Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/963/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/963/2004 Généré par l'IA

Issue Preclusion in Boundary Dispute Relitigation

Numéro de cause ATAS/963/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court considered whether a prior judgment barred the current action concerning the determination of a boundary line between two properties, where the prior suit involved a similar dispute between the same parties regarding an adjacent segment of the boundary, despite the earlier ruling not explicitly covering the exact section in dispute. The court reasoned that the prior judgment conclusively determined the underlying issue regarding the legal establishment of the boundary line based on a prior survey and recorded plan, and because the current claim involves the same fundamental legal question and parties, the doctrine of issue preclusion applies to prevent relitigation of that already-decided boundary determination.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Issue Preclusion in Boundary Dispute Relitigation: The court reasoned that the prior judgment conclusively determined the underlying issue regarding the legal establishment of the boundary line based on a prior survey and recorded plan, and because the current claim involves the same fundamental legal question and parties, the doctrine of issue preclusion applies to prevent relitigation of that already-decided boundary determination.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
action en bornage protection des prestations règlement du conflit juridictionnel rectification de limites doctrine juridique servitude d'empiétement

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive regarding the imposition of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1887/2004
Issue Preclusion Based on Prior Judgment Despite Varying Parties and Facts
A/3643/2006
Property Rights Dispute and Preclusion Analysis
A/2540/2004
Property Rights Dispute: Issue Preclusion on Ownership Claims
A/1417/2003
Res Judicata Barring Subsequent Property Dispute Litigation
A/645/2004
Property Boundary Dispute Resolution Based on Survey and Historical Evidence

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the imposition of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

   

&'(()&'(() "&*+,&'(()

"

 " #"   #  #

-. /0  % ', 1  '(()

  

% 22222222222 



# #"  3   #4   !   " #$ %& ' ()

          ! "#! $% , +*- ,

 5"

./ # 00000000000  "!1!  . ) +&&%  " " 1( " 233  " 2 1 4,1(  5 ) 2 "2" ! " 67 8 "(  "/   91:! :2 ) )! "1  .  +&&.  :! " "   1( " 21 ;00000000000 <'= :2  ) !! ! 1  " .> 1 $ +&&? ) 33  ?. "! $ +&&?/

+/  "! " -  +&&%= 2 2 3 ! :  " " ! @!=  3 :2 !  "$ :! "2 1A  "2 1A!/    33 11 :2 !   8 "     :2! "  !!

;00000000000 <' 1  1 " 1 " .BC&&& 3/ "1  +% @ +&&./

?/ 2!!  3 ! 11  .>  +&&%/  (8 : D

E F " .  +&&.  ?. "! $ +&&?= @2 !! ! " ;00000000000 <'   1 "   !! "G  "!" "    )! 9  1"

E @   1  8! " 21  @    1 , !

E  "! " 8!  1!=  3 " 8!  $ )$  !!

E   1  "2H    1A! ! "2 H  1

E @ 3  1  1! : @  "!1  )!  1  !" "  !! I/

 @ : :2  )  8  86 "   " 67 8=    !! " : 2!  8!  " =    ! 1 ! " 1!" ' " 68  1( " 8 "  /

%/  "!  11 " ?. G +&&%=  1 !   3 !

: 2! 2) 1 " 9 " ! " 67 8 '  1 " . ) +&&%= ! 1" 1!! :2 " 1  H  "(  +J  +&&%= 1  :   "  !/

J/ 2!   33 : " 8 "    " "  1  +%  +&&%/ : @ 1 7=   .B  +&&%=  ) !"!  1 " 1 ' # K00000000000=    :2!,8! " 21 ;00000000000 <'/

*+&&%*+&&% , ?*- ,

-/ "  > ) $ +&&% 1  $ " != 2!  "!! : D

F 2 "G  !" ' 3   )! "  !!=  8 $!!3 ") " 1  1 !"/   1) 1    68 "291/  19 " := " 3 : @2! 2  11=  !!=   =  " 3  )! I/

  1  1!! : D F @    1 1!1! "  "  8 "   1 7= 1 : @ 1 :  2! 1  1= 1 :  G  1 : @ 66 " ) I/

L/ < :=    !! 8"! ' @8/

  "

./   8)  28 @" 45  !! "3!   != "(  . G +&&?=  $  "  =  1! " J @8= "  1!"   ),1!"= J 11!  .- @8  4/ . /   J- 5/

< ' 2 " 2! " .- @8 = 1  $ 3!"!  +L @) +&&% 4 M .?&  .&-5=  "  8)  "1!=  .?

3!)=  "1  8 1   $  "   " !8   '  @8 = = " 2 " 2! " )9 @8 /

<    " " 1$=  $ 3!"! = "  H " . @ +&&%= 3 ! :  "1      1   ! 3 = " N=  " 3!"! 4 M .?&  ++-5/

+/ 3 !  ' C/ J-  / . /  6/ B =  $  "   N   : "  1!) ' 2 J-  :  ) '   3!"!  2,67 8 $8  2" !   "2)$! " +J @ .>B+/

<  1! 1 @8 "  "21(   !$/

?/ @! "  "!  3  !89=    )$ 4/ J-  -& "   3!"!   1 8!! " " "   " - $

*+&&%*+&&% , %*- ,

+&&& 4 E < B?&/.5  %> / + "   8)  ( " 67 8 4<  + +&5/

%/ 9   " 2/ ?. / ? /   = 2 1 " ' 2" !   " !" " 26 " )=  1 : 39  "! : 1"

2 1A E  1)  3 "!$  E  :! "2!= "  $ "28 "8 " 21   " "! "2 11 3( ' 21/

<  @1"=  ) : @ "2  13  1$ '  "2  1A 2 1 " ' 2" ! := $ : ! 3   1  1=   ' 1"  "! " 2 1A  3 , " ( "! /    =  33=  "! 1  $ "2 "1  2" ! " 67 8  !8   ( "2" !   " !" " 26 " ) 4 M .+?  +?%5/  !8"=  9  ! 1!    " ' 2" !   " !" " 26 " )   " '

2" ! " 67 8/   "   (8 8!! :  1 :   " " 8 ")"  "  11 " 21 2!() ' +&O  1=  !1! 1 9P  3   "! " 2 1A 4  <  K &.*>+= 1/ % Q .-5/

  1  " 2! : ! , H   11 " )   : ! E   )  1 "2 1A E  : 1!"  '

" " ! " 67 8 3 "   " 1!" " "33! " 21  " 1) 1" !   )! ! "  1 :  "29=    $ " "    :2   !8   2" !   " !" " 26 " )= : 9  !8 " 1 "  " A " 4 .>>B= Q ?= 1/ B5/

    )6 "33! :  !  ) "  1  $ '  "2  1A : "!3)  21   "  3  " , R  1     1 "2  1  ) ' !"  $ 3/   ) " H  :" 21  "29=  :2  != 1  " ! "  =  1 "!3)    )  !! 4 M .+?  +?%5/   1 )!   "2! "1 "2 1) ! "  !! := 1 "    != 66 ' $ " " ! 3 "   )  !! 1"  1!" ! :  "33/

J/  21(= 2! ! ! "  !! ;00000000000 <'=    : =   8 "  /   ! 2 8  @= 1:2 !  "2 1 " .BC&&& 3/  +&C&&& 3/  8 2) 1   :! "2!,8!    :2  28 "(

*+&&%*+&&% , J*- ,

 1 "2 , /    "   " .> 1 $ +&&? ,, !! 8! 1 2!,8!= # K00000000000= 3  1" "  : 2 2! :  !! !     "  !! 43/ 1(,)$ "  1 1 " > ) $ +&&%5/  ) " $   "$ :! "2 1A  " !/

-/  ' "!  2   ) 1 "   "2  1A : "!3)  21   "  3  " ,/  $ 3!"! "   "  :2 2A  1 "      1  ) ' !"  /

   33 !  "   1 1= :2 2) 1    )  !! "1     ?. "! $ +&&?  : ,= ) ! '  "= " 3=  )!/ 1"=   !

  8 "   @:2 +%  +&&%/  2 !"!  1 " 1  :  " " 8 "   :21( )  1 :2' "!3=  2$"  " !/   ":! : 2 2) 1 8 1 7= 2 1 :2 1 :  2! 1  1= 1 :  G  1 :2 ! 1! ' 66 " )/  91 2 1 )  $ " !/ M   1 "  : # K00000000000  : '  ! =  1 (   1/  "! 6 2   2 ! : 1  !! "  "!3)   )!/

 :2  =    !!  11 "  "    33/

*+&&%*+&&% , -*- ,

 # "5  " #"   #  #

%

/6   7  8   9: -+'  $

  6  ./ !   )$/

% 6

+/  @/

?/  :  1!"  8/

%/ 3   1 "  :2 1) 3     1! H "  "! " ?& @ "(  3 1 1  "! "!  $ 3!"! " = <6ST63: -= -&&%   =   9 1/  "!  1 H 18!/  !  " D 5 ": 9  : "!   "! $    1 "  "! :!R $5 91 1 : 3    1) " "   "!R 5 1  8   "  1!/ <  !    1   !!  ! !!   5 $5  5 ,"=  $ 3!"! "   1 1   (    :2 ") "! )$/  !  "     A " 1)= :  @=  :  "! :!  2)11 " :   !! 91!"!   4/ .?+= .&-  .&B 5/

 833(D  !" D

#,  U  V   

 1 3  " 1! H  3! 9 1   <! "2  ' 2!  1  833

*+&&%*+&&%