Statutory Interpretation of Repeated Numerical Reference
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case involved a dispute concerning the legal effect of certain provisions within a legislative or regulatory text, specifically addressing ambiguity regarding a numerical reference or time period denoted by repeated characters in the document. The court determined that the intended meaning aligned with the interpretation that incorporated the full, repeated numerical sequence, rather than a truncated version, concluding that the document's clear expression required adherence to the more specific and complete reference provided in the text.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interpretation of Repeated Numerical Reference: The court determined that the intended meaning aligned with the interpretation that incorporated the full, repeated numerical sequence, rather than a truncated version, concluding that the document's clear expression required adherence to the more specific and complete reference provided in the text.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.
Texte complet
DCSO/375/06
9/+.:90..;& !#/<"$0.(!0..; !( 3#! !( "#! =7 >>>>>> # "!! ###!)#?0..:''''+/2"!!!#$ !$ )#?0..:'''',8@27
$!!##!5$A !!$A $ B C !D $#!!!1 (! /< /;: /0//#1(+ * !""!#$% )#?0..:''''+/2 77""!"!! !#=!/, /-:; /00< 3 ! "!! !# "$$ ! % "$ $!&$ $#!' ! !!#(!#""! ! "!! ) !*!# +& ,-+.& /0// #1( ,2& 3#$ 4# ' $!!#$!!#5$&#!'61#!"!!# $#$!!# )7/87/2!#56#!1 ! ""#3)70.27 ! !#!5 !# 5 # !"!!# $!!# 5$ #$#!##!1(#13!"$$5!#(!$ $!!# #5!#!(!!#7 * !""!#$"&''!()*+&$!* $% )#?0..:'''',8@2 77""!"!! !#=!/, /-:; /00< 3
7 =7 >>>>>> ' !$ # !# !#!(! # # ! 3 E##! $! >>>& F>>>>>> #1( ) G*'''*'''''''*'27 $ $HDD &# 5$,0:"7#3#! !#H# ##H!!>>>&F>>>>>>#1(&# "(D>>>>>>7
7 D"!! ##$$ ##$/"$(!0..:7
/, 0..:& H""! "!! )!* 1A H""!2 !#(#!$ ! 3#! !(& # ! (! # (# ; 0..:7
7 =7>>>>>>$$$;0..:7D$!!#$ !$!#& !!#5 !# !1!##&5%@! !'& ##$ !5! # 13 "!!& # 63# < #(0..:7
7 0. $ 0..:& $ B C ! D & 3$# ! !& ! D>>>>>>#"!! ##=7>>>>>> #$#<4;.0&;:"7 ## H#!'I""$# $!/!,/$0..:&#J(#!5#K3#!!( $!$7
#H$!#!""!! ##=7>>>>>>&5H! $ $/0..;&#% 5H!#(#!&##!#"#$ B C ! D # (! ' $!$ !3# / 0..;& H""!$$$# $!$D>>>>>>!$#3#! # 33 !!& !" 5H ##! # $# $! "!!7 !$!!##!H!#(#!!#!3#!!(#H#"! H6H##!#7
7 !5!!# !# $ !$ =7 >>>>>> $$ # " H!" #63#0,6#(!0..;7 #$#!#H"!H(# "!5! H""!!63#7
L7 /- (! 0..;& $ B C ! D ! D>>>>>> # "!! !# $ !$ =7 >>>>>> % $# <4;.0&;:"7 5H (! ! # "!! ## #!7
7 /8(!0..;&$ B C !D E&#"!! ## =7>>>>>>&#$ !!$ $!!#"!&# !$53#!!( $!$04,0:"7$!!$#$"!
!5!!#"!#&####H$#($!!#!H# $#3#! 337
G7 0. (! 0..;& D>>>>>>& $#$ $ B C ! D & !! !!# $# H# !# $!!#& # !#!5# $ # 5 ! $!!# 3#! !(#!$$J!# $01"!!&!# =7>>>>>>#!I## I$ !"!!K7#$ !!# $# ! J#"! 5 ## 3#! #! )!2 !# !$& # # ! I ## I$ )#2 !K7
7 # # /0 ! 0..; !#& H""! # !#! #H!(!!$#!1!!!##67
/7 !!# $# $#& # 5!$ H!$ ## )#!52(!#& ##M !#!!3$# ! 3#H'$!#"$5!## 5 (! 6!!!& !#! 5 !# $#! 6! !#6!"!$ )7 /< N7/<7/7//70N7:;7,@27
!3##5$# !&!#!'6 6O ###!#)7/<702&$ !!$ $!!# "! $! H""! # "!! ## # !7D#$!!"!''!3#"## ! !)7/,7/027
07 H""!#!5 !3##!5!$ " !#& !"5H #! # $!$ # !(# "! 5H! ! #$ # (# 3#!!(# $! $#$"!!!# "!! ## # !& 5 "! ! JH!#(#! !$/0..;&5!#H"!H6H# !##$!K7
D# H70+8 7, & $#! # !# # $$ $$ # # !&5!#H# $$ ! #35! $#!#&# # !#"$ !#7 H(! $! $( ! !!# ! #!## !" 6 !# 5 $! (!#3 6 (!!##!16 !!#$ P H$!#)7;- L27
# H 1& !3## $$ !#"$ 6 !# # (! ' $!$/0..;#! !3#7#H #$ $!!## !&#! (! !#&#! H!##
#!# H$ !#7 # 5!$ $#!1 #"!! ###!7#!#5!# $!!# H$ H$ !# !! H# !# !!3$ # $ !! $ $!!# "! $! H""! # "!!7 # # !( "!& ! ##H 5!$ 3!##5##*$#!17
,7 D! 3! ! $ !# ! $ # "!! ##& !3## M # * !# ! * 5 3#! !(#5!##! !# #"!! !#$ !$!!"!!7
! ! "! " # H!#(#!!# 3#! !( #"!! ###!&#$#*!HI !! "#$ * 5 3#! ! $ H!#(#! "!! !# $ !$ ! ! "!! ) !!!$ 5 ! #H !# !!# $# ##27 & !3## ##!##$(!##!#!#(#!!## "!! ## # !& $ P H!#(#! # % 5H$!#&Q# !$#$$(!$ #"$# ' 70+8 7 , ;- L7 $! # $!#H!#(#!#E!!16!$ P)7,070 70 LN L0,<90..:0<0..;#!702&!1/ 0..;N ! !($ $$# # (! $$ !!$& ! !# 5 H!#(#!!#!3#!!(#"!! ## !#5!##$#"5$!!##""!# $!#$# $#! 5$ # "!! # (# % !#5!# !! $# !#7
#HI ! $!!# ! #"!! !# $ !$ ! ! "!!& # !5!!# $$ # "H!"#5H#$#!& ' !3##&#H""H(# "! 5! 5 !5!!# ! !#(#!& H !!# H70,.# ##$($7
+7 $# !#!#%$$!(&5H!!!3$# $ !!$ $!!#"!$! H""!# "!! ##!#!$$5H!"$# !5!!#!#$ !$!!"!!7
:7 $ !# 3! )70. 7/ 7/ N 7;/ 70 7 27# %$#$ #)7;07027
RRRRR
, -
$ !( !# 9/+.:90..; "$ 0. (! 0..; !( 3#! !( "#! =7 >>>>>> # "!! ###!)#?0..:''''+/ 2 "!! !# $ !$)#?0..:'''',8@27
!*.#A =7 S = & $!#N =7 !! B = =3! D &63**7
# !!#(!#A
#I S= !*3""!1A $!#A
$#$!!##!5$ ! H""!##$ !3#' ! 3""!1