Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/941/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/941/2005 Généré par l'IA

Contract Liability and Issue Preclusion in Successive Litigation

Numéro de cause ATAS/941/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a challenge to a judgment that determined liability for an obligation arising from a contract, where the claimant sought enforcement against the defendant, who asserted defenses based on prior legal proceedings. The court reasoned that the prior determination did not preclude the current action because the issues of fact and law necessary to the judgment in the present case were not fully litigated or resolved in the prior proceeding involving related but distinct claims; specifically, the issues central to the present claim either were not addressed or were not essential to the prior ruling, thereby defeating the defense of issue preclusion.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Liability and Issue Preclusion in Successive Litigation: The court reasoned that the prior determination did not preclude the current action because the issues of fact and law necessary to the judgment in the present case were not fully litigated or resolved in the prior proceeding involving related but distinct claims; specifically, the issues central to the present claim either were not addressed or were not essential to the prior ruling, thereby defeating the defense of issue preclusion.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
contentieux contractuel responsabilité de l'entrepreneur concours de responsabilités voie d'exécution exclusion de responsabilité violation essentielle du contrat

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF
The appeal is declared inadmissible based on this procedural rule.
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The appellant is ordered to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/1887/2004
Issue Preclusion Based on Prior Judgment Despite Varying Parties and Facts
A/1472/2005
Claim Preclusion in Contract Dispute
A/2135/2005
Appellant's Liability and Issue Preclusion on Prior Finding Validity
A/2046/2003
Issue Preclusion in Prior Litigation
A/2502/2006
Contractual Liability for Debt Enforcement

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF

The appeal is declared inadmissible based on this procedural rule.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The appellant is ordered to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

   

&'()*&'++( &,-*&'++(



! "! #  ! #

.  * % * /  '++(

  

  ! "

!" 

##     $  $ $  $% & !"  '( &"&. )* + ,-

           !"# $%

4 0/* 4

%  0 1%  %  5..6& 7 " 7&-&&".% 8!&" .9"  : ""&! !:."&  6..  " "! ;

  0 & 033*%   : .". + 766& "!  : ! <9. =&4: ,   >  -& ."5&  0? - & 033* :  !" % ! "'!!"&"% :! ! 6& @ % :!  !""  ?A033 6 B ;

  6!"   : .-& !. :  !"!  % 7  % : .&&!  0) & 033*% &6! . 7&". . C  : &  ' 9  6 & "&  :! ! 6& ."&" 6. ;

7&  &&C. C 7&". . -&"  :!&5&&".% !&"  :   !"" -  .& "&"  ! 6& :! !&6&  :  " &""% !&"  6&  @."  :  " &"" +  6 & ;

 : .&&!  *   033)% 7   D". 7!::!&"&! 6! . : 7&". .  2E D& 033* ;

  E D& 033*%  !"   !&C. + 7   !- -& 7 !""  *AE)3 6 B% !"  : &  ' 9  + !- .". 6. : .&&!  2) :"5  033* ;

 6&"  !"   ."5&  6"   0) !"!5  033*  0A)3E 6 B 1) ;

 : .&&!  23   033)% 7   6.  5! "   6"   !"  ;

 : .&&!  !::!&"&!  2F D& 033)% 7   !6& . ! 6 ;

 7&". .  &" D". !   21 D&" 033) !"  &" .&&! ;

  ! : .-&  21 :"5  033)% 7   !  D"  !  ;

  2E :"5  033)%  &5  .  C&  7   @:&"&! C" + 7&&"&! 6&9 "   " !& .&&!  0) &% 2) :"5  033* "

23   033)% ! C 7&". . :!-&"% !&" !&6&  :  " &"" : .-% !&"  6&  @." " C "    &66.   !G" ;

  22 !"!5  033)% 7   &6! .  &5  . C7+ 7& 7 !- @  "" 66& % & ."&" &:!. +    .&&! : "  ' 9

/0)12/033)

4 1/* 4

 6"   !"  ".  0) !"!5  033* :!  !""  0A)3E 6 B 1) ;

   C  !& 9-!&  7! 9&"&! D&&&  =>  .". !&6&. "  &"&".% ,  2 !G" 0331%  &5 "!    !&% !:!.  ) D9% !"  : .&" "  -&4: .&"% ) ::." " 2? D9   = "B 2 "B " )? > ;

 &" + 7"&!  7."&!  2? D9  % :  &5 6..   0F D-& 033* = # 213  23?>%    !& 9-!&  !:".%  21 6.- & %  &:!&"&! " &"!&   9" : """  &5 "!    !&  &.9    + " !& D9 "&"& % %  7"""  7."&!  !-@ D9   ;

 !6! ." + A "B )?  B 2 "B  'B 1 %  &5 "!    !& !H"  &" &C  !"""&! : .- + 7 "& )?  C& !" "&- +  !& 6..    : ""&! !:."&  + 7 4-&&%  -&-" " &-&&".  2E   2E?) = #> ;

  !:." :! D9   7:, " && ."5&B

 7  :"% ! C7& !""   5  .."  !  C  .&&! ""C. "  !.  "!" ! : "&%  !&6&  : "  DC7+ 7-!&   .:!  !  ;

7 7:,% 7   .D+ !&C. ! : .-&  &5  . ;

7&  :" , !  : !"&6& +  ! "  .&&! ;

7& !-&" , !   :   "   : !:!&"&!  5!  + 7&". .  !""   6"   !"  ;

 "" : !:!&"&! ! "&,  "&6"&! +  ! " ;

/0)12/033)

4 */* 4

  #2  "! #  ! #

% 340   5  6   78 *9' #$:

  0 

2B .   !  -5B

% 0

0B 7"B

1B   .&&! &"&9&B

*B ! " + 7   ! 99"  22 !"!5  033) + :    ' 9  6"   !"  7 !""  0A)3E 6 B 1)B

)B &" C  : !.  " 9 "&"B

?B &" C :!  C&  " &" @ : ""&! !:."&  6.. %  : "& :-" 6!  !  !"   : ."  ("   .&  13 D!  ,  !"&6&"&! : :& !.  .  &5 6..    % $'I&J '!6C& ?% ?33*   %  " !& @:& B  .!&  !&" K > &&C @"" C .&&!  ! " .&  !5"&  & " :   .&&! ""C.; 5> @:! :! C !"&6  ! " "& :!-!&  "" "  .&&!; > :! "  &9"   ! " !  ! : .""B $&  .!&   !"&" :  " !& .." .. . ! ""  > 5> " > &4%  &5 6..      :!  : "   "&,    !  C7& -  .  & -5B  .!&   !  "&!  !   !L  : -% C&  !" D!&"  .!&  7& 79&"

 :&,  :!&!  ! "B $ !" .9" D!&"  .!&   .&&! ""C. " 7-!::  C   .". @:.&.  ! "

= "B 210 23? " 23M>B

 9 66&,    .&" K

 &4!&  N ! & O   

 !:& !6!   : ."  (" " !"&6&. @ : "& && C7+ 766& 6..     !& :  9 66

/0)12/033)