Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/116/2007 • CJ GE DCSO/116/2007 Généré par l'IA

Promissory Note Enforceability and Negotiability Dispute

Numéro de cause DCSO/116/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns disputes over various commercial transactions and debt obligations evidenced by multiple promissory notes, with the court ultimately examining the validity and enforceability of these instruments under relevant statutory provisions concerning negotiable instruments and related charges. The court reasoned that certain instruments failed to meet the specific requirements for negotiability due to conditions or references outside the face of the note, or because they involved the addition of unauthorized or improperly calculated charges, leading to the conclusion that those specific notes were not enforceable as negotiable instruments, while upholding others where the requirements were met or the charges were deemed permissible under the governing law.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

Abus de droit. | La créance du poursuivant n'apparaît pas manifestement dénuée de tout fondement. Plainte rejetée, il appartient au plaignant de saisir le juge du fond (art. 85a LP). Cause jointe avec A/4808/2006. | LP.22 ; LP.85a ; LP. 8a 3 let. a ; LPA. 70

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
billet à ordre papier-valeur différend commercial droit des obligations condition légale protêt

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to regulate the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/3837/2007
Promissory Note Validity and Guarantee Enforceability
A/1393/2004
Promissory Note Validity and Consideration Dispute
A/1713/2004
Promissory Note Payment Terms Dispute
A/2186/2004
Negotiability of Instrument Dispute
A/2435/2006
Promissory Note Enforcement and Written Modification Requirements

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to regulate the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

     

DCSO/116/07 



                       

 <4=3><733, <4=3=<733,'$!2>&#!77"#1733,$     ' #! "!  !%#" " ?  ? @ A'  'B *



#(#BC

  "!#!C ""?? @ A'  ='DE#: 273+ 

  "!#!C ""?? @ A'  ='DE#: 273+    "!#!C ""? !! @ D'  2'": $!+,=4 2337   !"#$%&'($'!$      !     ! "# $ $ !  "  !!"!%&&"$"&!!'(#!" !! "$$"&!!)*+,!*-./*!"0"#$#" ! 1!&#"#!'233324'"!"56( !&"!%5$#" $!"!$#"#)*233!*27!* 8/"!(6 "$$&&"9:)*233!*-!* 8/*"0#":#" !:&&!!'"(!!'(!%(# !!"!; "$ '0:#)*47 8/*   

* (0"746 733+'?*DFFFFFF! : " 5"9"% )E$C! "5/5&" 5"%9! B"5"5##$?*FFFFFF  ? FFFFFF B 9 " 4,%3,2 &* G+' $!  ' " ! !" "H #' !"'",%-,2&*73*

 24733+'?*DFFFFFF&&B?*FFFFFF"" $;'$I3+5555+-D'!",%-,2&*73 #0B+J" !-2"#17334"!""%9!&"-2"#1 733-)2%324&*2+/'7+7334)2%2,-&*>3/'2=7334)-+4&*4+2%+G> &*=+/'726!!7334)2%2-7&*G3/'=$17334)=2-&*4+/-2"#1 7334)7=4&*>3/*

 ?*FFFFFF&#$$B*

  "# " 2= 1 733+' !  " 5  0# B -G%3=G &* G+ !  " 9' 9 5' "H B ?* DFFFFFF $ !% #"#$!;#& "?*FFFFFF?FFFFFF)&&FFFFFF FFFFFF/*

  7G "#1 733+' ?* FFFFFF  ? FFFFFF' $ !% " ! !'$#?*DFFFFFF"! !",23&*=3$#! "&&#  !  (%! #! ),%-,2 &* 73/  !  #" ),%G>7&*/$! "5*

 2733,'?*DFFFFFF#$"(! "5%  $ 1"# ! ( " & "H !  B !%5# "  "  &# 5 & ( !   ## #:! "#  ( $#"-4>&*43(!%6!  "7,&*43* $## !    ( !  " 5   &   " !!"!""!$"6*

 =733,'! "5&#?*DFFFFFF(%;# !!#"#"""!!"2733,*

* D 5 #( " $    " !  " ,23 &* =3 $! #0 B +J " ! -2 "#1 7334 &# $ ?* FFFFFF  ? FFFFFF  ":#  ?* DFFFFFF' !%&& " $  &!! "  ; B &# B  " "5 " " $;' $   ""2>7= !733,*

 "$##&$$#"%$$*

*  " " 2=  733,' ?* DFFFFFF   &  & B ?* FFFFFF  B ? FFFFFF""$;'$ $I3,5555+28  I 3, 5555+3 ' !  ,%-,2 &*73   #0 B +J " ! -2 "#1 7334   " !" "%9 ! & " -2 "#1 733- )2%324 &* 2+/' 7+  7334 )2%2,- &* >3/' 2=  7334 )-+4 &* 4+  2%+G> &* =+/' 72 6!! 7334 )2%2-7&*G3/'=$17334)=2-&*4+/-2"#17334)7=4&*>3/*

 ?*FFFFFF?FFFFFF&#$$B*

*   $# ! 77 "#1 733,' ?* FFFFFF  ? FFFFFF  $# $!  $ ' ! " " $;' $ I 3, 5555+2 8'  ! " " $;' $ I3,5555+3*

  $! " ?* FFFFFF  ## :#  <4=3><733,' !! " ? FFFFFF <4=3=<733,*

  "5 $## ! B  ( ! !!# " " " $; $&  #' ! $ ::# B !  #   "%1 " "* ! 5$ ( ?* DFFFFFF % 6 ( ! ! #"!%$$&#""$;&#!24 733+ B ?* FFFFFF' (    6"%9 $##  (%! % B  6 $  "#9 6" $ 1 ! ! # " $$ &#5""$;(!##&#!2=733,*! &&(!1$ $?*DFFFFFF("!" !(%!$(%!("$B! &" 6"(' ! "# " !  " 5 #K 5$#""$&(!(!"H%#! B-G%3=G&* G+&#B!(%!"%"#6B(#*?*FFFFFF ?FFFFFF6(!$"?*DFFFFFF"%$! $1! (%!  ! "% $&! " ! 6* &' ?* FFFFFF && ( ! $ " !  !%16 ! ! "  " B 1 ! !#$1!"$B#$"%:' "!L9'"$"%#0 1!1!'$ !!:"!%&&"$*

   $$' !%&& " $ $$!!  1 ! 6$"  !$1!#"%!$&"!%1 ""! (%!%$'!(" ?*DFFFFFF" "&!  "&$!"9%!"#6B##$;# !#$! """&"*!6(!$!:$  "#$     #:  " "' ('  !!  $ $ !%! &!! " ! $' $ B  ! '   " '

"%"   5   ! 1 " !%* = !* - !*  * %&&"$!6"!$!*

  # B $#  1 ' ?* DFFFFFF ! B !% 1!# " ! $!' 1" B  6* ! && ( ! $!: $" "  ( ! -2 "#1 733-' 7+ ' 2= ' 72 6!!' = $1  -2 "#1 7334' !  #1! "  "%9 $  ",%-,2&*73$"5 ""2"#1733-  -2 "#1 7334  ( ! ! 6: "  $# $  $!#"##'! "51B&5 !"9"#1*'!%$'"#%;## "   ( " &"' ! $ (%!  "!:#   0 "%1""*'!15$!:"%:$!  " !% #: " " $ &  !%# !! !!# " ! #!:"%$09!5'$!  "!$!*

   "# 7- &#  733>' ?* FFFFFF   B !  " #$"%!(%! "#!2= 1733,#$ &#"#! " 6  $! !  B  "" " !  ( ! #$""#$"#"27"#1733,!$"! B$!*

 

2* "#(!$!I <4=3><733, <4=3=<733,!0 $!5"&! !0$1!6"('! "  !!"#""!6"0$#")*>3 M*2- !*+/*

7**  "#$#$!$!  "N5#&#)*2>M*23!*2M*+,!*-./*

 ""1"B! 6")*2>!*2 /*D !N5 " ( " " #!  "  " 6: " ) 8 22-7' "  ."  2G=G273/' ! :& (N $ $#  1 & " "' $$ 5$# B !N* 7 !* 7  !1! " !N1! " !N" 6"('  #  1! "  !N# "  !!(N!":#!N!0";(N&& ! " " !N5# &#'    ! $# !: !!E0 )8!  '  D9O' " *2> I7>M E1 !!#' ' " *2> I==M 8 "' 1:9!9 9P""9:Q'OR" Q!2-S-3D9O'7333' " *2> I7>4/*  ! :& $ 0 ! #  B !N " ! &"N""$;'("!N$"!N&&"

"B!#("$B 6B$!)*2>!*2/*

"#!$$$!""56B$"!L!$!:  " !  (# )*2> !*7 /*  !N# "  !! "  "N&&' "#$" 0 "  $! )*77 /' ! !!# "   B " "$ #"# " !N#0 $1!  " !N#0 " $  $ B ! $#"' !  " #     ! :& " !!# ! # 0 " '!" "##'$$#&"#'#"1" !!!#"($#"&&#*

7*1* !N$'!$!##"#$#"!&$$"! " !!"""$;'" 6 B $!' $ ! $  (  ! (!# $ : $   )*2>!*27M*2-/*

 !!""5B!"!!!#"$"## &(%!!$""%1""*

 !!""#!# 1!*

7** D%:"$ !!$?*FFFFFF!7-&# 733>'! $$ ( ! $## #  ! $   (%!  & $!*  "#!$""$"#*

-*  &!# " " " $  !! " $ !  ""N:!&"H#)*-=!*2/* ""!N5#&#$BE"#"$  $#" "#1    "N $#  "  $  !N5 "  "  ! %$$  B !%&& " $  5 # "  !! " "#"   $# !:  5:# B 1 "  * &'  !N  "N : " !N5# &#  ( B " & $! #: B !! $ !(!! !!  ## $# '!!$#1&""'(N$$#:#$!! )*7 !*7 /*  & " $ !#:! "  " $  & " !N:("$0!B(!T !!* '! N $ 5! (N  " $$ " !N" " !N1 " "' ! : " !N5# &# "  N$$ B " (0' !! ( " #("$""$'"!6' & $  "N#1!  &  " " $;  "   $ $    ! & "N  " &!!) 822+2="*-1'D.2G=G$*433'." 2GG2>,M 822- 7'." 2G=G272 82274>"*2'." 2G==24+MD.2G=>$*2+,/*

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

!!9;$9$ 0"(N5$!!'!%&&" $!#" !!" 1&K 6:"'N:""!N1!""! (N!&5!B!N"""!N5#&#   ' "   $!' "N1 & " "*  &'  !N&&  !  " # N $" B $#" B  !; $$&"""*!" $ "!N5 "N 1 & " " (  ! 1 "N#!#  "N 1! "N"  : "# " &K $ ( !"   "##"&!#*

 ! N6 ( ! & "N " " $; $#  ;!#:!"N$!$$)*2-+9*7 /*#(" $ $ " $  (  &' (   :! :##! !#: B !! !' ; $ !( ! #  "$ "N  " ! #) D<2=3<3-"*-* "77733-M D<+74<7334 "*7* "7=17334/*

  0  $1!# " 2,  733, )>*-,<733,/' ! 1! &#"#!  &# ! "# " G &#  733, " $ !  " # ) D<>+<733,/ !(!!   "## ( ! $  %  $ !# 1  !  " ! $' 0   "#9 %$    "% !# " & $ " ! " "%# !! #: "# B #:! ! !:*   &&' !  ! ! $   ! $    ## "## $  "  !

$  & ! (  #! # 1   $ #( $1! " &"  $# B " ":  #0 B 9 " 23%=+3%333&*

#"#) D<+>><733,"+1733,/'!  " #   ( ! $ ' (  "   ::# " $#"  $#! (  ! B !% " $ '   99# B $# "$"%;'$$$ ": "#!"B!$$'!(!!$ 0" !!!!W"$1!#W'("  &#'  (%!! %   $ : " ! ! 1 "   $ *  !%$'!$ &&B$#""#1'&$# "$('$$+33%333%333&*$!%  $!!#!! #"$$&#5""$;' "( "$$$!$$*

4* !$!'!$!:& !(!$ #$ ! !"!"!(%!$(%!(" $ B !    &" 6"(' ! "# " !  " 5 #K 5$# "  "$& ( !  ( !  "H %#!  B -G%3=G &* G+'    &# B ! (%!"%"#6B(#*

 !""%1""$$!(! "51B&5! "9"#1(!(! B!%5 "!#'!!(B!%5#""  :! " $  ! $  "  " 6: " )* -G   ! $& "%  M   E  , 23/  (  "#  ! $ 6: 5# )&* "$& " ! "# " 2= 1 733+/*

 ! ' $ !!' " " " $; !:5 ( !  " !%1!:   !" "%9 ! & " -2 "#1 733- )2%324 &* 2+/' 7+  7334 )2%2,- &* >3/' 2=  7334 )-+4 &* 4+  2%+G> &* =+/' 72 6!! 7334 )2%2-7 &* G3/' = $1 7334 )=2- &*4+/  -2"#17334)7=4&*>3/*

 '"!"#"!"#"2=1733+"! " 5' !  & # " (  "%9' " $  ,%4>3&*=3'2%4=+&*'--%,G-&*4%427 &*=3' 95* !$X"$   "#  !  5# $ !" ' !(!!  % "  $ $#  !  '  ! & #' (% " $%"$"*

! % ( ! # " $  %$$X $  & "##"&"'#$$!#(%!%$$$B! " #""!!E5:#B1""1 6: " &"* 8   #( "%"' # $$!# ( ! 9;$9 " !(!! !%  "% : " !%5# &# $#  1 & " "  $  0  (%5$!!'(!$'("#!B!&" " " $; !:5' N $ ## ( B " & ! #:B!!!$$"!&!!(%!! $1&""*

  ! & ( ! $   !#  $# ! " " $; &#!24733+'!(!$#"" ! "5 #$"'(%!%$'B6'(!! #"!%$$& 5""$;&#!2=733,'! ;"% )* == /  $ "%!! $ " "# ( ! $ !: $""%1""* "#1 '$!!'(%! % $ !!#:# $ ! $!: (%! ' ( B 5' !!# ! ! # " $$ &# 5 " " $; (%!  & &$ !2>7= !733,*

+*  $!: && ( ! $ ":# B !   $1!"!#?*FFFFFF""B1!!# "$B#$"%:'##$ !! :"&&"$)*=/*

   6' ! " " $$! (% "#1 (  &# $$ B  $$!"!%$$%$####"#&  $ !%"!%*=+*!#!"$! #'  !$1!#":"$'$!%!&!%16"$ 6&#* ' ! 1! &#"#!  #   ( "  0 " 2>17333)>*7><7333/&#"#!(" ( ! $     " $!!  $  !%  "!%5"!#"#"$('L! 6:!B!!!#"!$'!!E$ 0(#5 "!%*=!*-!**0" 7+ 6!! 7337 $ 5 8 27=  --4' ! @ '  #&# B !%0 $##'! #(6$" $$#!6"( $1!  $1! " "#1 "H $ '   ( ! """!$%5!$#:  " "#1  (%! %;   "  ! $$ " " " ! $  !%"1!# "% !!   '  $!' !:#  ( )$*--,/CW                                                               

                     !    "#$ #%&'(W*

! $$ " 5 $!: "  ! 6: " &" "%    " !%5 " ! # "#"  $' !(!'     &"#' ! B ! !!# " $ "## (   !$(#5)*=!*-!*/*

,* &"#'!$!6#*

YYYY



  )            *



(+,-,.-/*

.!$!I <4=3><733, <4=3=<733, &#!77"#1733,$ $ !""$;$ I3,5555+28!""$;$I3,5555+3*

-, &(*

"#! 1!*

' &/#*

2* 6*

7* #1!$"!*







!+0,/C?  U A  @' $#" M ?* 9!$$  Z' 6:  ?*?! '6:$$!#*

"! " !!C



8!$$?   U A  @  &&C #"C    $#"#(#$ B!N&&#$! :5$$!:&&!