Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/954/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/954/2005 Généré par l'IA

Property Transfer Validity: Security Interest and Procedural Compliance Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/954/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case addresses a dispute concerning the validity of a property transfer, where the appealing party argued that the transfer was invalid because the underlying transaction violated a statute concerning the creation of security interests without proper filing, or alternatively, that the transfer was invalid due to a failure to comply with statutory requirements for transferring particular types of property. The court held that the transaction did not constitute an invalid security interest under the relevant statute because the transfer was an outright sale, not a transfer intended as security, and further reasoned that the statutory requirements for transferring the property type in question were satisfied by the execution and delivery of the necessary documents, rejecting the appellant's procedural challenges.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Transfer Validity: Security Interest and Procedural Compliance Dispute: The court held that the transaction did not constitute an invalid security interest under the relevant statute because the transfer was an outright sale, not a transfer intended as security, and further reasoned that the statutory requirements for transferring the property type in question were satisfied by the execution and delivery of the necessary documents, rejecting the appellant's procedural challenges.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
transmission de la propriété opérations portant sur des titres condition légale validité du contrat gage immobilier compétence en matière de trust

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive to regulate the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/2919/2007
Property Transfer Validity Dispute
A/204/2006
Property Transfer Validity and Statutory Compliance
A/2043/2006
Property Transfer Validity Dispute
A/108/2005
Validity of Property Transfer Based on Consideration and Execution
A/1537/2001
Property Transfer Validity Affirmation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive to regulate the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

   

!"#$%!&''( )!#($!&''(

)

* )+ * ),  * ,+

- . "

 / 0 . &''(

  

  !"!

!" 

#

$$   %    $  $    !89! &$     $ '   $  & $          (  )*  +! $#,- ./ 0 1+

 $ * '       %  ' $$  * 2#  1- 3-4 56 0 7

              5:;

 1+)

6?  @-"# ! 66 + 5==;*  .1" 3"4 ! 4 ! A"1 # (,A1 )  A8  !+ ! !"  * 8   / A#"4 6<B5 #   * 8  5 #4 6<>/* "8  !# ! 5< @+ 6</.?

5? $  399 ; ! @-"# A8#8*    !8  A#- A "#8 ! + ! A8+2 A9 C A 3 ! 8AD !#  "-?   #"    4 ! 8 A C , A1!   ! "## 0 #98?

.?  @-"# ! !+ # !+ !89#9  5; " 5==>?

;?  4 ! 8  #8 ! A#  " !  ### ! A8+2* A  #A8  ### !89!   A# !  ""C  "## ! +  ! A# C !#  "-* # #  5< @+ 6</. #  5; " 5==>?

>? $   !  $$   %    $  $    &$     $ '   $  & $          (  )* ! 5B A#"4 5==>*  A## C A!#  "- A  !"! # ! 6.=E=5= 9? F=* !8!# 9# !  "" ! 6.E;/F 9? <> A8##  + C +#  "-* -"#8 ! #8G# 8 @C& ""# ! !+? $   !   $ * '       %  ' $$  ! 56 A#"4 5==>*  !  !"! # ! .6E><> 9?

B?  !"# # 8#8 #" D A#  !# ! 6< #4 5==>?  @!#   !C8 CE0 !89# !E4+# !E  ; +"4 5==>*  G# # !  ## 4?

F?  E4 !E4@# !  !8 9D8*    8#8 -!8 0 @-?

 ,+)

6? E#? 5> !   98!8   4 A- !  A8+2 A9* +* ++# # +!#8 ! 6F !8"4 6<<. (')* #8  +-  6 @+ 5===* 1-  A8!   ! !+? C  @#  # A !&!   A## ! # 0 A#- (#? 655 #

65. ! + , )*  @- !  ! !+ "A8##   ! E#? F. ?

:6<;.:5==> .:;

6 !   98!8   A8+2 A9 ! 5> @ 6</5 ()* # 0 1+  4 # !   !A  6 H# 5==.* !#* A1 C E99   8#8 #" (#? 6;5 )* D8# !E99  A#-   4 !  8 ! 8A## !8#"8 A  @- ! !+.

5? $ E#? 55 ' (+ #  +- !A  6 @+ 5===)*   ! !+*  A## ! # C !#  "- # A#-8 9"8"# D #? 655* 65.* 6;6 # 6;5 I  #? . 0 > ' EAAC# A -  "## 0 #98 (? 6)?  3C @#*  A## ! # 0 A#- A! 0  !998 #  A## ! #* -"#8 ! + ! 4 A- D## 8+#"#  ""# ! !+* #  A## ! #* -"#8 ! + ! 4 A- D## 8+#"#  ""# !   ! "- (9? #? 5; ')?   *  @#

0  A## ! # # 0 E+ ! 4 A- D##  ""# !   ! "-  #8G# !  ""# ! !+ ( ' 65/  5.=I ' 65<  ;;;)?

.?  &A1*  @- ! A"1 #  !8  A#- A "#8 ! +  C A  8AD !#  "-?  !# A## #* !& A#*  ! "-  5< @+ 6</.* !&# A#  5; " 5==>* !# 0 C  @-"# ! !+ # !+ D8#?

$  !"# A!#*  A## C A!#  "- A  !"! # ! 66B&>.5 9? /> (6.=E=5= 9? F= J 6.E;/F 9? <>) #! C  C A  !"! # ! .6E><> 9?*  #8G# 2# !8@0 8#8 8 A  ### ! A8+2 !89!?   !"! !# 0  D,8A  "## ! >/&5BB 9? ;= (66BE>.5 9? /> K 5) # ,  !#  "## ! 6>EF<F 9? >= (.6E><> 9?K 5)* ! # C &#  !"! C !# 0  !"!  "## ! ;5&;B/ 9? <=?

;? 9"8"# 0  @A!* !A  @ !8#"# A  A#- @CE ""# ! #9# !  A## ! #  !  !"*  @# !+8 4889 ! ## A##  !# 0 ! #8G# "A#   "## ! ,?  #8G# # 8  #D """ 8-  E#? 65 ! E!   A8+2 A9 +* ++# # +!#8 ! 6/ + 6</; ( 5)    #D 8-"#*  , # A8 ( '  A48  .B:=5 ! 6/ @# 5==.)?

>?  8""#   AL*  A8! 8## -## (#? F. ? 5  # /<M ? 6 !     A8! !"##+ ! 65 A#"4 6</>)?

:6<;.:5==> ;:;

  ,)+1  )+ * ),  * ,+

 234   5  6   78 "9& ,:

6? +#  $$   %    $  $    &$     $ '   $  & $          (  )* 0 #98* ! "A# !   *  "" ! ;5E;B/ 9? <= 0   $ * '       %  ' $$  *  9+ ! !"  ?

5? +#  $$   %    $  $    &$     $ '   $  & $          (  )* 0 +*  A !  "##* ! #8G# "A#   ! !8#* !1  5; " 5==> @CE ""# ! #9#?

.? &2 !"  ## C ! 4?

;? # C  A8! # -##?

>? 9"  A# !  CE A+# 9"  #  A8# G# !  !8 ! .= @ !1  #9# A A ""!8 !8  4 98!8 ! * $3NO39C B* B==;   *  # D"A?  !8  A# G# A-8?  "8" !# K ) !C D#"# C !8  # !8 4#   # A !  !8 ##C8I 4) DA A C "#9  #" A+ !"! ## # !8I ) A#  -#   !  A8##? $  "8"  ## A  # 88"# 8"88  ## ) 4) # ) ,!*  4 98!8 !   A A #  "#1    CE !+ !8 +4?  "8" !  "#   "2 ! A+* C # @#*  C  !8 ##C8 # E+AA ! C   8#8 DA8!8  # (#? 6.5* 6=B # 6=/ )?

 -991  8!# K

,  P  Q     A 9" ! A8# G# # #98 D A#  C&0 &99 98!8 !   A  -99 

:6<;.:5==>