Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/468/2007 • CJ GE DCSO/468/2007 Généré par l'IA

Appeal Regarding Knowledge of Possession and Jurisdictional Value of Stolen Property

Numéro de cause DCSO/468/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns an appeal against a conviction under a statute penalizing the unlawful taking or possession of specified property, where the appellant argued the evidence was insufficient to prove that he knowingly possessed the property, asserting it was taken without his knowledge, and further challenged the trial court's refusal to direct a verdict based on the prosecution's failure to prove the property's jurisdictional value. The court held that the circumstantial evidence presented, including the appellant's close proximity to the stolen items and his subsequent flight upon police presence, was sufficient for a rational trier of fact to infer the requisite knowledge of possession beyond a reasonable doubt, and further affirmed that in the absence of a specific request by the defense to submit the jurisdictional value issue to the jury, the trial court's decision to treat value as an element to be determined by the court, or its acceptance of the established value, was not erroneous as a matter of law where value was proven through undisputed testimony.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Minimum vital. Retard injustifié. | Contenu de l'avis concernant la saisie de gains. Paiements effectués par le débiteur en mains de l'Office des poursuites. Retard injustifié dans l'expédition du procès-verbal de saisie. | LP.12; LP.15; LP.93; LP.99

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
chose volée doute raisonnable possession originaire compétences juridictionnelles acte d'usurpation ou de trouble saisie de biens

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
P/22263/2018
Appeal Concerning Conviction for Concealing Stolen Goods
P/18020/2024
Appeal of Theft and Property Damage Conviction Upheld; Confiscation Order Partially Modified
P/370/2019
Appeal Regarding Conviction for Receiving Stolen Goods, Illegal Residence, Traffic Offense, and Drug Consumption
P/4103/2024
Appeal on Theft Classification and Unlawful Entry Acquittal
P/9648/2011
State v. Accused (Receiving Stolen Goods Acquittal Upheld)

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

     

DCSO/468/07 



                        

 >0(*+>$#32(#&'(+?$#2@" AAAAAA"



'4'BC

      !"# $%&!&'(&)!*&'+, +!)!, 



D   !"# $' (#&+  '+)!(# !&)!'    &+  '-).('.& ' 





 !"#$"$"  %&' '  (#) $+ , -. / (#0"((*1    ' 2 2     && 2 &34'   22 &,"+5"061" 7 '2'  %&' '3((83  9)4& :92'  2 2' ',"("($" -1 4) 22&& ;<,"("0" -1" 7' <'  <&&3 434:4' = 237<',"8$ -1"  

"       2 E *5 9999+8 F 4 2 :  3   & 3 :&&  2 ,D2 C :&&1   ' B@" AAAAAA(#$#2$$#"

    &9'3 @" AAAAAA : 2'' B :&&   2''  <'  2D% 2' "

 @" AAAAAA =  4' B :&& 4:    2   2'  2  3 :&&  ' ' :9'    <  $:$&"2:&'5?$#2: :    <" :&&  '< '%  2D%   ' E*559999+8F ' 22+2%$#"-2   '  2 E *5 9999+8 F '  4  2 E*#9999GH 42: 3 "

"    (+ ? $#3 @" AAAAAA  2' 2 B      :    < 2'' 4: '  I  H?$#"

 4:4'2:  ' 2 '3  D  ')B'4:24   J            J  &   4  &   "  ' 4: %   B   (: &" 2   4: :'3  : 2  2%' :<  "  3  2; B :&&   2   2  2 4: & ;4   &  AAAAAA /    :&&   ="&34:&&2 '  '2 "

"   22  8 2% $#3 :&& 92 4:2  9  ;<  @" AAAAAA3   &9'  4' % B $:$ &" 2 3  '  2''      < D   =  4' 4:  2&2 2D '2D%  'E*59999+8F"

 :&&  4 : 4' 2   & && E(*3 4:  ' ': 42 ' 3  '%)4:B4:&&2 "

 /:<  4 '%%;43:&& '4: :2B2  4 '% 29<4 &9' '"

" 'B '23:  ''4::22 B)"

"  :'  2E*59999+8F4@" AAAAAA'B :&& 92 (:&";38)0?$#"



 

("" /&    K   2   ) 3  2 7 2' 2 B :' 4: :&&B 2L2)&'&"2 7 '2'  9)  K2< "2 772'2 22 ' ) )&',"(#."+5"0 6."(*"(1"

("%"  2' 2  &' 2  :' 2'3  :  <3)B232 '%23 44'2<2"'' '2' & ' 2'2"

  %"

(""  2322;B:&& 2 '  '2 "232 2I2D % 4 ' ) )&'3% 2"

$" %32< :  < 4: : 4 2  '   23     '   2 ')B'"4: ' ''  &2'&"2;B:&&   2   23       3   4: %& :'"

0"" 4  '%  ) B  2 2   3 :&&3 2 '2 '4 232  B =&2' 2:&& K%B,"HG1"

  27 ' & 42'2'   2%  '%  B  & ," G0 " ( 1"   2 7  2    2 B 2  :9'    ,"G0"$2;"(1"

 42' '2 2%2 32'2'2' '%4 '22:44: :&&,"GG1":&& 4   B :   & 2' B  &&3   & E(*::< : "    <  J<'J3 :      '  '%   4    9''"

 / &   :" (+ 3  % &' '  ' ' :    &  < B 2=    2 2    &    2%' ,&1 4 2 :  &   :22&  2 ,"("(&13 '  2   : & 4  2 324 3B9'%2 %&' ' ,"("0"$"$&1"

&'J J' '2 % &' ',-"(*1  4' 2   '3   :9'     3    '%3 :B     3 :  4                                     "

 '44 2 )B 2  :9'   2  22 B D ," ((* " ( 1"

0"%" :23B42' 2<:4'3 ; B 3   2 3  E *5 5$H8+8 F 2   '   '  4   2 4 2 :  3  &"

 3:4'34CJ                J''%&&'3:&&=  4'4 J                    J"

   <& 2 4     2   '  ''34: '2&&<24::2'   &'  4   : 2 '' 92' '  4: : 2 '"  2242742 2B2 !9' ,"G0"$2;"(1"

4 '%&:%) 223:&&3K    :     <3   2 ) 9

4   2 4 22 B   "   2 43   ' 22 ):9' 3 9 '4 2,"((*"(1"

  3 :    2; B :&&   2   4'  : < ?2 '%"

 23    '  4  2<  '' &'   '%) 2 <'BB'2  :I4 ' ;4243 B &3 '23'7&"2     '  '< 3 2 ;  2 & :%) :7'3 2D% 44' '%B:';'  ' 22,"((81"

0"" <&&'B:  : <  & '"32 7)'"

8" :&&  2   :2  2 & 2  2  '2" '%%''22,"($1"

 :23 :'  2E*59999+8F42< 2=' :&&(:&"8)$#(:&"0?$#3 4:2 '   &3 :&&  ' B :  3   &  GH5 &" (+  G ) $#  GG+ &"  H ? $#"  B  4 2'   2<3 :&&   <'  4:&&'2' '  22''" 2 7)'2"

+"  ! '%34 7&9'&  &9 !9' , -((+(*036 (GG((*H13  ''   %   !%' ' ' 2 ! '   2    3  <     3  !   2 !' $# ,/>  0 5*"*81"   !)B%,;"1=&&& <  '%   &  ;&&< ,;" "(1" - '< 2    !  %,;""013 74  '2  2% B !9 ! ' 2&3  4 & 2 22 ;  3!)&'B ;<  '% ,;" "81"  ;3  & !'<3   '4 <M 3& !3    %      2 7 2  2"  ;<&3& ''2; !& ! '% &22 ,/6$$(0.-I3 /6$#H8.+H"1"  '< % 3!22% 23    3     4  '% % ;4 3 4 %7!''2 <<"&&3  )& 2  2'<  ' 4 ! 2    23  '  '"2<!2 % 3 L322'2. < 2    '2 2%B!  '% &, -G5536 (G558G. -(*$(#36 (G##+H1"

 :  B )  4 :&& : 2 2%'   ;<  2<   4: % ;4   &    '"

 2 7)'2" 5"   ' 2D%   "  2D%  <' 2  &  :2=' 4 2  B :2'.  '    '  '%3 '3):; 3 %342' 2 ,"(($"(1" :92  ' 22 )3:&& 2& 2 2D%9' '%,"((81"

224''9''5?$#3) : '%  :     <3 4  '  22  ' B ';'+2%$#432 :2';'3:&& : ) 2 4'  2D%   9 2"  ' & : )&'"

2 23  '  22' 2 :&&  :  2D%    : B 43 ' 3  2     '%  4:9 '"

#"  23    ' 22 4 4 :&& '  :9' <  '%D22 !"G+" + 3 9  4  & 4 2  B     42%'7 '  '%D324  D2 !'  B&  <     ,&"    !&& 9 ;  ; 3  $G ? $0.  />0HG>*5  (+ ) $5  " $"%.  />+(#>$5 $+?$5 "$"%1"

NNNNN

   $            /

,*)(% /

' %  2 >0(*+>$# &'  (+ ? $# 2   :  2E*59999+8F"

.*)!/

(" : 2"

$"     22' 2 :&&  2     2D% 'E*59999+8F"

0" :&& 2B4' B@" AAAAAA 4:9'2 !2''"

8" '%2 "





&01 !C @  OP  F3 2' . @"  @ FP )< .@"6 3)<22'"





   C



@        OP  F &&C       ' C

  2' '4'2 B!&&'2  '922<&&