Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
ATAS/914/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/914/2004 Généré par l'IA

Contract Breach and Timeliness of Performance

Numéro de cause ATAS/914/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court considered whether an agreement with a stated deadline for performance, absent explicit language making time "of the essence," was a material breach when performance occurred shortly after the deadline, and whether a subsequent tender of performance was valid. The court reasoned that absent a specific declaration that time was essential, a delay in performance is generally treated as a breach of a secondary term, allowing the non-breaching party to claim damages but not necessarily to terminate the contract, especially when the delay is minor and performance is later accepted or reasonably tendered.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

; AVS ; ASSURANCE-VIEILLESSE, SURVIVANTS ET INVALIDITÉ ; COTISATION AVS/AI/APG ; FIXATION DES COTISATIONS ; ÉTUDIANT ; BOURSE D'ÉTUDES | LAVS.10

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
point secondaire du contrat inexécution d'une obligation contractuelle exécution en nature observation du délai prestation en vue du paiement retard excusable

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Généré par l'IA

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision governing the allocation of court costs is cited in the dispositive section regarding costs.

Art. 64 LTF

The provision governing legal aid is cited in the dispositive section regarding legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               $%&'($%'') $'%($&(

!!

+ !,+ -  +! -,

(.  /0 1  %* 2 1 &( 



 3333333333 





, - 4-,  - ,-  !" #$%&'()*

++,-

              ! "#

   1&./1  

 5,

%2  "-++ " 3 4 %//0  +  5*+ " ,6+ 7+1 6)8  +9 : ;+<-  ++ 6 " 6 =+ >??????????:&@%&(;2('66-+""A*+:,%//3:!@& 0;23' 6  6-+" " A+ : "-,B %//32  ++ -+ B-   B+" " 3 @!&/ ;2 *- 6  C" + + " ## ++;+D 7+16)CE92

&2 %'6,B%//0F+--+A-"-++6)"  ,,++  "   ,+) E2  ;++ *+ DF+ -+ ,G1+ : F+*+- " )*  ","+ : $ +"-- ,, 1+;6,+"D+*+B--;++-"6+2B" -A +6D+*+6H"B+"-+" : 6B++-D+*:#)"F#B+++2--5+- I3 /./02

J2 6-*+"%&*,B%//0 +A"2E -B--;+"FB+"+6*+$+,+-:B+ "*+"$+"--,,+"-6"2

!2  &B&'''F-"-6-" "-++" +"&(4&'''D++6--""-++;+<+"-;+++*,  ++ 6 : &@'0 ;2&  6  6-+" "FB : "-,B %// 2   +*D-  ;+ DF+ F*+ 6 H  <+ ;+  D  + F-+ B- 6 "  "-++   ++-  "<+), -#5 "F-+2--5+-I &/.&'''2

2  + " &/ B &''%    "-- +   " & B&'''"-++"++"&(4&'''2

32  A5, " &! A*+ &''& +;+-  &' ;-*+ &''&  ,,++  "   6+  " + "  5+-  

3 /./0 &/.&'''K-"L2

02 3,&''&;+*+: ,,++"D  A5,  B+    ,+; "  , M + @*+ 6 +-  "<  ,+ , + +A-  " " & B &''' 5+-,- &/.&'''2 ,,++"",+  "," "  A5, " -*++ " %J *+ &''&  "-  -++6+"3 /./0L*,-!&&.&''&2



.%&/!.%//0  1J./1   (2 A5,"%/6,B&''& ,,++"- ;""++5A-+A-%'6,B%//02 *+ +"+D- D  B " -A : , -+ " 6;+  + 6;+  "   :  6B++ : F+ "  *+ " ## -D+* :  #) "F#B+++2 E F+- "  F+--F-5+6D##++"+++ "6";,+B"-A:,,B+B+6L"F;;  6A " ##   6B++2 ;+  B+" " CE -+ "+-+,:F+";+"*K52

/2   H  &J "-,B &''& 6  +B ;-"- "  F+--  "-6-   " "+ ",+++;   A5,  6++6,:+:D++6 6 F- %//3 + ;+<-  , ,++,2  F -;-- < +) -B+6 +B;-"-6"-,+"F-"++5-D  B 6+*+ 6 F-"+ "*+ $  6;+, + 6  ;,+ +) 6 D + K *+ -5, + " + ,6 " 6-+;++- " #D  "F6)2   B "  -"+ "F +* "F#B+++-+A"F*+6+B++-"F+)+*++ -+,$,F+D+2",+DF+*+#++66:*+ "+ ,+ F;;+   "-B#- D F+5, +*++2  ;+*+DF+F+"F+A,+6$,,-6;" "+,+6B++6-6-:,2

E +  "++*  D F66K+  "-++ "  + -+ + :  + "  , M  ;;+  "+;;-  F66+NB+"ONBOD+F*+6+"F$P+F5++B+ 6L "F<,+  + - " #D  ++ D  ;++  +B;-"-2+6+6##++;+DF-+ 6,+:++:+"++D+-+,6+"2

;+;+DB+""CE++*,-*-6+"-  6 ,, B--;++ "F  "F-"+ -+ <6+B 6  ;+ DF+ F5++ "F "++ "-,+ 6 + " "+"  ,,<";,+;;++,,+*F<+"F 6;+ +B-2 ++  , " B+" *- F,6$#+ , "F":F+--"F-"+6-A"##:,2

%'2  + " %( , &''J  +B ;-"- "   ","- :  ,,++  "  "  "-,+   ;+ D  B, " A5,6+++6DF*+--,6-"+<,,B6 ""-++2



.%&/!.%//0  1!./1   %%2 & ,&''J ,,++"+;,- +B;-"- "DF*++-5-:+D,,BPF"+++, *D-FK66++6:-F-+<-*+--,6-2

%&2 $" A*+&''! +B;-"-"",+ *K-   : F+-  ;+ DF  : * "  ,6++ ;, :  +2   , M  6 D+ F*+ 6 6++6-:-""-++;+5+",$,"B,"A5, -+-6-*+;+6+"F+-K"A5,2

%J2 *+- :  "-,+ 6  +B  "  + * +-"")%4&''J +6+-"-+6 + "  B &''!  *K- 6  6 :  "-++ "  ,,++""%/6,B&''&2

%!2 "-,++--,++--5"-: A56 +B"-2





 !-,

%2 +5*+F5++A"+++79--,"+;+-++-") %4&''J +B"+,6-" A5 "6-+"*+16-+" 66-%3A572%2  3 92

E+:F+"F-+"%3A56 +B;-"- &0A*+&''!7 C%J'%'39" +5*+"6-%J;-*+  "+6++++56, +B" + " +-5   : + A5 ++  " F " F-+"*<A572%3&92

E    " "+ 6B+  +B ;-"-  "  $ " %A+&''!;+,-D"+6+++++++6 +  -+ ;, " G  "+ ;-"- 7 C %J'  &&392 F "  ,6++ 6-* : F2 %3&  D  +B " -   F6)2





.%&/!.%//0  1 ./1   &2 ;,-, : F2 J 2 J " "+6++ ++   +"+ *F-*+5"+6""* ,,++"   -- ,+ "F;;+  +B  "  + ++D+,+)"@1*++ *+* 7;2 2 3  92  +B " -  ++ ,6-   ,+)2

J2 +;-"-6+5--""+"+"3B &''' 7+16)8  9  -  *+5  % A*+ &''J G " ,B,"+;++"",+"+2"F6) ",;+-5+6"+6++*+5ADFJ%"-,B&''& -5"6++6DA5"+F6:6" +"-+,"+;++""+"F-";+6-+:" "-,+ "  "-++ ++5+ 7 C %&0  !30 +"2% %&%  J(3 +"2%BP;2-5,"+6++++2(&2% 926- ++5-D<,+-:,+)""+6++"+;-"-  F1*++*+*"&'"-,B%/!37+16)8  E9 " )5, F1*++  *+* " J% B %/!0 7+16)8  E9*+5ADFJ%"-,B&''&2

!2 -6-";,"-++,6-6+6-*B *"F2(! E2

2  + K ;- " +"-   ,, -"+  -  ++6B"B+"6H"6"CE6+ ,,  *  ;, " 2 E 6 "  D+ " *+ +  "+$,,-"+"A+6"" +B;-"-"2

32 EF2%'2% E-F<H+*+-+*6+  ++ *+B   "++ +2  -"+  +*+- +*-+-,K";"6B+6" + 6+  ++ ,++,, 72 %' 2 &  E92  ++ " 6  +*+- +* 6 D  ++ ,++,, F 6 6-*"-,+-B";"*DF+" 72&(2% E92

E  A+6" " C   +"-- ,, -"+   " F2%' 2 &  E  -)* " -B+, "F+5, ,K  6-+ D+   -5+), +, :  ;,+2  ;,+ "+ *+  B 6;+2 C+5 6,+  -B+, "F+5, 6 <,6  5K, 7K-9  - , "F++  - "F+5-+   - " ,,2  < +*+- 7# -9     D+   ,B "



.%&/!.%//0  13./1   -B+, "F+5, 6-+2 E   -6- -"+ < D+ ;-D  - 6-++-  "  : ) +    6, "  -"6 "  -+ 6 <  6;+ "F++  " 62 E  A+6"  ;,+ "+ *+  B 6;+2  -D  6* $ +"-- ,, -"+  6 D+ 6 " -"  6  6-6 : F<+ "F +*+- 6;+ ,+ 6 "F ,+; ,, 6 +-$ ++;+D"B"F5+A"++,<+*+6 "-B:#5"++6-*-7 %/(/62 J&PE%//!62( 92

 +""F-"+"F2%'2&  E"-6" 6"D+"*++6D+-"++- ,K";"6B+6"+,++D,""*++ 66D+-"F-"+2

 F$ 6B+- + E %//! 62 (   C   -,-  A+6"   ,+)26,+$"&';-*+%/(!7Q% /.(&9++"+D-DF+K *+ + "F66-+  ++ ) " #D 2  K *+ -" +*++"F2%'2& E")DF-+*+;++) ";,+DF-"++,,+-"+*+-2B"-" : *+  6+ "  ;,+ : " ;+ + 6;+, "*+ -5, $ 6+  ,62  ",+ "F-" #++ *+ -5,  +,6",M+",+7++5++D,6- +"15,+D9 *+ ,,  6+B++- 6;+ F+5,"-,+D2 ;++;+<,++-A:F-5*++ B"6;+,-++"F6A"##+ #"<"6;+,6;+2

   $ " ,$, A 7Q &J!.(&9  C   ;+,-  6+D ",+++* D+ ++ : G  D+- "F-"+ < 6 +*;++)";,+++++-*+B6;+2  -"+*++6*+1":"+"D-"+ "F#)""6*+*+B6;+2;+DF6 6)""-A:;,++*++DF+<-+*+-+* "6+-ADF:6+"-"++6,+; 6+"-+D+-"F-"+2

 F C %%   3  7  %/(/ 62 J&9 +  -- A5- D + D+ +*+ " -" 6 6"   <H  6;+ : + 6++6  6*+ $ -6- +* 6+++,  ;,+2  -"  D+ F+,6+ 6 " -"+ 66-+B " ,6 " *+  6*+ $ #*-   + "F<  6;+ : + 6++62 +  F66+;+:D"F-"++:"-+* " 66",+A+;++D",M



.%&/!.%//0  10./1   6*++,+F+5,"-66"F5"*+ ++ "+6- :  ;,+ D+ 6) "F-B+, <D  + "F-"+ F66+D+ 5--,  "  -5+ F-+ +6+- +++,2

;+"$6B+-"%,%//'7Q&!'.((9 C  D+-"F-"+:-"-A "+"-+- " ;-D -5+),   " FB+5+ " 6  <, * ) " B 6;+ *+- 6  ;,+ #++  " ,6 - : 1+2

 + "   $  C   ;;+,- DF * " ;;+ "+*"B"CE+;+<,+"#D6+++ +B+ -+ ;;- 6++6,  6;+, 6;+ ,6 + -*+",,  ;, R +"+ R "F5, :  ## ++;+D  E+  +  +  +B+ *+ 6 BA+; 6,+  ## + D  B+   :  6A " ##   66 *  6;+, 6;+ 7E %//! 62( 9

02  F6) C *K- :F+-"6DF "  ,6++ ;, :  +2   5, +*D- 6  """""+",+++;B+6,6D 6,+)-+++ +B"-:6#:* D+ "  + "   "F-"+  * "  A+6" +- +1" D+ B+5 : <,+ #D  6++   ,6 " +2

+"%&6,B%// CE+;,-F-DF+*+* -"+"//@/%'21;27"!@/%'21;2";+""-6,9+*, 6A N,, +++2  6B++- D++  "+ ,+   -6+"++*+6-"%3%(+)O2-"+-+*%& ,+ : ,6 " % B %// P +  6  + -- 65- " + ,+ DF-"4,6,:C-""+"F+*+- " )*2  B " -A : , 6 D  -"+ *+ -- B -+ 6++6,  -"+ "F *5   A 6-+-  B--;++ "F ",+B+B+#)D""+,+26-+"* 6  B+"   F 6 <- "F+*+- 6;+ F "+ DF++F+",6:##2

 ,, " F C  " &' ;-*+ %/(!  ",+ "F-" #++ +  6B++-D++"+,+F;;D6""-B#-"# "F+)+*++2+6,$,,+;+-*+"D F-  *++ 6  B ,,+ 6  6B++ "  *52



.%&/!.%//0  1(./1   B;+DF+*+"-A:,+--"DF+*+"-A:<- +*+- +* 6*  B " -"+ * 6  CE *++ :  6;+,6;+2*DF+;;+*,--,,-6  +  6 " 6; "++ :  ;- " "+ " F+*+- " )*2  66+* 6;+ 6++) 6  6 B--;++"-A:"F"A+;++6+,-"+"F*5" B"F+"6"6;2

 ;+ D   F+ 6 6 B--;++ "  ;, "F-"+ " F- M +  ;-D- F-B+, ,+ F< 6 DF+ 6+ $  ,,    6 " ++ <  + "  , M +  *+,BB D F-B+, ;-D-  6-*K+ 6 " 6++6D+2*+;;-:, ;++-+-*F"""K";-""+,+2

*"D+6-)",6"B6;+*+-6##" ,6-:1+";+DF<H++*+- 6;+  "  ##  " ;+ D  +B+ " CE -+ ;;- 6++6,  6;+, 6;+   "*+*+G"F-"+2

(2  "+ "+ " $ *K- :  + 6 DF "  * "-++ "   " +"- F1:1"+ +    "F-"+;+<++6-D2



.%&/!.%//0  1/./1  

!  -,5  !,+ -  +! -,

 /6   7  8   9# %:& -

  6 

%2 -*BP

 6

&2 F",P

J2 "-++"++" +5*+",6+ "34%//0P

!2 *+:F++,-6*"-++""+"-P

2 +D6-"5+P

32 ;,  6+ "  DF 6* ;,    6- $ "  "-+ " J' A ")  +;++ 6 6+ ,,"- "-  +B ;-"- "  E#S+T#;D+ 3 3''!     + <,6+2  "-+  6 $ 65-2  ,-,+ "+8 9 +"+D <,D"-++"-+B++6""-++ D-P B9 <6 6 D ,+; + +, 6*+ ","   "-++P 9 6  +5   "  6-2 E+  ,-,+  + 6  + --, -,--   9 B9  9 +1"  +B;-"-"66,+)DF+ "*"-+*B2,-,+",+,K " 6* D+  A+ ++ D  "-++ D-  F*66 " D--<6-"+-72%J&%'3%'(92  5;;+8  -+"8   >+"  =  +        -+1A+8 =+Q == 

6+;,"6-$+;+-<6+++DF:F;;+;-"- "+65;;



.%&/!.%//0