Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/920/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/920/2005 Généré par l'IA

Statute of Frauds Compliance and Contract Enforceability

Numéro de cause ATAS/920/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The matter concerned a dispute over whether a specific communication constituted a legally binding agreement under the Statute of Frauds, with the lower court finding against enforcement. The reviewing court determined that the essential terms of the purported contract, specifically regarding price and a necessary modification to the description of the subject matter, were sufficiently detailed and objectively ascertainable from the written record, which included multiple connected documents, thus satisfying the Statute of Frauds requirement for written evidence of the agreement. Consequently, the appellate court reversed the judgment, holding that the writings evidenced a complete and enforceable agreement.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

; AC ; CHÔMAGE ; CHÔMAGE COMPLET ; CHÔMAGE PARTIEL ; GAIN ASSURÉ ; TRAVAIL À TEMPS PARTIEL ; TAUX D'OCCUPATION(TRAVAIL) ; ACTIVITÉ LUCRATIVE À TEMPS PARTIEL ; PERTE DE GAIN ; SALAIRE DÉTERMINANT | LACI.23; LACI.23al1; OACI.37

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
contrat d'enregistrement validité du contrat escroquerie objet du litige exécution usage de faux

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/1491/2003
Contract Validity and Enforceability Dispute
A/1701/2002
Contractual Dispute and Breach of Agreement Enforcement
A/3309/2005
Contract Validity and Statute of Frauds: Property Description Sufficiency
A/1295/1997
Contract Enforceability Based on Mutual Intent Over Formalities
A/1099/2003
Contract Enforceability Based on Ambiguous Written Notations

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               #$%&'#$''( #)$'#$''(

""

* "* +  *"+ +

+, - .

 &/ 0- $''( 



 !"""#$% & '!'(

!('

%%   )  % ' *'!"'+,   ("# -!(./01 +/++   .

               !" 

   5/2,5  

 1

+6    #  +743   ('8"#  +779 $ " /334 ! !-(:$+33;-!'!"#(#<% 6%!"'#("( /339(/334='6,>433656

  !#  #""! -!' #:('  !8 ('8" ? @" /339 ! !-(: -!'  !"#(# &  $ 13 ;  -!'  "'  ='6 9>443656 #(#""#-'((!"#(#-!'/0=#8'"'/3346

/6    'A"  ""(#  *BC -'?   "  *BC% D"5-'?E"F(#"'G""("!#(#!8'( =8'?+''/3346

.6 ' #""!  +3 @" /334   "  ''H(#  C" '#  G"(#'# $ ='64>3.1656   '8# AG" 8"( #(# !8 8 G-!I' A G'# C(!(-('8"$+33;(AG*'*"(((('8" $ -" (-6 %!  "'"' '("8 $ G""(#  *BC  %  J @8"'/33.J +1D"5-'?E "'"'%  +1F "#("(-!": -("'!-(-#'"!!K(LG("8"(#"=#'"'8"(#(#L'#-!' ((AG"I"(-'("":(''"'"'(-'##(6 !(=!"   G#("( -    G'#  5" I( -'M  "' !''-!(L13;='6,>43365 !"(='69>443656

96 %"($G!--!"("!G'# "G'@(#-'#""!.3@"/334  !("8("!('A'8!"$"'"'%  +16

46  /1 @"( /334  G'#  '!' !(' (( #""! -'?  '": (!'!"'8(A!(LG("8"(##("(+33; -"-"L(AGG8"(('8"#$13;A-(('?!'( -#'"!6  '"( G"' N C(' ! (-  ('8" $ +33 ; ? @8"' /3346  *'*"(  -!" $ +33 ; ( (""( ! A ! ""("! 8"( H(' # ' ! '8 !''-!( $ ! (L  ('8"$+33;6

,6 4-(:'/334 "L-!#AG""(#*BCG'# #((  13 ;    :""( -  -'( "":6 %"  8"( #(# ""# $ 03 ; D-' L- 8  =( $ *'CF   '"( 'M  ""(# # '  C" '#  ='6 ,>433656 %! C" '# 8"( ! #(##'!I!O'"'!" !"(='64>3.1 43D7L9>44365( .L,>43365F6

16  . !(!:' /334   '":  #  (  "  !-'("! -'!  !'  A G'#  #'# A  "'('" 



2/1.32/334  5.2,5   &#("(8*'*'!'AG('8""(*O<6  G8"( CC# $ 13 ;  " -'!(((  +33 ; ? A  ('8" C('"(6 P"(   8"( #(# ""# '  !"#(# 8"( #"#  -'-'!A-('!!""(6"L-"A#A8"' A  '!'( 8"( '#"#  ! '"' -!"  !"( ='6 9>44365  A !''-!"( $ 13 ;  ='6 ,>43365   '!'(  :""(  -'( "":   A"  G(!'""( - $ -''  !-( ! "' $ -" (- ! C" '#6  L"("(  "'""("! $ G!('   '!'('"5"-!8"(:##=""'G""("!$03; !'"( --''"'='6,>43365!C"'#6 G#("('"C#-'?  %   A " 8"( !="'# A "  '!'( 8"( 'M  "'  ='69>49365'"(-H('""#':GC"'#='6,>43365( AG" GC""( G  ""(6 % -'( "":   %  "  !="'# AG" ="( ("' !-( G "' !I6 %! I(? "=!'("A  " -'(("( - G:!("' $  ""("!   5$6  G8"( ! '*Q8'6!!:(((("'""("! -!8"(A !="''#""!'!--!"("!6

06 "(A!"#(#C'#$@C'6

 "

+6 !"C8!"'G!'C"("!@"""'DF#(#!"="#("("(# ? +'!N(/33.  '":(!'!" !-!#4@C  !(-'#"((8"5-'#"( 4--#((+,@C'D'(6+(6 '(4, F6

%"($G("!G#("!+,@C' -' '":=##' /1@8"'/339D P+.3+3,F ' !"C8!"!-(# +.=#8'"'   "-!"("!('"(!"''C(-'((( '":(!' !"  "#C'  ' $ ('!" @C ("("'     G(((  G#("!!8L@C'6

/6 ('@(#  (- (" 8(  @'""("! !-#((   '!' ( '8: D'(64,(6*60(,3 F

.6 F L('G'(6/.6+  ('#-(#C"'#"'#('"(     #C"("! ' G % A" ( !:( !'(  !' G ! -"' '--!'(  ('8" '(  -#'"!  '#=#'  I !-'"  !("! '#C"?'( 8'# ( !8 !('((    ' !K!(-""(#-!'"!8#"("#$GL#("!('8"6  !(( L"  C" '# D'(6 +0  F !''-! $ "  G'5"(!:"C(!"'6C"G(-'#-(#'#!'AG"G(("(



2/1.32/334  592,5   -!((""6 !"=##'#('"-#'"!'#=#'( ="L!((""6

%! G'(6 .1 6 + $ .     C" '# ( # '  :  "' !I  "L '"' !"  !("("! D'(6 ++F A" -'#?(  #"5' G""("!6 (#('"#': "'!I!O'"' !"  !("("! -'##(  #"5' G""("! "  "' ( - #8#A"'!I8"#$G6+6-#'"!'#=#'!$!'"' @!'-'##(#:(-'(C"$-''!"#'("!AA !"((G"'"-("!*BC6 @!' G'#!"(8!"'!("#!O !"!"-(#"5'--":$-#'"!!("("!6

:F"'"'%  +1-'#8!"(A""(!("('R-#'"!'#=#'    (L G!-("! 8'":SE  C" '# ( # G-'?  (L G!-("!'*'*#-'G'#-!'((A'"'"(('8"#$(L G!-("!!"#C(!("#-("L!"!"#"5' !("("!6:((('?C(G#8"('A'#A"(- "#"((G""(#*BCD F!'AG"-!''"(="'D-' A 8"(" G -'(  C"  8!!("' ! :"  "":F  ! !(  -'(C"G!8'-"#"(('!"($G D-'L-'"!G ('!-=":'#("!'(LG!-("!F !"(-#=8!'"#!'AG" L''!((#'"'(''!"($G 6

96  G-?   " (" A  "'"'  %  +1  -'( -  -''!-(C"'#,>433='6?!'A-#'"!'#=#' -(#:('(#'"'(/0=#8'"'/3346 ==( ! -#'"! +'@"/339/0=#8'"'/334!"$-'("":-"A '!'(:##="""(!'"'-!"GC"!''-!($13; "'-'##(,>433='6 !"(9>443='6

(("?'8!"''"(H('"8"?!'A"'"'%  +1 -'#8!"(L-'#( G-'( AC"'#(#$+33;"G'# '*'*-!"$+33;(!("#!"-("L!"$+33; #"5'  !("("! ( A  G(' -'(   :(  (( '?C ( !(( G#8"('AG'#J!(-'(C"G!8'-"#"(('!"($G  J!"(-#=8!'"#6' G-? ((G'#A"G8"(- '!"( $ G""(#  *BC 8( ' /334  ? !' A ! '"' "' !''-!"( L 13 ;  ! "' -'##(6  !('   '*'* ==("8(-!"$+33;(!("#$+33;'(-"L!" #"5'  !("("!  /0 =#8'"' /33.  /0 =#8'"' /334  !"( L(( -( A"O !"  /0 =#8'"' /33.  .+ " /3396  !#A   '!'(  '!"( $  ""(#  *BC =!# '  C" '#  ='6,>433656



2/1.32/334  542,5  

46  8   A" -'#?   '!' !"( H(' " (  #""!   " #-!'!8""(#*BCG'#  !"#'(6



2/1.32/334  5,2,5  

" + 1  "* +  *"+ +



203   4  5   67 /.$ 8

  3 

+6 #''!''8:6

 3

/6 G(6

.6 #""!'!--!"("!.3@"/3346

96 8!"$"*BC% -!'!8#""! !"#'(6

46 "(A-'!#'(C'("(6

,6 =!'  -'("   AG -8( =!'' '!' !('  -'#( ''H(   #"  .3 @!' ?  !("="("! -' -" '!# '#  '": =##'  '  %*T"O'*!=A" ,  ,339     ('!" L-"'6  #"  -( H(' -'!!C#6  #!"' !"(E F ""A' L((A#""!'!'(#"'!:("'"(-#""! ((A#U :F L-!' -!' A !("= " (" -!8!"' ' (( (' #""!U F -!'('  "C(' !   ! '-'#((6 %"  #!"'  !("( -  ('!" ##( ##'# ! ((' F :F ( F "5   '":=##''-!''-(''("?'''!'AG" 8'#''"''8:6#!"''!'("!'!'!I  -'8  A" '!( @!"(  "" A  #""! ((A# ( G8!--  A#(#L-#"#'!'(D'(6+./ +3,(+30F6  C'=="?'  '#"(   I% #'" 

 !-"!=!' -'#( ''H((!("="#L-'("(%'#('"(G (($ G#!!"-'C'==



2/1.32/334