Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/912/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/912/2005 Généré par l'IA

Appellate Review of Procedural Rulings, Contract Interpretation, and Evidentiary Rulings

Numéro de cause ATAS/912/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellate court reviewed several unrelated issues stemming from various lower court proceedings, including challenges to procedural rulings, the scope of discovery, the application of specific legal standards in different factual contexts such as the interpretation of contract terms, and the admissibility of evidence, ultimately affirming the judgments in some instances while reversing or remanding in others based on the application of established precedent regarding matters like the sufficiency of evidence, the scope of judicial discretion, and statutory interpretation across the varied claims.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

; AM ; ASSURANCE DES SOINS MÉDICAUX ET PHARMACEUTIQUES ; ASSURANCE DE BASE ; MÉDICAMENT ; TRAITEMENT À L'ÉTRANGER ; REMBOURSEMENT DE FRAIS(ASSURANCE) | LAMal.34; LAMal.34al2

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
demande d'interprétation contrôle juridictionnel pouvoir d'examen suffisance des preuves contentieux contractuel décision préjudicielle attaquable

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1340/2005
Appeals Regarding Statutory Interpretation and Evidentiary Rulings
A/56/2005
Appellate Review of Evidentiary Rulings and Jury Instructions
A/1737/2005
Appeals Regarding Enforcement and Interpretation of Prior Rulings and Agreements
A/2315/2007
Appeals Regarding Statutory Interpretation and Application in Property, Contract, and Procedural Matters
A/1932/2005
Statutory Interpretation and Application in Appellate Review

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

   

"#$%"&''( "$)&"&''(



* +!* ,  * ,+

- . )

 )) /. &''(

  

  ! "

"

#$ $$ %   %   $ $  &! "01 '"  () * +  ,- . "/

           !   % 528 %

 0+

,9   " 1 :( +  %0+ +" #$! " & ;%:(  %0+<! +:  , =* 566- : > ?)" + 9

  +1:1  55 *0? 566@!  +0+ :( +  %0+ *"

. ?"  0?0" + A B" 1"?   :  C0 : . $"%  * " ? . )%%$(*  &9

59  +1 + - +10? 566@!  %0+    "1! B"

+  0?9

-9 >"11  B01 ::" . +" +1  5- +10? 566@! 1)"

D E =>C("  01+0"  & +: :D +/  "   :11+" 0>" "= 0?1  ""9   * :  D  * )F :D> " 0 0C1 + @66 B9 : 1 G9

@9  +1  ::" + H B1* 5667!  %0+  /:D1 D   + ?"1/ )1 "  $ "  :' + > :1!  0?0" + :"" BB"1 +  "" 00? >::1  B" + " "( I  1"1 01+!  +1 + 1= "  "': + :"" " " / D  ?" + 1= " >" + :""9

79 >"11  "="1   ,H B1* :( + ? + 19

49   :1* + 5, 0 5667!  %0+!  1B1" /:10" .

   6@2- :?1 : >BB B1+1 +  "1 :?D  5@ 0 566@ "  +:"" "CD + >+   ? " + : " + >+  +  +0 + > 0+ * BB"

  , =* 566@! ::  =" + 9

H9 *"1 .  +1"0! >"11 +( D E    6@2- >  .

B +  010 + #$   01+0" C"1  & "

+1?"1  '  +A 9 ""  >1"" : +"1 / 1 0 /  +>9 %  1"1 +1:1 D0" : "0:  ?9  +0+ D  B0 " "1 + 0109 >/" + B0 ,,, " ,,5 >/" +  + +" +> D => J + #$  D  +1:1 +  010 + #$9  B0  :" : + 01+0" C"1 . >1")9  0D + "1 +  +" +>! => 1"1 +"   K = > : " 0  :( + #$  = > : :  BC + ,L766 B9 +

2-3425667 % -28 %

00" D  01+0" C"1  $ +1:"  ) 11  :"" :  + ,L766 B9   0+ :11+" 0>" "= 0?1  01+0" C"1  & G9

89   +:D + 55 = 5667!  %0+ :" +  9

39    1"1 "0 : B0" . >"11 "    1"1 )+1 .

=)9

 ,+

,9   )*  >)" =+ ;<  1"1 0+B1 "  ""1!

+(  , M" 566-!  ? " +  ! 0:1 + 7 =)! +"  :1+" "  *%:1+"! 7 ::1" " ,4 =)  ;"9 , "9  " 74 <9

$" . >" + >1" + ,4 =) ! :  ? B1+1  5H =* 566@ ; & ,-6  ,64<!  +  )*  +:"1!  ,- B1*!  +:" "" )" :0"""  ? " +   + 1)   . " =) ""! ! + >""" + >1" + */ =) 9

59 B010" . L"9 74  9 , "9  C9 @ !  ? " +   N"  " D + """ :1* . >"

74  D " "* .   B1+1  >%0+ + ,8 0 ,33@ ; <9

$ 0:1" : =) +  +>:( "  1"?9

-9  "! "="1 +  B0 " +1 1)/!   " *? B010" . >"9 ,   " -4 +   +>::" +   B1+1  >%0+ + 53 0 ,33H  D>/ "9 74! 73 " 46  9

@9  ") :"   D" + *   %0+ "   " + 0?  01+0" :" :  01+  0 C"1  & *9

79   0 O >1"" + B" D +" F" ::11 =+D0" >"

"(0" 11 :(  , = 5665! +" + >"1  *) + >+ + 5, = ,333 "  B1+1"  +> :" "  00"1 :1 "  "" 00? +>" :"   ? " + : ;  <!  ") +" F" /01  >) + >::" + ""

2-3425667 % @28 %

1)" " + 0+B" +    " + >  D>  "N1 ; & ,5H  @4H<9   * + 0F0 +   B1+1   :" )11 +   P  + 4 "? 5666 "1  *)  , =* 566-9

  + >BB B1+1 +  "1 :?D % &$ :"   0+B" '" : ?=" >"+" +  " :1 +> 0+! >)0" + +"   + 1= C + > "" 0:1"" "  0:B" + B0 9

:" + , = 566@! ""  : 1 " +"!   + 0+  + 0""1 +"  1=   "" +> " "" +  2   +  $!  :1"" +  " :1 +> 0+! + "B" :* + 0:0"  + B0 ,,,! . ""  :""  " D >*(" 1 + :" + * 01+! 0:" " +  " + :"" " +  +1 :1* + 1=9   B" : + +"" "  001+"0" 1 "  19

 >1"+ + +" / :""   + 1= "0: . >1")!

 B" D >'" +" " ""! ?11B + "! : +1"C1!

CQ0  1"+" > : +>+9  D  M" + :"" B . >1") " 0?1! " +" +*" +10 F" 0: I  1"1 01+ ;,<! 0:" " +  +1 + 1= ;5< " +  " + :"" ;-<9   + 1= "0: +  " "" +  00"1 :1 2 + >    $!  : 1  +" .

""  :"" D " 1 : D> : :*  1= "  +* : " CA  D0" :  B )9  " .  : ' * + *" D  : 1  + +  " "" +  2 + >    $ : * +  01+/9 D> >' + /*0" . "" B!  M" +    " :  C) : >""" +> 0+ 0:1"" D  %   +1  +  +1*"  B0 ,,59

49  >:(!  %0+ >" B+1   +"* : B + 0?  B" + 01+0" C"1  &9  +1 :+"

+  :1* . >""" + ? + 1! D E = + .  *1"1 + + D >::"   " + +"* + >&$  0"( + :  C) + :"" "'1 +  :' +   + >  >" : + : 1*+" G9

 " * D   + =" :1  "00" +  F"  58 * ,338 + >BB %,56237! ; + =:+ ,338  P 6,8-,<! / "0 +D   +0 D > "" 00? + D >1 1+" +*"

:+  C) + :+" 01+/ C"1 + > "" 00? *9 

2-3425667 % 728 %

 B!  >" /:10" B+1   "9 -6 " -4 + "1 9 !  +:"! "* .  ? " + 0C+! >" : 1"1 "B1 :  $9  1D!  +:" +    "

::?9

H9 < / "0 + L"9 -@ 9 5  !   B1+1 :" +1+ +  :  C)! : L ?)" + ! + M" + :"" :1* / "9 57 9 5  53   B . L1") : +  01+9  :" +1)   O L ?)" +  :+  C)  M" +LC0" . L1") : +  " D 01+9  :" 0"  :  C) + M" + :"" B . L1")9 L"9 -@ 9 5   :+ . L"9 58 9 5 + :=" +   +  B1+1 ;&& ,335  575<! +:"1 :   + ""  ,H +10? ,335 ; ,335 :9 ,-67< " :   "  7 "? ,33- ;  ,33- :9 ,8@H< O  L +1  .  0D +  :" + :0"9

$  ? + L"9 -@ 9 5  ! L""1 /1"*  1+"1  "9 -4 " -H + >+  L%0+ + 5H = ,337 ; < "B . L1"+ +  :  C)9 $  :0( +  +:"! ""1 E"" . L1")G! L ?)" +  :+  C)  M" + ""0" BB"1 . L1") +   +L) +"  +10"   "  :"1 ;9 5<9  +1"0 :  +  O  B +LC0"

. L1") " ?)"0" :  C) : + 0"B " D 01+/ ;9 -<9 B "" +:" B/ L1"+ +  :  C) + :"" . L1") ;9 @<9 $ L9 , + L"9 -4  !  +1:"0"

;1:"0" B1+1 + L"1< +1)! :( * "1  00 0:1""!  :"" :1* / "9 57! 9 5! " 53 +   +"  M" 1 . L1") " :  C) : L ?)" +  DL  :*" F" B  $9  +1:"0" L :+" : B" ) =DL.  = + "" +11)"  0"B D  00 B1+1 + :"" )11  +11 D> " + :"" :1"1 >1""

: 1?9

  B1+1  %+11)1  :* 1)0"  0"( +L1"+ + :""  +1:"0" D! :   :1"1! L : 1"? + "9  L +0 : 0 D  *"1 0B"1 :   B1+1 1"" + B ) +  B"1 :1* . L"9 -@ 9 5   +(  D  0"   +11)1  +1:"0"   +L1"?  " + :"" D  :*" F" B  $! 0 DL L" 1)0" :1 + B/  + +  :  C) +  M" ;B9 "9 -4 9 @   K & ,58  H7<9

?<   "!   " +0"" D! +L 0( )11 "

?!  1 D L" 0! . L1")! . + ""0" 01+/ D  :*" F" +0"1  $!  : :  ?"  :  C) /

2-3425667 % 428 %

+" + L"9 -4 9 @     0"B D  " +  ""0" L : 1"1 1"? " DL L" :  * + LF"9   ="B" +L""

0 D L& $ :( * : " + B" DL " " L" 0:0"

: 1? : +L1*+" ! 00+! + "  " .

" +"!  :  C) +  M"9  L" : : ""

1 + 0?    1"?"!   : !  " + :"" +(  D  () 1) " BB00" :1 : F" ::D1 ;B9 & ,,- ? 45 +9 -<9  '    :" + L +L :" D  :"" %   + "9 57 9 5 " 53   % 1:+"  "( +L+1D"  : 10" : F" B  $ " +L" :"!

D  "( +LBB"1 " +L10"1 " 1)0" :  0:" ; & ,58  H7<9

89  >:(!  " >" +  & +  ?" +>C" + 01+0"!  D /" :110"  "( +>)9  >" :  : 1)1 D  01+0" :"  :*" F" B  $9 & +(  " + "" D  %0+ > : . :+  C)  M" +  01+0"9

39  " >1" :+" +  D>  " : " 0:" + B" D> " ?0" 0 0C1  &9  >'  :+" : + +" .  ?""" +  ::"    D >%0+ +*"   0:"  :""  ?)"0" .  C) + :     "

: +> :"" 1) ; & ,54  --5<9

  B" D  01+0" D  & "  >:( 0 C!

 " F" :""9

,69  " *D B  B" D  :11+" %0+ :( +D  *" 1"1 BB1  " "= 0?1  B :C0"D 01  &! " D > *"  D "  " :   * >"01!  >" :  + "" +> * % "

>" : :"1 :  BC + ,L766 B9

 :: +  ? B 1)"  ::" " >+0"" " +0"19 >"  D> )0"   +1 1 :*" ?) >+0"" . " .  +0"1  *") " .  !   +" *" " 1 I

,9 D >""1 " "* +  "" (" . >1)+ + : +1"01 K

59 D> " )"  " 1 * ) +  0" +  0:1" K

2-3425667 % H28 %

-9 D >+0"1 >" :  + 0:" 001+"0" + >/""+ + )0" ?" I

@9 D>  " B+1  % : :+ + +:" D>  "

0+B  ?  :1=+  D> " 0!   ? +> )0"  +> +1 1 + >+0""!  " D> >" :  0 +>0:  ? + :1=+ K

79 D   >" : C)1 +:  00" O  )0"  1"1 +19 ; &  :?1 9 9 + ,3 0 ,38@ K &  :?1 99 +

54 = ,38@ K &  :?1 99 + -6 "? ,33H<9

$ BB"*0"  " 0? + +" %1011 " 0:! B " + "" D >"01 > : %0F0 :  C)  M" + 01+0" C"1 :11+00"9   " +(  . :1" >?) . "*  B* + >1!  "0" .  9

2-3425667 % 828 %

  ,+0  +!* ,  * ,+



1/2   3  4   56 )%& ,7

  2 

,9 1   *?9

 2

59  =""9

-9 " D  :1+ " )""9

@9 B0  :" +  D> :*" B0  "  :1" F"

+  +1 + -6 = +(  "B" : : 00+1 +1  ? B1+1 + ! $CRACBD 4! 466@   !  " /0:9  +1  :" F" :)19  010 +" I < +D /"0" D +1  " +1 ?"   " : +  +1 ""D1K ?< /: : D 0"B  "0 :* +0+ "" " +1K < :"  )"   +  :1""9 $  010  "" :  " 110" 1011  "" < ?< " < %+!  ? B1+1 +   : : "  0"(    D> +* +1 *?9  010 +  0"   0' + :*! D " ="!  D  +1 ""D1 " >*:: + D   1"1 /:1+1  " ;"9 ,-5! ,64 " ,68 <9

 )BB(  1+" I

%  S  T   

 : B0 + :1" F" " "B1 / :"  D>. >BB B1+1 +  "1 :?D :  )BB 

2-3425667