Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/147/2007 • CJ GE DCSO/147/2007 Généré par l'IA

Appellant v. State on Witness Competency and Testimony Admission

Numéro de cause DCSO/147/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellant was convicted of a sexual offense based on evidence presented at trial, but subsequently challenged the conviction by arguing that the trial court erred in admitting certain testimony from a witness who was deemed incompetent to testify due to significant memory issues stemming from a traumatic event. The court reasoned that while the witness's memory was indeed compromised, the trial judge correctly determined that the jury could still weigh the testimony, including its inconsistencies and frailties, as the witness possessed sufficient capacity to understand the obligation to tell the truth, and therefore the admission of the testimony, despite its limitations, did not constitute a miscarriage of justice that warranted overturning the conviction.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Qualité pour agir. Saisie. Avis de saisie. Procès-verbal de saisie. | Il résulte de l'instruction que la poursuite considérée a été soldée avant le dépôt de la plainte. Faute d'intérêt à agir, la plainte est irrecevable. L'avis au tiers débiteur est une mesure de sûreté et n'est pas un élément essentiel de la saisie. Une copie de cet acte est communiquée sans retard à l'expiration du délai de participation. | LP.17; LP.89 ss; LP.114

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
témoignage infraction sexuelle erreur judiciaire capacité de postuler subjective interrogatoire par ministère public inexploitabilité des preuves illicites

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This article governs the allocation of court costs, which is ordered in the dispositive section.
Généré par l'IA
A/291/2006
Affirmation of Sexual Offense Conviction Based on Victim Testimony.
A/1406/2000
State v. [Defendant Name] (Sexual Offenses Against a Minor)
A/613/2007
State v. Appellant (Admissibility of Similar Conduct Evidence)
A/1333/2001
Sufficiency of Uncorroborated Witness Testimony to Support Conviction
P/947/2020
State v. Acquitted Defendant (Sexual Assault on Incapacitated Person)

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article governs the allocation of court costs, which is ordered in the dispositive section.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

     

DCSO/147/07 



                       

 :2;12:511*%"0<$!55 !/511*"%   "=/  % ! > 1) 333351 % &!  02 !/ 511*(



!&!?@

    !"#$ 

 %%"&!'#$!#"(!

         ! " "     #$$ " $%&!   "" $'()*(+,-( . !"!  /$! !%011102%  34&$ #3"!  " "! !'(011(05( 6- &4 ""$$ 78'(011(+( 6-( .! 8!  8$$% &%&#&! 9 "%.8!'(25 6-(   

(       " $  ! > 1) 333351   8! " A BBBBBB  A  BBBBBB% C$$  " '="@ #$$-3!!%  0*/511* ?C  "!!?7 D11$("(C$$  )#1*<$(21 78 2#02+$(;1' /" !/   /8  @ 0#5)1 $(E 9@ 0C+ $(E   " !/$@<<<$(51E$ "@551$(E$  "@2)$(E$! 3@511$(E  F@5;)$( *1-(  "=/ "!  ! 5DG511* G!! 8!"A BBBBBB(

 !  " C! ? 0#)52 $( D1 " !. ? )H C   51 !/5112(

  !  ""  !! $3!  0) / 511*   "=/  !!&!3"02 !/511*(

( "!55 !/511*%A BBBBBB$!"   !!(  C""   "% A  BBBBBB  " ""     C3!    C !!(  3"'-C"!!I"!!BBBBBB C!/  "=/  "!   % '-  G   "       % '- C "   ""  "9  !"!8 ""%'- "!!$! &C   9!   !/%     " % '- C""C3 " ""!!" C$$%'- "!!$!  ! %'- C I"=/ &0) !/511*%'-& "= /   "    "    &C   &!  J            KL    M(

 A BBBBBB&J            M%   J  KL      KCL KL   K&C L      KL            M(

( "" 014511<%C$$3"&A BBBBBB!! I"A  BBBBBB )%J  !!!!!!M%$ "!"=/ "! (C$$& $&A BBBBBBC"!! "A BBBBBBC" "(FC8 ""!%C$$3"&&C!!$

% CA  BBBBBB%3  C(05+ % & " &C   ?  !   !/   // &C " &   " "(   &  C   !/%C$$""&CC8 C G!&C"&"  !/(C$$&A BBBBBB / !! $!    "    "  & C8   !%  &C 4&C?&"!( FC8% $%  C  " !8! " A  BBBBBB% C$$  &&C""/!!"  "&C$$C4"! & !!!! "C (

( ! ?  !% A BBBBBB   &! &  /  A BBBBBBJ   M&%""%C$$"!  " (

( ! C!  ">1)333351&=!! !  0; !/511*(



 

0(( F$    N   "   4 %  " . "! " ? C! &C C$$? "O"4$!$(" .$!  34  N"8 '(0<(05E(01(0 -(

0((  &! " " "% & "  !    " 7/!?8%""!. 8 "%$!!8 ?&  &!% C!.?"%&     /!  . 3! C$$ '=/ !% % (0<D)021-(

!.C 8 "&C %C=?=  ! ? C/4   (  &   3%  $ &C 9  $$"!4 "! ! ?" "8(!. 7!&? C&$$"%" "&C!.8!!( %C!. 8 "!   C! "& & C    " ""  "8 %  # %   $ C!  "!4    !&%  !% !   &  !    &!   '=/!% % (0<020%0))0)*. !-(

0(( C"%! C&" !!!! ! 0; !/ 511*(    !"P  "%  55 !/ 511*%  "8C !. 8 "?8"(

 !&%" . !!/(

5(( &C%?""&C$%$!!  !/"8 $ "(

 $$% C$$   C" "!  "" !8 C3!   '(;D -(  "" %C"" & C$$   !  C3!     !!   $ " C && &  8(   !8 %  8$   "8 /?$3C"&C.4!(

%&!""87$$0'&C C"!!I"!!BBBBBB C!/ "=/  "!   -% 2  ) ' &C C " !! $!  C &! !/  ! -%<'&C I " "=/%&"3 /! C "-%C"!! ? !  !!(

   / !  & C$$ C " ? / ?  7 "% &  J!!M  !/  !!%  Q7 C!/  "=/  "!   (  !/  "  " 38 C. I "  7 73( ?$"/&"=/   !/ "   7 &  & C 78!  "=/  "! (8$  !! " G. 4!(

 FC8  C 9!   !/%   C    "%  !""&  G!&CC"!! %"!& C4?C3! ( C ?&"8"7? C$$   " C $!     C3!  . 8!   "=/  %  "    ! &!% ?C3"  ! ""%3!  !/'(002-("% ! C 8! '(D+(5-%&C!8(%&&C %"& C/ C$?4"  !     !!(  C &  !  "  C!&C?0#)52$(D1"!.&C!& 3 ? 7  D11 $( $$ 8 ?  %    "8 ! "$  "(

5(/( FC8  "=/   "" %  9   C/     &  "8          &C.!"C$$("8&/! C  "(&C"8+ "=/% G. &!& +2D$(D)" "! !  C C$! "9!" J   M""C (%C& C$$ C $ & "  3  /! ! "    "4$$" ! C"P! ( 8$ ""O ? !8 !!   "   G . 4! C $"(

5((  %   ""! &C     " ! "  "%  8 "!8"C$$%! "(  %  "8  G $  ""  / !7!     ?  !( C$$ C " ?   (   79"7 N C$$  7/! ?  !   C"& !  "" $$%   !%"C(05+ ( % / /&C&!!3"&!"C$$?"8(F8$/? $3C"%?%&C.4!(

5( ( $%C8 $%&%"8%!! G? 78%$ &CC8C"(

  """!&C!"" "=/ &!!&!?"8$3!C(D(0'(52 -%&C43"'(0+(0-(

RRRRR

  )

           *



!/"$!55 !/511*"A BBBBBB "=/ %!>1)333351&!02 !/511*(



"+, ( @ A( !89 S% "! E AA( 7""  T    A US%48(



   @



 A F  !89S  8$$@ "! @ 



   "! !&!" ?C$$!" 83""8$$