Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/98/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/98/2004 Généré par l'IA

Compelling Arbitration Despite Prior Agreement Conflict

Numéro de cause ATAS/98/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party sought to enforce a contractual provision mandating arbitration for disputes arising under a contract, which was executed between the parties and involved the transfer of certain assets and rights in exchange for specified payments. The opposing party asserted that the arbitration clause was invalid due to a preceding, related agreement that purportedly superseded it or contained conflicting dispute resolution terms, and also argued that the current dispute fell outside the scope of the arbitration agreement. The court reasoned that the plain language of the challenged contract clearly mandated arbitration for all disputes arising thereunder, and the preceding agreement did not explicitly revoke or override the arbitration provision of the operative contract; therefore, the court granted the motion to compel arbitration as the dispute was subject to the agreed-upon mandatory arbitration clause.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Compelling Arbitration Despite Prior Agreement Conflict: The opposing party asserted that the arbitration clause was invalid due to a preceding, related agreement that purportedly superseded it or contained conflicting dispute resolution terms, and also argued that the current dispute fell outside the scope of the arbitration agreement. The court reasoned that the plain language of the challenged contract clearly mandated arbitration for all disputes arising thereunder, and the preceding agreement did not explicitly revoke or override the arbitration provision of the operative contract; therefore, the court granted the motion to compel arbitration as the dispute was subject to the agreed-upon mandatory arbitration clause.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
clause compromissoire partie au contrat justes motifs incitation à violer ou à résilier un contrat clause d'effectivité contrat d'échange

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The provision is cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court fees.
Généré par l'IA
A/4469/2007
Enforceability of Arbitration Clause Despite Prior Defective Agreement
A/3820/2005
Arbitration Clause Validity Versus Contract Validity Dispute
A/4256/2005
Contractual Ambiguity and Compelling Arbitration
A/592/2006
Contractual Incorporation of Arbitration Clause Dispute
A/436/2004
Enforcement of Order Compelling Arbitration Based on Prior Award Under Contractual Mandate

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court fees.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

    &'())&*++, -&.)&+/

0-

 -!  -"    "

%,  *++/

(1  2 

  

   3333333333   !"  #$ $   %& '  () * * +  )$ *$$

% 3333333333   !"  !$, '-  () * *+ $ )$ *$$  

 

!4  " &$*. /0- 1203 %4 ' $ $)

                    !"# " $%

5 0675

 5-

/8  9. * : 9$ 0220- $+) ;  $  01 9$ 0220  <  / 9$ 0220-  $= * $> $   )  *$ $   *$? * $.   )  /@ A)?$ /@@3  !* BBBBBBBBBB- $ C *  5$ *( )$+-  !$ BBBBBBBBBB *  $$ )

=.8

08  ) * *$? (C  ) )   )-  9.  *? *)A$$ $A  3  = 02208

38  A$- !* BBBBBBBBBB  $ 9 )     9. -        *$ ) *  . *   $ *  $ 8 &   *  * *  -   * 9 $  *)-   D *

00 $ 0223-   .  $ $) *   $ *  $ +$  !$ BBBBBBBBBB *  *) * $.- $    /@ A)?$ /@@3   3  = 02208

E8  $? $. $ ;+  )*)  $= * )  $ *() =$ +    $ * $=5. * !$ BBBBBBBBBB ()?$ F  *  * 3/ G 0220 F 7/3H::3 A8 @78  $ $) *    )  07IH11: A8-  #$AA *$8

78 &  $ $ * 1  = 0223 * $ * !$ BBBBBBBBBB- (?$ * )?C *  *$  ) ) A))     * $= . F  + !& F %$#8

I8  $ *  $   *)) *(* ?  #$AA )$ )8

6/71160223

5 3675

 "-

/8 & ( 8 07 *  $ A)*)   $=5. *  )?C A$- ?$$- ?$?   $?$*$ ) * /: *)= /@@3 JKL-  9. )    * ( 8 :38 8 / *  $ A)*)   )?C A$ * 07 9$ /@10 JL $ F >? *>  / G 0223  $=   *  $- *$ ;)  *(AA$   . * ?$    = *  ) * ) $ $ A$;)   9. * *$?-   * *)* * 9$      $ *  $ F  .8

08 ( 8 00 8 0 K )$ +-  #+ 9$ -    $ *  $ F  . * F  *$AA)      $ *  $ . ) * ?$ * $=5. ;$  )?    * *$?     $ *  $ . ) * ?$ * $=5. ;$  )?    *  $ * $.8   - $ C  $ *(9  F    $ *  $  F (?$ * $=5. ;$    *  $ * $.  $ )D    * *$? J D * $= *$$  $A 8 * // *)= 022/L8

38  (>-   * 9 $  *)   .  $ $) *   $ *  $ +$  !$ BBBBBBBBBB    /@ A)?$ /@@3   3  = 02208 *   * - $  )    $ * $=5 .  3/ G 0220 * 7/3H::3-@7 A8-  +   *  $ $ *  $ *  $  &$ M $ & 8

E8  $ $) *    )  07IH11: A8- $ ?$ * A) 5 $     * $=5. ?  !* BBBBBBBBBB > *  +   * >?8

78 $  9 *) $    . 9+(  * A *    $ *  $  *  *-  9$ *$?) =))A$$$ *     $  *$ F * $ )D   $     * 5$8  $ )D   )  ; $$ ).  ( 8 /0 * (*   )?C A$ ?$$- ?$?   $?$*$ ) * /1 ?$ /@1E J 0L    ; ). $- $ $5$  )$ J K  =$)

 3I620 * /1 9$ 0223L8

6/71160223

5 E675

I8    N !$ BBBBBBBBBB   $ *  $ * $ ))*   +    $ *  $  ) ) ?)     =+) * $= .-  ($ )D ).  *G     F A)- *>  3  = 0220- *  * ( )  A * ) * *$?8

:8     * $ $.-  )   <8

  "-5  -!  -"    "

% 67   8  9   :; '<* "=

/8 ?$   + !$. F %$# F ?     * $=5. ) 0/@E337 J  *  K* $ * $=5. ' 3020807822L * !* BBBBBBBBBB > *  K* $ * $=5. *  +   * >?   * 07IH11: A8   *)=$ *   * !$ BBBBBBBBBB ) E0 /00 I/@ 20 O

08 ?$   + !$. F %$# F ?-   *    - * $ )D   $  ; $$ ).   * $*) - *>  3  = 0220- 9+(  * A O

38 (C *   + =$ O

E8 $ +($ (  < *() $ ) *($*$ ) O

78 A   $ *  +H ? A     ) D *  *)$ * 32 9 *>   $A$ $  $ *) *)  $= A)*) * - &#P$Q#A+$ I- I22E   -  $ ;$8  *)$   D  .)8  )$ *$ R L $*$+ ;  +H *)$$   *)$ = $  $   *  *)$$  +)O =L ;  +  $A $  $ ?$ **     *)$$O L    $.    *  )  8 &$  )$   $   $ ))  )))    L =L  L $5*-  $= A)*) *         $>    +H$ *? *) $?=8  )$ *   $   C

6/71160223

5 7675

* ?- +$  9$ - $$ +  *)$$  +)  H? * +   ) ) ;)*$)   J 8 /30- /2I  /21 L8

 .AA$> R  )$*  R

ST  % !C  ! 

 $ A * ) D   $A$) ;  $ $$ +HF HAA$ A)*) *  $   .AA

6/71160223