Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
ATAS/933/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/933/2006 Généré par l'IA

Breach of Contract for Failure to Deliver Goods

Numéro de cause ATAS/933/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party sued a corporation seeking damages for breach of contract, alleging that the corporation failed to deliver goods as specified, which caused financial harm; the court reasoned that the language of the agreement clearly defined the scope of the required performance and the stipulated damages for non-conformance, concluding that the evidence demonstrated the corporation's failure to meet these explicit terms, thus warranting a finding of breach and an award of the contractually established remedies.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Breach of Contract for Failure to Deliver Goods: A party sued a corporation seeking damages for breach of contract, alleging that the corporation failed to deliver goods as specified, which caused financial harm; the court reasoned that the language of the agreement clearly defined the scope of the required performance and the stipulated damages for non-conformance, concluding that the evidence demonstrated the corporation's failure to meet these explicit terms, thus warranting a finding of breach and an award of the contractually established remedies.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
inexécution d'une obligation contractuelle défaut de la chose longa manu traditio versement de dommages-intérêts garantie du vendeur envoi d'une chose non commandée

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Généré par l'IA

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was cited in the final order concerning the costs of the proceedings.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

This provision was cited in the final order concerning the allocation of costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



                !""# $%%&   "'' $%%&



( )(  *  ( *)

+,-  '

 $ .,-  $%%/ 

  ! "#$ ! %&'( )*! +$,$ + "#" -, ,  ! .* /"0 " 12+ $$! "*%&!)*

,

3  .    .   ! * " "$:" 4$5,%!+,67(!%''% .  

..   ..8 !4#,,,(9! +,:4!;'<;= 2!#+,*$,""# 1$,""-,0> "$. 2  

                  >&?%@>  

 0)

%A  !$%966!",,$:B!$,$,+)"   " 4C#D " .E", ,+: " * , *F. G")%<+,#H%99;A."$>"1$,",/01%@ +,#H&'''A

&A   ,,!   $,$ ::$ I  3", ,,, ++$,*  F>+)  3",G"%<+,#H%99;%@+,#H&'''A

@A 1$$,$4+,$,$*,"$+,#,"+E4," >"$"&7/*&9/*%999!"@%%#%999+"%< &9#%999A

<A  1, ,*$  +,$ " ,* I %''J " % :$* %999  @' +,#H%999!,:,#$"K" , ! +E4,I>"$A

(A  #$" +E4,  " 1:: , " 1#+ F G!   !   ,#$! "  ++, " @' /, %999 I ",, " 1 !01+,,"+#,"1$$,,"('J")%,H%999A   +E4,  "$$ 0 1+,$ " ,* $,, ,#+ , 0 1::, $,, DL M$"*,MA . ! 1$ +*,  K  +:! ,  M,, #$" K +H,$ " +#,M!   #,$#+$#,":#,I*DA

6A %,H%999@%"$#H%999!1+,$",*"1$$,$" ('J,:,#$"K" !+E4,"$+,#," +E4,M ,,,,MA

7A  #$"/D$01I #+,"&;/*&'''!1$,,",$"1$ +#,,,+",*I%''JA

;A 1$+B"#,$*,N

>"#,$"4C#DI%''J"%<+,#H@%"$#H%99;O

>"#,$"4C#DI%''J"/*9:$*%999O

>"#,$"4C#DI('J"%,H%;:$*&'''O

>+,,,++,$+D)",*I%''J+  +$" " %' :$* %999  @' +,#H %999! + I ('J " %,H%999&7/*&'''A





?%99;?&''(  >@?%@>   9A 1$  $,$ DD$ * ::,  &% :$* &''' +  8 ! ## *",40 3 A 0,$"1#+E$!$,$::$I ..    .. 8 ! ,,, " +$*E +: F>+)  GA

%'A 1$  I * $,$ 4+,$  ,$  *,  "$+,#, " +E4,">"$"%9/%%P,&'''!+"%;&;P,&'''! +",HH+A

%%A ,,",*,I8 +:@%P,&'''!+ "#"A

%&A  !#$",,,"+&@#&''%!+$$"  ++, #$" " &6 / &''& ",$ I 1:: , " 1 *",$ F>+)  G! 0  +,, $,,  +,$ ,, " ,* "+  @% P, &'''!   "1 +E4+,4 40 * +4 "$,,H+A#,$0+,,*,$,$4+,$I0, ++01,*,"+4"$,,+40A

%@A   ++, #$" " %7 /, &''& I 1,,, " 1 !   A

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



?%99;?&''(  ><?%@>   &'''!+"%''JI+,"%9/&'''A 1E+"1K##$"K +$$A

%<A "$";,&<*&''@!1 ,E$I1$,,) "1*",$+D#"*::,%  /&''%A1 "$$ 01$$,,+,$,,",*"+%9/&'''!",I+, "0$,$$"$""1$A

%(A  ,, " &( P, &''@!  , "1,  , " ,$ " 50  ,+$ +#+,"1$,"#"$"+"+, 0,",""I"+,,"1*",$A

%6A "#"" !1 ##0$""1$", "7*#H&''@A

%7A "%%#&''<! $",K+,,"1*",$" 1$A "#"K,$#,$,1+,$",*, 1*",$! # $   " K,$ ,#+  #,: 0  +,$ " ,*"1$1$,,+#$$"+,H%999,011$,,+ # " :  * "#,A  !    "$$ * ::, ##$",,,"+$*E>HD,#,:01$1*,+ #+"$,",$":B#+),,*$"0!+01*,# "#,#"0*,:#,",I*",$A

%;A  ,, " &6 ,H &''<!   " 1$ 1,  ,$ *  3", ,   "#"$ "1K#  +H,$ " * I  , " +,,"1*",$AK$I"#""*"#,!",1 "1"+$*E"+4C#DA

%9A "#""3",!1 ,#+"""1$ %&*#H&''<A

&'A "%<:$*&''(!3",,#$01$,,",""$H," 1+,$ " ,* " 1$  > ,  %9 / &'''  1  > 0 $,, "$,#, + "$: 0 ,,, " +$*E $,, #+$,, + *   $4$, " +,,A ! I ,, $+0! 1$   $,, + ::$A

&%A  7 / &''(! 1$    H , "   "1 "#"  +#, "D$ I  : ,  3  .    .  ,, ..   ..8 A0, " H01"0",,,"+$*E+:, #+$,, +  * " +,, "1*",$! + 01 "# ,, ,,,*#,"",+,,*::,%/&'''A



?%99;?&''(  >(?%@>    )* 01I  ", I 0  "$H,$  +,$ " ,*! ,  %9 / &'''!  $,, ::$ I  ! # :, #0 0! "1 , C,$!  +,$ , #+,H I  ::, "H , *", 0  "$H,$  01 $,, ::$ I  3",A  D +", 01 :$* %999!  0 " 4, 1 $,$ $*0$! + + 0  :, 0  + " ,* +,1Q,0+D)A

&&A   #$# " $+ " @% P, &''(!   , I  0  H,,01,3",0,"*H"+,,$#$! 0  "#" , " "$H,$ "  "#" :#$ I  , , "#$ K "$+ "1,! ",  +,+, K 4 "  *,A 1++"!K+0"#"## $,  $+", K 0, $ I  ,$  "  DD#, +

8 ! " , 01  +, +$," I " +,, , >"I " * HD, $DA , K +,, " +$*E HD,!  ,,01,"+1 "+$*E!+)"0  "#" $,, ::$ 01, * 1+,$ " ,* I 1D " 1*",$!K,$,,K,$!,,#,$0,#+!, 1+,$",*,1*",$A

&@A $+"%&+,#H&''(!3",,0"#" , , "  +$*E +: HD, " 4C#  &':$*&'''!0+,$",*,+,$+01"$H,$ %9 / &''' , 01  +, "  $# " , "1*",$A  :, #00)D#,+"K+,#,"$:,"1*",$" 1*",$,01,"$+",I01  :K$"$H,"1+,$"H",*!,%9/&'''A

 #+, " +$ 0  3",! H 01E, #,$  H , 45, "  "  !  ," +$, >  H " $A  4,   ! +H " * " +,, "  3",! 1 :#$ ,$$+40#,  && / &''6A

&<A  " " &; / &''6!  H  0 " 1  1++, " ,:, #$"K   *  ,K "1+,$ ,  *#, " +,,!0$,$:,","7/,&''6A

&(A  ,, " ( /, &''6!  H  "#"$ I 1  + " " " 1$A

&6A  +, , $,$ *,$ I +"  "  +) +", + "&(P,&''6A



?%99;?&''(  >6?%@>   &7A #*"@'P,&''6! +,$"!*,0  +$" " + "1,*,$ +: *, $,$ ,  D" " +$""14+,,A

&;A   " % +,#H &''6!  "#" #,  KD  :, 0  +)+#,,,":#+,$",*"%:$*%999&7 /*&'''A)*01+,,,0I1D "1*",$,HI1D",,+,$A

&9A +),#"")$,K+,!$,$D"$I/DA

 *)

%A D*RD,/"FG$,$#":$,,,$!") %P,&''@! H,"!#+$"(/D! ",  +$", ,  *>+$",! ( ++$, , %6 /D  F,A % ,A,(6 GA

.,IR,"R$,"%6/D!+ H:$"$ &7/*&''<F 3%@'%'6G!" D*"+,$!%@:$*!  "+,,,D,+#,,, H,"  " $D   I , /D ,,! ! " R,,, " R$,"*K/DA

&A :#$#, I 1,A (6  A % ,A H !  H , "   -,  , 0 " ,,, ,* I  +$*E +:++,,,,"+$*E!#+E,E,",! E #+   " "*!  0RK +$,,  +H,$ F,A @@% I @@%"""HD,O,A(&!(6!A%!,,A7@":$"$ +$*E+:"&(/%9;&FGO,A%<&""*GA

1,A7@A%#+I40,""$D,H0-,! "),,!",,,++,,,,"+$*E! #+E , E, ",A ., $  ,,, " +$*E D,$ " ", +*$  " ", +H S  H   0   +,,##HD,0R0+,,R$,", >"IF,A<9A&GS,:","+$*E:*"+  D,$! "  "# " +,, 0 "$+,  ### HD,F,A;9HA6 O 3%&&@&@"A&GA+$"",Q, #+!+",!++!D,,O/D,,:,"1::FA&GA : ,  )D  "#  " "$:"    " 1K+,, " 01$$,$DD$F,,$!A@GA



?%99;?&''(  >7?%@>      "1+)!  "#"  $,$ DD$ + 8  )* ,  H$$:$"+,,"1>4C#D*$+. !I)*!" ,0 H"$,#+$,,,,I"#,)0"A

@A 1*, " 1, +$* I 1,A 7@ A %  1, # ## , I 1H*,"1"$!",0"#",*HA

<A ,+$$0:$"$"6,H&'''+,D$$"","   F G ,$  *D  % /* &''@ 1, + ++HK,D#,)"+$*E+:A

.1D, " ", ++H , ,#+!  E   "1++0  "+, $D , $D#,  *D  ##, T  :, /"0#, "$,#,  , +", F 3 %@'  &@' "A %A% ,  $:$GA  *4!   0   +$"! , I "$:, " )D ,, ,!  * ", 1++0  $* ")  / " ,$  *DF 3 %%7  9@ "A 6H! %%&  @6' "A <O    %99;U@7+A@%6"A@HGA

,  "+, $D#, " ,,, " +$*E! , ++H+3",)D#,*D")%/*%999 &''',+ !)D#,"%99;A

(A , ,D  0, " * 0 ,,, " +$*E , , " *"#"+,,"*",$A

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



?%99;?&''(  >;?%@>   +,,   " 1,A &6 A @  F 3 %&@  &6@ "A %! %%;  <( "A(GA

:#$#,I1,A&6A%!"+,":$"$1 *",$"%9/%9(9F,A&9 G1++0,+DI" ", K +,, "1*",$A .  ,,, " +$*E +" > K+,#,+*>"$:,"1*",$,"1 !, ++$!"*":,$!+1,#,"1*",$ " D " 1> *",$! : 0 ,, ,#, ++-, "1#H$,HF 3%&6@%%"A%:GA ,,:,D, *,  #, +  :K, " "D$ "1*",$ F 3 %%(  &';G! # $D#,+"$,#,"##,I+,"0+,$",*" 1$1,"$,$$"#)H,"HF 3%&@&7%"A& ,$:$,$GA

* 1 3 %&9  7@!  H :$"$ "   $  : ,D, " ,,, /"0#, "$,#, " ", " 1>*",$ I 1$D" " 1,,, " +$*E 0 > 1, +,,$"+$""#,,*!+,""+$" "1",,*+/,""$#*/01@%"$#H&''& F,A7@H ",*D/01I,,",G+!+)1,$ *D" %/*&''@!"+$""$"1:: "1>*",$F,A76A%,A ",*D/01 @' / &''6O :A ") ,, ",! +  +$" " +$*  ,A (7   , 7@HA&,A: ,$*D%/,&''6O&''6&''@,&''7GA

 1+)!  "$ "1, " ; , &< * &''@ "1 , ,) " 1>*",$I1$I+,"%/&''%,"%*&''@,$,$ ##0$ K "$:"! I  "#"!  7 *#H &''@ +   ,  %& *#H &''< +  3",A ,, ##, 1, + ,:,"1,A76A%,A !+#,,,K"$:"" :*","1++,A ,,*H+)+$" "$ A,,,,"+$+:K,+D" 1>*",$ " ##, "  * " 1+,$ " ,* "1 , #+,! "$+"##, " +, " *   "+, $D#,+,"$:,"1*",$"1>*",$A

7A  3", +$ 01 1   " 1$, " ,,, " 1 !  +,   "$H, " 1+,$ " ,* "$,#, +  ",K+,,A ")0##,I+,"0+,$" ,*"1$1,"$,$$"#)H,"H+"I/ &'''!01,1 A



?%99;?&''(  >9?%@>   1*! )D01+,$",*+,,""#", ,$ I  ::, +) "1! " , 0  +,, $#$ "*,Q,*+3",A

  0   "$#,, " +H,$ +,* " "K ,,, " +$*E K0  $  $,$ *#, ::$!  /+"  "$", " 1,A &@  01  ::, +! + 0 1 ,,, " +$*E , , I +,,! 0 1+,$ " ,* , "$H,$I$+0T 1$$,,::$!#01"*,,K,! , ,, +,$ " ,* , 1*",$!  , "1$,, K,$! ,#+,#,$A

 E K,$#,$1::,I1D"1*",$,#Q#0  0 1, "$/I #:,$ ", 1::, I  +$$", ,,, " +$*EF,0,-$+,$",*GA

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

;A G 1+)!01KD"K,$#,$!E " * 0 1$ :: " ,H ::,: H+ F3@%A9G "+ /* %999,",H"+,$F36'A9G"+1"A ,H, I1D"1*",$,,,-$+#)+,$",*"%''J



?%99;?&''(  >%'?%@>   "&7/*@'+,#H%999!+"('J"%,H%999&7/* &'''!0"#"$,,::$I3",A #Q#,H, +*0$+,$,,,"H",*")/&'''!01$ $,,::$I A1+,$",*%999!$,*I1$#D ",HH>+0:"1+,$I1D"1*",$!", 1::,I3",!",01E"1"#,,K,$#,$ *>A

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

! H,,01,I3","1"#" +,,$I*",$A

9A ,I"$,#",I,""#"A$,$,,$+0 3", 1, + $ + 1$*, " 1*",$ + 1>*",$! "  # T  1 + $,$ ,$D$ I  +$" * + 1 A  "$, "  3", "  $, "*, 1,,$ " $! *, 0K"$,"1>*",$!,,+  "4$ 0 ,-  : ,D, "  "$ " 1> *",$"1,A&@A,,,$,$"::$,3", *,$,H"$#+,"+,,A,,+$,!/D", $0 +$" I  ++ ++$, " :, 0, I 1*",$



?%99;?&''(  >%%?%@>   +$,$+"#"F* 3+H$"&6/,&''6!A&7?&''( "A@A%I@A@GA

++,"1,A6'A&,A!R,,,++$,*,,,, " +$*E , "1:: R>4C#D , " $  *, HD, " H$$: "R"#,$ /) $ + ,, A

.1,A<A%A%A&A%&W")D#,"3",*D%/*%999 F>+) N  )D#,G!  E  *",$ 0! + , " #"  "1",!+$,#+Q4$":B,#++#, "1K+:""$+E,,*,$$#$$A

 *, " 1,A &@  F,  % /* %999G! , ", I " +,, "R*",$+0,*"I"('J#" R ! , 0 $,, $ 0 , * R+,$ " ,* ",   , I RD " R*",$A  ,K ##  $,$ H$ I <'J * 1,$  *D " #":, +,, +   "1+)  % * &''<A 1,A <A%A%A&A@ " )D#, +$*, 0  , "1*",$ "$+" " "D$ "1*",$A  *",$ " 66 &?@J " ", I  ,,,$ " +,,!*",$$D+$I('J#"#"66&?@JI #,$"+,,,*",$"#"('J"",A

 ,"+)" "!,##,#$"!0"#" ,K"1*",$*,D$"+$""#)*,N

>"&7/*%999@'+,#H%999*#,N%''J"1*",$O

>"%,H%999&7/*&'''N('J"1*",$O

>"%9/&'''I/N%''J"1*",$A

 H*,$03",I"$,##,," "#"D""0+$)"A$4$,!>,"#+," #":,"1,A&@%*&''<A

%'A , I K#  "#" " "$+ "  ! ,##, I ,, " +,+,K4"1*,A

0:""$+"!R,A7@A&+$0 , "*, +$*  +$" #+! +" ,!  ++! D,,A R,A;92 A % "     +$" "#,,* " %& +,#H %9;( F G+$*,0,I0+$",D,,++,A ,:!  "$H,$##,+*,Q,#I4D"+,0D," #),$#$,$#D"$D),$A ::,!0 H:$"$ "  R "#!  +H,$ " #,  D,,$   " 



?%99;?&''(  >%&?%@>   ,$#$  ,/,$ I  $D) ,  ++ D$$ " +$" +$* + ,,H4"F 3%&6%(%"A<HGA

/+"+$$0R*$IR$4,Q,#$I +$,,,)"$D),$",$#$,$A:,0R, "$+*"4")::,++II:$, ,)A  :,> 0R $$#, S ,0H S R/, H/,*#, +,N+,$",*,#$+$"0"H#Q# +*,  ,  " #+,!  , " R,,, 0 R +*, H#,KD"R!0$,,"$+*"4") F,0.%99;+A%9<GA"",D+,,",," +$*E +:!  +, " *   +) , ,$#$ ", Q, ,4$  K#,  #,  #+,#, " "$H, " ,, "  +$" /"! # $D#,  #+,#, *,  +) F 3%&<&;(GA

 H:$"$"$D#,++$0RE": "::$ ,! "R +,!  , ,,$ +  # " : " +$"I4D"R+,0D,+$D),$"#),$#$ "R,A;(A&,A":$"$R>*,**, F .G F,#, ,A 6% ,A  "   :$"$   +, D$$ " [ !*D"+%/*&''@],!"R,+,!  ", K "$+  R,A ;( A & ,A :  . [,#, ,A 6% ,A D  ]!",0R++$,)"$*++$/,"R," "$+I+,D,#",F,0.&''&+A6%GA

K0H,,D"+$",,, +$,$ +  *, ! "R , #)! +  + 0:$! +*,+$," I" "$+0R"*+,+)" I$D)" #) ,$#$ F 3 %&;  @&@GA  R+)!  H " $ ") 0R,,,"""#",Q,0:$"$D)!",$#$A

!,,$,D,4D$",54"",+H1, +++",I""$+01H,,D"A #+,, #H " D, 4D$ " ,54 " ", +H ,##,   !  , >",!  >#" ,   " + F 3 %&'  @(& "A 6GA K+,#,! " "$+ +*, Q, $ 01"+,,$""::,$"!I*, "$+",$,,$F 3 ;6?'(+H$"&9P,&''6"A7A&O 3%%9<(6"A6HGA 1,+1+)A



?%99;?&''(  >%@?%@>  

  1* )0  )(  *  ( *)



234 ,, 5  6     7 8 !/$ *9

  4 ,

%A $"#"*HA

 4

&A "#  3  .    .    I *  "#"+,,$I*",$+)"+,, """$,A

@A /,,  "#"  ,, 01 , "D$ ,  ..     ..

8 A

<A ,0+$",D,,A

(A :#  +, "  0R +*, :#  ,  +$, "$""$"@'/"),:,++##"$"$  H:$"$"!.4XV4:06!6''<  !, K#+A  "$  +, Q, +D$A  #$# ",N G "0 K,#, 0 "$  "#" "$ H,   , + "  "$ ,,0$O HG K+ + 0 #,:  ,# +* "#" ,, ,"$OG+,D,"+$,,A.#$# ,, +  , $$#, $#$$  ,, G HG , G >"!  H:$"$"++,#,)0R "*"$*HA#$#"#,#E " +*! 0 , /,!  0  "$ ,,0$ , R*++ " 0$,$K+$"$"#"F,A%@&!%'6,%';GA D::)  +$",     33 U. U    $,>/,N ."   

+:#"+$,"$,,:$K+,0RIR:: :$"$"+D::



?%99;?&''(