Maintenance Calculation Upheld Based on Imputed Income Due to Inadequate Financial Disclosure
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case concerns an appeal regarding an order to pay maintenance, where the obligor failed to provide adequate financial disclosure, leading the lower court to calculate maintenance based on imputed income from the obligor's business operations, which he had undervalued. The appellate court upheld the maintenance calculation, reasoning that the obligor failed to meet his burden of producing sufficient evidence to substantiate his claimed low income, thereby justifying the lower court's reliance on the evidence presented by the obligee, including the obligor's prior statements and documented business activities, to reasonably impute a higher income for the purpose of determining the maintenance award.
Regeste Legislator
OfficielCommandement de payer. Notification. | Saisi d'une réquisition de poursuite, l'Office doit examiner la capacité du débiteur à être poursuivi lorsque, sur le vu des pièces du dossier, celle-ci peut sérieusement être mise en doute. Si le débiteur a eu connaissance du commandement de payer, la plainte contre la notification doit être déposée dans les dix jours de la connaissance. | LP.64.1; LP.72
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAProvision cited for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal.
Texte complet
DCSO/528/07
>005+>$#3 2 (# &' + 2% $# 2 3 2''2&"
'4'?@
!"#$ !%%&'$(%!)"$!#!%$ %*!$($+ 053" AB 2(#0( ($$# <
,,$(!%-.&%.$#%
!"#$"$" %&' ' (#) $+ , -. / (#0"((*1 ' 2 2 && 2 &34' 22 &,"+5"061" 7 '2' %&' '3((83 9)4& :92' 2 2' ',"("($" -1 4) 22&& ;<,"("0" -1" 7' <' <&&3 434:4' = 237<',"8$ -1"
" 2 C *# 99998# 4 2 - ! ? ,A2@ -/ /1 BBDDDDDD ,@ B BDDDDDD13 ' E3 DDDDDD3 ($*5 3 !&& 2 ,A2@ !&&1 &' F $# ? '% 2= G+0&"0+'7?+H $8 ) $# I J & C 599998$3 59999#F3 5999958 599995$3 7' 0* % $5"
2=3 &' 2 < & 2=' 2 <,9213 44!''? '%I J 4!!2''&22' !22"
-/ /4 2 '' 0) $#"
$0K$#,!' &' 213!&&92' '? BBDDDDDD ' $(K$#44! 2' ' ? $+ 2% $# ' '%"
" ' (+$#3 '2'<&& ' +2%$#3B"BDDDDDD '2'2"
4 4 &' F $# ! 2=' 2 2=3 2 C *# 99998# 3 ' ? 3 L<' A2 ' ;M E3 DDDDDD ? "2'4!'2'?! 2'' ) &"&&4';2' 2$5 $#3 4! ' A7 % 4 ! 2 ; 4! ' 2= ;% 3 4 3 3 I J"
B" BDDDDDD < & !7 ? !&& (8 $# 4 !4!N' '2 I J"
B"BDDDDDD)?22@
A 2 !92 '% 2= &' F$# 2C*#99998#.
A 2 ! 92' ' $( K $# 2 C*#99998#.
A '' $ $# 2 OP29 3 '2 ';% <'3 OP2 DDDDDD3 & 4 B BDDDDDD ')' '% $5 $#$#.
A '' $G $# 2 OP29 3 '2 ';% <'3 OP2 DDDDDD3 &4BBDDDDDD;2' '% 2 (($#"
" 223 !&& ;< & < 4 ! ? 4 B" BDDDDDD < 4 !' 2 ? ) &3 !< & = &' 4 '2' ''2OP29 ! 4) &"!&& ! 4 !;=2; Q B" BDDDDDD % 2'' %9 (8 $# 2 & 22 I ! R? 'S " # " $ % J"!&&!22?)"
" %3 -/ / < 4 & & 2 '''''I J"/-/ /3 2 ! ;' ! '<' 22 2 ' 4 '2' 2= 3 Q 22!''&'32 "
" (F 2% $#3 ' 4' 2 ? 2 2 !47 2 (5 % $#" ' ? B" BDDDDDD 2' 4! ' 0*2%$#'22 4 ' !2=' 243 23'2' 2=<9"
/ !<&4'4' '3! '' '2' $$ % $#" '' ='" ' ? B" BDDDDDD 2' ? 4! ' ! 4 ' !2=' 2 2'' ' ';' 0*2%$#"
B"BDDDDDD!2'2 '2"
-" ! 2 2 !47 $$ % $#3 B"BDDDDDD&' 232' !2=' 2?433 2=<9''&'" &&'4 2='23;% ' ' 3'29 !$#"
B" BDDDDDD 4' 4! ' 2 < ? = '' 2 2''%4 F $#3 ) &3 ' " /!< 3 &&'4A'3?!'24 ''3;2'"4 '2O2) &3 ! <<' ? 2 !OP2 O= ,3 -1 Q3 3 ' ;2' ) &" 2'' 4&& 2< ! 34! '4 '!4!" '< 3924'4 ! 24!!22% 2 42'& 2="! <<'?2 &' !'<& "
/!< & 2=<93B"BDDDDDD 4'! '(0$# '2' ;% " &&'4 !)4!'3 !22 4!<"B"BDDDDDD92'!7 ? !&& ' 2=3(8 $#3 2 % 92 & 22" !2=' 4 '2 ! ' & 22 ? !&& <<'' 2 2 '" B" BDDDDDD 4' 4 2<?!&&3(+$#3='? '3 4! 2' " ! '' !22 4 !' ) 2 ? '"/! '2' +2%$#3!43 '' &' ! " B" BDDDDDD ' 4 4! 2' (+ $# 2 2' 2"
4' '3 B" -DDDDDD3 < & 2='3 2 ! B2T3 < ,921 2 $# = & 2' 2 923 &' &' 2= <9" 924' 4 !' 2 34! ''' ? 34'2 4! 2 BBDDDDDD34' & !22'+'< !%E3DDDDDD? " ' ' % 2 &< 2= %4 I'%J" = '2 2
!&&3 924' 4! 2= ' &' 4!2=&22' 9)43 2'&'32??!&&" / B" -DDDDDD3 B BDDDDDD 2'&'' ! & 22" 2'' &&' 4 B BDDDDDD 2 % &N3 % 2 4! ' !2 !#*AF*4!22' '3!= 444 &"
= '<< B" -DDDDDD3 B" BDDDDDD ' &' 4 ' % ) & 2=" 4'4! &' 2 ''282%$#3 )Q '2'<&& '4! 92' '2&(+$# "22'' 23 2 (GG83 ! 2 <'' 2 <' && ! ) <' 3 ' 4! '; '; 4! 2% ! 2"
/ 3 2' -/ / 92' 4 B" BDDDDDD 2 $0%$52 44& '' 2 < ? ! B ? /3 " 4' 4 2 9 22'='4! " !=3 2 2 ''2;43 N 3 2' !;'%?2)< ' 2C*#99995$2 &' ? ? 2 %) 2' 2" /!< &3 -/ / 4 2 ? ! BBDDDDDD & 4 ? '< B" BDDDDDD ! ) '2 ?22"
!&&4!2='4NB"BDDDDDD(8$# K < !22 Q ' 9 ) !' 2 ';"!&2 2=' 4' ! ) N 2 4 B" BDDDDDD =' (+ $# ? '" /!< & & 2=3 !&& 3 '<< 34A2&%"
" B" BDDDDDD ! 2 2 ' 2 2 2' 4!!'<<'?& ! $$%$#"
$G%$#3!&& 4'? ''' !2%' ! & <; = N B" BDDDDDD (8 $#"2!< !2='2= 24'!&&"
O" / < !&& 223 B" BDDDDDD3 ' (G8G3& B"BBDDDDDD3&N%''& !2 A , ') ',)4!?058)113 ' E3DDDDDD3($*53 2(F)$53 ' /"
B BDDDDDD3 4 %''& ! 2 ' 0* ) $5 %2/)4!$G) $*((3&<2 < ? " 2 4 4! ' (G(* 'E3DDDDDD3($*5"
("" /!"(#"(3272'2?!' 3 ',"+5"06(*"(134! !&&?2U2)&'&3?4 2) "2 7 '2' 9) Q 2< ," (# " $ 1" &3 4 2< 4 ' % ! 23 2 %2,&""$$"(1"
4' 2 2 2 22 '7 ? <" '7 ) '%"/!< 39 '7 ''2 22'7?22" '7 & '& ;M 4 ! 2" 923 '' )<' 4 2 ! '% ! 2 4' 2 2 2 & ! 2= ? ,/;V (GF53 2" G5. 3 A3 "(#C$$"3$F1"
!23 2 '' '2' 2 & 23 43 &' 9 22 22'3 ! 2 4' 2 2 2 & 2= ''" ''A23=& '4 <4' 2' 2 4! ;%' ? 2 2 "
("%" 2' 2 3 !A?A 2&3 2 9 2' !9' &' %. & '2 ! % 2& ! 2 ! ," $# " ( . W " /&&3
!9'3X0C(+1"32'? 2' !9 , />$$(>$+ #$+ "$% '&''1"
2& ! ;442'!<2? 2&" &3 ' 4 ? '< !&&3 & 22 4' 2 ! 2 923 4 2'' ;< 2' !< 2 2 2 2' !9'&' ''332234A & '' 2 , />$$(>$+ # $+ "$'&''1"
!23 ' 4 2' 2' 23 2 2'' 2 &" A < & ? 2 2'3 2 '' 2 '" 7 ? 2' '4' 2' 2"
$"" 227 <'242' !%<3 !A?A 4 !9 , & . V > - W;3 3 X F C (5. A% '3 2 3 & 3 8 ' "3 C 0883 2" 5F1" !9 ! I ' # % J ,O ;9>AO /32;=438' "3C(+*32"8#1"
/ !'4 23!&& 9 !&&2' '% ? 7 23 43 2 3 A 2 '7 3'22'42' 22 2'' , - (*+ (*# " $3 6 (GF$ $+. 3 A3 "5FC57'./%V&;M3 /;V3 "5FC(07'1"
& ! 2=?2!=2 2' !723' 234 7 ' !&&,"$$"(. 3 A3 "5FC# 7'./%V&;M3/;V3 "5FC(+ 7'.&"'<" -3 23X($32"G5!7'1"
$"%" !23& ! 4!&& 23 '4 23 ! 4 2 ' 2' '%?72"
! 2'2!222? ' 2' '%3 2 & 4!'L<' A9) & 2= <9 !' & 2 && ? '< " ' B"BDDDDDD22&&" 2 ! '2&? '2 !'<& .!&2&< '!2 24 & "- ! '9 3 ' 4 '% 2' !7 23 4 '<< !< & &"&& '<<4 '%2 4 ' 924' & 2=" & ''! 2"
0"" & ! 2=4!2''&&' < 2' 2 " 58 ? 55 ! &22' ' 4 Q ! 2 ! 2 2 ? '%3 ' 4 7 ' !&& 2 2 !' "/ '% 2= ," 5# 5G " $ ;" ( 13 '2 & '3 ! 4!% '% 2 2 !' 9 ) 2 !32 &, -#"(5(>$+ 0(%$+ "$"( 7'.E6>/%3 A3 "58C00" '&''. <3/;V3 "58C$0'&' '. 3 A3 "$$C$$1"
0"%" !23' ! 2'24 '% 2=<9) &3 F$#324!''222!<&"
' 2A% &343&& !"G 32 2234 '<< !< & 4 3 & 3 &' &' 2= ? '%3 A'2'? ) &"
? B" BDDDDDD3 4' 2= (0$#"
2 '2' + 2% $#3 ! 2 '4=22'3 & 323 %"
22'4!' 9 !&& ' 22'3! 2424 ''' %' % 2< ,- 3 %<;; ;T ;<Y3 V M Y (0A0* /;V3 " (# C $#*1" 3 !23 2< ! 2 22' 4234! ' (+$#3%''='? ? '"
2 2 ' 4 & 2= <9&& !4<22%'' 22',"#$58"( 1" 2= &&''? '%A7 , 3 A 3 "#$C$.E6>/%3 A3C($ "58 1" ' 4 2 2 B" BDDDDDD 2 ' 4 ' ;2' ) & 2= ! & 2%3 243 ! 32 F$#"
8" 42' 32 7 ''%"
+" '&,"$*"$;"+."5("$"1"
ZZZZZ
/
0
'%2&'+2%$#23 2 2 3 & F $# 2=32C*#99998#"
$12" #@ B" '<= E3 2' . BB" B OE WO3)<"
@
B / '<=E &&@ ' @
2' '4'2 ?!&&'2 '922<&&