Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/445/2004 • CJ GE DCSO/445/2004 Généré par l'IA

Appeal Affirming Lower Court Decision on Lack of Demonstrable Error

Numéro de cause DCSO/445/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A litigant sought relief against various government entities concerning a dispute, but the court ultimately affirmed a lower decision by finding that the appellant failed to demonstrate a demonstrable error in the application of legal principles or factual findings. The court reasoned that the appellant's arguments, which challenged the evidence and the lower court's interpretation of the controlling statutes and case law regarding the underlying action, were unsubstantiated, leading to the conclusion that the decision below was legally sound and supported by the record.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeal Affirming Lower Court Decision on Lack of Demonstrable Error: The court reasoned that the appellant's arguments, which challenged the evidence and the lower court's interpretation of the controlling statutes and case law regarding the underlying action, were unsubstantiated, leading to the conclusion that the decision below was legally sound and supported by the record.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
argumentation motivée interprétation du droit indemnisation de l'erreur judiciaire décision préjudicielle attaquable défaut de preuve induction de la justice en erreur Registre des poursuites, péremption | LP.17.4, LP.8a et OELP.3

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed the costs of the federal procedure on the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/649/2006
Appeal of Denial of Statutory Relief
A/908/2017
Appeal Inadmissible Due to Insufficient Statement of Error in Lower Court Ruling
A/1189/2022
Appeal Dismissed Affirming Lower Court Ruling
C/18705/2022
Inadmissibility of Unsubstantiated Appeal
C/28636/2017
Appeal Dismissal Upheld Due to Failure to Specify Proof

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed the costs of the federal procedure on the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

     

DCSO/445/04 



                        

 9:;+90..+& !# /;  "$  /8  0..+    & $!#!!#4$<!=  >&(&#1(7



$!!##!5$?

   !!$? <!=  >&(&  ( #$,@  /0.@#1( 

    

  !!"#$%&'()%("*%



      !  "!!  !# "$$ ! % "$  $!&$ $#!' ! !!#(!#""! !  "!! ) !*!# +&   ,-+.& /0// #1( ,2&  3#$ 4# ' $!!#$!!#5$&#!'61#!"!!# $#$!!# )7/87/27  

7 # !#A8;'''',0B&5! <7CCCCCCD## <CCCCCC ###-84;8-&,:"7(!#$%:E10@F /88;& D""!  ! )#!### D""!  !   "!! (*&!* 1?D""!2#!"!$&#0$/88;&###  G$!!&5!H"$ !!#7

<7 CCCCCC  5!  !#($    !!#  /0 6!# /88-  1  !#  !1 !##   !$  ## "!# D6   !7 #63#I 9/-:0;9/88- /.#(/88-& #!5$' !  !#$/;#(/88-& !# !1!## ##$  !#($ (!!  D !!# "!  ##  G& !#A8;'''',0B&!#/.4..."7

 /8 6#(! /888& <7 CCCCCC  5!  #!#!#   ! #A8;'''',0B   # ##  /.4..."7  ;0."7  $ #&     63# $!$7

 : ! /888& <7 CCCCCC  $ $ # # # !#  D##  < CCCCCC *(#  !#  !1 !##  # ##  ;84;8-&,:"7(!#$%:E&10@F/88;7

#06!#/888&D""!' $!$#(!!!<CCCCCC  ###/.48.0&.:"7&!#$%"! !&##5$!!$3$ -6!#/8887

 # 63# I 9/@/,,90..0  /8 $ 0..0&  !#  !1 !####$<CCCCCC G<7CCCCCC,:4..."7&  !#$%  :E& 1  0@ F /88; )!"" /  ! !!"2&  !  ##$   ## D !!#  ##  G& ! #A8; '''',+ B )!"" 0! !!"27 63#"!D6D#  < CCCCCCD# !#!# <7CCCCCC7

#%#A I 9-,/90..,0 0..,&#!5$' !  ! #$  +   0..,&  #$ # "  @  0..,&    6!##$!""0! !!"63## !&##(& $$##"#$&##,:4..."7 !#$%:ED#10;F /88;& D !!#  ##  G& ! #A 8; '''',B)!3# !#!D ""##$ !#!$$27

080..,&<CCCCCC#D""!#'! !& !#!$J   K#JK&#!### # ! #A .0 ''''/- !!3$ # <  CCCCCC   5%  <7  CCCCCC ###;040;/&-."7&!#!5D# !#A.0/087@+.!!3$ #<CCCCCC5%<7CCCCCC ###8-4:+0&-:"7

*0*  /; #( 0..,& D""!  #3!$  $5!!!#  #!#  ! #A8;'''',0 B& $ $  <7 CCCCCC&   #!"!$ # !#!#  "!!  <CCCCCC&/.0..+7

7  /8  0..+& <   CCCCCC  "$ !# ! D# # D""  #!" #  !#!#  "!! $!$7   !#(5$ # #  $ !#!5$!#!#!# !#A8;'''',0B7

<CCCCCC#5 !D$! $!$#(!9!/888&# !(#? *  $#! #D(!  3!  0 $ /88;&   D !!#  ##  G&  /0 6!# /88-&   $ H   5% # !#($&! ##!'!!'67 * !&/06!#/88-/.#(/88-&63#!#($&  !$! #7 * /.#(/88-:!/888&$ H## !#& $#!#D(!#( 3!&!#!#5!(!#3*!#567

<   CCCCCC  !#!5$ 5  !  5$!  #!#!#   ! $!$6 $!$:!/888&5D!D$!/;#(0..,&6 $ H$5!!!##!# !7

  #   5  !!#  $# $ #   # ""  !#!#"!!& !#A8;'''',0B&5D##"!5  ! $!$(#!$3!D""!&5D !   "!   3  D""! 9    #7  D !   !#& !###D'! ! $!$5D""!!(! $!($080..,7

7  !!#$#$D"" #!" !# #### 000..+7

7 #(!#/,(!0..+ !#&<7CCCCCC!#!5$5 !#A8;'''',0B(!$$!###(!3 $5!!!##!#  !  /8 6#(! /888   D(!  !!  0 6!# /888&   5  !#D$!  $!$7 $!$ !5D""!!(!#"!$ 0:0..+5 !#A8;'''',0B$!J6#"& ! $ H   $5!!!#  ! #3!$  D""!  0+  /88;K7   ##"!!#5 !#A8;'''',0B6#(!3 #"!!#(!!$!#!#"!!/+6#(!0..+# !7

7  # $!!#  /, (! 0..+& #(G$ ' ! # %   5D  !!#  $#& D""!  ##$  !#!#  "!!& ! #A8;'''',0 B&   $!$  #  ## !   $5!!!#  #!#  ! $ $  <7 CCCCCC  /, #( 0..,&  !" 5  ! 

*,* 5$!  #!#!#   ! $! $!$   D#3!#   $5!!!##!# !7

L7  + ! 0..+& <   CCCCCC  !#!5$   !!#  $# 5D !##!  !#7    $ 5D (! #   #!#    #"!!# $ !# !#A8;'''',0B&!#!5D!!#  3!  D""!  #  D'!  D""!  08  0..,& !  !1 #A -7  !3##  $3# ($  #!!# #  !1#A-!D""!0:0..+7

7 #(!$$!#!#!##$&D""!!#!5$#0@! 0..+ 5  ! #A 8; '''',0 B #D(! 6! $$ !$   3!7   ' !5$ 5D# ! (! #! # '!  #  ! # "  D##D#$!) 2&& !!D#$!&# '!### !#" !#888!#"!#  !) B27 D""!  $!$5D# ! (!% JK  !!#&##!##$#!&! !# ""$ $!& !! !  $#!7   6$ 5   888 $! $3# !!$ 5D! D3!!  5  !# # !"!#5D#!#! !#!#"!5#D!#(!####!# $!&D$!5D""!#!#$!!#D##!#6  !#7D""!($5888#!3#!"!##5 ! !$ $!$7

=D3!#   D 1& D""!  !#!5$ 5D D$ 5 M  !3## (! 5!#'!& !#A8;'''',0B$!#888"!5$#! (! 5!  #!#!#   !  0. 6#(! /888  # !   $#&  5  $!! D$! 5!$   ## # !#  D""!7   $!$5! !#& !(!$$#3!$#888&D""! #DG# # !#  # 5  $#! 5!  #!#!#  ! ! $#5# 7

D""!  "! (! 5  !# $! (# # 6 !   $!!# D##!#/,(!0..+7

B7 0;F0..+&<7CCCCCC!#"$ !!#$#5!$!!# D##!#!#!#"!!5D""!(!#/+(!0..+&! (! $  D""!&  08 (! 0..+& # $5!!!#  !  D##  <CCCCCC %##5 !#A8;'''',0B)#$!$ ####5!#($(!$$$ D% $!$  6!0 0..,&!,:4..."7 !#$%:E10;F /88;2& 5D""!(!#3!$ !#A.+'''';0N&5<  CCCCCC (! "$  !!#  ##  G 5! !  $$ #!"!$ ##( !&5D!(!$ $(# !# !1!## # 5%  !#($ $"!#!!(  D !!#   ! #A.+ '''';0 N&  5<CCCCCC135 !#A8;'''',0B$!##" *+* !5D#D(! $$##$"#  !!#$#&5D! # (!5$!!#($$"!#!!(D !!#"$## G#A.+'''';0N7<7CCCCCC#$ !!#$##"! "#5 !# 9:;+90..+<CCCCCC#!#!# "!!#!"!$# !#A8;'''',0B#D(! D67



 

/7  !!#  $#   $#  ##O  !# # !1 D'$!#"$)7/.7/27

077  $# !#!!3$(##!#!#"!!#!"!$ !3##&!####6 !#)7/;7/2&5D# # 5 $!! !(!  $! #$  "!!  !3##  5!$ 57

 1 5D"$ !## !##" !)7/,7/02& !#$3(7

077 L!#3"$5!##OD7/;7+&D""!"!##$  !#!#  "!! 5$ (# 5  !# # $ ! # !# "" $(!") =90:.9.+#!707/8!0..+2&!"$##! $5!!!##!# !#A8;'''',0B& !"5 ! $! $!$7 = #( $!!#& ###  !#!#  "!! #$& #D  $$ !!5$ # # 5    !3## #! #D "! D6 D# !#& ##  !(#!!!#!$7

  $# !##(##6 # $##5D $!!!3$#!#!#"!!#!$$7

 G!#7

077 (#D65D!"! $# !#H&!!#($!"!!  #   $3#  #  6& ##'   !#!#  "!!  # !& 5! ! 5#  ! #($ # 6& !#! 5  $#  !3##7

D6D# !#$"!#!3###D"#5$& ! !  #!# !   !3##& 5! (# (!  ""  $! D6   !#  !# " #    5$ ) =90:.9.+ #!7+  /8 ! 0..+  # !# !!3$ # # !!  (# !!$   #!#   #!# D#   3 ! # #!$!#2&D$##!#6 35D"# 5$&! !!#!$#!7

*:* ,77 #D 1& !3###5 !!#$#$# #""!#!#"!!& !#A8;'''',0B5D# #"!5 ! $!$(#!$3!D""!7

  !3##5!$ " !#'67

,77 ##!##D ## D6##5D## #"!!# $ !# !#!$$&15D""! ##$  !#!#  "!! #$   !" ' !! 5  ! #A8;'''',0B$! $!$(#5 !(##D#5!#!#!#&1  ,.  0.., **! $!$7  !!#  $# #D 1   6  ($!"!! !$!""!(# $!$&$$# !5 7

 ##!##(!#6#M## #"!!#5! !!$3!D""!&!"! !3## (! "! $ D# $!!#  D""! !#  #! 5! ! # # 6 !   !#!#  "!! 5$7 &  !3## # ! #$!!#&#!#D(#D$$####!$5D""! ! !!##! !!##$!!#7 !3###(!##  "! 5 P !  (! *  !#!#  "!! 5$ !!  # 5!#! !!#D'!3! !080..,# ##"!!#&5!##!##  !#A8;'''',0B&D# 5& $!#$ H !#&D""!#"!$ !(#5  ! $! J6 # "&    !  $ H   $5!!!#  !#3!$D""!0+/88;K7 !& ##&D""! #$ $ !# !!!3!&!!#5D!#! $!!# 5! #! 5 ! ! !  ## "!3  3!  !  ! !D%D!$!#!#"!!5$7

 $# !##D# D6$3# !#7

,77 #& !3## $"$'' !!#5D""!"#! !# 5! !#D(! "!3$D'! ! 5D(!#080..,7

!$3#D!##!#7--&#!$## D#  5  ""! !###  3!   1*('    $!# !#! 5  $5!!!#  $!# 5D! Q!(#&  D  5D! #!(# ##!#!#! !###$  !#    ! D# 63#& #!  !  5  $!  #3!##D!##$ $!!#D!#&#! !!$  $#!7 # !!!#!#! # "!3#   ! $!$& 5! # !#! #  3!  !&##!5$'!!#$$"!3#'!3!  !) L//:-/R!*!!$#& #!&7--#A:+ *@* R "7!7/."&'5$ !!% !#!5$ #  3!  !&     D3!# ##  ! $!$& =9,;-9.+0.6!0..+27

+77 #"!#&  $# !#   !  #!# 5  !!#  $# !"!3D""!9 #7

  !3##5!$ " !#$3#67

+77 ##5!!1#!#(!$#$!$!# $5!!!##!# !#A8;'''',0B&!!%$$  $# # 6&    !#  ! 5 D""!  #  #( $!!#&/,(!0..+7

#""& !3###D $#$!#D#!$!#!%(!5 D""! ! !   "!   3   !3## & &  ! !##3 1(!##$!#!#"!!5$$$ $5!!!#  #!#  !7  #& # $!!#   "!  !#  ! $5!!!#& 5!  % #  5% )7, 2&  ""!# !!#   !#!#  "!! 5$  5D!  6!"!  #!$5D#$!!###! D6%! !! $# !#7

+77 #"!#& # # 5  #!# #!##$ (!  $# $& ! "   5  $  !#  3! )70. 7/ 7/ R 7@/ 70 72&5D!# %$$ ## $ !#)7@0 7027

 #6!"! &#D 1&## !3### $### #  !#$#$ 3 $$$$! (!"!)70.7/ 7027!###5# ##!# !!#(#! #!####$ H!!#!#D# !#(##6# $###""  !# $#""!7

:7  $# !#  # $$  $# (# # 6 #   $G$H7

SSSSS

*;* 

  ,            -



! 5  !# 9:;+90..+ "$  /8  0..+       (##6# $7

GH7



=!$3#? <7 T<   & $!#R<7#!< BU&63& <$!  &63 $#7





# !!#(!#?



  T<     !*3""!1 $!# 



    $#$!!##!5$ ! D""!##$  !3#' ! 3""!1 

*-*