Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/981/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/981/2005 Généré par l'IA

Contract Enforceability of Preliminary Commercial Agreement

Numéro de cause ATAS/981/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves a dispute over the enforceability of an agreement related to commercial activity, centering on whether certain executed documents constituted a valid and binding contract, or merely preliminary negotiations or agreements that lacked essential terms or final assent. The court reasoned that for a contract to be enforceable, the parties must have reached a final agreement on all material terms, and the evidence demonstrated that while discussions occurred, the parties did not intend to be bound until a definitive, final written agreement was executed, meaning that the preliminary instruments were incomplete and non-binding.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

; PC ; PRESTATION COMPLÉMENTAIRE ; CURATELLE ; CURATEUR ; CAPACITÉ DE DISCERNEMENT ; PREUVE ; FORTUNE PRISE EN CONSIDÉRATION ; DESSAISISSEMENT DE FORTUNE ; ESPÉRANCES SUCCESSORALES | LPC.5.1.let.j

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
promesse de contracter différend commercial exécution provisoire nullité du contrat entente illicite notion de marché public

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/2084/2004
Enforceability of Preliminary Agreement for Sale of Entity Interest
A/1701/2002
Contractual Dispute and Breach of Agreement Enforcement
A/2462/2007
Agreement to Agree vs. Binding Contract Enforceability
A/1430/2004
Contract Validity and Enforceability Dispute
A/54/2007
Commercial Agreement Breach and Termination Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

                ! !""# $ %&' !""#

$

( $ () )$*)  () * 

+  !

 '# ,  !""# 



 -.......... !"! #"$ #" %  &'#"()(*+,-

#"

*//  )$*)  *)) 0-1 2*3 "! #"& %./+ #"012/)()),-0

            

   4(354  

) / $

)6 $# 7777777777 84 ,  #"9 !  ):1( " # " & #&;!-(+##&#& <""!&1*=- (+6&! #! >"!&&#"&&& ""# # !" ?  " 66@6  , & >''      @  @ @A @84 ,  9&"&0-(+6

(6 B  #"!&C" ,&"#&=(+6 @#  #" & >;; & / =" (+  #" & # &> "  C# "#! &  && & ""#6  >D   & & ;#"?>!"C6#"!#"-"! #;#(1E- #!""&&"> !"! #<&>!"<<&#" 6  #"   & C" & # F  #!"! & #"  !"! &#" F&! " &!  &" & 1 #"#< ((6  #" " &-#! & )1;!-(16&&F&"#&!C"# #"!&! "&# # !"!?#G4! ##"  "" &, &  &"" %D #"%! "  # "# & &- ! - #6""#&&/1B;?- >! #?#6>-& "G"# ; )::: "#  # # "C! #  #"" & 1B;6C#"#" &"&""#F> H" & >- & "G"# (  !  &"   "# # I!3!"G !GJ&>#""&(B;6

16  &G &!# & ): #K" (+ >;;  &> " ="!  && & ""## !"&#"#&<&&>" " ;! >#"# & ""# &>"  #"; F  - &! "  <,6>;;"""&<&#""&1+2B+)5;*/ "?""& #&"%D #"%!"F&G4#&(B+0*;(*6

+6 @"?># #"#&#"&1 "<(+>;;&&!#  # #"#  &" & (1 &!< (+6  #;    # " &> < & # #&" ?  &"# &  ;#" " ; ( " ; (1#&!&"#&>!&"#&)*B;6

/6  # # & () &!< (+  " #" ? >"# &  &!## #"#"?F&##"-#D!?>;; #& ""## !""#";!&! #&!"#&> #""&<&F>?>#"#&&! 6

#"""  #<"!& &#&!"##" "&;#"&#"D"&#">"&6  &"&&> , >;; #!&!  !# "#&;"<""# #-!6@>C"&>  ! #  #    # ! #   ;" 



3(3(/  41354   >&""# ;  " & F #  >C"6    "# &  &!"# ; ;;"!   # """ &  "! D%F>"&# ;;"6@>C"&##F&!(1 >"#&! &&""& &L&&;F#" &>-"&>"!;#"#&"6?# #" & #&!"#&!"#;F"6 "?>&"!&/1B; &  >G4! # # 4 !"& >-# -!   #-  "  "#&"  &&  D" ? # #"6 "" F"# "   #"  #" #    ;;"-" M "" #  (1 & #=#&>% &#""" "&F>"- &E#" #!&-""!#">G4! #<#";- &#  ">#;; ##> !-#"!"6 -#F "& #"""#:2")(";?>"&"#&><" " "? #""#&&C"!%"&#"?>&!;& G"#;#?&C"!%6

06 ! #& ;!-(/>;;#"="&#6 !;,G&!"#;"-&"G"#"#&,F> "" "&&!#"!%!"G""&6@>C"&>-"& #"!;#"##"&F >-# ##6 >#&# & "< ""! "# &> F  #" #,& I&<!""C"#J6

26  <  #&#!  # "# # & " F >" "  &"&5(/6N ""## "&F!  <F#  "C-""""&"! D%F6 ""#"  && &  # "" " &" "  G " D%"F  # &C"!  >"#"! ""!6 #"  !"& # # "C!&F!F"& G>-"!C";#"#? ="6 # " "&>&!F>## "C!>G"  "#"   @6 @#   " "" F" !G6 " ? >#&# & < ""!   !"! !&C! ?  ! #F #O #   #!&"#;#"#&#E4>"!-!!-& &<""!&  #6

@ F#  "<  #&#! >#-" & F." - >&"# & BG4 ! # & #"  F  #&"#   " & >-" "#!6

56  &5(/ " "&-&#" <P #&:(+ <""!"#"F<&>&" !! F> >D   & "#Q F #    !  ! & &""  #"" " &  " #"< &  ;"! " E >-" &>"!  ;#"# & 1*  (+ "  "< & &"" & #   &



3(3(/  4+354    & // ; E >#&# & < ""! !-#D" >G " D%"F & )2  (+ E   #" & RS T  @  @   @84 ,R9&)*=(+E&!"#;(1!&C! "F#"";## "C!# "#Q6

:6   & )0  (/  " & G """ ? >"""# & " F> >"  #<&&#  ""!!?#<& &#!#""F#& #&!!&!6

)*6  <  #!&! ? >&"# & BG4! # & #"  &" & / - (/6 4  #;! -# -!  #"" & /1B ; F> &-"   #  "  F&  ! & # -#"6  > = "&  &> # ? F  #" " "!!6  C# & F#"# ;>-" &#""- ? ""! #F6@#"#"#;&#FFC" #" #  &&F> &""I J6

N > & >&   !"! &!&! &>"  F"# "- ? >G " D%"F F  < ""! &-" &C"  &!  # &>#K" (+D"!"!;G! 4?6

))6  <>"&!?""; <""!  &5-)2= "):#K"(/6"&"&() "<(/G  &>G " D%"F&"!&)0 "<(/6

 #" & "" G " F & "#< !F G"" &  (( #<="-!#-<(( G# D%##CF# "F"  !-& & "#< #C";  "" D%##" & "#< G!"; & "#< &  " & G #""-6   (1  #- !-"# #"  < C;"- &   "!6  "#< >CC-" #  &!< (+ -  %# ""#6  &C#"   " &! G" & C-"! #D - # #" - " !"%DF#";#&;<&> "6

)(6 #&>&&# "# #&&"&)5#"#<(/ >;;  &!! "  #"# & #" F  "  "! "!C"&##D# >#"#&&! 6@F# !"!C&!?=C6

UUU



3(3(/  4/354   ) * $

)6 #C-#B#C"#=&89!"!#&;!"""!&, )#K"(1 <"#&## #!&/=C &#" !&""-4 !&"/ !"")0=C8"6)"6 "/0 96

@"?B"#&B!"#&)0=C  <;!&! (2=-(+8 ')1*)*09& #C-#&# "!)1;!-  & #"#""#C" """ <"#& # & !C   ? "# =C ""  & B""" & B!"#&#-G=C6

(6 G"&>"/0 <&!#H""F & #"""# "- ?  # ;!&!   ""# # !" ? >---""-&"!&):):0/84 , 9 F>?  # "#   ""# "# # !" ? > - " --" " ? > -&"! & (/ #"#< ):05 84 ,  96

@# !" #=C&&B ,"!"<6

16 "="!&;#"&! !- # !"#"-< 8"6/0?0* 96

+6  ""# # !" "" ;!&! F "# #" &"! ? #-  <# -"G & # <!!; & " & B 66@6 # & B 66&#"&! #" #-" #6 ""# # #&" ?  &;;! "  -  &!"" "  - &>&#8"6+ ""61 96@#" # "# -#&#"D"&#">"&8"6/6)"6 ""6 16)"6 96

"" ,C >"  #""!   "  " "C  F"# & -#>D&&> ,&<&&#";""# "6

/6 @#= &"&#"B"#"!&""-#=C&#-" #&!  ;" # #-! F #FB #" #- &  !"! 8V&&W- #L%"+,!&"#):5+ 6)10EDC &-X"C%" ;C (, !&"# 6 (25 %6 /96   &# & #=C;#&&!#;& #"##"&# ;"F;"&B."!"<&,!;"< "#  -<< B"4?4& F !""  &C! & -< ! #&!"6   ;;" &#  FB ;"  ." #&!! " #  %D #"%, #<6  "#  !!" & ;" !C! #



3(3(/  40354   -C<  =C &#"   !%!" " G F  "   #<< 8 ' )(0  10* #&6 / "6 < )(/  ):/ #&6 %6 ( "  !;!96  BG"4"4   &#" &  #    #FB&""##=C&-"""&&#";-& B!8 ')(01((#&6/"696

   B&""# #  =C  ;#&"    !"# # & - ;#   -"C"# GF  &#-" #!& &B#;; #" #- F " ;" !""  &C! & -< ! #&!""F&B" #<"# #"  #&; ""  !"#  "  ; &B&" &B" - 8 !"# " ! & -E V  X"C-;%  & @#L-%C 6 ()( Y +/*E VZL3R[ X"C-;% & X"C%" ;C&&(!&6 61:Y)))" 6))2Y1(*EDC &-X"C%" ;C ( !&6 6 (2+E ;6  ' )((  +0: #&6 +)((((1#&6196

06    &> ,  ;" " F "  #"  #! ?  ## >G" &> # # "C! "  !!" & ;#" & >#&&+*>'?""&>";#G6

 &" >C" &  # # "C! ;# " & #"" F>  !"!  #<  " #"" %C! & C!  < & #   & #; >G" &> "  ! #6  "  -% !"< F> #  # & #" 8#" &#  < &  ;9>"! ,&"& G6<&;& #"C#""#"&>"#6@>C"&#""&!!?"" &>";  &-" >C &  - & >"  & #" &#" # "  &" F> #" &  F&"#  (1  !"" !C"-6  -%!"!!"<F#""&K BG4! #&#"<" <!"!-! #"!"&-#>"4?4&&#"(16

@>C" &   "! & &" & #" # " - F>=#&>%  " G"" #  & ;< &> "  F "  &&> "!&&"&>")0&#& -@6 "";<&> "#;#&>&!G"&C-"!#D"  "#"  !" &   ; & >! (+6  "#< # D%##CFF#"?##C#" !"F"?G& (( "#"6

 "&##""&> "F>C"&>## "C!" &>";#G>"G"F"&",-<<6 " -"&/1B;F!"!!"<;#"&#""F#" C#  #!& - # !"" #% &  , " >"   



3(3(/  42354   &>G F  F>  " &-6   "  &" #&! F> > " &   " %"" -<< F>  "! " C" # # "" ## #! #C "&&""&#" 6>D &F>";"&#&"C"#>"& &!=& F&"&#".""6

 #!F"  &!# & >#;;  ! "  &# -#D! # #-&!#&#&!"6#"F#<""C&  &#" ? & &!  #  "-  #"" F "" ;;  !"! & # "6 G4#";G!?)/;6

UUUUU



3(3(/  45354  

  *$ /  $ () )$*)  () *  

245   6  7   89 ':! *3

  5 

)6 !#-<6

 5

(6 >&"6

16 &!#&>;;&):#K"(+"(1&!<(+6

+6 -#  &# ? >;; #  #-  " #- &!#   &#&!"6

/6 #&>;; "&>&"!&)/'?""&&! 6

06 " F #  F  "" G ""# # !" ;!&!  " -" ;# # #"  !" ." &  &! & 1* =# &,  #";"#   #&! &!  < ;!&! &  @%XL%#;F00+    "#G 6 !#&#"P9 &FG""F&!##"&!#<"" & &!# ""F!E <9 G # # F #";  #" " #-# && "" " &!#E 9 #"  C" & #" # & #  !""6@!##"" "#!!"!!!#"" 9 <9 " 9 4&  < ;!&! &   #  "  ",   # FB &- &! -<6  !# & # "###D& -F#"=#"!#BBC" & ,  ## & #"6 @#" !C" =#"  !#  &!# ""F! " B-#  & F   !"! G !&!  #" 8"6)1()*0")*596   @  <@   ;; C   

# #;#& !".""#";!G "FB?B;;;!&! &# C;;



3(3(/