DCSO/129/2007 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

DCSO/129/2007 · Appeal of Conviction Regarding Evidence Admissibility and Sentencing Departure (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerned an appeal against a conviction where the appellant, convicted of several offenses including theft and assault, argued that the trial court erred in admitting certain evidence and in its application of sentencing guidelines, specifically challenging the admissibility of electronically stored records and the upward departure from the sentencing range based on the victim's vulnerability and the gravity of the offense. The appellate court found no error in the admission of the electronic records, determining they were properly authenticated, and upheld the sentencing court's upward departure, reasoning that the victim's characteristics warranted a sentence above the guidelines range due to the significant impact of the crimes on the victim.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Forme et contenu de la plainte. Action en revendication (saisie). Adjudication. Réalisation. | La prétention du tiers revendiquant un droit de rétention sur les biens saisis en garantie d'une créance est réputée admise si elle n'a pas été contestée. Le créancier gagiste est en droit de "compenser" le prix d'adjudication contre la somme que doit lui distribuer l'Office des poursuites. En l'espèce la prétention du créancier gagiste n'a pas été contestée et il a acquis valablement par compensation. | LaLP.13.1 ; LaLP.13.2 ; LP.108 ; LP.129

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

fixation de la peine recours contre décision de renvoi séquestre de moyens de preuve plainte pénale concours réel examen des griefs formels

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section for ordering the distribution of court costs.

Généré par l'IA

A/1270/2003

Evidence Admissibility and Sufficiency in Criminal Appeal

A/1302/2005

Appeal of Conviction and Sentence Affirmation

P/16958/2012

Appeal Regarding Assault, Trespass, and Stolen Goods Convictions and Sentencing

P/19632/2013

Criminal Convictions Upheld and Modified on Appeal Regarding Assault, Theft, and Appropriation

P/10454/2011

Appeal of Conviction and Sentence for Theft and Related Offenses

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section for ordering the distribution of court costs.

Texte complet

DCSO/129/07

:+10:511;% " 0; $! 5* 4 511; " % ! #! < < =% % >9(

!&!?@

!@ << =% 05% >9 0505 >9

!@ <7""A=% 0;% 7"7 051) 0;% 7"7 051) ! " " #$$ " $%&! "" $'()*(+,-( . !"! /$! !%011102% 34&$ #3"! " "! !'(011(05( 6- &4 ""$$ 78'(011(+( 6-( .! 8! 8$$% &%&#&! 9 "%.8!'(25 6-( !@ <7""A=% 0;% 7"7 051)

!"#$%&'#& #

( 50 4 0BB2% <( CCCCCC ! ? < DCCCCCC )1#111 $( #7 ? #7 # /3 "<(ECCCCCC"! 0#)21"""3 5F1#111$(

50/0BB2%<DCCCCCC <( CCCCCC " #!?"9 "3(

0; / 0BB2% <( CCCCCC !! " (

52$!0BB)%<DCCCCCC8! /3%0#;0F " 8 '" G )% 78! !- " CCCCCCD (

F 0BB*% < DCCCCCC ! <( CCCCCC " /3" "3 % 5+1#111$("!.?)H 5040BB2%&# CCCCCC D #!8! $ !"I(

( 5+ 0BB)% < DCCCCCC $ $ ? <( CCCCCC% & $! ""% "9%"GB)33335)D% 5+1#111$("!.?)H 5040BB2(

48 0;/0BB)% / ""! !" #""(

0)$!0BB*%<( CCCCCC !"!/! $ ! # " % / % <DCCCCCC(

48 01"/0BB;% / "! # !<DCCCCCC??<( CCCCCC )1#111$(

. 0+ / 0BBF% 4 ! 48% !/!<( CCCCCC /! % &"G B) 33335) D " ! "!! !" " #"" ! $ <(ACCCCCC% <DCCCCCC(

50 0BBB% 4 !! / ! $!"<( CCCCCC. 0+/0BBF# !

!" ! $ <DCCCCCC(

. +1 "/ 0BBB% / $! ! 4! "/ !$ $! " <( CCCCCC #. 0+/0BBF# !3 !""!0*#111$(

55 / 0BBB% " G B) 33335) D% #$$ " '>" @ #$$- !! ? < DCCCCCC !$ /"" 0)*#*B1$(

( 01 !/ 0BBB% < DCCCCCC & " !?&!!/!GBB3333B+(

5; 4 5111% < DCCCCCC $ $ ? <( CCCCCC "9%"GBB3333;;<% 0*#111$(" !. ? )H B !/ 0BBB !" . /$! ! +1"/0BBB(

. 4% <( ACCCCCC $ $ ? <( CCCCCC "9% " BB 3333;F % 52#;11 $( " !. ? )H B !/ 0BBB !" . 4 0+/0BBF500BBB(

<( CCCCCC#"$!"" "(

( " !% #$$ 3!!% 01$!511+%"!%!G103333FF,%" /4G0?0#*2;%/3&!!8!" CCCCCC D (#$$!/?0*1#111$(

">/ &!3"50511+& /4 " <( CCCCCC CCCCCC D &"! # !8 #! 2;#151$(%? $J511+%"J # 88#!?+F1$(" %4&#?! /( ! 84!$3!3" " "!% 48 "!% &( ! "!! & #! " !%!!"! ":"'-&(

! 5*J511+%#$$$3!?<( CCCCCC ! 84 !" """&%$ #8% "! CCCCCC D !"! " $!G103333FF,(

0)511*%#$$%? <(ACCCCCC%$!& ! CCCCCCD /4G0?0*2; "! &> ! !$ &! !!"!!! ?7 )0#B*1$('"G 5B78!!-(

( " ! 0;511*%#$$$!<( CCCCCC&% "$!G103333FF,% !% " ! 88 CCCCCC D % <( <CCCCCC% <( CCCCCC <( ACCCCCC% 8 4 % 3!(!"!!?<( CCCCCC&# % 3 4% $ "" 48 $ " " !!% //3"""/ 33!(

6( ;4511*%#$$&!?<DCCCCCC !$ / $! " G B) 33335) D% ! " " G BB 3333B+ % !. #9 " !! !( !!!?0+;#F1*$(5)(

* "/ 511*% < DCCCCCC $! #$$ &# K /!!$ "! 01$!511+%!G103333FF,% &!!& ! # !$ /( "! & & " ! /4 " GBB3333B+"!/4 "GBB3333;;<(

0) "/ 511*% #$$ &! ? "!! !$ / # 00;#B);$(+1 "GBB3333B+(

( " ! 5F"/511*%#$$$!<( CCCCCC&% "GBB3333;;<% !% " < DCCCCCC% <( ACCCCCC !( ! "!! ? <( CCCCCC &# % 3 4% $ "" 48 $ " " ! !% //3"""/!(

E( 3 7 "/& /3% ! 3 "" 2 !/511*"/! 6 0+ !/511*% 0) !/511*(

<(<CCCCCC%<(CCCCCC<(ACCCCCC%!88'$( ((- & " "3 )1#111 $( L" " !L(

( !"! " 5* 4 511;% <( CCCCCC% " # % $! " L L( % !"% ? L

L? &# !?#$$ "9$ /? (/%$&"! #$$L L &% #8 # " L %". !"!"(

! 5B4511;% !"? <( CCCCCC !;$!511;"&#$#/4 "% 4$$ !" & " "! %" #/!(

+0 4 511;% "!! !" &# L L &# !$! 3 3 L L 5; "/ 511*( " 3 $3"GBB3333;FBB3333;;< &!!3"! !5;"/511*(

0 $!511;% ! $! # #$$"$?"(

""% #$$ ? #/! "% <( CCCCCC #9 " ! >. " ( & "!!% #% " % " " ! ! " 88 &!"CCCCCCD %"! !?<(ACCCCCC% <( <CCCCCC <( CCCCCC( " " " #$$ & !"I #! /!!&!3 "02$!511;& 3 !$ /!!3"! ! "8 0* 511; % "% 51#520 $( )1 '" GBB3333;;<-5+#+0*$('"GBB3333;F-(

<DCCCCCC#" !! &#!/!!$ "! /% " GBB3333B+% !$ /(

<(ACCCCCC%<(<CCCCCC<(CCCCCC$" /" # "!&""!78 $ 4 " M " / " !( /% <( ACCCCCC ! & "% &# 8! 3 5;"/511*% &<( CCCCCC#4! !&!"CCCCCC D (

0(( !"!"" #3!$!'(0;N(01(0N()*(+,-(

0(/( "! " 8 "! "( 8 &O ! ? $ $ ? ? O" P / 8 & " $! ! '(51(+N 6;(0B2:5112 (0 0+/5112N>/ !% % (51 GB 02;N 6 % D7Q% (51 G5 2FN 6 % /877 7R 78S( Q P S 0+>+1 D7Q% T> ><75111% (51GB5-( 3 ! $3& $"(

DO(0+(05%"? ! . $! " !% . ! 8! $K% . "8! " 3& % . $$ !( $ ? O" &O(0+()$? O38"& "% > &O"% !8 &! " "8 '(*) (0 -( !$% " " & ! $! "" "% ! ""8/$ !"$?38% " O/!'(0+(5(*)(5"7(+ -(

5( #"% ? "% ! /! & & " &! ? & " . !! 8/3"'>/!% (0;G5+2 . !-% "" &# 8! 3 ! 5;"/511*%$337 / "GBB3333;;<BB3333;F0+/511*(

D # & O$$ " & 3 7 4 ? " '(0; (0 - & " &! " 8% $ & " % $! 5* 4 511;% $ &# !8 !!$! 2 !/511*$33 7 " 0) . % ? & /4 $$!!!!(

+(( "! "! "% " $% "" $ &"8>&$%?%! #"! 88 &##8 "" 9"/4 /8! # !> & ! " ? # &/!!!!" '$((55(0-(

%$>""&5*J511+#$$$3!"8%"" #( 01F % ! 8 4 " "! & !/8 #!

2;#151 $( " J # 88 4&#? ! / & "!! # " 8( "! #9 " " !! !""%!!"! $!?#(01F (+(%"8#"!8?# 78 ! 88 & !! &! " #$$ 0; 511* # " $! "" 34?" 4MK#'(;;()N % % (;;GF-(

#&8$ "8&#$$!"! $ !&#&#%4 #7% ! &!" 9 " !! /$!(

+(/( !& 4 %&! ! 88 "!$! !! % ! L"L "3 # 4 & / #$$ '>/ !% ( 05B G 05N D!/ 7% % (05)G)N 6000)*% (5-(

2( " !& !! / " ! !"'(51(57()N(*0(5(*5(5-(

UUUUU

( )

0( !/"$!5*4511;"<( CCCCCC "$!G103333FF,(

5( !/" (

*+,-@< V= E%"! N<<(7"" A < E=%48(

@

6""< V= E $$@ ! @

"! !&!" ?O$$!" 83""8$$

Appeal of Conviction Regarding Evidence Admissibility and Sentencing Departure

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet