DCSO/140/2007 · Affirmation of Financial Liability Finding Based on Statutory Interpretation (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellate court considered a challenge to a verdict concerning an individual involved in a financial transaction where the lower court had made findings regarding the construction and application of relevant financial statutes, concluding the individual was liable for monetary damages. The appellate court reviewed whether the lower court properly interpreted the statutory requirements for establishing liability and whether the factual findings supported the conclusion that the statutory prerequisites were met, ultimately affirming the lower court's decision, finding that the trial court correctly applied the law to the established facts regarding the obligations and breaches under the applicable financial framework.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Commandement de payer; notification | Aucune preuve probante n'est venue infirmer l'attestation de notification (art. 72 al. 2 LP) du commandement de payer, qui, comme titre officiel au sens de l'art. 9 CC a pleine valeur de preuve pour son contenu. S'agissant du deuxième commandement de payer, les éléments de preuve remis tendent à démontrer que l'acte n'a pas été remis à l'une des personnes visées par l'art. 64 LP. | LP.8.2; LP.64; LP.72; CC.9

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

droit des obligations condition légale transaction financière interprétation du droit décision préjudicielle sur l'assujettissement fiscal contestation de l'établissement des faits

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 93 % " = 1) 3333;2 = 1* 333355

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the judicial costs.

Généré par l'IA

A/1664/2002

Statutory Interpretation of Financial Obligation Exemption

A/2474/2006

Contractual Liability Appeal Affirmance

A/434/2005

Contract Interpretation and Financial Transaction Dispute Affirmation

A/3715/2005

Statutory Interpretation of Financial Transaction Obligations

A/1987/2005

Statutory Interpretation of Financial Transaction Liability

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 93 % " = 1) 3333;2 = 1* 333355 ,(

This article governs the main ground for the decision, resulting in the rejection of the appeal.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the judicial costs.

Texte complet

DCSO/140/07

:+;*2:511*%"0<$!52/511*" $ "9%"=1)3333;2 =1* 333355,(

!&!>?

! ! "#"$%&' ()#"*"$+"+""$"+,-.$ -/0*#" @$) 0500;

! 00+$)"

! " " #$$ " $%&! "" $'()*(+,-( . !"! /$! !%011102% 34&$ #3"! " "! !'(011(05( 6- &4 ""$$ 78'(011(+( 6-( .! 8! 8$$% &%&#&! 9 "%.8!'(25 6-(

( " = 1) 3333;2 & " A % !" 78 #$ '@"? -BCCCCCC% !>CCCCCC> 8%A$$ " '@"? A$$- $!% < 4 511)% "9>D E(

A$$A"8! A"" "9(

( " = 1* 333355 ,% !8 & " B CCCCCC% ! > CCCCCC > 8% A$$ $!% 2511*% "9 !/% D E(

A$$A"8! A"" "9(

( A"! >"%! 8$! A$$% & 3"%" 5;/511)0F4511*(

"=1)3333;2 %A$$%""" $3 3 5< 0F 4 511*% ! 5F 4 511* " 0) G 511* > B CCCCCC% '/@@% H $ A " 8! /& ! A$$% !8! " "8- &! A 8 % & "I ! >BCCCCCC "!>A$$(

( 5+ / 511*% B CCCCCC $! " $ "9% " = 1) 3333;2 = 1* 333355,(

BCCCCCC &A."!!>A$$0;/511*9 ""$ 3 "9"!!($$ A 3" (

3"&&%" "! !"!"%7/!7J K > CCCCCC > 9 /I 3 7J !! B CCCCCC > CCCCCC > 8% & " $!511*7/CCCCCC<0>(

> # $ "9 !!> !"$""(

5*/511*% ! A$$ ! A$$"$>" BCCCCCC%78 8 $ "8% " ! " !"""(

6( L "" A$$ < !/ 511*% "9% " = 1) 3333;2 % !! $! < 4 511) " $ A3"%BBCCCCCC%&$!A !! @.>CCCCCC> 8(

"9% " = 1* 333355 ,% !! $! 2 511*"$ !8 / %CCC%> CCCCCC<0>% A !!B CCCCCC%&A " !/(A$$ &&! A/ $!A% " A"( 3" & B CCCCCC !/ $7 M A7/ ( $B CCCCCC &!>A$$&A!""" & A"" !/ ! @! & A " "A""(

B CCCCCC !! > A$$ &A " " "& "9 !! $! > CCCCCC > 8 &A A9 7/ "( 3"&! & $ & 7/> %&A !8%"$ 4! > ( B CCCCCC &! > A$$ &A 7JK>CCCCCC&A!" "A CCCCCC3$ A7 ( $ &! &A I " B CCCCCC ! N A "9""(

A$$ ! B CCCCCC% & $ !/( &!7/ "0G511)>CCCCCC ) '? F- > ( % & @! "">CCCCCC> 8>$CCCCCC4&A>$ /% (B CCCCCC"&A " " B CCCCCC > ( && !/$8/I3 8 & ( $% B CCCCCC &! > A$$ &A " !! B CCCCCC(

L"" A$$%BCCCCCCA48!$$ >!8&A@A""CCCCCC>(L$8 /I3&" A""(

A$$ A & $ B CCCCCC "9%"=1)3333;2 %!"/% H!!> "$&A9 "$4!(

LA8 3 "9% " = 1* 333355 ,% A$$ A"! " !% H "! !/&!$3>$&AA ". $!(

( A " " A&. F 511< !%BCCCCCC/ &!&A 511) " > CCCCCC% > H 7/ % B CCCCCC $( B CCCCCC $$! &A" 511)% ! CCCCCC > % H "" &( &!"I !!B CCCCCC( $$! "%&AA "!&A9! A> A$$(

&! !%BBCCCCCC$!"! !> $ "9%"=1)3333;2 < 4511)( &! "9>"& >A $%"$&AA8/ BCCCCCC% 8D &&7E(

O8 &! !% B CCCCCC $! "! !>$ "9%"=1*333355,( &! "9 > " & A"" B CCCCCC & A "!! !(B CCCCCC$$!A4BCCCCCC(

P( L ! ! /& ! A$$ ""% B CCCCCC 8! 9 7/! CCCCCC > 7JB6CCCCCC 5+0FFF0;511+%"> CCCCCC7JB CCCCCC 0;511+0$!511*%"> CCCCCC> 0$!511*(

>B CCCCCC%8!97/!CCCCCC > 8 0/51150G511)%">CCCCCC> 0G511)(

" !! B CCCCCC $8 /& !"!!(

0(( ! "! " & " A3!$!&A A$$ > "I " 4$! $ > & " 4 '()*(+,Q(01(0Q(0<(0-(" . !"! 3 4 H "8 '( 0< ( 0 5 Q ( 01 ( 0+ -( ! ! !" " '( 55 ( 0 -(

0(/( A"% "8 $$ " 5+ / 511* " !! A &A > A$$ A7 0; / 511*( A " " F511<%"8 &! " D 9 !E &A A "!! > A$$ " / @"(

&A 3 % ! "8% &" !" ! 34 A(0<(5% ! 0;/511* !&"!! !"!"(

A&A9 A.A ! &"!!$!@ > ! 34$3!"A(0<(5( $$%&!"%%I! "% 8 $% " ! ! !. "/ A!. "&"%"%">"! '( 55 -% ! "! ! " . ! "'@/!% (*2@=5FQ 6001F% , 0F;< 5F-( % ! $ "9%!%"&&/!&!$ A!!!/"/(

5(( "9&A $ " $#/4 #.$&$! $'(<50*0-( A> ! "%A/ % A " " !8!"33"!"% / A 77 ! " % > !$% A " " ' 6 00< < ( +/Q R ( L$$% A3! S + = 51Q , T@TUVJ% W8

/8U % L7T 0FF*% "( 510% 512Q X JJ% $ %5115%"(505(=+<;(-( " " !8 . $! > > "!%">"%A"&&%"& A8$>. A $( % H 3 7/ "$% / "! % $$%& !!""> $ "7/! > A " '@/ !% ( *2 =F4" !-(

A( *2 " & " $! !/ > A H 3 7/ "$ &% A /% A " . > " !8 > "9!( % $ H " ! $$%& /.Y " A( 5+ " $ " !8 " &A $ " . ! & 'X ,: L/% @% (*2=0552-(

5(/( L A( <5 % $ "!! " "!"!% " "9! A$$ " " '( 0-( & " > $ 7& 3"4H ">&A!! '( 5-( L A( <2 % !/ " & $ "" %/"!%$ !! > & "9 > A$$ 3 4 > " $ "9(

5(( " $ " ! " $! ! $ !( " &AA"!/&A "9 $ ! " " A " " !8! " ( L% 8! $ !% A " " " "! " $ "" ! > " " ! A$!%!8! $AI%""%! @%! "9%" $'$( 6 05;010 (5%, 51155+QL7T5115)0511+00*-( % A% "% $ !8 "" &"/"!4 %"3" "" ! #""(

% $% "9 !" ! $$ & " ( $ % $$% " 8

"! " 88! / > $ 3$( " %" !" !"$"" 4 H " $$ "9%@".%& #. !7 $ ""% !" " $ ! ' 6 051 002 (+/%, 0FF<)1Q005;0 (5%, 0F;F5Q01205%, 0F<F05+-(

5( ( AA$$&"$ " $!8 "% "!4 A /8 " / > A!/ $("@/ $88!! "%"A!>$"'(;(5 Q @/ !% % ( <5 = 0; !$! !Q 600<01 ()%, 0FF+0+1Q 601<0 (0%, 0F;++F-(

+(( "% A & "8 $ % < 4 511)% "9%"=1)3333;2 ($$&AA &A> J@ &A > A$$ 0; / 511* 'A " 5+/511*-%"> A &A $$! > A$$ 9 ! ' ! ! > A F 511<-( > A$$% ! A8 $%&$! "9 !! !/ @. > CCCCCC > 8( " !% 8 $ &! &A "9 "&>A $(

! A8$ $&"8 &! &A 511) > CCCCCC > 8% H > $ & 9 7/ % ! &$ "9%"=1) 3333;2 /(

""/A$A $'(<5 (5-%&%$$ #(F '(;(5-%" ""' 605100< (5%, 0FF<)2Q 6 00< 01 ( )% , 0FF+ 0+1 !$! !-( & A !! !! $! " A"" "!" A3 ( $&$!"8%A8$&" & 8 D && 7E " ! % % A! $ ! $ !!(

"%&A 8!$ "9%"=1)3333;2 !&.4!(

! 8 "8 & " 3 "/!3"3& !/". ! "$""A"!!"!&A""!!!! "! !( !/""$$&!" / $ "A "A"" & ! "% !. $ '( ;) - " $ "48& A3""'(;)-( % A / " & "! " I %" "! "A"! "A(;)'(51(0(-" "! !!!" A"!"A(;)'(01(-(

+(/( LA8 3 "9%"=1*333355,%$ A &@A"!!/$!(!! " ! > ! & A !! A " !! > A "!"A(*2(%3 8 & > A3 ""! "9 >">&A !!!!$!(A$$!! A"! A $ !! B CCCCCC% & $8 " 3 8 A$$ "" A " "8(A A8$A""" A! " > & "9 !! ( % A" ! $ "9%"=1*333355,(

ZZZZZ

'

1

-#0*1

!/"$!52/511*"BCCCCCC $ "9%"=1)3333;2 =1*333355 ,(

0$1

0( 4 " &A 8! $ "9%"=1)3333;2 %$!<4511)(

5( " &A 8! $ "9%"=1*333355,%$!2511*(

+( !$ "9%"=1*333355 ,(

2( !/" (

(.#" ? B( !89 X% "! Q BB( 7"" W B PX%48(

?

8$$? "! ? B L !89X

"! !&!" >A$$!" 83""8$$

Affirmation of Financial Liability Finding Based on Statutory Interpretation

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet