Statutory Interpretation in Comparative Negligence Damages Recovery

 



 

    

DCSO/414/07



         
           
  


>$0(0>$#3
2
(#

&'

(0
)
$#
2
3
'


:' 

?
'
  3

@
"

'
4'
@
A

  
'
A
 

?
'
  3


  !"
 ##$%"&' (& $)&









!"
#$
"
$
"






%
&' '

(#
)
$+
, -
.
/
(#0"((*1




'
2
2





&&

2


&3
4
'






2
2


&
,"
+5
"
0
61"


7
'2'


%
&' '3
(

(83


9
)
4


&

:92' 
2


2'
'
,"
(
"
(

$
"

 -1



4
)



2
2
&&

;<
,"
(
"
0
"

 -1"



7
' <'


<
&&3
 4

3

4
:
4'





=

23

7
<'
,"
8$
 -1"

 

"


47




/BBBBBB3
:&&

2
,C2
A
:&&1

&'3

5

$53
@
?
BBBBBB

 

2=
2
D
*+999958
3

2

;
'3
'''

2
D
(
@
E

 

2=
2''3
@

A
(" 88F
&"
#+

'7
@
+G


(E"(("$+
$" 08
&"
E*
0" (:F5E
&"

'7
@
+G


(E"(("$+
8" 0*0
&"
*+
+" $:+0$
&"
$*

'7
@
+G


(E"(("$+
5" (8#
&"
#" $#+
&"
#*
E" $:+0$
&"
$*

'7
@
+G


(E"(("$+





2

''
&22'
:22"

(#
%
$53



/BBBBBB

4

'

:22
2

2
0
@
E"


)<

((
)
$#
6 >8+E>$#3

%

2


2'

'
'&

:22

2

$:E+0
&"
'

(F
2%
$+3

$:+0$
&"
$*
'

(0
)
$5


8E#
&"
8*
'

0

$5"



/BBBBBB

&'
22


)<"


7

(F

$#
, 6 >8($>*#13



)

'
 
)<
3

2

2

2

'2H


'4

2

4


2

'%3


2'

'
'&

:22
2

2
83
5

#3

2



0*0
&"
*+3
(8#
&"

$#+
&"
#*3
2

2
0
@


'7
@
+G
:




(:F5E
&"

(E
%
$+

$
&'
$#3
2

2
+
@


'7
@
+G
:




$:+0$
&"
$*

(E
%
$+

$*
)
$53
2

2
E
@


$:8
&"
$*


'7
@
+G
:




$:80$
&"
$*

(E
%
$+

$
&'
$#3
2




$:8
&"
$*


0
&'
$#"


'<
 '
?
BBBBBB
9
&


2' 

2

9
3
7'
@
5
&"

3


73



'
4

'
:
2
''
4
2

2
(

$

 

2="


$8

$#3



/BBBBBB

4




2
2''
@
;

I
       I"



)
@

'4

2

 

2=
2''

4
:7




6

(F

$#"


0(

$#3
:&&

 '
@
?
BBBBBB




2

(+
)
$#"



4

'3
=
2

'7

(+
)
$#


&
9
0(

$#3


E:*#+
&"
8*"

"



(0
)
$#3
?
BBBBBB

2'
2
@





:


'
4:
'

J

((
)
$#"

 
@



'3
2'%3
: 
:&&
2&
@

2
3
223



&

'23
:
:


4'

: 
@
:&&

I             !            "   # $       %   & '       (!            (!    ' !       ) ) *++++++ !   ,  -++++++./ .    I

: 
@
:&&


4

'2
9



'7

&3
@
:9

&
&
@
:



@

'4



2



K

'
'
 '

:

 
'4"


%3
?
BBBBBB





'
%)


2
D
*+
9999E8

43
@

3


9



:'2
:
2

%





/BBBBBB3
2

2' 
K

:'
2

22'

%L
,$(
@
'%
$$1
23
2

2' 
K

%L

''
&'


 
:;%
2'
2



/BBBBBB
,
$0

$81"


'<

'

E:*#+
&"
8*


:

3
4

2'
@



'
2
4



/BBBBBB

%

'

:22

2
2



0:#(*
&"
+*
4





'

(5
&'
$#
 '
@



6"
&3

2<
2;
@
:&&


2


2

2

+:
&"
&&'




'3

#

$#3
43


3

2

 





%

 

(:(*E
&"


&

:
'

@

'4



2




'
'3




"
EE


"

"

 

(8
)
$#3



'

&'
:&&
2&
@

2"

"



2'

$5
)
$#3
?
BBBBBB
92
4

$(
)
$#3

:
2''
@
:&&

@

3

4
:;

;<




&'
:'%

'2


'
%)


2
D
*+999958
"


 
@



'
:
:&&
@



'2
''


'
%)


2
2''"


4


'

2
'

:7




6


$:8
&"3
4


2
2
4

'

''
 '


'7

4:
'4

'
' 

2
7

E:*#+
&"
8*"

)
4
:2

+:
&"
'

&




/BBBBBB

8

$#
'3


 
2'3

I            0   (/  1    2  /  I

4



:&&
&'
@

"


3





 4
: 

2'

%


'
4
:&&


:
' 



@

'4



2"

&3

 
4


4'




2
43






3
'&





E:*#+
&"
8*


:


3

:;=2;
K
2





:&&3

 
4

 '
@

&&

2%3

& 


2&

;'4"

"


22

0
)
$#3
:&&
92
43


2
23



2

2&

:7
 
2



6

(F

$#

:
2

<'

23

4:

&'



'
4

'
%)


2
'

0:+E*
&"
(*

$(
)
$#"
2

2&

:7
2''3
:&&
 4
4

'

'2


A

• 2
0
A
*#(+,-
2 
9
'7

9

+G

(E
%
$+

$
&'
$#
,
80#
)1




(:F5E
&"3

• 2
8
A
#(+-
2 
9
'7



(E
%
$+3

• 2
+
A
 #(+ -
2 
9
'7

9

+G

(E
%
$+

$*
)
$5
,58
)1




$:+0$
&"
$*3

• 2
5
A
,#("
2 
9
'7



(E
%
$+

• 2
#
.-#(+
2 
9
'7



(E
%
$+

• 2
E
A
/,#(+
'

2
M
,#(+0-
2 
9
'7

9

+G

(E
%
$+

$
&'
$#
,80#
)1

$:80$
&"
$*3

'7
@
+G

$:8
&"
$*
'
''


0
&'
$#"





'


0:8(+
&"
++
@
4
:)

'7
@
+G

$:8
&"
$*

@
2

0
&'
$#

)4:
$(
)
$#3

0#(+13

&

&

 

2=

0-#(+3

&


'4



2

1#(+1-


&
&
@
:

:



-#(+3


'

0:+5$
&"
$*3
@
4
:&&

)'



(#
&"
F*
2 
@
:'
&
:


 
C

:;=2;
K

2
'
&&'

<;

:&&
C3

0:+E*
&"
(*"
:&&
2'
4

'7

''
'

9

+G
2'

:7
2''"

 4
43
2


&9

$$
)
$#3


&'

2<




'

4




'2 

$+
)
$#
43



'

3


'
2%

'&
:9 


"

22
@
:&&
4:

&&'

2

+:
&"






/BBBBBB

0

$#
,    1

43


3

%

 


&

(:(*E
&"


&3
:&&

4



/BBBBBB



2
'
4

2<

&&'






4:
'4

2

2
7
2

 '"

-"


%

$*
)
$#3



/BBBBBB
 4
4

#

$#3


J

?
BBBBBB



+:
&"

4


:
''
2'



&
&
:%)


2
D
*+999958
"

"

'2

22

:&&


%




/BBBBBB3
?
BBBBBB

 '


@



'

$
N
$#3

4


4

'
O

J



+:
&"

#

$#


2
:
&&'

%


2
D
*+
99995#
3

9

4:


'3

 4
&



&&'

"

'43

'
4:

'2'
2
2'

9
2
I/       3 #                  $     $     &2  ,4I3P


'


2

@
:

:



(+
)
$#
:


E:*#+
&"
8*"

 

("

2'
2

''
'2'

2



&
2
2

!'
2'
,"
(#

.
"
(*
"
(

(0

.
"
+5
"
0
61"







)
@
2
,/;Q
$+3
2"
$0*
.
 />8+5>*0
 "
+"%

$*
%
$01


2

4'
2
<
2

"
$"


23

2





'
%)


2
D
*+999958


4




'
&<

:

"

2;
@
:&&


2


2

2

+:

&"
&&'

&


2

:
'

@

'4



2

4


'
'"


@
:

:

"

0"
/
'
:
%


&3

:22

9
&&

2

9
'



' 


2'

9<'
@
%



, -
((+

$(
R
/6
(FEF
2"
8
 "
0%
.
-
((0

$
R

6
(FEF

($*>($(
 "
$%
.
-
(($

8E
R
6
(FEE

(8+
1"

'%
4



'

2

<
2

%

:22

&


<&


 


2' 

'3



';'


 
:


%'

3

:



2


2
,"
E+

E+
13
3


3

:

'2'

: 
,"
E5
13

4




2'
9

)<


%9
 "

8"

2


'4
''
2
%"

+"

:23



'
:
2

2'


2


%C& '




'
%)


2
D
*+9999E8"

23
 


4
:22
&'

 

2=


2
2''

''
2
'
2
7




6

(F

$#3
4

'&&

9'
2
:
2
&
:%)
:


%
&' '"

8""
4

2
:
2
2 
2
:22

2

)<3

'
2

4'


@
:92
:
'

<
)
@
2


&

 

2=
,"
EE
"
(
1"
:&&

2' 


@


,"
EF
1



'%



2

,"
F*
2;"
(
1"
:


22

2

:"
F(

,"
F*
2;"
$
1"

!2

&
' '
2

%
&' '
,-"
+13

!

%<


&


&
<
2
2


,"
(+


"
(
&13
!




 

@

2

3

4

'


23
! '

'
2





'
,'' 
-S93

C3

"
F*3
D
((1"

/
!"
F#
"
$
3
!&&


4

%
'
2
&

'


23
'7

&"


&





%
4!

,"
F#
"
(
13


2





'3
=
2
'7

&3

2
%'
4

''


';'
'



2

2
 ''
,"
($
1"


223



2'
4

!&&

2


!2

2
&
2

2

'
2
,"
($
"
(
13


'%
!
%''
2

2
4
!

&



!&&
.

3

7
!
4

'


:'
2'
2
'
!&&
!
2


2


4
!

&



!&&"

2

2

2
&&'

2


J
4

!&&


N
&'
2

2
,
3

C3

"
($
D
8
.
C%
'3
3
 "
"
($
D
0(1"

+"%"


4
!&&
&
&<

!




2
2 


2



23
'7

&
N
2

2
 ''

)
7

!

!





9'"

&
' '
2

%
&' '
,-"
+1

2'
!
2
4
!&&
 4



'7


&

!

3



9
2



9
!'7


 !






&
,T
2

'

&"





















'7
@



G



















2
&
U1"
!

'%




9



!4
!

 

23
'
2''
4!
2

<
@

22
2

!&&3
4

&





N

)

2


4!
!=


'&

9' "

/
!&&

 4




'7


&3


& 
)







2

2
2
 





&


 4'3

C
4
2

!'
&
&

<'


,

2

 
2
21
, />5(5>$5

$
%
$53
 "
$""
@
$"".
-
#"$($>$51"

+""



:



2
&&
:&

'%



@

&
4:
2
2 

2
3

23
7
2'

2''3

:=
4



22


@

'<






"
:'
'<'
;
:



4:


: 


'



3
:&&

22
2

 '



%'4
,'' 
-S93

C3

"
F*
D
(E

$01"

+" "

:23

22
4
:&&
:
2
%




2&

:7
 
2



6

4



E:*#+
&"
8*
&<

:


'
"

'3


'2H


2'
23
:&&

&'



&'

2<3
2


$$
)
$#3
4

 


2

$(
)
$#
'

0:+E*
&"
(*3

4

2

'7

)4:@



9

+G


:7
2''


&"




'2
'%
2
:&&


22

0
)
$#
4



'
2
4

2

%

'

'&

:22


0:8(+
&"
++
,((F
&"
8+
M
0*0
&"
*0
M$$
&"
+*
M(8#
&"
M
$#+
&"
#*
M
$:8
&"
$*
M
(8#
&"
5+13

'7

9

+G


2

$:8
&"
$*
'
''


0
&'
$#
,&
2
"
1"


3
:
@
)

4
:&&
:
2
2

 '
:2

+:
&"
4

2<

'




'3

#

$#"

&&3
:&&
:=
2
''
&'


23
&&'





23

:
2
@


2"

23


%

$*
)
$#3

2

4


:
''
2'



&
%)


2
 ''"


22
4:


'2H


'4



23


:'
2
'"
N
43
:&&


'4


@

'4

 




@

2<"

+""
/:<



'7



&3



'

43

@

4
&<


2
D
$

;<'

:&&3

'7


7
'

9

+G
4


'

2

$:8
&"
$*3




'

 
N"



5#
&"
E*
&<


%4
I'7
I


2
2''


9"

22 
@
:&&3
4:
2 
@

%

3



'7





$:8
&"
$*3
43

0
&'
$#
)4:




'
,"
(88
"
0
1"


9
&


23



'

43



K

'
:'
2
'



'2H


'4



2
 ''3
:&&
'
& '
@
'

%

&
&
@
:<


'4



4:@
:

:

"


'3



'3

'2


%<


!&&
@
!22

!3
:9
2

'<'

&
2%'
2
:&&


2
 ''3


4


&<

!



7
 ''
<



4


&9


2'
N
2

'%
,"
$

.
C%
'3
3

"
(5
D
5
 
.
 />5(5>$5

$
%
$53
 "
$""
@
$"".
-
#"$($>$51"

5"

2'
23


4:

@
:

:

3


)'"


''

%)


4:

@

4
:&&
2 


9


'

2

4:
'%

'23
:&&
=
'%
 
'2


22

0
)
$#"


23



'

4

'%
4


'7
@
'&3




%

3
:
9

9' 3
2
 
@
:&&
4:
'%

'2
&3
'
22'
4
:&&

!

22
2

:'%


'2
4


2

''


'
, 
=C?3

C3

"
(88
D
0F1"

5"


'

&

'2
,"
$*
"
$
;"
+
.
"
5(
"
$
"


5$
"
$
1

V
V
V
V
V

 2            .

34#(.

'
2
%

2
&'

(0
)
$#
2
 

:

3
2
D
*+
$5#858
"

#!".

("

4

2


2

%)



2' "

$"

)
2

2"

0"
'%

2



"

$564!)
A
?

WX  Y3
2' 
.
?
-
/ 

?"
 
// 3
)<
,1"








A


?







WX  Y





&&
A

















' 
A


2'
'

4'
2


@
!&&
'

2

 '
9

2
2

<&&