Contractual Dispute and Breach of Duty Affirmation
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe court addressed a dispute arising from a series of transactions involving multiple parties, where the central issue was the validity and enforceability of certain contractual obligations and associated financial instruments, complicated by allegations of misrepresentation and breach of duty. The reasoning centered on interpreting the operative agreements to determine the parties' respective rights and liabilities, concluding that the evidence supported a finding that the governing documentation established clear obligations and that the contested actions constituted a breach, thereby affirming the lower court's judgment regarding damages and contractual interpretation.
Regeste Legislator
OfficielProcès-verbal de saisie. Acte de défaut de biens. Péremption. | L'acte de défaut de biens n'a pas été délivré en violation de l'art. 149 LP et n'est donc pas nul au sens de l'art. 22 LP, même s'il aurait dû être délivré à l'expiration du délai d'un an de l'art. 93 al. 2 LP. L'acte de défaut de biens doit mentionner le montant de la part non couverte de la créance en poursuite. | LP.93; LP.99; LP.100; LP.116; LP.149; LP.159
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAApplied because the appellant must bear the cost of the proceedings.
Texte complet
DCSO/121/07
:22*2:511* :2;1*:511*% " 0< $!% "% 5< /511*50 !/511*" (
!&!=>
!"# !> ?6@ % 5% 051*
$$"%&!' #!"(!
! " " #$$ " $%&! "" $'()*(+,-( . !"! /$! !%011102% 34&$ #3"! " "! !'(011(05( 6- &4 ""$$ 78'(011(+( 6-( .! 8! 8$$% &%&#&! 9 "%.8!'(25 6-(
( 0;/511+%!& & AAAAAA'B">AAAAAA-% #$$ " 'B"> #$$- $! "9 C 1+ 3333+; ? = ? AAAAAA " 0#10<#015 $( ;1 "!.=*%5)D 0<"/0EE)"! F # 0)40EE*(
#""&? AAAAAA$!= "9!! ! +1 5112( AAAAAA & " 5E45112(
0* !/ 5112% #$$ !! "B/ ! C1+5220+;?%"&"C1+3333+;? AAAAAA% " E+0#)21$(%&#$$ % !$ /(
+ 4 511)% AAAAAA ! # " :2:511) "B/ B !$ /(
68 $!&#(0<(2!%#$$"! != 3 ! &! 9! " 8 50511)=#"9 ? AAAAAA%!!AAAAAA% ? AAAAAA= )*1$(" " " 5#1E1$(" 04511)%& =? AAAAAA= "%8$: 0+(
! G:+50:1) +1 511)% ! !! / " :2:511) AAAAAA% &# ! " /4 "! %9!=#$$"&#" # % " !% !/ & 3""B/ F8!"!!%=4 "B/ "(
!"!!%"! # " & " = " ! ? AAAAAA' (2-%& !" 9=" " ' ()-( !8 %#$$! != !? AAAAAA"4 0#111 $("%= # !" !!AAAAAA= "!(
( 5< / 511*% AAAAAA !"! " "B !" ! 4 4$!( "!! 8!! :22*2:511*(
#"" "%AAAAAA3"& "!" ! G:+50:1) +1 511) " !% ! #$$%8! * 4%<F;"/511*(AAAAAA &&#$$ ""B/ %&#! #!/= !!%! " ( $%AAAAAA &#$$# "/ ! 4 4$!(=# " = & #$$ 4% /$ ! = $3 " % = 3! ! +1 511) "! % $% " # !4=!(
"" 0<4511<%#$$3"& 3& !" ! ! +1511)% #7 78 = ? AAAAAA( 7 !! ! " / = & #3B!" ? AAAAAA( H "/ = !/ 511)H% #3B !" ? AAAAAA ! = #$$% & & ? AAAAAA # " = " &# !&#" !$!= #$$( %#$$3"&# !!&#=& "!&#&& 9= ( #$$ 3" & = !!"7& AAAAAA511*%#! #"/! %" 3"&!% ? AAAAAA%4&#!" ? GAAAAAA% & # &! #$$( 77!!$$!=!" AAAAAA *4511*%(#$$ "#4@ 3 AAAAAA( !% #$$ &# F !%="!" 50511*% !$ /(
$%H$ "8!! $""!H%#$$% " C 1+ 3333+; ?% !! !$ / " ! 0) !/511*%"! = $ "B/ 83(% I#"9 ? AAAAAA " ! % #$$ & 9! ) 4 511<% #48=! 51#);1$(#$$3"&#= %#"9 ? AAAAAA$$! =7 51#);1$(" 6@ %&
# 88! !/% " 0<4511<%==#$$ !" ! !( !8 % #$$ " % ) 4 511< ? 0<4511<% !!AAAAAA 0)4511<% & & ! !! " 51#);1 $( " $ # J !% &# $ " 0)4511<$ (#$$ &&# !!%#!8!=$$"7 $ AAAAAA = $ # !$ / !! 0) !/511*(
$% #$$ 3" & = !" " :22*2:511* 5< / 511* AAAAAA% #7 78 "! ! = # ? AAAAAA 0; !/511*( #$$ & &#! ! ? AAAAAA& " " " !/511)&#/!!$4 # ! 0#111 $( " !! AAAAAA( #$$ & "! # ! " ! ! +1 511) !! ! = (#$$&" :22*2:511* /4% $$!"!!AAAAAA(
( 50 !/ 511*% AAAAAA !"! " "B !# !$ /%"C1+3333+;?% !! 0) !/ 511* " #$$( " !! 8! ! :2;1*:511*(
#"" "% AAAAAA & #$$ !! #" ! !$ /% "!" " C 1+ 3333+; ?% $$ ? AAAAAA #"!&#/= #$$ 3! ! ! +1511)(AAAAAA8&"/! #$$ # " 3 88! &# % !7!% !" & " #& # !$ /( AAAAAA"!"&" !"!" 4$!#" " /4&# =.$&!"= &!8!=8 ""!("! $&9 ! ! #!%# 51#2E1$(& F.!(
AAAAAA = # # !$ / !! 0) !/ 511*% = & #$$ 4 '- = 3! ! ! +1 511) '- !" 3
8! " :2;1*:511*&#= & " " 8 "! " C 1+ 3333+; ?% '- "! % $% " # !4=!%& #!=51#2E1$(
"" 5 $! 511<% #$$ 3" % !% !"9!9= """( & " = $$ " !! AAAAAA #!="= ! ! +1511)%AAAAAA/ 8(#$$ &H"4!""8=# !/ "9 /4H( #$$ & $ &# $$% = !" ! !%$ AAAAAA $# !$ / !!0) !/511*(
/ *$!511<%? AAAAAA3"&/& " 8!# !$ / !!0) !/511* "C1+3333+;?%8$!"AAAAAA 3 = 8 " #$$( "%? AAAAAA&""/43$ !88!8! #$$! AAAAAA #K ! !&( G ? AAAAAA% !/% 9 3 = "/! #$$% # " "! !% / "(? AAAAAA 3"&#.""/ $&" #"!!( &8"="& $ = !8 !! " #$$( ? AAAAAA =&" :2;1*:511* AAAAAA !!/% / =!%AAAAAA!!=38 #9$ !(
0(( !&"C :22*2:511* :2;1*:511*. "3 $."/4 &% ! ! 4 . "! '( <1 L ( 0+ ()-(
0(/( "" ! 4 4$!".$!" '( 0< ( + -( & "% "8 &! " " # 4$! #3! ! ! G:+50:1) +1511)(
G"$"338 $ "" '(0+(05-(
" :22*2:511* /(
0(( " :2;1*:511* !! $! " " #! "! ! # !$ /%& 4 = "% " " 9 &! " 8 " '(0<L(01(00+-(
!8/(
5( % ! & $!!8!! ""!83(" /&# "$ #3"( !" /&!78 /! 3"/(
% $ # & #$$ ! 4$! = 3! ! ! G:+50:1) +1 511)( / "8#"!! #$$$ !"M " :22*2:511* 5< / 511*% " # " & ! !! % " & #$$ 9 !$%&"%"( /(
$$%$8 $!&!!=#(0<(2%#$$ N "! ! & " "! # & " ! ! +1 511)( N$$ 8! = !/% 0; !/ 511*% !! &N " 4 ! 0#111 $( " " !! AAAAAA(
G "% " :22*2:511* " !& /4 "! (
GN8 " % N$$ N $ ! N & & !/ " " $ !"% " !/ 511)% &N "" ! !/ N& !8 " N3! "% N = 4 +#)21$( 78( N=&N$$ !!&N="!(
& "! % $ & " :22*2:511* ! /4 I #$$ # " / " !8 "B4 N3! B &N N " 8! "B/ $ "!(
N$$"!&!B=!" "! !B=/ " !8 " "!!% 4$$ " "" N="/5112( %$!3 "8%& "B/ F8!"!!3"(
%""!&#=%#"/!'()- "! / "'(21 (0-( "" .!" 8B!. # %""!"B' G:*+2:511* 5/ 511*% (*-( 8$ "8! = 8 "! "3!88!8! #$$ 8'$( "8+ " :2;1*:511*) "-# " = . 3! " ! "! "(
+(( ! ! # !=!=" 4 3! '( E+ ( 5 L O : 6 P7% %<! (%511+%Q5+C)0L8 ?R7%G7O % (E+C*0(LB/!% % (E+C051% ?77% B% (E+C0;+-( ! # =$ #3! 4' 600* 0) (5%, 0EE5<)-(
!$ #3 $#/4 " !!%#$$ ! !$ /3!'(02E(0-% &% # !$ / !! " " % " 3 " &! "! " ! ""! = " '(00)LP (G$$% #3!%Q)C25(<2L?7 7% B% (E+C515(-(
# % !$ / !$$" . !! &# " #3! " "! &=$#"!!!=#$$' /9B?% B% (02EC2!$!!-(
& !"M #"= ! " " ! ! 3!!' 600*0)%, 0EE5 <)-(
+(/( (EE 011 "% "%&&" "!%"!"!"! !/& ! " " #& &# #$$ & B " = # !!7(
#( 0)E " #" # #"9 & !#/8 #$$ " #"M% 3% " = #$"" #"9! "! 3 !. "! B( /8 " ! # ! #!%"3" ' /S%$ %% (0)E %C)-( % / "!"! "B/ #$ "8!!'(20-(
+(( &$!!&#"9#"=#!7! % ! = " . & &S&'(00*(5-(
& " & #8 "% !& $"$ 8!!"!& "= #3" ! "" 'B/ !% % (00*C00-(
+( ( ! " " . . &# 7 ""% "! & !/ ! &# " ! " #& &# #$$ '( EE -( ! " $#/4 #37"/&'(055(005) (0 - # 8!=8!'(0+1 -("&%! " " & . !! 3 !( #"&#(0+0"! 3 !3 !&#""&3! "&#$$#"! $!=#(011"! &/ " '( E+ - !/ # " &! #$$ '( 00* ( 5 -( 3 ! " '( 0+0 ( 0 - & !8 #( 0 % ! /8! !/% = #'(0+0(5-%#""% $$%= #(5*1'G!/7% B% (0+0C0E-(
+(( #"% #$$ = #"9 !/ # B=7 )*1$("" %" 5#1E1$(" 04511)B 50511)( ! ! !!= "3!% "!! "50 511*(
! ! % 50511)50511*% #$$ F % " = "8% 51#2E1$(')*1$(3+T5#1E1$(3E-(#& #!!"!!"#"9 !/&# 0)4511<%" E " "!" 8(
#"9 !/ &!&8! 4&#= 48!"!"(
+($( !""=#$$&#$ "! ! %/ #%$# != #"9% & $$ !8! " % " !$ !8 & ! &!( &# &# B#"!% M#"9 !&"!!" ! '( 0)E - $! ! 3 " #8 $! = #( 0+0 ( G #"9 " /8%#$$ !8!!'(20-(
#%#$$ 4&#)4511<%& ! "!! " " $ % " = #"9 "" " ! "! # = "! 51#);1$('>51#2E1$(-(
6 &#$$#"! 8& !!&#!! 4$! &# / " (
!%4 #7!!"(
!4 #$$ "! 51#2E1 $( 8! #"9 !/% " = "8( "8 (
2(( # !$ / " . !! " &#" & ! /"3!( ! # !$ /3!"!/ # #! ' 605)++< (+/%, 0EEE0;<L /9B?% B % (02EC5-(
#"%#$$/!/5112"B/ " 1+ 5220+; ? 8! " "8( G = " :2:511) !"! + 4 511) " "8 = # "B /%"3!! #"9 !/"(9 !&# !$ / !!0) !/511* "C1+3333+;?# "!! #(02E# " #(55% .# F. !!=#3" ! # #(E+(5 "" $" (
2(/( # !$ / & ! $8 !& "% & " ! "( !. % & = 3% .! 4 I #$$!/# !$ /($!" !' /9B?% B% (02EC;!$!!-(
#"% #. #$$% " !" &!# !$ /&!( $$ " " 51#2E1 $( #"9 !/ & #$$ #"9 !/%"="8(
9 # # !$ / &! # #$$ = ! !$ / $! &"! (
)( "! " 8 '( 51 ( 5 7( ) L ( *0 ( 5 (-(".! !"'(*5(5-(
UUUUU
)
*
#+,-,.(>
, " :22*2:511* :2;1*:511* $!% "% 5< / 511* 50 !/ 511* " "C1+3333+;?(
,$ #.*
!/(
$ &*
0( " :22*2:511*% I!/4(
5( N$$ "% = !" "! !% = "! $! !5(
+( "" :2;1*:511*(
2( & 8 "!! !! AAAAAA "C1+3333+;?"!!(
)( = #$$ " "! = # 51#2E1 $( " " 8 "!! !!AAAAAA "C1+3333+;?(
*( = #$$ " "! 51#2E1$($ AAAAAA(
<( # !$ / !!0) !/511* "C1+3333+;?(
;( =#$$ " #!/ ! !$ /%"C1+3333+;?% F $!8! !(
E( !/" (
"+/(>?( !89 V% "! L ?( GG % 48 % ?! %48""!(
>
? G !89V $$> ! >
"! !&!" =N$$!" 83""8$$