Marital Property Division Finality in Enforcement Proceedings
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe dispute concerned the validity of a prior judicial determination regarding the division of marital property, specifically investments and financial accounts, during a subsequent enforcement proceeding, where one party argued that the prior ruling was a non-final, non-appealable interlocutory order concerning property distribution, while the other maintained that the prior order was a final, enforceable judgment. The court reasoned that the prior order, which explicitly detailed the specific disposition of designated assets between the parties, contained the requisite finality to be enforced, as it conclusively determined the rights and obligations of the parties regarding those specific assets, even if other general aspects of the overall dissolution or further calculations remained pending.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Marital Property Division Finality in Enforcement Proceedings: The court reasoned that the prior order, which explicitly detailed the specific disposition of designated assets between the parties, contained the requisite finality to be enforced, as it conclusively determined the rights and obligations of the parties regarding those specific assets, even if other general aspects of the overall dissolution or further calculations remained pending.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe court applied this provision in order to rule on the costs of the federal appeal.
Texte complet
DCSO/323/06
9+:;890..:& !# /; "$ ,. $ 0..: & $!#!!#4$< != &(#1(&# 1* (!!(#$"!##>.,''''0, 7
$!!##!5$? !!$? < != &( @3###0 A.+: /0//#1(A
!"#$%!$&!
! "!! !# "$$ ! % "$ $!&$ $#!' ! !!#(!#""! ! "!! ) !*!# +& ,-+.& /0// #1( ,2& 3#$ 4# ' $!!#$!!#5$&#!'61#!"!!# $#$!!# )7/87/2!#56#!1 ! ""#3)70.27 ! !#!5 !# 5 # !"!!# $!!# 5$ #$#!##!1(#13!"$$5!#(!$ $!!# #5!#!(!!#7
7 #0-"$(!0..0&<BBBBBBC 5!# !!$ #>.0''''8,D& 4## 4<7 BBBBBB # (# 4# ## 8;48/: "7 "! !#$%& ! $# $# # " #>BBBBBB !( (# ! (!#7 C# 1*( !!& $! #>.0''''8,D& 4""! ! )!* 1? 4""!2 !!& # 0: 0..0&($!E#!&!!$BBBBBB&#$ F!BBBBBB7 ($!"!$$(#!5$ <BBBBBB&"! 4$ <7BBBBBB&(#!!#5!#4 $$#$#$! ! ! 4""!7
0: 0..,&4""!$!#$"!#$"!#!!" 1 !!& ! #>.0''''8,D& # ## /.A4;-+&;:"7 "! !#$% !&!G' $!$<BBBBBBC 0-#(0..,706!# 0..+&<BBBBBBC $ $#$5!!!##!#!# !"#$ $"!##>.0''''8,D7 $5!!!#$$#3!$ #>.+''''.:& 5! !! $ ' ! "# # $! #>.,''''+0&#!$!' !!####( //.4;8A&8."7 "!7
7 # 4!#(& ! /+ 0..,& <BBBBBBC (! 5! # <7BBBBBB # !& #3!$ #>.,''''0,D& # (#%$#5"!#46 ! $!$ #>.0''''8,D70/ 0..+&<BBBBBBC 5!#!#!# !#>.,''''.0, 7
7 C# 1*( !!& $! #>.,''''+0& 4""! (! !!& /8H 0..+& ($! $!$ E #!& #$ F! BBBBBB& !!$ BBBBBB& !$ /.4..."7& (#!5$ <BBBBBB7 "!*!&<BBBBBBC $ $#!###!# (#!!# # < BBBBBB& , $ 0..+7 # 63# 08 0..:& !# !1!##$$(#!!# <BBBBBB&!E!! 4""!# ! "#$!#>.,''''+070#(0..:&<BBBBBB!#6$ #63# $!$74 # ##7
7 # A $ 0..:& 4""! $! # 1*( !! (# $"!## !#>.,''''0, 74""! ##!#!5$5$!#4(! !#!!54!#4(! $#!!!7
7 ,. $ 0..:& <BBBBBBC "$ !# # 1* ( !! (# $" !# #>.,''''0, & I 0,$0..:7
<BBBBBBC $ # # 4""! # (! "! "!3 ($! E !!$ BBBBBB # 1*( !! 5$7!#!5$54( $(#!!## !"#$!#>.,''''+0&4""!# (!!3#4'!# ($!&478:7, $(J# !!!#(#!5$ !7
<BBBBBBC ###5 1*(!!(# $" !# #>.,''''0, ! !"!$ "I# J "! "!3 ($!E##5!#!!&54$"!# $!($# !!##$7
K7 # # 0, "$(! 0..A& I 0- "$(! 0..A& 4""! !#!5$ 5 ! $ L !#& ! ! $! 5 ! #>.+''''.: % ! $# 5 ! #>.,''''0, !!$54!#! $' $ # % ! $# ! 4' ! $! # ##!# # 47/+8 70 7 6$ 54# #L $#! $! #$!7 !!# $# ! ! # $! /0(! 0..A& #3$ 0/ (! 0..A& "! $!#!# $#!7 # ! 0/ (! 0..A& G""! (# !!#!#!5$5"!$ '$5!!!# ! % $# #G #!!" G# ! 5G! #! "$5# 5G# $#! $ !(# ! $5!!!# ! # % $# "!# G!# !# ! !#7 G""!!#!5$5G!!#!# 1*((#$"!# #>.,''''0, ## !#! !! ($! #!$$ 1 5G! "! G6 G# !! #$! 5 # ! $!!# # ""! $!#$$#!!!#)780707/+A7/27
7 <7BBBBBB#G ##$!G!#(!!# !!#$# $!# !#<BBBBBBC 7
/7 !!#$# $#&##5G!$##)#!52 (!# )7/, M 7/. 7/ 7// 70 M 7:A 7, @2& ##N !#!!3$#3#G'$!# "$# (# % #$ (!6!!! "$ $#! 6!!#6!"!$)7/;7/,27
5$#G 1&(!# 1*(!!(# $"!##!#6 !#7
$#!1 !(#& !3##5!$ " !## ##7
3!# !)7/;702&!#!5 #$!!"!# ''!3#"## ! !)7/,7/027
$# !##$$(7
077 5!# !!3! (! ! ($! !! # $! #>.,''''+0& "!#G6 G# (#!!# $$ # !1 !## ! # !!3! (# 6!& ! $3# %!!# !#>.,''''0, &$# $!$5G!G3! G#!5!#!!$!7
077 G""! !! !# #$! !"! $#! !!# # !& !#$% "! )78; 7 0 2M ! 1 !! # !! !#!!"$5!!!##!# #$! $!#$$#!%$!)7//. 7 / 27 5 ! $!!# # ""! $!#$ $#!&G""!'$!L#!! $#!$!!# !! !# ! )7/+:7 / 7/ 27 K!##& $#!5! !! $!!#G $$$!#$$!#$3#I! #$"!# ##! J$)7/+87/ 7/27CG! #GJ !#!!& 1*(!!(# $"!##G7/+87
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
077 #G 1&$!#>.,''''+0 "!5($!#!$$ $$!!#!$!' !&! $!$#!#5 ! !(# "! ## !##$ 5 $#! )! GPL ! /4,+A&A:"7& < # /40//&.:"7& BBBBBBC 0;0&,:"7 ' "! ""! (# ##!' C !(# 0A/"7 8.;&0:"72& !#! 5 ! #>.+''''.: !3##& "#$ G $" !# #>.0''''8,D /.A4;8-&A."7
1*( !! (# $" !# #>.,''''0, & !! !!3!'&###$!($! !3##&!#!G % $#& # ## & $3 ' !#$%& ## $!)//;480A&+."727
G""!1(&($!#!$$&!$/.4..."7$#$ 1 !## # ! $!!# ""!# $!#$ $#!"#$!#>.,''''+0&G####(!#O"! $!7 G65 !#! $#!$!#5!# %5! !$5#&!!#5G!!!!(! $"#!#$%##!$!#G$(!#' ! G## $! # !5 5& $$#& ! ($! !! # ! ! $ !& # !# # & ! $#$"! G#!!'$$#G! (!7
G""!"!#3##3# (!G $!!#7#GJ !!!##"!($!#!$$7
077 #G %5#!# $! !$"!3# 1*(!! (# $" !# #>.,''''0, & # 5 G""! #G #$ O $! $# !# !!& #G '& ($! #!$$ #G$# # !#!!& ! # $!$ ##!!7 $(#!!!!# G##&5!$# G""!"!"!65G (#!)7-702& ' 1 $#! #!# # ## #33 #!#
! # $! 5! ! $#!& ! J ! 5 G""! J !#!( $!!#5($!#5!#"!G6G#!!#$! #$!#>.,''''+07 $!!##G!G# !! ##*!! ($! # ! #>.,''''0, 7
,7 $# !##! !#&##7
$ !# 3! )70. 7/ 7/ M 7A/ 70 7 27# %$#$ #)7A07027
QQQQQ
' (
)*#%+(
/7 $ ( !# 9+:;890..: "$ ,. $ 0..: # 1*( !! (# $" !# #>.,''''0, 7
$#, (
07 G !#7
,7 #(!G""! !!"!#!# $*! !$"!3# 1*(!!(#$"!##>.,''''0, &"I# J !#! $!!# 5 ($! # 5!# "! G6 G# !! #$!#$!#>.,''''+07
+7 $ !#!#7
-.*,&?<7 R < & $!#M <<7!! CC #! < PS&637
# !!#(!#?
#J R< !*3""!1? $!#?
$#$!!##!5$ ! G""!##$ !3#' ! 3""!1