Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/470/2004 • CJ GE DCSO/470/2004 Généré par l'IA

Surveillance Evidence Admissibility and Reasonable Expectation of Privacy

Numéro de cause DCSO/470/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on the admissibility of evidence obtained through surveillance methods, specifically whether these methods constituted an unlawful search under the relevant constitutional protections. The court reasoned that given the context of the surveillance, the expectation of privacy asserted by the party in question was not one that society is prepared to recognize as reasonable; therefore, the surveillance did not violate the protected rights, and the evidence obtained was properly admitted.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Surveillance Evidence Admissibility and Reasonable Expectation of Privacy: The court reasoned that given the context of the surveillance, the expectation of privacy asserted by the party in question was not one that society is prepared to recognize as reasonable; therefore, the surveillance did not violate the protected rights, and the evidence obtained was properly admitted.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
preuves issues de surveillance sphère privée perquisition droit à une enquête effective saisie de données informatiques présomption d'innocence Saisie, retard injustifié | LP.149.3, LP.89, LP.90 et LP.53

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied to order the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/2238/2006
Warrantless Surveillance Evidence Admissibility Despite Initial Defective Authorization
P/25/2016
Surveillance Evidence Admissibility in Prison Visitation Rooms
P/14336/2012
Appeal Regarding Admissibility of Telecommunication Surveillance and Secret Observation Evidence
P/23355/2020
State v. Appellant Regarding Data Surveillance Authorization
A/878/2004
Admissibility of Expert Testimony on Surveillance Footage and Sufficiency of Evidence

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to order the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

     

DCSO/470/04 



                         

 9/+/,90..+& !# !#6!"!$"$:6!0..+    #  #!"!!#  1*(  !! #     ! #; ., ''''/:<#<7=>>>>>>7



$!!##!5$?

   





    

*  ! "#$%&"%' "

      !  "!!  !# "$$ ! % "$  $!&$ $#!' ! !!#(!#""! !  "!! ) !*!# +&   ,-+.& /0// #1( ,2&  3#$ 4# ' $!!#$!!#5$&#!'61#!"!!# $#$!!# )7/87/27   

7 0/0..,& 1*(!!#;.0''''-@A(#   $"  !#  00 ! 0..,& B>>>>>> =   5! C""!  ! )!* 1? C""!2  #!#  ! !!3$ # <7 =>>>>>>&!#D>>>>>>!*#E&#(#04+/0&0."7

 $5!!!#$$#3!$#;.,''''/:<7

7 C""! !#!5 (! ' $!$ # ! (!  !!  <7 =>>>>>>  + "$(!0..+#(C#!!"!'$/0..+& !&!*!#CE#  $$ $# 3C!!#!!&##(!!! ,/0..+#(C#!!"!'$+!0..+7

 <7=>>>>>>#C ## $$ $## 3C!!&  5 !*!  $ $ #  F '  # #(!#   #!#&#(#317

 C""!   #(E$  <7 =>>>>>>&  #  !3#  # ! !   /G ! 0..+& # !#   $# ### #  '  !#  - 6!# 0..+& # ! ###H# 5C $" ! 5!  3$#$"!# " !57

 /6!0..+&!#$#$!#"&C""!5!  3$#$  "! # <7 =>>>>>> #  '   " !57

7 :6!0..+&B>>>>>>= "$ !# 1 !!#$# !#6!"!$#!#$5!!!##!# ! $!$&#!#!5#5C#C(!6 H 1*(!! 5C#$ ##$!#-(!0..+C""!!(!$!& 0G(!0..+&5C#!!$!I"!'$+!0..+)J$!E#$$2 # 3#$!K7

7  /+ 6! 0..+& C""!  #$   ! ## 3#(! C#*L3   #!3#   $(# !# 5 <7 =>>>>>> (!  C#*L37  !&  0: 6! 0..+& !  #(E$  !#5 #5 ) (!  #5 ##  #1(& C= = &  $! =!&  #5 <!3   #5  2 !#! 5C   =! (!###!!C#$#7

7 # #    00 6! 0..+ )H  0: 6! 0..+2   !#  B>>>>>>= &C""!"!$$ $!$5C!(!# !# (!$5!!!##!# !#!$$7

B7   #   !!#  $#& C""!  !#!5$&  0,   0..+&5#E1!#"!5# !C#(!C(!!!( #!#I !#$K5 !C$$0..+&5 !## 3#(! C#*L3 ! (! !#!5$&  /: 6! 0..+& 5 <7 =>>>>>> #C$! !#!  1 C# !  L3& 5 C 1  $ # H  !#! #! #$&  !! ##$ #C(!  $ 1 $!=!&#5<!3#5  &5C (! # (# $  1   #5 ##  #1(    /40.0&+."7#!# ###3#!E#!3#$5 ! $#! # !  33 ! #  (#!5 # !  $"$#&5C(! $ 1C== ##0/-&0@"7

 C""!  $!$ 5 !  #  #! 5C! (! $!($    #'$$ #&<7=>>>>>>C$! $#$#'@M0..+& 5C!#!#3!&!(!$!# 1*(!!(# $"!# ##04:@8&:@"7



 

/7  !!#$# $#  !#"$#  !!#)7/.7/2&###5  (! 6!!! &  # C 1&  $#!  6!   !#6!"!$ )7/G7/027

# !# $#!6!!#6!"!$ %"$#  )7/G7,27

# # 5 !(#& B>>>>>> =   5!$   !# C# $#!  6!   !#6!"!$ #  !#   $5!!!#  #!# # !7

= !# !"! ' '!3#  "   ## !   ! )7/,7/027

 $# !##(7

07  $#!  $#$"! C# !   $"  !# $!($ # # !  5$!  #!#!#   !& !  $!$# 5$!##( !&#!'! $ !#&# (!   $ $#!"!!#C### E&$$#&C#!#($C !!#)7/+87,NO 7=""&!C'$!#&P@#;G@/--NQ ##9B!!#O& #!&G1$70..,&P,/#;/827 5#!!!C# $5!!!#  #!# # ! # (!   (#3& C""! !  $!!E"! $ C""!!!!#!# !!&$$#&#!"!#!#!#"!!$!)7-8 27

C""!!3!#&!!7#(!##$!$(!!# /:$/88+#$#(!3/6#(!/88G&C7-8 $!!5 C""!(!##!$5!!!##!# !##$! !67=!$!C$$ $ C'!3#C#!#I# K&  #C  !#  3 C#       55 6 #5C!"63C'!###C#!#6!"!$)O 7 =""& ! C'$!#& P, #;@GN !* !!$#& #!& 7-8#;+7N #$7&!#=Q&7-8#;0&,.,,N  R39A#!O9 <7Q9<!#Q##&=Q&+1 $7/88G&7-8#;/27

 $ C'$!# "$ ! % #$ ( !!3#  ""!!$7 5C! E! !&$3!C $(!*%&#!## $!!$"'!#C!#&$! !#0. 6 #!"!!### E)7:87070& 7--7/NO =""&!C'$!#&P,#;:.27

=#"*!#!  #$!#!!#C(! !!)78.2&! 5 #C!##!C#  !3# 5# ! (! #C  ! !# # H )7,+ 27  #C!"!### 63 #C#(!C# (!  !! ! C'$!#   !!7  #!& C #!$  (5  $!#" C(!!!)7@,N =9+@:90..,  0.  0..,2 ! # "( C# !!3#  !#  $5! !&!#!5$C!!C'!3# 5$!!(!$!!& !5C!!E !! CE"!  $# )78/ 7/ 7/ 2& !     # (# 5C #C!#(!##& "!#  !!  !5 5  !(! 3#! # !#(!!$1!#)78.N!*!!$#& #!& 78.#;:N #$7&!#=Q&78.#;@27

!&C!"! ## !""!$ !55C""!  ##  '$  !!&  C#  $! )!*  !!$#& #!&  7-8 #;@2&  # $($  $5!!!# #!# !5C""!!#!#(#(! ##F    !   ! )"7  !!5 !$ !# =Q 0..+ 7/0&"!#$ 8@4+G@!!'$$#1(#0..,27  # ""  (!  ##     ! !!#  C""!  E# #$!  5  '!3# $3  $ !# %  $& C""!$##L$!3$C3#!"H#!# "! ! !! !!#) B//8/N =9,-09.+#!70

  0. 6! 0..+N =9,0@9.,  /, M 0.., #   9-0,90..,N!*!!$#& #!&5!#!( '7/*,.#;,27

,77 # C 1& C""!  ! ! !  !  #(E # ! (!  !!  $!&  #       !#!#  #!5#  ! ! 7   # #! # !  #(E # # (!  !!&#( # !#!#7

   $! # #   ! (  '!3# $37  E  & !#$#!#&  !#6!"!$ #  !#   $5!!!#   !3##7

,77 #!& C#(! C# !#  $!   5%  $!(# C# ##!####!(!#E5!!M%  #7  $ !# %  S !## M& 5!# 5  !!#$#!!!(S%# !#5C##(!  !!#!#(E$ $!&! !(!$$#(E$! !3#&#"$#''!3#$3)7,+27

  $ #C# #  !# $$ # !  C""!  6 !&  % 5  #  #!3##   (! ###  !!  $# 5 C""!  $  !(#   ! ## 3#(! C#*L3 !!#!#!7

,77 6&C""!"!#! ##$!&& 1(! $$# !#3!&!$!# 1*(!!(#$"!#7

 C#!5 $# !# !#6!"!$&5!5!#"#$& (# # 6 #   $& $# $!$ 5 C  $"  !#$!($ C""!#C C6 $# !#7



TTTTT



  (            )

*+$&, )

/7 $( !# 9/+/,90..+ !#6!"!$"$:6! 0..+ B>>>>>>= # !#;.,0+://:<7

%$-!)

07 !5C""! !$"H#!#6!"!$!$5!!!# #!# !#3!$#;.,''''/:<7

,7 !5 !#(##6# $7

+7 $ !#!#7

 ./ +-') <7  U <   & $!#N <<7 V(   !(! OA&637 

# !!#(!#?



 #E   U<     !*3""!1? $!#? 



        $#$!!##!5$ ! C""!##$  !3#' ! 3""!1