Affirmation of Evidentiary Rulings and Dismissal of Appeals
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe court addressed multiple procedural matters, including challenges to admissibility of evidence and granting of continuances, ultimately affirming prior findings and dismissing several appeals. The reasoning centered on finding no abuse of discretion in the trial court's evidentiary rulings, such as admitting photographic evidence and testimony, and in its management of the trial schedule, concluding that the record did not support overturning the initial judgment on the grounds raised by the appealing parties.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Affirmation of Evidentiary Rulings and Dismissal of Appeals: The reasoning centered on finding no abuse of discretion in the trial court's evidentiary rulings, such as admitting photographic evidence and testimony, and in its management of the trial schedule, concluding that the record did not support overturning the initial judgment on the grounds raised by the appealing parties.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAThis provision is cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.
Texte complet
DCSO/236/07
:*0*:511;% " 0; $! 0< $! 511; " % ! #! =8 = %%>(
!&!>?
!? =8 = % @A5 051;
!"
#$$!%&"'
(()&"*"$+,!%$!)-"$
! " " #$$ " $%&! "" $'()*(+,-( . !"! /$! !%011102% 34&$ #3"! " "! !'(011(05( 6- &4 ""$$ 78'(011(+( 6-( .! 8! 8$$% &%&#&! 9 "%.8!'(25 6-(
( 50 !/ 511*% B CDDDDDD & " > # =(DDDDDD%> 7(
+04511;%#$$ "'A"?#$$-$! " =(DDDDDD "9"E1*3333+5,(
"#"!!$""! #""(
5F511;%BCDDDDDD& "(
( 5* 4 511;% /& DDDDDD & " > # =(DDDDDD%> 7(
0 $! 511;% #$$ ! ! "9% " E1;33330* % & $ #/4 # $ $ 0+$!511;(
( 0<$!511;%=(DDDDDD"!"> "9"1*3333+5,1;33330* !>"#$$(
3"&#> %#"!!>#$$%;$!511;% $ #/ A" &#> % "" #3 3" 8!>(
=(DDDDDD !&#&! !$@%"#.!"! !"%511+"#!/> G!%$ ! $!4ᆟ*%"&##!$> 7H I/!H( ! &# #9 " $ " > " 511+(
=(DDDDDD &&#! $@&# #""78 # >#$$ "" !! #"J&# ># $(
"! & &# > !"% ! ! > 8"&#G&!@"#> % &! "> 7("!&##4 ! > % & " #9 " " $! 511;%&# !#"8(
#"" "% =( DDDDDD " " ! $ 511+% " 3 ! K 3 K " #! 5112 511)% " # / = =DDDDDD =( DDDDDD " #> </5112F/ 511)% "8! 4&# F/ 511*% " # / #"J " #! 511)% " # / 3 $ > 3 ! L"511*(
> ! ! "9 " 1* 3333+5 , 1; 33330* % / (
( ""% #$$ & " " " " !/!> 511+ 4511*% !"J "8(
#$$& " 4511*" !& > 7HI/!H&##" " #3 (
#$$ ! &% " "" " &# # ! I/!H " 4511*%"8 .!"/ $>(4&##!%# " 7&&##"">4(
( "8% !" !" " I/!H(
! "% =( DDDDDD " " 3 !4 I/!H / 0 4 511* 0) M 511* ) M 511* ) M 511;% " # / 8! + $! 511; B"DDDDDD%#"9 =(DDDDDD%=DDDDDD" # > 7H + $! 511; + M 511;% ""9!" $(
6( # &# !2511;% =( DDDDDD " " # B" DDDDDD% & =( DDDDDD "9! B" ,DDDDDD "04511*4&#>4( "!&BB" DDDDDD>=(DDDDDD7/> 7H(
&!&=(DDDDDD7/> 7H " 4511*% &# !4" (
=(DDDDDD !!&!4 8 #$$ ""! !> 7% #!!$3(
4! &% 7 3A!" $% # " "! > % & " !!8! $! 511; &# #! ! "8( &! & # N% 7 DDDDDD#!&# #7 &=(DDDDDD #4!> (
=(DDDDDD !!&&!511+% &##!!> G$"I/!H>" 4511*(
!&"#"$! $ "9"E1*3333+5, "/ $&#$$ #&!!/(
=(DDDDDD !!&$ " 8 $ " !!"7 &# ! 3. & > " ( 4! & #! "8 7I "% "8 $% #!!(
$%"!!&=(DDDDDD#"8 ! #>%&## "8 ! ! %&#>% #"! />(
#$$$! ""#""!>#""! !(
0( @$ G " 4 % " . "! " > #! &# #$$> "O"4$!$(" . !"! 34 G"8 '(0;(05P(01(0 P()*(+,-(
#" # " & $ B "9 4 > "% & " &! " &"(
"!"$338 $ "" '(0+(05-(
"8 "" #3 3 " 8! > % ;$! 511;% & # > #$$ $ #/ A"&#$$ !!3 " >("$!0<$!511;#!! ! 34 "&!( 4
!! 0;$!511;% !3""4&% 0<$!511;'(+0(+-(
" !!/(
5( > " ! ! B!. "/ B!. " & " " > "! B! B$$!%. ! " !"!'(55(0-(
"$'(2*- "/ "!$% ! ""! & "9 $! " $$ "!"/ ! " 34'(0;(5 -% "> $"! %7%.!"!/ "" B$$%"%B $' 6FFF ( +% , 0<*5 +2P 6 <* +0 ( 5% , 0<;+ 5; 4" !P @:*55:511* 5/511* (0/(-(
B % B/ 8 $ ! $$!B "(
"! B B% B $% 8$O!% G B8 B & $ !/( ! . ! B$$ " !" B " '( 55 P A/ !% % & ( 2*A))% E++-(7%& $"!/ !/&B/( "9&%B !!/$! %B"(@ !/$" ! "% " " B$$ "! !'L (@$$% B3!%Q+% E <2(% "( ;; 4" !P $( !8( A/ !% %& (2*A))%E+54" !PCA/@7R"/7% A% (2*A))%E50 4" !P 6F5*+ (2%, 0<)*<<-( B& !/ & B " "! " 3 4 $ "9 & B! "!""B$$ ""! % & 'A/ !% % & (2*A))%E++-(
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
B " "/ &B " B 4 "" !! %$$&B"" $ 3% " "$% $S> >!4/!%& / .B "" G > $' 6*<< (5%, 0<2+ 21<P 6*<5;; (5%, 0<220;5-(
" & !4 > B!8 " @ &B@ 3% % !. !3!% &%B!/ $4> !8 J"' 6;(520:511+ F45112 (2-(
!"J "" B !% " !8% ! $ % " % " "/ $$ !3 B3 &
& $ . > !8 "!" $% & " "$' 605) 011 (+ !$! !-( $ " ! > 3 % G B8 & B ' 6 ;(520:511+ F 4 5112 (2P @:0*+:1) 55511) (2(-(
&B"!4 3 $$!&B 3 % & "!%" B/ ' 6;(520:511+ F45112 (24" !-( /$! !%> !8 % &$! B "" > B!8% . !> !"J ""% " B!"$ B!!@%&B ' 65 (00F:0<<+ 0+$!0<<)%"/! 7*2%"(210 (+"(21)(-(
$% 4" "! &B B8 / " . & !/3!&B9 8 ' 6 )0 0)F ( 0%, 0<5* )5 B. !P @7T0<F5%""(0+% E+-(
2( #"%# "!"" #!/&# !"J !& " 8! E 1; 33330* % 5*4 511; $ "9 " E1*3333+5 ,% +0 4 511;% !/ #! " ! > &# !! ! > " 511+ " I/!H " 4511*(
8 #$$ ""& !/ !> 7 "04511)( $%"" " !/% /% !& !/! > < / 5112 F/ 511)% & !! "8!% 5 / 511)% " !% 4&# F / 511* &# "9! "J > ( @ " 4 5* 511)% " "! "" !/>3A!"%!8&# / 5112% !/> (
!8 #!/"B"DDDDDD&% " 04511*4&#>4% !/"9! B",DDDDDD &"8//&#> " "9!( !/ !8 " " 3 !4I/!H/ 04511*0)M511* )M 511*)M511;(
#3" $% "8%&> %& !/ !!"7& % #" #7>($$% &!& "&!@<$!511;%&# " "8%&# !""!> 7(
6 &# #8 !& " E 1; 33330* $ "9 " E 1* 3333+5 ,% !/ #! " ! > &# I/!HG#!$ " 4 511*( ! &% !/ ! ! > #!8% #9 " $ " & #$$#!""!"""!!(
#/ $ % ! "1*3333+5,1;33330*(
UUUUU
. /
(,%0"/
! / " :*0*:511; $! 0< $! 511; " "1*3333+5,1;33330*(
!(,*/
0( # (
5( "1*3333+5,1;33330*(
+( !/" (
)12"-? =(!89N%"! P=6 @ =(7"" V %48'-(
?
= @ !89N $$? ! ?
"! !&!" >B$$!" 83""8$$