DCSO/271/2007 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

DCSO/271/2007 · Will Validity Contest: Capacity and Undue Influence (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute concerned the validity of a will executed by an individual who was in poor health and whose capacity was contested, particularly focusing on whether the testamentary instrument reflected the true wishes of the deceased and whether undue influence was exerted by beneficiaries. The court reasoned that the evidence presented, including the medical condition of the deceased and the circumstances surrounding the execution of the document, failed to establish that the deceased lacked the requisite mental capacity or was subjected to coercion sufficient to invalidate the will, ultimately upholding the challenged document.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Minimum vital. Saisie de salaire. | L'insaisissabilité d'une rente a simplement pour conséquence que la rente elle-même ne peut être saisie; elle n'en doit pas moins être ajoutée aux autres ressources du débiteur pour le calcul du minimum vital. Rappel de la jurisprudence relative à la base d'entretien pour les enfants vivant avec le poursuivi et envers lesquels celui-ci a une obligation d'entretien. Conditions de la saisie de gains dite "arrangée". | LP.92; LP.93; CC.277.2

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

validité du testament moyens de preuve médicaux captation dolosive usage de faux vocation successorale validité du scrutin

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited for the imputation of court costs.

Généré par l'IA

A/1369/2001

Will Validity: Undue Influence and Testamentary Capacity Dispute

A/1450/2002

Will Contest: Testamentary Capacity and Undue Influence

A/336/2004

Will Validity Dispute: Capacity and Undue Influence Claim Fails

A/1931/2004

Will Validity Appeal: Testamentary Capacity and Undue Influence Rejected

A/1201/2007

Will Validity Contest: Testamentary Capacity Upheld

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited for the imputation of court costs.

Texte complet

DCSO/271/07

:005;:511<%"0<$!51511<" (

!&!=>

!"!#$%&'&(( )*$(('#$+,

%$%"-./(&%0'#)'&)* "&&(%#$%& &(+$)+$%$) 5*% ? "++< 0500+

&+"(0'#('&%(

! " " #$$ " $%&! "" $'()*(+,-( . !"! /$! !%011102% 34&$ #3"! " "! !'(011(05( 6- &4 ""$$ 78'(011(+( 6-( .! 8! 8$$% &%&#&! 9 "%.8!'(25 6-(

( "&=@ A BBBBBB'! C 1* 33331D -% @$$ " 'E"> @$$- &! !/ @3!=(

A BBBBBB @ "!! = @$$ 5* $! 511<( % @778 @8!""E/ "! &A BBBBBB8!(

& A BBBBBB " A?% & " )#5<* $( % & 0#211 $( & 78 " 9 0#1+1$()1% $ " 551 $( $ " <1 $( " # " @FBBBBBB"9!(

?/ 8$"A BBBBBB%@$$ ! !% " "% @3! 8 2#5)1 $( " $ 511<% " &% * 511<% ! " @ &@ !$ " @ !% @3!" @"9(

05511<%@$$ 8"!! !%"" !% =@A?(

( 51 511<% A BBBBBB "! " "E !(

3"." .!"@$$( ?% . +#)11$(&$3!"@$$00 "/ 511* " ! C 1) 33331) G% H @ " 78!( & !8 "9! ! .! = +#)11 $( 4 $ = 78( A BBBBBB " = @"" ""E/ %!C1)33331)G(

"" )511<%@$$ &&@8 @3"& " $ &@ " " . " !/ / )11$(= $ ,BBBBBB%"& %!0;<;%"" "!" @/!8(@$$ &" ! ! 8 $& !/ !!"""9&!(@$$ & !(

?@8 !% $! ! ? @ $!" !&!!"%" @""=4% 4 "(

( @ 02 511<% A BBBBBB !"!! "% $&@""@8 !!( !8 &! !! 7&! & @ !! 9! = "9% &@ !8"9!!.!=+#)11$(&@ = @$$ &@ " . "9 " ! & @ @" 8!&(@88!= "9 !8 &@.! " !% / @ $% ! & "9!&!(

A BBBBBB""! 78% 3"&@$$ 551$("@$$ $ "( 78 " @$$% &! "9 +11 $( " / @ ! ! " @ /&% 511 $( " @ H I! ! &@$%&5*1$( $ !!"7%8J!!(

A BBBBBB$$!&$,BBBBBB!K8! " 8E & &@ % = 78( A( BBBBBB = $ ( @9 " 7L8% "=""&! 7$$(! " ! "978/511*%/ != M511*(A BBBBBBN @ $=<11E D11$(

@$$ $! ""% 3"& &@ !% ! 7 // & A BBBBBB "! " !8 " % " & 8!! (

( !&!!"=$$%A BBBBBB" 3"%>

E " @ !! BBBBBB ? 0< / 511*% & & 0 4 511< 9 " @ O/3P 5+1$(

E " @ $ ! " @ FBBBBBB * 511< " " @E 511<'+<5$(-Q

E " @ !" *11$( !!0+511< "/&BBBBBB=Q

E " @ !" *11$( !!0$!511< "/&BBBBBB=Q

E " @3+0/511* " A BBBBBB" /&BBBBBB=Q

E " $!!"!% " 0+<$(;) 5D$!511<"$$ !!?BBBBBB % 5+1$( 5D $! 511< " A BBBBBB $ !! BBBBBB ? % 01+$(<)5D$!511<"$$ ? % 01+1 $( )1 5D $! 511< " A BBBBBB $ @" BBBBBB% 3$5+1$(D511<"A BBBBBB$ !!BBBBBB? % 01+$(;)D511<"$$ !! ?BBBBBB % D1 $( *) D 511< " $ $ ? 01+1 $( )1 D 511< " A BBBBBB $ @" BBBBBB(

( <4511<%@$$&!3""E/ %! C1*33331D(

0( "! " !! $! " " @! "! 4="""9&!" 8" '(0<Q(01(00+-(

/(

5(( @(;+% %$" % 8% . & / @% " " & !=" 8 "! ! @%" ! " & " / @( ;5 % " . % ! $ &"!"! "/"@ !/ $( ".""= " @3! ( ?% !% @$$ @ $ !" % "@" 3(

5(/( ?@(;5(07(;% @(51 $! ! @E" @(05

$! ! 0; 0;*) " "! = #E % !/(

!% 4" % @ !/ & 7 // H3 " & @ " " ( ! /%$ " $& !/"/= " 9 /% & " " @"/ ! 8( & % %& " = $ @ / @(;+ ( @/! @ " " !& &E. ".Q@ ".4! 3 !/ " ' 6 "/!) B02:511< 02511< %+(0Q 6012+D%, 0;D10*Q 6;<0*%, 0;<0010Q ?:<+2:511) +1/511)Q,E A79% %R+<5-(

5(( @"% $! 3 "" ""!% !/ 4 ! *#*<* $( ')#5<* $( '- S 0#211 $( '--%@@$$(

+(( @ !/%& .$3!$ $3 @3! ' 600)01+%, 0;;001D-% !! / @/! ! ! " @ ! " % 8 % @ " @! 511< '?: + *1(12-( @4=/'7(-9$$$ 8 !/ $ 7$$8 '7( (0-( 6 !8 " @ /'7((+-% .& !" "/ = @3 @ ! "$% & $ " "" 7 %@4$!= 78 !/ '7( (2-( 7% $ @!8% !& 8J %$ @% / " . " "( 78 $% $ !!"7 @$ @ !/ $ " " '?, 5111 50+Q 6 05* D; (+/ $% , 5111 51Q 6 "/! <( 550:511+ ( +Q 6"/!<(0<0:5112 (5(0Q 6"/!<(<:511< (2-(

? $$ "9! . " " 'A7 7% E% ( ;+ C D5 ( . !-( "" " " @ 9( !/ " ! =" H!/ / @ "9 $$ 9

" @ ' 6 050 51 ( +/% , 0;;< 0*+Q 6051 0* ( 5% , 0;;* 0<;% 0D0-( @ !8 "!&$ !"4&@ @!"3 @/ ""/(?@8" $ " " 7 % @/! "! 3 01 $% " "% ! "" 551$('55""-(

$%!8 / %@""/ "% % & !/ / 7& % & / . @!! " 88 ( $$% 4$ " "!8 ! & @ " "% ! !("8@" /% T%""!"Q 8 " !" "/=@ !/ $ ' 6 ;* *% , 0; 2;Q 6 015 0<% , 0;<<)D-(

+(/( / @ "! " @/! "!! " 7 $ " & E/8 @( / !" @K8 @$'(2(-(

@ @$4@ !/& "&"/8!8=!8 ( 4" %@(5<<(5 ""/="" & " @/8 @ @$ 4 &% = 4!% E @ " $ """! " & %= !& "% " @38 @3' 6"/!<(511:0;;; 5*/0;;; ( 5Q 6 "/! <(55D:5112 0 !/ 5112 ( )(0Q 6"/!<(01;:511) +1N511) (+(0-(@/8" " @ $ E = 4! @ 4$! & & @$ " $ & E "$( % @/8 @ @3 & " $ "$Q 3$% "$ $ "! " " "% . @ " "T ( $$!% $% &@ @8 "!/$"$%."& 4 !4=88!( $ " 88!!=" $3!4!' 600D ;<% , 0;;2 +20Q 6 05< 515 ( + +$% 6 5115 +1DQ 605;+<)%, 511++)<Q ?:512:511* *511* (+(Q ?:5+;:511< 00511< (D(-(

? !!% / @ @$ " @ $ " "( 7%$! '3 @"- '$ " = @3!% "% 8 "- = ! "!$"" E'?,511150*(Q ?:512:511* * 511* (+(-(

2(( @"%9 @/ &@=/ &@$$ !!&@9 @ "@" $3!00"/ 511* &@ @9 " " "8 @/ )11$("$4,BBBBBB%! 0;<;( ""! ! +(/( E $$ $""(@""T""&A( BBBBBB " $% = "$% " =" !/7!4!("!! $$=$ % "=%""&! 7$$(% "8%! @" ! "978511*% / ! 3 " !( @ " !!!% @&%&&@% ! " "3"4" / $! !""!(

2(/( !8 3 "" ""! ! +(( E 3 4$$ " % "8% ! "" @/! " @! 511<% 8 @3! % @!/>

/" !/' (0-> 0#011$( 9' (0- 0#1+1$()1 E ' (+- 1$('"9!- 6 "' (2(/- 551$( 6 "' (2(- <1$(

%$)> 1 #23

" *#*<*$(' (5(E - 78 '5#251 $( )1-% &! / "8 = 2#5))$()1%@@$$(

&! / "!! " @$$ $$ @%$ 4"(

)(( !$ &"8 &@$$&!@@ @! = "9( " % N . &! &%!! "!! 8 3!! " @$$( % "8 & @$$ 3! 8 @ (

)(/( "" @( ;) ( ) % 3 & $ & " = & "/ !. ! 3 !/% @$$ % $U % &@ 3!!. !/&@ @"9 " " !& "% ! "!! &@ " & E" @ ! @$$=$ 8 '$( @$$ 3 7 7 % 5; N 511+Q ?:+D;:1* 0) 4 511* ( 5(/Q ?:)0<:511* 5) N 511* (5(/-(

@"3& @ !&@&" !3 !/"@$$=3! 8 O8!P"L&@ =@"9( @$$ " @ " @""!% ! @ @(;)()' % E% (;)C+<-% ! "% "% L @8% 8$ @""! ! "" / '( 0< ( 0 Q ?:)0<:511* 5)N511* (5(/ !!-(@3! @ $ @ 8"!" ! 3" @3! @ % & ! @ "% " ! "% " 4$% & . !! / / !% & !. ! @ "K @ && $U( @( ;) ( ) . " @ $U "&"&&@$$!8!=@ !& @3! @ ' ?:)0<:511* 5)N511* (5(/-(

)(( @"% @ ! & @$$ /! " @""!&=@"9 "8@ !!'(;;Q$/8C01-(

$$% "8 ! ! 9 &! " . "9 !!%@=4&@$$ ! ! @3! = ( "% @ " ""! @!! "/" "&@ "9

"!" &@4$ @3!" 8 8!(

" !84!"(

*( !$ !" '(51(57() %*0(5(% *5(5 -(

VVVVV

/

4

)$ #4

!/"$!51511<" @ &!"@$$ "05511< "%!C1*33331D(

' "4

0( 4(

5( !/" (

&!5$%> A( !89 W% "! Q A( 7"" X % 48 Q A(W %48""!(

>

A ? !89W $$> ! >

"! !&!" =@$$!" !3""8$$

Will Validity Contest: Capacity and Undue Influence

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet