DCSO/274/2007 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

DCSO/274/2007 · Appeal on Admissibility of Prior Inconsistent Statements in Liability Dispute (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns an appeal regarding the interpretation and application of certain evidentiary rules concerning prior inconsistent statements made by a witness during a trial where the primary issue involved liability stemming from an alleged breach of duty. The court reasoned that the trial judge correctly admitted the prior statements under the relevant rule because they were made under circumstances that provided sufficient indicia of reliability, such as being recorded or signed, and they directly contradicted material testimony given by the witness at trial, thereby allowing the jury to assess the witness's credibility based on the conflict between their in-court and out-of-court declarations.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Concordat par abandon d'actif. Inventaire. Cession des droits de la masse. Récusation. | La seule hypothèse reconnue par la jurisprudence permettant à l'Office de refuser d'inventorier un droit est l'incessibilité manifeste, absolument patente dudit droit. Une prétention en responsabilité pour les actes relevant des organes visés par l'art. 5 LP ne constitue pas un droit de la masse susceptible d'être cédé conformément à l'art. 260 LP. Les liquidateurs d'un concordat par abandon d'actif sont soumis à l'art. 10 LP (récusation). | LP.5; LP.221; LP.260; LP. 299.1; LP.325

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

crédibilité des témoins déclarations contradictoires manquement au devoir motivation règle de conflit interprétation de l'arrêt

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of court costs for the federal court proceedings.

Généré par l'IA

A/4340/2007

Prior Consistent Statements Admissibility Upon Claimed Memory Loss

A/1826/2002

Prior Consistent Statements Admissibility to Rebut Fabrication Claim

A/4263/2005

Evidence Admissibility in Subsequent Proceeding Despite Prior Exclusion

A/28/2004

Appeal Regarding Exclusion of Evidence of Settlement Negotiations and Prior Inconsistent Statements

C/9174/2015

Appeal Regarding Admissibility of Witness Testimony in Labor Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of court costs for the federal court proceedings.

Texte complet

DCSO/274/07

:0)0):511;% " 0; $! 0+ 511; " % ! <! =, %%>(

!&!>?

!? =, % 0)/% " "51@@ 05000

!"#$# #%#&'() %$&'*&"''%"+,"($" %! %! &($"&'- "$ * ,&'''"+,"($',&.'$/ !? = A% 02% "210 050005

! " " #$$ " $%&! "" $'()*(+,-( . !"! /$! !%011102% 34&$ #3"! " "! !'(011(05( 6- &4 ""$$ 78'(011(+( 6-( .! 8! 8$$% &%&#&! 9 "%.8!'(25 6-(

(( =( BBBBBB3"!" 8! /C%&<$!%40D@D%!!9 BBBBBB E !! <"% < &8 ("% /!!% )#111#111$(! !)1#111 < 011$(7(0DD1%<!8! "F !! BBBBBB E 'F"?!! BBBBBBE -!! !"8"GBBBBBBE 'F "? GBBBBBB E -% !! 0DD1% & % < ! ! =( BBBBBB% =( BBBBBB% =(6BBBBBB=(BBBBBB(

(/( !! $ BBBBBB E 'F"? $ BBBBBB E -% ! 8 ! !! BBBBBBE " ! </! 8!! 3 2 4 0DD5% ! ! " 3"/ 0DD0("!!78 ! " <!! 8"GBBBBBBE $ !! BBBBBBE (

(( 5+0DD;% < GBBBBBBE 78!!! EBBBBBBE 'F"?EBBBBBBE -H I( =( BBBBBB% ! EBBBBBB E % 8! "/ <""E %!!"/ <3! (

<! =(BBBBBB%""7 8"GBBBBBBE !! 8! !! ABBBBBB E % !$ " < 0240DD;&"!"!/ !! >"">H4I>!(

EBBBBBBE <7!" !"J%5*K0DD;% < 8 8"GBBBBBBE <"4 <%!/> 0)"/0DD;%&&8"<" /!! > > 9 " < " # & <! '/% " " 8!!- !8 !! 8"% !8"/% &%$$/ % !! +0 !/0DD*% !! BBBBBBE % !"/(

"" ! @"/0DD;%EBBBBBBE !8!& !! BBBBBBE ! !/" <(;5)(5 ( < % EBBBBBBE %$! >48 %!8 3> "" < ""7 !! ABBBBBB E ( < EBBBBBB E & "! EBBBBBB E ! <$$(

<&/ "4 <!/"EBBBBBBE < 0240DD;% < GBBBBBBE "!8% 0DD; !/ <! 0DD@% ABBBBBB E !/ /% & "! "" <"!!"EBBBBBBE (

0) !/0DD;0)40DD@%EBBBBBBE !// "0DD;F5111(!"! $><30DD; ! 88 (E/"%/ ! GBBBBBBE ! < 0@#111#111$(

ABBBBBBE <" " <" <""!%5)$!0DD@%&"& $$/ " /&%&<$"7!<88 8( !8 H4 I ABBBBBB E !!"000DD@(

<!7 !8ABBBBBBE % < GBBBBBBE ! !% <!050DD@% !" &. "!! 8"%><3" BBBBBB E BBBBBB E ( . !% =( BBBBBB &! & " . !0)L51L% &< $%1L )L ! <;1#111#111$(

EBBBBBBE $! 7 2)+#1)5$(;)""! M> ( " / <$ BBBBBB E '$( ( (/( F -% EBBBBBB E " ! 0;1#))0$(5)%&!! %> % > <! ! 5+ $! 5110 ' N0@1-(

0DDD%>$<(;2@ %BBBBBBE "$ "$ EBBBBBBE "(

(/( &. 0*0DD@% < !48 <! BBBBBBE !< <

<!/ < " / <$( ""! & =(BBBBBB=(OBBBBBB (

510DD@% / " !>&. BBBBBB E % ! 4&# 0@ "/ 0DD@ " "" " / <$ !8! =( BBBBBB =(OBBBBBB&! (

! !! "8! 4&< 0@ $! 0DDD " 48 / " @/0DD@%&$!=(BBBBBB =(OBBBBBB $(

02 !/0DD@%4! ! 7!!"4 " / <$ > "" !8 =( BBBBBB =( OBBBBBB 3$ & %&=(BBBBBB%=(BBBBBB=(BBBBBB% &! / !P=( BBBBBB =(BBBBBB"! !"(

48 5540DDD% / "78! "/ <$ BBBBBBE %.! !.51 0DD@ ! =( BBBBBB =( OBBBBBB 3 $ & P =( BBBBBB ! % 8( / !8!/ !(

& ! <! BBBBBB E 5+ $! 5110P=( BBBBBB9"! 2+*#500 $((

(( & "" < 3" " 3 "/0DD+>0DD@!! <! 5)5111 ! & % % !% % 5; "/ 5111% ! $ BBBBBB" ! BBBBBBE !/ !% " +0 !/ 0DD*% 4&<+0 !/0DD;(

0;45115%$ BBBBBB ""!H BBBBBBE % 97 $ BBBBBB"!! <3"4 5115I% " !"!% 0@ 4 5115% "" ! $ &38 BBBBBBE (

"" 0;45115&%/ "0DD2> !$ / 8 0DD)% !&/!% " " 7 $Q$$"/ !$ !!!"!! % K $% "" 0DD)% "! > 8 $$ $ "" !/ / 3

& " "!"<(;5) ( ! &< 3% 8% " < > $!> <3"%<! "!! $R$$" BBBBBBE (

+0 !/ 5115% & / BBBBBB E "! 0)#;2@#111$(8 BBBBBBE %" > <88 !!+0 !/0DD2+0 !/0DD*(

(/( !"! 5* 5112% BBBBBB E $! =( BBBBBBEBBBBBBE " 0)#;2@#111$(% "!.>)L 040DD*(

BBBBBB E !8! <. ! <7 0DD2:0DD) ! H/ "7&I "&< <! !4> > 0);#111$(+0 !/0DD2.&! ! !! <3"!! % &/ K. !"! "" 0DD)( 8% BBBBBB E " $$!$ """/!"$ /!!0DD2 0DD*% 8! "" $ BBBBBB 0; 4 5115 ! '$ "" !? 0);#111 $( +0(05(0DD2 02#21)#111$(+0(05(0DD*-%>&4!H !I' 3 - 0#)11#111 $( " / / <30DD*%"$ +00DD; =( BBBBBB% $ BBBBBB E % ! 8! > < =( BBBBBB(

8 50/5112%=( BBBBBBEBBBBBBE ""! =( BBBBBB% "! > &< &< ". !>"9> BBBBBBE (

E "/% / " % 48 ;"/511)% !/! BBBBBBE '7(2-% 3 !" <%" ! "! 511#111 $( > "" 3 7 "$ =( BBBBBB EBBBBBB E '7( )- !/ " '7( *-( E "" % " ! 4 "! > ""% / !!/'7(0-% ! =( BBBBBB EBBBBBB E 3 !"% & ! 511#111$(> ""37 < =(BBBBBB'7(5- !/!" '7( +-(

. 00 511;% 4 ! 7$$ 0% 5 + 48 / " ; "/ 511)% "" =( BBBBBB $! " =( BBBBBB EBBBBBB E % !! /4% ! BBBBBB E 3 !" "" % " ! "! )#211 $( $ < =(BBBBBB% $! 48 / " 7$$ 2% ) * "$ ! BBBBBB E 3 !" <"" "" "" % & " ! "! )1#111 $( > "" 3 7 "$ =( BBBBBB EBBBBBBE 2#111$(> "" 37 < =(BBBBBB( / !"! "' :5110:511;P$((($(F -% BBBBBBE &! &< < " / $! ! <. 4"!!(

(( !% " ! 00 4 511+% =( BBBBBB EBBBBBBE $!" ! !> < =(BBBBBB=(OBBBBBB(

9 !8! & =( BBBBBB EBBBBBB E "$ BBBBBBE 0DD;"9!" "!$!8!ABBBBBBE /&%& =( BBBBBB ! . 8 $( !% =( BBBBBB EBBBBBB E "! 3 & BBBBBB E > EBBBBBBE !! BBBBBBE & % & !! ! " % < !8! ABBBBBB E . !8! " % ! ! BBBBBBE "><!8 8"(

$ 8$% /% < " "/! > 4% <!88! !" !/% <" ! 7% < $R "!"! !& 4$!% / ! 7% < $! ABBBBBB E " " 7 % < BBBBBBE >"3 !>">&"!! ! $ $ /! GBBBBBB E % < "9! !8 F"< "" <!8! !% <$ $!! GBBBBBBE % <$ <"!(

% ! !> ! <3 ! $R ""$ % <9 !! <! =( BBBBBB =( OBBBBBB & " & BBBBBB E > 4 </ 9$ $ !% " & <" " ! >

9$ $% ! $$! !% "! / " $ & & ! $ ! # " "! " " & !! """!% <$ ! !"" " " !(

! +1/511* :D)@:511+% ! &<<"> & "/ <$ BBBBBBE > ! =( BBBBBB EBBBBBBE !!(

@$!511;% =( BBBBBB EBBBBBBE "! ! !% ! & ! +1 / 511* H S&T I H I(6 < "3"% &! & & "! :D)@:511+<!"(

0*$!511;% !!" 3 "!! &< < " $$ < !$!!% " "% "$ ! +1/511*(

(( ) 511;% =( BBBBBB ! 3 & BBBBBB E < "! $ BBBBBB E > < BBBBBB E ' EBBBBBB E P $( ( (( F - <" ! "" !! < "!!( & & H I(

. % =( BBBBBB &< "! $ ! <()!$ BBBBBBE >< < % H I " 0)#0D2#502 $( *1% H ! " #$ %&&&&&& '(() ! "I(

=( BBBBBB & " & =( BBBBBB =( OBBBBBB % "!%! <8 "! 4 $ & " "/ & ' /- ! > !.>"""%" $!3(+5)5*1(

<9"R !"> )511;%=( BBBBBB! & BBBBBBE 02511;(.% & 9! !& " > < < " 2+*#500$('?@;#525$(++P$((( (F -% H * +&&&&&& ,+I(

! 5511;%& BBBBBBE %" =(BBBBBB4! H '- #$ +&&&&&& ,&&&&&& ,+ - . / I( . !% & BBBBBB E & & H # #$ +&&&&&&I(

<"" !% & 3! ! 3 & H ,&&&&&& ,+ 0 1&&&&&& +- S" % & T +&&&&&& ,+ 2 3 $ '(4 ' (( 516 3 $ !! 516I(

(/( !"! 8$$ ! 0+ 511;% =( BBBBBB $! "% <$$ "$ &. "% ! & BBBBBBE 5 511;("!!8!! :0)0):511;(

<"" "%=( BBBBBB &&& BBBBBBE < 4 " 7! &<H 7 ! "I <! " H I ( !8 % &% / "" <! & BBBBBBE "35112>511* " 3>"%&<H 8' !!9 .:; <!=(<==4$> +&&&&&& ,+ .:; 9<!!!<!!!$>I &<H .:; ?

8<(@!<@@8I% &< H .:; =<= '<9!! $ 8' !!8I(

8 & " & H A'U- I(

3"&"!BBBBBBE 'EBBBBBBE -% <%$ !H #$ %&&&&&& ,&&&&&& ,+ +&&&&&& ,+ '((4 '(()I( &&"! ."!><> 7 0)#0D2#502 $( *1 " > $$! 51L H ,&&&&&& ,+ '(() +&&&&&& ,+ 3!"6I(

=( BBBBBB&=(BBBBBBH A I% V '-H '((4 '(()ST ,&&&&&& ,+I%'-&< H I BBBBBBE >$0DDD EBBBBBB E !!% '- &< H +&&&&&& ,+ ,&&&&&& ,+ '((4 '(()I(

E<8 "!< %=( BBBBBB &&< H +&&&&&& ,+ ##$ B&&&&&& %&&&&&&I( & &"! .!>7 0)#0D2#502$(*1(

=( BBBBBB % ""% > <% " > ! ! & BBBBBBE 5 511;% > &< ! > =( BBBBBB =( OBBBBBB ! " '-"!>BBBBBBE '- "!>< ! =( BBBBBB=(OBBBBBB&& %"%> &< ! " > < "! BBBBBB E BBBBBBE %>7 0)#0D2#502$(*1< ! =( BBBBBB =( OBBBBBB & & % "%>7 0)#0D2#502$(*1% >&< !<" "" "!>< BBBBBB E >< < %>&< !&"! BBBBBB E BBBBBB E < ! =(BBBBBB=(OBBBBBB&& " $$3!(+5)5*1 > !$ <3 "!"%%/ %>& 9! > ! " <" > !"& !"(

(( 0* 511;% ! 4! <$$"$&. " >H

1&&&&&& ,+ '@<'(=< '= $ 9! * - '@<'(=< '= $ 9! I%" =( BBBBBB 0+511;(

( ( E!& =( BBBBBB 0+511;%<$$ "% "N1;33331)%$!2511;>< "9 @;#525$(++!.>)L< 510DD@( "9 &/&H I?HC * @

51 ST ##$ %&&&&&& B&&&&&& +&&&&&& ,+ - * $ #$ +&&&&&& 8 .:; =89< '' 99 !"

3 !"6 3!"6$I

!!$""! <""(

(( / 50 511;% BBBBBB E % !"%4 " =( BBBBBB(

<"" % BBBBBBE 3"%/%&"! BBBBBBE 'EBBBBBBE -% .&>< < "3 BBBBBB E 3 <78 & !7J & . "! ( "! % " % " <$ " . ! ! > =( BBBBBB( >/ && $! "><(

($( 50 511;% =( BBBBBB " 78! ""!%" <. 4 00 511;'$(( (/(F -%&" BBBBBBE +0 !/5111(

. % !! / $ $$!>& ( !!!"!!" /!& 5D511;( % ! "! ! !" "! "! " " ! :5110:511;( < % " % & $ !! "!!3!% V<" < !4> !! :D)@:511+'$(( ((F -(

0( ! & '- < "/ <$" . !$!!%%> !" <(+51(5%> !" " <(0;'&, =: % F% (+0;N51P 60+1;*D (0%, 511;0+;-( > ! $ ! 3 ! & > ! $ '& , =: % F% (+51N0+(PE7O0DD;"(5+5-

8! ! & $ < < !% ! "! " W "( % " "% !! !"! " " " 9 &! " 8 " $ " '( 0; ( 5 P(01(00+-(

/(

5(( 3 <(5DD(0%J"% < / !/" >( " !8 <!/ < $ '( 0D; 550P5) 6-""/"8 < " / <$ 'F/ !% % ( 5DD N 01 05P% F% (5DDN+P ,8:G7X : 7=(O:=O%E7O% (5DDN+(*-(

5(/( $%<$$/&7Y$ '( 550 -% 9 "% "% ! $ % &<!%& "! % & "! "/! 8 $ "!!'6RY% F (550N2%"!(00 05!$!!PX (E$$% <3!%Z00N))-(

7%4" < 7/ " $ / $! !% "! 8F!. < $ "/!" C7<" 3$ & ."!> <' 600250 ()%, 0DD12+P 62+5@0%, 0D0@ 0+-( "! / " < " $3 < $ & !7 J $( <8 " " < "!$& & % "!

!% &< &! " 3( <8 / "J < "! ! ! 8!83%!""!! $' / "8N+ , 0DD12*P 62+5@0%5@)(% , 0D0@0+%0;-(

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

79"7"4" "><$$ $ < </!$%/"% ' 6@0055%05+%, 0D)*5)P 6)@00+%, 0D++00P/ 9% F (0D;N2-(

<% . 8! " $ '( 55@ P ( 5D +1 6-% " . "!! 4&<> J $ ' E:2)@:1+ 5;/511+ (+)(/P E:;@:511) 5$! 511) (+(-(

5( ( $ </4 < <( 5*1 '""/ " / <$ " <( +5) -% ""$>< $&!7" J $ F.%> & 83 3"/ </>

" &<> ! ',F 79% "( (% , 0DDD +*P $( !8( F/ !% " %$ %N512)(%"(+@0-(

$! > 4" < 7/ " $ / $! !% "! "/! " 8!"<()7" "/ <. ! ! $! > <( 5*1 ( "! &"">7&! "!4 /" ' 6 002 50 ( )/- -% , 0DD1 2+% 2*(P 6 2+ 5@0% 5@)(%, 0D0@0+%0;P 62201*%, 0D0@05)%05;(PA0@:0D0D N010 (+P"" ?. / $! ! +1 / 0D@1 "/! 3 6 01* +51 (2% , 0D@5 00)-(

+(( <"%%> 4" ""!% ! "!&"8 "/ $ </4 <%%$/(

+(/( E<8% "% "! BBBBBB E ' EBBBBBBE -%"8 &<$ " BBBBBB E V ! < ! " > EBBBBBB E ( "8 " BBBBBBE > & !!$!!"" "GBBBBBBE ( 3$ <!/ BBBBBBE % "88"&EBBBBBBE " ! <7 " GBBBBBBE % BBBBBBE (

< " H 6 I F % <. 4 00511;%$ < &EBBBBBBE !! !"GBBBBBBE " BBBBBBE ("N2" " "8 " $$% 3 "8% F8 3 "! GBBBBBB E $ BBBBBB E /"J H" BBBBBBI(

<! " $ " % &! BBBBBB E " $ <! "! > < EBBBBBB E ""W ( $ & BBBBBB E ! !>011L"GBBBBBBE &EBBBBBBE " ! <7 ! <3! BBBBBB E ( 3!!".7 ! !% " 8%&"!&"8 > < EBBBBBB E "% / ! % $ BBBBBB E "/ <.! !( 8! &"4" /$! !

""! ! 5(( & $ / "!<""W "(

%<>&& $! > =( BBBBBB < "! > < EBBBBBB E (" . "(

E<8 > > % & <! " "!! "!!%9 0)#0D2#502$(*1 &! "% V% <!/ " <%$$ $ !8 !' (5((F PF/!% % (550N00 (525 ND-(

+(( & % 3% "! < % "8 $ /3 & &< "& "/ <$ BBBBBBE &< < !4> !!> !%3 J! EBBBBBB E % :D)@:511+% 4 <7 ( E "8% & >W"/! < <()(

8! 8$$78! "! %$ < &<>/ && $! " "!><( /$! !$$&% "%"!" $( <!"/%".!' 600250 ( )/---($/ "!< &"8 $ >4"% $ !"(

< "" & < 8F!. <( ) "" !!!""'E7O0D)5%"(;)-& ".!""!"F'$("(3( E:*+2:511* 5 / 511* ( *P E7O 0D;@% "( 001-( E< <9 $ !% "8 / " % "! " W "/! 8 '(21 P$( 600250 ()/--( %$ & "8 "$ "" ""! V% . & & $ < "! !!%"" !7!>"! &< $ > < &! " > (

2(( " $$ !$% & &! "! !% & " <% <! ">"<$!' % F % (0;N*1 (50N+-(

2(/( <"%& !> >&. "8 ) 511; > &< "! > < BBBBBB E ' EBBBBBB E - "! > < BBBBBB E & ' ( +(/( F -( % & <9 &<> !$! > <4 & $% "8 >!<8 < "! !! /4(

"8 $ > & & ! H I "!( % !! ! " 7% & ! " ! >>$( $!3 <(+5)% !<" </ ""& %"%> < <(+51(5%" !% / "J " 3 8 . " 'F/ !% % (+5)N@P&, =: % F % (+5)N;!$!!-( <3 & !<8 !&<! " 3J! !$!><(+5) '$( ()F -(

< &&>! &<> /4 !! 3 "8 >< <"!>< < '$( (+((F -(

)(( & < "/ <$><(01" <( +51 ( + ' % F% ( 01 N 2P &, =: % F% (+51N55-(

<(01"!!/8 !!!>! 0 7$$0>2%&""!. <8! 4 '7( 0- & " " "!R <$$'7(2-( <8 <!/4 8 "%""% <!$ <!.'$( 6012 0% , 0D@1 0D-( $$ & <"" "!$ !" <8(E ! /4 . " ! 'F/ !% % ( 01 N 21-( < % "" <"/$ <!.$$&<! "'% F% (01N@-(

! " . & " !! " / < " > <! ' % F% ( 01 N D-( ! " "! " W $$! $ ! & < "/ <$'F /!% % (01N50-("!<8! <8 < &!% !8 " "! '% F% (01N00(-

)(/( <"% 8$ "8 $ " =(BBBBBB( <8 $ " $ % . /% <"! =( OBBBBBB( % & ! =(BBBBBB3!F"(

=( BBBBBB !! ! EBBBBBB E % 8! "/ <""E (!!"/ <3! $!0DD;"GBBBBBBE % &"8 "!! ! ( " $% ""W ! & =(BBBBBB < $ <!. & <".7 ! % /4 "% & > "! !BBBBBBE 'EBBBBBBE -% "8(

9 %>!8 % <=(BBBBBB>!(

*(( < $ \ " & \ " < $ \ " <78 \ ! " 8 !. '(521 -( < > " " "" ! !( ! " 38 < \ & \ &< " "" ' 600*0)@ ()%, 0DD0)@, 0DD50@1-(

*(/( <"% "8 > &< ! <" "" "!>< BBBBBBE < (

V !! F & "! < " $ > % "8""! /4( &<% !&% !"J "%"8" """/ "&<F.&>< < 0+511;(

E<8 "!BBBBBBE 'EBBBBBBE -%$ < && <" "" !" =(OBBBBBB ! ! $ "!%" ! $

> "8( "!! ! > ! > !8 ( ! . > / !7!% " ! "" <""& 3 ! %!""!&EBBBBBBE M! <0DD;>0DD@ & <7!5*K0DD;'$(" H 6 I%( ((-( E< . ! > $ "! !!% . "!! 3 ( +5) 5*1 $ "8% & <" !7"">" ""( % =( OBBBBBB ! " !7"">"! 98 ! ""&""/(

%2 "8 .4!(

;( !$ !" '(51(57() %*0(5(% *5(5 -(

]]]]]

-

0

1 &2'0

!/"$!0+511;" ! & < #%#&'() %$&'*&"''%"+,"($" %! %! &($"&' 5511;(

,1 %(0

0( < "(

5( & < #%#&' () %$&'*&"' '% "+,"($" % ! %! &($"&' > " > < "! BBBBBB E 'EBBBBBBE -> 0)#0D2#502$(*1(

+( & =( BBBBBB ! <8 ! > "!!7$$0F (

2( =( OBBBBBB ! < #%#&' () %$&'*&"' '% "+,"($" % ! %! &($"&' > % !% $" > "!!7$$0F (

)( !/" (

"#3'%$? =( !89 ^% "! P =( 7"" A % 48 P =(^ %48""!(

?

= E !89^ $$? ! ? "! !&!" !3"" 8$$

Appeal on Admissibility of Prior Inconsistent Statements in Liability Dispute

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet