'' A        2 &  ' C *5 $$8*($"

,(' 1

("  4: :=  2  &   2      A : DEEEEEE"

$" '  <9''0()$#    2&'C*59999($"

0" :&& 2AADEEEEEE2  "

8" '%2 "



$2+ B D  PU  L3 2' . DD"   //   PL3)<"





   B



D        PU  L &&B       ' B

 2' '4'2 A!&&'2  '922<&&