Mortgage Modification and Default Interpretation
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe appellant challenged a lower court's finding that they had defaulted on mortgage payments, arguing that a subsequent arrangement where they paid a different amount, accepted by the mortgagee, constituted a valid modification of the original agreement that excused the alleged default. The court reasoned that for a modification to supersede the original clear and unambiguous contract terms, there must be clear and convincing evidence of mutual assent to the new terms, and the evidence presented—primarily concerning informal, post-default discussions and partial payments—was insufficient to demonstrate a meeting of the minds required to legally alter the original obligations or waive the right to declare a default based on the written terms.
Regeste Legislator
OfficielNotification | Pas de vice dans la notification de la commination de faillite. Exception de non-retour à meilleure fortune. Compétence de l'Office des poursuites pour en connaître. | LP.64; LP.265a
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive orders concerning the allocation of court costs.
Texte complet
DCSO/223/07
:);0:511;%"0;$!0*$!511;"
!&!<=
!"#$%&'&()&"*+#",&- #!*& ./.001
22,&%&*'3!*!+&*
! " " #$$ " $%&! "" $'()*(+,-( . !"! /$! !%011102% 34&$ #3"! " "! !'(011(05( 6- &4 ""$$ 78'(011(+( 6-( .! 8! 8$$% &%&#&! 9 "%.8!'(25 6-(
( &. #> > % #$$ " '?" = #$$- $! < @(ABBBBBB% !"% "9 " C1*333352%5*4511*(> D E $8D ! " # $$$$% E(
"!!$""! #""(
*4511*%@(ABBBBBB#"!!87 #$$"$ "" !&##!"<$(
! ;4511*%#$$!"!!&$ $F/4%"!054511*%!!!!5+4 511*&%!% #/! #3" <$(
48 0G"/511*', :0+0;*:511*-% / " % " "! " !$% "! ! #"" $! "9 " C1*333352(
F! " C 1* 333352 % &F $!!$! @(ABBBBBB0) !/511*(
( 0*$!511;%@(ABBBBBB"!"< (
!& $"!!$!%&% # )$!511;%48 / "78! "$ ! ! " :5G+:511; # !& " !(
4 &% ! ; 4 511*% #$$ 4! #3" ?<$&#$!*4511*& 48"!""3"(
( ""%#$$ &&% H$ !/ !!!!5+4511*&# !$ /#!! !!% # " "9 / " "&##3" ?<$(
#$$4&0) !/511* $!!$! <@(ABBBBBB&$&"! !< $/! "!/&$ #3" !/ (
( ! < "! / "% > > &# $ @(ABBBBBB#9!!! !$ / !!< #$%#3" ?<$"I $ !(
4 & ! #$$ 4 #3" ? < $ ;4511*&"%$!0*$!511;% $ (
( 48 ', :+*01:1;- ) 511;% / " % " "! % ! ! < &. $ $! 01 4 511; " > > < # @(ABBBBBB 4&#< 48! "! " ! :);0:511;(
6( ! ! " " " F $(
&F+1511;%@(ABBBBBB$! &#J #$$ ;4511*%&# !!"7&/ #$$& &!&##! " $ ! < 3" $ & $ !! !! &#!<""" !(
&! &# !! 8 &! # BBBBBB> 0KG1 <0KK5%"&!! !!& !" $(><$%"" !! 8!</< ! F !$ / 5)L0KK5(
@( ABBBBBB% 8 % BBBBBB ABBBBBB% " ) 0KKK% !8 $! & $% "!054511*%!!!!5+4511*(
@(ABBBBBB4!& $!""" ""% "% &# "" " & #J(
&! !%@(BBBBBB%$% !!&# !""7#3"! $ &""7#3" !/($!&0+ !/ 511*% ! ! < " ?9 &
$ $ ! 0+ !/ 511* M( !!&#@(ABBBBBB & $! $(
"!!&#< "0;?;&! $? &# #7/ $ "9 " $(
""!&# !/ !%G7+1K711%K70)" % #! @( ABBBBBB% &# ! < "% & "!!"!" &#$! $(#3" !/ $"!! #9"!& $%&#""!#3"! &!!!<#$$(
!4!&#!!<"" $ < @( ABBBBBB% " !% &#< 7& $ # @(ABBBBBB&!" &##"! #"< (
$%$$!&#/#3" !/ $<@(ABBBBBB&##"" ""&# !< (
>< %@(ABBBBBB !!&% #"8 !&% N?< <017110) !/511*&# L& K711(
"$$!& $!""" ""%"%"!!%& " $ $% &# ! """J<# $&# &F!! !"(
0( >$ H " 4 % " . "! " < #! &# #$$< "I"4$!$(" . !"! 34 H"8 '(0;O(01(0(00 (5O()*(+,-(
$ $ 4 < "%&"&!"&"(
"!"$338 $ "" '(0+(05-(
"8 # " 8 ! 3 4 $ $&!( $% H& $ "%&"$ ! & ! 3 #$$"'(55% (5(/(? -%4$ #"!"(
5(( "9&F $ " $F/4 F.$&$! $'(;50*0-( F< ! "%F/ % F " " !8!"33"!"% / F77! "%< !$% F " "' 600;;% (+/OP (>$$% F3! Q + C51 O , R?RSTN% U8 /8S % >7R 0KK*% "( 510 % 512 O V NN% $ %5115%"(505(C+;G(-( " " !8 . $! < < "!%"<"%F"&&%"& F8$<. F $( % H 3 7/ "$% / "! % $$%& !!""< $ "7/! < F " '?/ !% ( *2 CK4" !-(
" . $! !/ < F H37/"$(>F/F". <" !8<"9!'(*2(0"7(0 -(
38 $% "! 3 ( *2 < % !! "" < $ " 7/! < F " < 8 & " " $$ %$F!" " " F"%<& " F 'P ( >$$% F3!% Q + C51<55-(
5(/( " $ " ! " $! ! $ !( " &FF"!/&F "9 $ ! " " F " " !8! " ( >% 8! $ !% #
" " " "! " $ "" ! < " " ! #$!%!8! $FI%""%! ?%! "9%" $' 605G 012%, 51155)O>7R5115)0511+00*-(
5(( > F( ;5 % $ "!! " "!"!% " "9! #$$ " "( & " < $ 7& 3"4H"<&F!!( "?/ $ ""! 3 3" F " $ $ $ &F % 4&F< " '( G ( 5 O ?/ !% (G C +1 (% ( ;5 C 0GO , ( %>7R (GC01(ORPW77:>77%>7R% (;5C02-(
FF$$&"$ " $!8 "% "!4 F /8 " / < F!/ $'(51(57(5-( !8 % !$ / "8 " . F/! " ' % ?% (51C02-(
"?/ $% ! 8! # "% 8 8!! "%"F!<$" '(G(5O% ?% (GC;O?/!% % ( G C +1 ( ;5 C 0G !$! !O , (%>7R% (GC05O 600;01 ()%, 0KK+ 0+1O 601;0 (0%, 0KG++K-(
+( #"% F! " !! #3" ! $&!!$!0) !/ 511*<@(ABBBBBB(
%&! !%" !%$ " ?9!""7#3" ! $ "!! ""7 #3" !/(%$ !!%&# !/ !%#! !/?&#<# ?%& "%&#$! $ #3" !/ $ #9 "!& $%&#"! #3"!&#!<#$$(
><# $% !/& "" !! & $ !! ! ""% " " "% &# " &# $ !!$!0) !/511*&#& !! !"""%"& !!FJ ""(
!!&& $%&F F" !! ""8% !<& $8/!!$!"!!0) !/ 511*(
"! " ! $ ! 4! /!(
2( "8"! &#""&#$! "9 "C1*333352 L.48 $ $" &F!!"$&FF!"<$(
2(/( > ! &F " ! < "! / $ %&". &F3"'$( 600) 0G ( +/O >:2)G:1+ 5; / 511+ ( )/ :00);:511+O >:0K5:1+ 55 511+ ( + :*+1:511+-% F3" ? < $ '( 5*) ( 0 - .48 $ "%& /$! !F F 6 052 +;K% 7 4 '$(6 %>7R511+"(KK(-(
"" <#$$ #3/! #""% " $(#$$!$" !!! "! ! " ! < ""% !<4"$#/4 #" " !/ !(7%#$$#"<!$#3" <$/ %48" ! ' >:2GG:511+ 0+ / 511+ >:;5K:511* 0G !/ 511*O 6 052 +;K% , 0KKK 05*O P >$$% F3!%Q00C0+)O ,8:A7P : 7@(R: @R%>7R%2! (0KK;% (;2CK-(
#"%""&%" ! ;4511*%#$$4! #3" <$!""8&# L%$!<4" "!!%!$" !!! ! 34$ "9 48( #$$ "! "!( !% ! #$$ ;4511*#"$#/4 #" ! 34$%""8 "!"(
"% ! & F3" ? < $ " . / ! &F< F F "&/ F !$ / !! & F $ '(5*) (5 "7(5 - " "! ! " ! F $ '(5*; O ?/ !% % (5*) C+5 ( (5*) C;OA/%>7R% (5*)C0+ (5*)CK5*-%& #"%"8"/ # !$ / !!"&##! "$ !<#3" ?<$(
XXXXX
4 5
0( 4" :);0:511;$!0*$!511;" "C1*333352 /!(
5( !/" (
67&#"+= @ PV A% "! O @( >> @ 6 > %48'-(
=
@ > PV A $$= ! =
"! !&!" <F$$!" 83""8$$