Taxpayer Penalty and Interest Assessment Upheld
Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe litigant challenged the imposition of penalties and interest arising from tax assessments, primarily arguing that the deficiencies were based on a reasonable interpretation of complex tax statutes and that the underlying actions were not willful or without justification, pointing to previous advice and the lack of clear guidance at the time. The court reasoned that while the statutory language was intricate, the agency's interpretation was legally sound and that the taxpayer failed to demonstrate reasonable cause or lack of negligence to overcome the statutory presumption of correctness for the assessed penalties and interest, thereby upholding the determinations.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 LTF; Taxpayer Penalty and Interest Assessment Upheld: The court reasoned that while the statutory language was intricate, the agency's interpretation was legally sound and that the taxpayer failed to demonstrate reasonable cause or lack of negligence to overcome the statutory presumption of correctness for the assessed penalties and interest, thereby upholding the determinations.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs, specifically referring to Art. 66 LTF.
Texte complet
%&'()%&+ %,(-%&+
""
" ! .! ". .!
./ + $ 0) 1 &+
!!!!!!!!!!"# $ %"&'() " $* + + ,%+ ## $ -%+## .+ /
+
00 - 11 " # + $% 2 34"* +5'6"&'&& &7
! " #$
:'8&6:
2
&; !!!!!!!!!! < :* = > - %?" % &366" @ $+ * @ "A B+#* $ &33&+ , +%#$% <+ + # , + # + ?;+$ %+*= ##A@+%'((&+'((5;
'; '9C &337"- %%+%, + $#- #+ D- +E$ + ; F+% + -+ @ + % #A F, ; G # # E D + # % H$+ A+ =$+D+ =$# H+# +;
7; 7C &335" D #* ++ #- : , # +%;
5; &6 @%, &336" !!!!!!!!!!" F H +F *%# D" +++ # +$%# D- %-+@ + %#A+ H2+% +% %#+ H+ H; + *% + + %+% # @@ ; + +F # F, + # $%# + HF + +F :
+ H #%G++ E # +; @@ + #- % F D # @@# ++ # +;- * +%#+ , %+ ++ ++#%@ + ,; # D *#+D#$ * @ %+ + # D%*, +* G + D- 2 , + # + : # + # * @ A % CD- " I+ + + , ++$$G @% + + : # D%I; +D#* + #,* @ * +*D- * J+ $ + , ;*+ + , +@ +#, +++ ,# * #+ , #$% #+ , # + "# E-%*$*JF++++ , +%: ;
6; #% #&6 K+&336"-@@ + #- : , # +%< :* => - ? #%E- % + # $*#=& C &335"G% #H %#- , # +%#&((L;
9; - % ,% +$ + &335 + &334; ,$G &33)" + E #% + "- , +* %# # %, ;
4; D+ #'#%$G &33)"- % =,D- ## @@ +%E #%* ## A#AF, "D +* + +D- #* G=$#$%$ ;
); &6#%$G &33)" !!!!!!!!!!+++D-%++#+%-+HH ,% #* A$ "I* +# + @ +" +++$%@+ * $* ++ # $* + $+ + + A+ # #A + * +% ; * + # $ G +% # + + # F, + # - + + :
+ H + # $ % # '( L; *+ + * + # # $% D * $+I;- * +%#+ , %+ +#&((L;
3; &5, &333" !!!!!!!!!!+++%D-+ , +%E&((L* + " # $ + # #$+" %+ + * G #= &5 , &333; ')
8'5)78'((9 :78&6: , &333" * % "E#$##- "D- %*+ * # + , +% +% # %* + :+F H H + $ D- * + A @ + #-$* 2%#G "#%*$+@ %D++* +# #F H;
&(; '6, '(((" !!!!!!!!!!"*% +0 MF H " #"E #$# # - " A* + ; * # H + # I++ * = @ + # #A + H , %, + +F D # F, + # - + + :+ H * *$+ E HF + E $ # #H % E # +; @ + # F +D D# + * :F$% I;
+ $ D- + , +% %#+ #*+% + * G E &(( L <+ + * @ ++ #G +" #%*$+" * + # F H?; + #" +F #= +% ,#F, HF; &336"+ , +% #G +#%CE%+%* G;-%++@ + ,#F, HF + A G$+#%H # ;
&&; '3 C, '((&" - % #%G+% +H 1 + #-+%H + @ < ?;
&'; &6$ '((&"# , # %#*++ * @ * * %: $*+ + # - J+ # + , + + # - % # '' @%, &' $ '((& + # * E 6( L #= &7 $ '((& +++% * !!!!!!!!!!" F H +F *%# D:* H+ #+H#D+ $ " +CD-'4$ '((&"* $+++ G ,+ * $*=+A+ 1 ;
&7; =', '((&"- %"E ,"%+% * +%#+ , + ++'7 , '((&" !!!!!!!!!! # D% E - D *+ + @@ + # # @ $%* $* ++ +F ;
&5; '9$ '((&" !!!!!!!!!!+++%D- %, +#K + $* +H ## EF, HF"# +@ + -%+ +++$+ *%C %; * +% # + , G$+ A H G -A* + # !!!!!!!!!!%+ +,G$ @ + $ + #%*$+$A $$;2 , + HH ,+ # - +F + G + :+ H HF * + AIN+% I;
&6; +#- G ,+ * @ =,D+H"D #, ++ $ '4$ '((&"%+%% +%* ='&C #-G %+ @#- %+D- -++ $ %'6, '((&; "- %* , ++ , D$+ * + E 6( L $$ $* 2% # G " # H " $ * @ "$ , $%# %+ +% ,#G; , + # $* +$+ +% * ,+ # # @@ +%H + * @ ;
8'5)78'((9 :58&6: &9; 7($ '((&" !!!!!!!!!!"$%# ++# " ,%D ++ #- %#%H # ++$++#, +G + E +F #=# F, HF" %,+$+ # F, # +; * + , #$+ # &(( L # + , +% %#+ ; $* +$+ + ,$+ * + +% #- %@ + +* % + ;
&4; &' C '((&" # + # =, D - % + % E A + , +%E*#6(L$ D* +% % ##+ , G$+ A H G+#46L#$%+ #-$* 2%#G " #H # $ * @ ;
&); &( C + '((&" !!!!!!!!!!" $%# : # - " +++% D + +$ #- # * @ %+ + + - %-, +*;7& K+ '((&" * % % D- @ + #%+ $ # -A* + * @ # %+ + @ $%* A$$%# * # * ;
&3; 3 C, '((7" + #- G ,+ $%# # - # * D $%# , + #< ? # +#-A* + G" +$$+" #- A$ # - % # &4 C + + &6 K+ '(('; # + , + @ + - GC+ #- D # 2+F= $+ # * # ' + G '((' , + +" F$+ H + *2F + ;
+ =, D - % * + # # D D + # A F, " * @ A C$G D # @ $ $+ # A" , F, HF ,+@%"*+ "+@+ H$ F+; F + + + , # * F# # $ ; 0!!!!!!!!!!" +F *%# +" # H + DI +F + G :+ H +#- + + #F * +HF" * #- +F :+ HF" +F * %:$% + # +; 1++ * = +% 2+F= # #A + H + F2* +F $ $ H # - + ,+ #&337I;
* +#+ , * + "- %* , ++ , E&((L, #$+E)(L< #*% ?;
!!!!!!!!!!" *2F + " # H + D I + G #%* @ % +" %* #+%H ,2# $ $+ D<077;(&?"* +%#2 <0 9(;'?"++* + #++ $+ D#* ###"++* + %#+ H+ HI;
- %, +,%# # @@ "%#+ *% G" ++ $* +$+#*+%+#G D *+ %, +"*= # ++"# @ + %*%+% , * + + %#+ ; , # *+F H *2F + D H , # - % * +% % # # + , $ +% E 7( L #$ #*+%* +%,+$+J+ ++%;
8'5)78'((9 :68&6: - % + # =, D -A$ *2F + D H + * G=$ $* +$+A#- %#%CE#* # +D -%+ +* , # A +; * +% #2 * # + E + G H ,# += D + + +* *@+ $ ++;* +% % # -%+ +# **% E7(:5(L#+ , +% *+ $ #*+%;
* + %+ +*+O+#%@, G $*++#H ,+ G# += D * %+ + - %; -+ * +" - +F * % # F, D # #%H # +% $+ # * F %" % ++ *+:J+ + ,+ F H D * %+ + + D" $*+ + # -F2* +F $ $ H#%, % #* %%#+ + ,+ ; * ,+ A G #,+H + $+ #-H # - % + + + @ E +G + #*+F H *2F + D;
'(; &6$ '((7"# , # %#*++ * @ * * %+HE @ #+ , + E G , -++ +# + $* +$+ # - %" % +E + ++E@ + + "* %,#'9$ '9 K+'((7;
'&; '4C '((7" @ #+ # +#-%,+ + +H #- G ,+ + $+* %,#'9$ '9 K+'((7;- %, +%+% J+ $# # &( , 7( C '((7; #A $ # * %" %+ + ++% D $* +$+ + -++ +# # - % * + # * G=$ , * @ ; $ + + +$$+ H @ , G$+" D # ++ + $$ + + =# @@ ;*" - % +*@ +#-, # *% ; $* + * # +H" + $+ * * , + , " D + ,A @ % %+ + %H + % G * + ; $ + + * G +" %+ + # @@ #-@@+ %,+ * @ " - % # + + $+ * $ # :$J$" , $D#$ + ,+ * + , ;
''; '(C '((7" !!!!!!!!!!+++%#-* +%#+ , #6(L#= & C +'((7"* #(L#)'(C +'((7+#6(L#='&C + '((7;
'7; - % * +H7(C '((7CD-3C +'((7"#+ED +E , * +%#+ , ;
'5; 7&C +'((7"@ #+ # # + ,+D- % -%+ +*$ + %$ + ,%E+ , +-, +* G %G #% $+ # $ P $$ + %+ + # @@ " - % $ + + H @ , G$+; HG#- %"+H%+ + + $*;
'6; &7 K+'((7"# , # %#*+ * @ * * %A$ #- %1 , $%# %H < :* =>1 %$?;
8'5)78'((9 :98&6: '9; '4 K+ '((7" - %" * %+% * " H% D - + *+ # +H * , + D$+ # * +% + + # + , +++%E$ $+:E;
'4; 4 ,$G '((7" - % #$#% 1 %$ * D ,A$$%# %+ +% ;
'); &' ,$G '((7" - + $% D- , A$ *2F + D 1 %$%+ +% ",-%F#+HIF/I;
'3; '4 ,$G '((7" - % #$#% E - D- D + + + #-G # , $%# * =# *2F + " M!!!!!!!!!!;
7(; '( $ '((5" M!!!!!!!!!! # + $%# ; - % @@ + #* &337 #- %* # #%* @ $C " % + 0 77;'" # + G # A 0 56;5 + # + + # * +% #2 0 9(;'; %+ + * +% # + , + + #* #%G+; * , + + #%* + @@+ + *2F +F% * # + ; * + %+ + % ,% , $ G # +%< "# "+ +#* +%?+# %#-%, + ;-2 , +*# * #-+ , +%* G;
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
8'5)78'((9 :48&6: +H E0 #+ ;- %++# %H $ ##I+ + I" $*+ +++ + $*+@ $+ ;
2, + * +%#+ , #'(L$ #=C &337+ * +% # 6( L #= K+ '(('; * +% %+ + %# + * *2F + D E 6(L#+ , +%#*+% *G $% D;-+ $+ #A* + # %+ + + * + + ,; $ * @ %+ + * G" $ #, + + $*+ # # @@ +% + " % E -$%H$+ # * +% # - %" D #, + * J+ $ E # + * H #++ + ;I#, + @ %++#* +%+# ,+ , +%# F F#-+ , +%#*+%I;
7'; ') K+ '((6" %#*++ * @ # + + E + + ,- %#&6@%, '((6;
+ ,% D - % + + $G% # C # #%G+ @%, '((6 , + D- + +% + , F + @@ #* # , + H; ,+ H+ $%# %+ + $ @ $+ E C+ -, + %+% + $ E - E C ; %,+ +F% D # - , # +%%+ +@@+%" G#- ,,+ , # +%" * #+E -A #- + , +% # , 5 11 '((( & + , #- , # +%%+ + %# + + #-#%#+ #&(L"#+$ = D +A#- , # +%%+ +#66L;
77; * %#'9 K+'((6"- #$#%E + H, # $*+ # * ++ *= G #- #H % #- , # +%#66L#=& K+'((';
75; #% # 7& K+ '((6" - %# + + + = # - % E #$ : +#=& + G '((6;
76; &3 *+$G '((6" - % -+ % E ++ #% ; -A + + + , C+ @ + %, # +" %++ $%# -%+ + #- HH ,%; @ + + + F2* +F= * # $*+ #%#+ #-$ $$'(L" $*++# F# *"# +# +E+ :D + # +;
79; =& ,$G '((6"- % D #* ++ #- :FO$H;
74; 7$ '((9-@@ + #-$* < :* =>- ?-#% %*+ *$+ ,+ D- , + + $ + @ + $%# # &7 #%$G '((6# !!!!!!!!!!++++#-* +%#+ , #6(L#=& K+ '((7 + D- -%+ + :$J$ #% % *+ *$+ # # + , +% * $+++#+$*# %*% + + #A , ;
8'5)78'((9 :)8&6: 7); 'C '((9"- C+%- + #- % ,+D ++ 2+$ + ,%- + # ++ = -%+ +$ # @ %# Q%D # - #+ -$*JF + * -A #- + , +% #*+% E #- 6(L"D-, +%H$+#$ - ;
73; 9C +'((9"- % E- + #++#% * =# G + # + E + + E - + #- ++ = #=& ,$G '((6;
# H + $ $+ # #%*O+ # #$# + # - , + # * %# # %, %+ + #+ D" @ D- @@ + * # + G *2F + D"D * , +$ + , %, # +;
+ + F2* +F=" -A* + * G+ # " + *G # + , D$+E76L; , + #-#%#+ #'(L"C+ @ % # + * + * @ # <H # # @@ +% E #%* " # % +" RH" * * @ ?" +A#- , # +% +#4'L# +# +E ++ = ;
5(; '(C +'((9"- C+# ;
5&; ) K+ '((9" - % +%" ++ D # G " -# + # !!!!!!!!!!+M!!!!!!!!!!;
5'; 1 D %+%H #%ECH ;
"
&; H, S H + C# <?%+%$ # @ %+ + +%"#= & K+'((7" G+ # " $* %#6CH" # +* % #++, :* % #+"6%++&9CH < +;&+; +69 ?;
1 +ES+ #S%+ #&9CH "* G@%#% '4C, '((5< 0&7(&(9?" # H, # *+%"&7@%, " # * + + + H+* $+++ G+ # # %H E + CH + + " " # S+++ # S%+ # ,ACH ;
'; @ $%$+ E - +; 69 ; & +; ? F; ' G + # .+ # +++ * %, E - +; 69 # @%#% * + H%% # # + # # 9 + G '((( < ? D + + ,E @%#% - , # +%#&3C &363< ?;
1 $*%+* CH ##S*=+ %+G ;
8'5)78'((9 :38&6: 7; "+ %, H & C, '((7"+ G#-*=# $J$D# * + # ,$ # @ + "+ %, H & C, '((5<'((77)6'?;
5; + H* + D+ #, -+EC++ + D- + $% %# + ++ = # +G%%@ + +E#$ : +#=& + G '((6;
6; + %*+% , # +%"- * +%#H + + * + * %$%* $+ # H # %" %++ #- @ $ +% H% +" #- $# #- #+ < +; ) ; & + 5 ; & ?; + %*+% * +% # H + + # $ + #-$G * + #* G +%#H #- % $ F% # + , %D G % D + #% + " ++ # $ + %+ #- ++ +E+%*F2 D $++D-* +* =+ +$++ $ # %#*++ A H G< +;4 ?; %, +A#- , # +%" , D - % + * G+ - -%+ + * , # + $* % , D- * + G+ A B+ -+ , +% D *+ G$+ J+ A H%# * =+ +$++$ # %#*++ " $ F%# + , %D G %< +;&9 + +;');' ?;
9; -+ %, H #5=$ %, # $ # @ %+ #- +;'); & + @ E -%F $+ # + +A #- , # +%; D- + + = %+ + #% * ,+ E % #= D #H % #- , # +% ++ H +99'87L"++# * + * %, +#% $ #- + 2 + :D +# + E % * %++ #H % #- , # +% #- $ 9( L + + + = E # ++A+*% E4(L" # + + ,E- + #- D + #- #$ : + #$ + FH%; ,F" * * #%, % CD- * C * # $+ = #-%,+ # - , # +% ,+ , # +%" D + -$* # # 5=$ %, # < 0&7(75) #;7;5P 0 *G %#&4$ '((6" 48(6" #;'"#9*+$G '((5"'538(5" #;5?;
F/ % + @" #H % #- , # +% # + J+ %,% G #- $* # ,; " , D - % + * G+ - -%+ + * , # + $* % , D- * + G+ A B+ -+ , +% D *+ G$+ J+ A H% # * = + +$+ + $ # %#*++ " $ F% # + , %D G %; $* # ,-@@+" =H # "F @@ + A+$+D* G $ ++##A ,+ @ ++- ,-+ "# @@% * $+++ # +A #- , # +% <$%+F # H%% # $* # ,P 0&7(75) #;7;5"&')7( #;&"&(5&79 #;'+ 'GP CD- 7& #%$G '(('> +; ') ; ' P # & C, 7& #%$G '((7> +;&;& %+ ,- +;&9 P#* & C, '((5> +; ') ; ' %+ , - +; &9 ?; * %# E $* # ," , + # * $ $+ # #
8'5)78'((9 :&(8&6: # + E +P , , + , # +% # ,+ J+ #%+ $ % * + E $J$ $ $+ + $ # @ + # , *+ G #- @ # + E +" , CD- $ $+ Q #% + #"# ,+J+ * $*+< 0&'3''7 #;5;&"&')&45?;
, #- , # # + J+ %,% ,+ + + @ + # ++ * @ =+ # - +% %; -G #- , @@+ ,$+ % %" 2 # %@% A# %++ + D"+D- %++# DJ+ + + # #-@@ @%#% #++ + D< 0&'9 49 #; 7G8 + GG?; $ # D ++ # ++ + D # ,+ J+ %# +" #%*# # -$G # + * + * @ # * + < $ ++ % F# *" RH" % # , " + +%8+%H #-+ + # %C + +A #- *+ ?+ %+#-%,+ # $ +#* , #- % + ; #%#+ H G$A $$#'6L ++ + D* $+#+ $*+ # # @@% + %%$+ D *,+ @ , #- + , +% + ,<@; 0&'94) #;6?;
, # * , # #%+ $ %+G + #H % # , $G* %* #% +D- +@@+ ,$+* % $ $+ #%+ $ + %+ + G +% < 0 &'3 ''5 #; 5;7;& + %@% ?; # + J+ %,% # $ = =+ D * G G D- , +" =H H%% " # %@% # D - % G+ ,+-++ +E+%;
4; ** +#%,+ +% %<* A$*$# "- #+"- * +% # + , " - , # +%" -++ + E - +%H +% *F2 D $+? + - + + #@ +#- # $%# ; "* * , %+G # +#- %E #* ++ "-#$ + + CHG ## $+D$%# # + @ ; - % + # # % $%# ,J+ $* + #-++*H ## +A+;C * ## * % %+RF# $%# "* A$* #-%,+ #- , # +% #-++ +E- +%H +%" #-A$# # +%+ + -%,%$+ #++ ,## $$H< 0&''&6) #;&G+ %@% P1 " * ,# +# " > %H-F #M : G +
1 MT M:R"'((("*;'9)?;
- : , # +%" - + + # @ + #- # $%# @ # +#$%# + ++#+ %E-@@ #- : , # +%"A* + #$%# #%*#+#- + ++ #- "A$* + D%* + #- G ,+ $%# #- < 0&'7&46?"A* + * # + * * + DA* + $%# # %* CH#* $ = # # = + <1 &334" *; 7&) #; 7GP " * %# #$ + + , : , # +%" +F= 0 G H &333" *; &5'?; #
8'5)78'((9 :&&8&6: -%,+ # - , # +%" +RF # $%# + E * + CH$+ -%++#+%+E # D #D$ +* D+ , +%- %+ *G#+ , ; + "# %$%# + ++%%$++ * #%+ $ D+ ,A *+ " G$+"A H #- % < 0&'6'9& #;5+ %@% ?;
); D , * G+#- +$%# "D +#%+ $ + -+ D * + + H A + @ + - GC+ #- %+# + %" D +@ # #A$ $*+"D- * %H$+ #% + * + A* $% * * A$ %" D- + %+% %+G * #-$="D# *+ # +A+$%# +- % + # ++ $%# + +@ D #-A* + + #K$+ $ + ,%; #$ +" -%%$+ #%+ $ + * , * G+ -+ - H #$ 2#* , #% H+ $$ + $$ A* + " $ G + G + < 0 &'6 76' #; 7" &'' &9( #;&+ %@% ?;
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
G? + " S +;67;' "S *+ , #% + #% + @ $$+ *% @ DS + $ @+$+ % + D + @ + ,J+ $* + +G; " # + * %, E - +; &4 @ + #%@+" #% # + *+J+ %,+$+$ # @ %#-* = =H GE #% + # #% #$ + + , *% @ ; CH - + #$ G # #% #% "* $ + @D-+# + %" @+ @ # ++ C # D A ++ $ $+ Q #% %+% #"
8'5)78'((9 :&'8&6: $*++#* + D, H E-%* D< 0&&3543 #;&G8+ %@% ?; G # #% + " H + + % # # +" # $J$ D- +++ % %++ # - % + # @ + < 0 &&4 &4 #; 'P &&6 7&5 #; 58?; #% + # + + +@ * J+ + $+ + + + , A$ # # + E G # * ++ # H # %; * + " H #- + + * %# + + +$* E , % + # ++ * = A$ * @ # # @ +; " A+ +# $ @+ + J+ #$ D - + # * ++ #%*# # # + $+% # + -A$ * , #- % + " D+ E + # *+ # %%$+" + D #% * .+#$ G $*++# ++ #@ ++## +< J+;# &3#%$G '(('"'''8('" #;7;'"+ %@% ?;
&(; ? -*=" + # * = $%# # D -%++ # +% # +-+*$% %#* - #+#&3372+# % E- + #- ++ = #- , # +%"$ *+O+*%C %;
@@+" !!!!!!!!!!" + H%## #* %# # %, " +++&6#%$G &33)D-%++#+%-+HH ,%#* A$ ; + !!!!!!!!!!" '6 , '(((" =, @ + D -%++ @ + , # F, HF , A G$+ #%H # ; !!!!!!!!!! * " '9 $ '((&" #- @ + # F, HF ++$+ *%C % + #- HH ,+ # - +F + G + :+ H HF; !!!!!!!!!!+ $" 7( $ '((&" D ++ # - % #%H # +$+; @ " =," 3 C, '((7" D - +F * % # F, D # #%H # +% $+; " *+F H *2F + D"D -, +*%+% ,+ H%E-%* D"+$+ %++* !!!!!!!!!! # D * *2F + + ++ # - %" M!!!!!!!!!!+1 %$;
G? ,#D * %=#" +$ @+D-%++#+%# +-+ * $% % #* &336" ++ # * + # , $+ D D *2F + D; " -+*%+G D %D#-%++#+%#- % * +%#H +G FH$+ $* ++# + E$ + @# %, ; %D" %, # +##-# $ + # : -+*C+ @ %;
&&; ? % +%"- + $%* %#%E #% + ##% + #- + #- +E&((L@@++ , % + # %D# @@+ $%# # + * +%#+ , "+ +++ $*+ ## H + *2F + D ,+ H%E-%* D; #% %D" # * + # , # % A F, " - % * , + A + , +% #*+%* "* + $*+# H + *2F + D" %# ++++ , +%
8'5)78'((9 :&78&6: * GE+A#6(L"@ #+* -, *2F + D#1 #'( + G '((5;
, + #-A$ # + #- + #% + + $* +** + = $+##%+ $ #% #- + 2 +E &(( L + %+ + $ @+$+ % #= D += # - $* + +G# + @ + +G # %;
G? +%H #" ##% + #- + #- +E&((L"- %+ + * # +# !!!!!!!!!!#&6@%, &336D$+ E @ * +% # + , #%@ + , + F + # $ * @ ;
G # % ++ D D+ # - $*+ # -%++ # +% # - % * +% # + , - % +% * %+% ,+ H%; @@+" !!!!!!!!!! :$J$" , &333" + $ D- + , +% #*+% + * G E &((L" D U!!!!!!!!!! =, '6 , '((( * % +D-%+ +#%CE* G#=&336; ++* +%%+% @ $%* !!!!!!!!!!'9$ '((&+7($ '((&" !!!!!!!!!!$+ D-+ , +%%#+ E&((L+* G; &'C '((&" + E* +%A H G#46L+3C, '((7 +++#-* +# , $+ D#-* +%#+ , E)(L#+ , #*+%;
? + # # , + $%# A D -+ $+ # * +% # + , # +" $*++#% AF, +E #+"- @@+ ,$+ * %+% %,% +$+ * - + $% #= D $%# +++"#=&333+ $J$D-%++#F, # +-+*%C %" D* +%#+ , # : #+ , +% *++ $ ++ + # &(( L" , # )( L < A* + ?; +A + + = % H% #- * +%#+ , + ++ , +# D+++ $+ : " @ #% $ ++ $+ D"%+ +$ @+$+ %;
*#+" + D*+F H *2F + D# +D -, +"E -%* D"*%+% ,+ H%"A + + + $+#%CE&336 ##% + # +; @@+" -A* + H D * G=$ $* +$+A#- %A + +#%CE#* # "D- + * , + + # A + + D # H + # * +% #2 * # E + G H , # += + ++ * * @+ $ +++ %# +* +%#+ , E7(:5(L;
" M!!!!!!!!!! @ $ -A + #- *+F H *2F + D#* &337 H+D- -2*# * #-+ , +%* G + 1 %$ ++ D @ H +% # * +% + * G%$+ D *2F + D A + + %H$+ &337 * D- -%, D ,+ #%* + # - % +$ &335; + %H #" 1 + $ D
8'5)78'((9 :&58&6: - * +%#+ , **2F + D%+ + %# +E6(L#= K+'((' $ $ + ,*#+ +++#+: ;2 # + D*+F H *2F + D # + + $%# +% #$+++ D- + . * +% # + , <# &(( L * M!!!!!!!!!!" # 9( E 4( L * +#6(L* 1 ?%+ +#%CE* %+&337;
&'; , # @ +" -2 * # D - + #- + + = E - %%+ +"&336"#% $ @+$+ %;
@@+" - % ++A#&((L#- * +%#+ , @ A%* *2F + + ++ : @ #+ * C * # # 0 D $%# :+ +++H%% $+ "## +"E* # * + * *+ + # + # @ D - +E# < 0&'676&? :+D- * # $*+$ 2#+A#* +%#+ , @ A%* +* 1 :#+A*G +7(L+A*F+ +6(L :- # + + * +%#+ , # +#5(L;
1 @@+%* # , # %#*++ * @ '5 K+ '((6 + D -+ * ++%" , , + , # +% @ # ++ + D< 11'((' &* F $$A B++ , +%# , 5?; , , # +%+#@ ;64-(();:; , , # +% + # @ ; ''-)(7"'(<5( LA@ ;64-(();:?; " , + #- D E , , , # +%#%#+ "D,#C * ## 0 + $*+ +# $* ++ $ ++ # +"*+J+ @ A%E'(L< 0 #&) K+'((9"5()8(6P 0 #'3$ '((6"'798(5?" +* # &( L D% * - + $%; , , , # +% + @ $+ # @ ;&)-'5'"9(+" %D"+A#- , # +%#9)LD" + #- +;') #+ , H CD-7&#%$G '((7"# # +E ++ = #- , # +%;
- +D#% + # +#&6 K+&336-%+ +*$ @+$+ %;
&7; ,#D * %=#"#% #- #7& K+'((6 %# + + + = # + E #$ : + #= + G '((6 D #% + # ' C '((9 @ $+ + * C+ @ % #= D- #= + #% + # &6 K+ &336 $J$ D # + %E+ #% + +* $* ;
&5; %D" #$ " #% + H % + #$ +%#@ ;&-6((;: % +"EF H#- + $%;
8'5)78'((9 :&68&6:
" . 2 ! " ! .! ". .!
$
34 5 6 7 89 0+& !#:
5
&; % ,G;
$ 5
'; -#$+;
7; #% + # - # ' C '((9 + # 7& K+ '((6;
5; #$- + $%E, + #$ +%#@ ;&-6((;:;
6; -%$ $+"@ A%E'((@ ;"+$ EF H#- + $%;
9; @ $ * + # DS *,+ @ $ + * %+ J+ # #% # 7( C #= + @ + * * $$#% # % G @%#% # " 1FV / F @D 9" 9((5 " + A$* ; #% *+ J+ * H%; $%$ # +> ? # D A+$+D#% +#% G+ +*##% ++D%P G? A* * D $ + @ + $ * , #$# ++ + #% P ? * + H+ # * %++; 1 $%$ + + * + %%$+ %$% % ++ ? G? + ? :#" G@%#% # * *+ $+ = DS #, #% ,G;$%$ # $+ $ 2 # * ," D + C +" D #% ++D% + S, # D%+%A*%# % +< +;&7'"&(9+&()?; H @@ = * % #+ 21 %
* @ $#* %+ J++ + @ %A* + DSES@@ @%#% # * H @@
8'5)78'((9