Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
DCSO/113/2007 • CJ GE DCSO/113/2007 Généré par l'IA

Sexual Assault Conviction Upheld Over Evidence Admissibility and Jury Instruction Challenges

Numéro de cause DCSO/113/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellant was convicted of multiple counts of sexual assault based on evidence including contemporaneous outcry and testimony, despite asserting consent and challenging the admissibility of certain evidence and the court's instructions to the jury. The court held that the trial court properly admitted the evidence of prior sexual history to rebut the defense's assertion of consent, finding that the evidence was relevant under rules allowing admission for purposes like rebutting a claim or showing motive, plan, or absence of mistake, and that its probative value outweighed its prejudicial effect. Furthermore, the court found that any perceived errors in jury instructions were harmless in light of the overwhelming evidence supporting the conviction.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Sexual Assault Conviction Upheld Over Evidence Admissibility and Jury Instruction Challenges: The court held that the trial court properly admitted the evidence of prior sexual history to rebut the defense's assertion of consent, finding that the evidence was relevant under rules allowing admission for purposes like rebutting a claim or showing motive, plan, or absence of mistake, and that its probative value outweighed its prejudicial effect. Furthermore, the court found that any perceived errors in jury instructions were harmless in light of the overwhelming evidence supporting the conviction.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
contrainte sexuelle force probante preuve libératoire classement pour lésions corporelles possession de pornographie enfantine ordonnance de renvoi

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied to order the appellant to pay the court fees.
Généré par l'IA
A/291/2006
Affirmation of Sexual Offense Conviction Based on Victim Testimony.
P/60/2019
Accused's Appeal Partially Upheld; Rape Conviction Confirmed on Credible Testimony.
P/23847/2021
Sexual Contact Conviction Upheld Despite Contradictory Testimony
P/13825/2016
State v. Defendant (Sexual Assault Acquittal Upheld)
P/23904/2020
Conviction Upheld for Rape, Sexual Coercion, and Assault Despite Weapons Law Appeal Dismissal

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to order the appellant to pay the court fees.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

     

DCSO/113/07 



                        

 <4=>2<733,' $! 2=  &# ! 72 "#1 733= $  ' #!"!!%#""? !8  ?  ' '@ *



#(#@A

  "!#!A ""? !8  ?  '  +'": 2734 

  ! "#$%& !&#"&' "!#!A ""?"B  '  24' " $!432 2722 27

 ((&)#*+'!,*!&"*

     !     ! "# $ $ !  "  !!"!%&&"$"&!!'(#!" !! "$$"&!!)*+,!*-./*!"0"#$#" ! 1!&#"#!'233324'"!"56( !&"!%5$#" $!"!$#"#)*233!*27!* 8/"!(6 "$$&&"9:)*233!*-!* 8/*"0#":#" !:&&!!'"(!!'(!%(# !!"!; "$ '0:#)*47 8/*   

* ?* CDDDDDD  ? CDDDDDD  $$# " ! $!! E 5555' $! 4+'"!" *

 !""%$E335555=3 ":#$( DDDDDD"'  !("  ?* CDDDDDD' !%&& " $ )F$ A !%&&/  !$"$$##"$##*

 G@!#(" &#$( DDDDDD"'!("'! 2,67334'!%&&$1!#'"!8 "H6733+'!% " $@!%*=-8*

  $! " , 1 733+' !%&&  (# @ ( DDDDDD "'  !("!%#"9:!$!!E5555*!#! !" !$"$$##$#"?*CDDDDDD@-++%333&*

 #"9:"5#"!9;$9#$'$ :'   : & ! -2  2>HH  6 IIII' $  !9"2%+4,%37=&*$##DDDDDD)9*2/'! "  ## DDDDDD )9* 21/* ( DDDDDD "'  !("' &:!#'!"#$#' $!'#0&,1733+'@273%=,H%4=7&*3+*

* "221733+@!%&&'( DDDDDD"'!("' #!!"#:$::'&(!!F $#!0#("0$1!#@ "1!*

  24 1 733+'  ## DDDDDD  # !%# " 9:'  ! #$"$DDDDDD*

 $!"#"4 1733+'!%&&&5#@DDDDDD*"#! " :6$ '" !6:$#'" "*

  7H  1 733+' DDDDDD *  &#' "  ! 1! " $ '""":#( DDDDDD "'!("'##DDDDDD*

 2-"#1733+'##DDDDDD#$"*

  6: " -2 6  733, ) <7=2-+<733+ J . <2+--<733,/ ! 1! " $   "#!#  1! ! "" &# !

7H 1733+$DDDDDD*'"$"!%#! "K!"!"#!$*

*  22 "#1 733,' !%&&  (# @ ?* CDDDDDD'   $ @ ( DDDDDD "'  !("  "# "# " H"#1733+"!(!!!(!$#" DDDDDD*$"(!$""##DDDDDD## #"(!#&:9*221"!$:4"!%#" 9: " , 1 733+  "#  ( ! # : $ ! #"! 9;$9#)6 IIII/#'"("#"!! $# (%!!  "# " : & &# @ !%* ,H !* 2 8&!%"6"*

* "#$#$":&&"! "#!72"#1733,' ? CDDDDDD  &# $!  ! "# " !%&& " H"#1733,(#$5'?*CDDDDDD'!!27"#1733,' " "  #$* !! !'    "#$' @  !   (%!!  @ ! " " ! #"! 9;$9# " : &* !!  ( !"!%*H=- !%$$!1!#"!%*,H!*28*

   $$ " 27 6  733,' !%&& 5$!( (%! "  $#" @ ! ""!#"!9;$9#L"6"9! $"$$##" ?*CDDDDDD*  9'!$##!" $'! !#!"5$$#$ (%!"!*!!'?CDDDDDD9!$"  #$5' ! #"! 9;$9# !   $(%!! " "  !%( $$# " ! $!!* %&& ! @ ! & "  "#*

  # @ $#  1 ' ( DDDDDD "'  !("  !'    "#$'  6 " ! $!*  1' !! 5$ ( !%*H=- %$$$!1!@!"%$'"%#$ #!#!$# ;$#&($#""%#$"9: " ! " " :: & $'  ( ! "# " !%&&' (  $$!(# !%*,H8'&@!!*

 ,&# 733='?CDDDDDD#@! "#* !!!  ( !%&&' @  "  $$' M (%  L !!  $ (#"!$"$$##!#"!9;$9#$!0* !!'!!6($#($'!F$    #0 @    : 1!   !! $   ! #"!  #   ! & " ! # "%   * ? CDDDDDD $$#((!"#"!%&&$!""! #"!9;$9#(&!%16"$!"&#(! #"!9;$9#"#":&&!%"6"'

                                         *

 ( DDDDDD "'  !("  !%&&  ## $!!# $ ! "#*$"(#(%!!%$$@6! !  !! $ $ ? CDDDDDD* %&&  #$" (  "& !    (%! "   !! "#    " (!$!&#$DDDDDD*##9#*

 $!':# <4=>7<733,'&!%16"%"#" 6$! "#) G<227<733=/*

 

2**   " #  $# $    (  ! $!"N5#&#!(%"!%&&@ !!$M$6&#&)*+,!*-.J*23!*2J* 2=!*2/*

2*1*  $! " 0 "#$# " ! "5 6 " ! L ! $!:   "!)*2=!*7/*

2** !%$'!$!'($!5:"&$@!%*2- !* 2 '  ## &# ! 72 "#1 733,   "# " !%&& &#@!$!:!27"#1733,*

 !!""#!# 1!*

7* %16 " ! $# $!  ! "# " !%&& " H "#1 733+   (%!! $ ( ! #"! 9;$9#   : & ! -22>HH6 IIII: 2:!$!!5555'"  '  FG5'  "# " : &  & !%"6"":*

 !""!%"$!'!$!:' "!" $$"!%&&'$$#(! #"!9;$9#"#" : & &# @ !%* ,H !* 2 8'  & !%"6"   : &                                       *

 $!!#$! "#'!%&&"#!#0"%"  "&!$#%$$#@6*

   " # "  #( ! $!' ( % $ " 16!%&&%;$&:"!&!#(!# !%* 2=!*4'"(!"#"!%&&"&#"!$##*

 !%(%!%;$!"$! !"!%*H=-  !%$$!1!#"!%*,H!*28!!#:#"!$!*

-* &#5*73!*79*+',2!*7!*,7!*7 '!N; $!"$ "N#!"6'"N!!""#$*

OOOOO



  $            -

%(',-

 #! 1!!$!&#!72"#1733,$! "# " !%&& " $ " H "#1 733,' " " ! " " ! $E335555=3 '(%!!$(!#"!9;$9# :&!-22>HH6 IIII: 2:!$!!5555'  "  '  FG5'  "# " : &  & !%"6"":*

!('#-

2* %"*

7*  ( ! " "#  "&# " !    A P #"! 9;$9#"#":&&#@!%*,H!*28 &!%"6":&'&"""5 $$#  "6" " ! $  5 9 @ ? CDDDDDD' $$#"!%#"$!!P*

-* #1!$"!*



&./"A ?  Q R  C' $#" J ?* " GG ' 6:  ?!#   '6:$$!#*

"! " !!A

8!$$?   Q R  C  &&A #"A    $#"#(#$ @!N&&#$! :5$$!:&&!