ATAS/908/2005 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATAS/908/2005 · Jury Instruction on Intent Affirmed (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellant claimed that the trial court erred in instructing the jury regarding the element of intent for a specific charge, arguing that the given instruction lowered the required burden of proof below the statutory minimum. The appellate court reasoned that while the instruction was imperfectly worded, the overall context and other instructions provided the jury with a proper understanding of the requisite intent, particularly because the required mental state was correctly articulated elsewhere and the instruction, when read as a whole with others, did not mislead the jury to apply an incorrect legal standard, thus affirming the conviction.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Jury Instruction on Intent Affirmed: The appellate court reasoned that while the instruction was imperfectly worded, the overall context and other instructions provided the jury with a proper understanding of the requisite intent, particularly because the required mental state was correctly articulated elsewhere and the instruction, when read as a whole with others, did not mislead the jury to apply an incorrect legal standard, thus affirming the conviction.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

degré de la preuve intention délictueuse interprétation de l'arrêt ordonnance de renvoi exécution des peines verdict de culpabilité

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs were imposed based on this article.

Généré par l'IA

A/352/2005

Liability Case Evidence and Jury Instruction Challenge Affirmed

A/1809/2002

Statutory Interpretation, Sufficiency of Evidence, and Jury Instruction Review

A/1379/2001

Failure to Instruct on Affirmative Defense Warrants Reversal

A/389/2005

Denial of Supplemental Jury Instruction on Damages Upheld Due to Insufficient Evidentiary Support

A/2902/2006

Fraud Conviction Affirmed on Intent

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs were imposed based on this article.

Texte complet

"#$%&"'$$& (")$*"'$$&

!!(

(!+ +(+ !+

, - .) /0/ '$$&

" "$

!"#

$"

%% & %% #'(( !$!. " )#)*+, - %

! !

&,-1& + 1(

)( "2.!! )1 $ 3",)#%"4!5"&!6" .. 7 588!!$! 5 88! !" # . ,, 9! ):;1# $ .6 # # . ); 43" ):;<# 6"= !& ! %% #76"$!")" $ 3",)(

,( .6 2 5.$$ 6 >!$$. " $!$! 6 " 6."! 5 $ 3",)7",,# %% ?!7" $"6"4 !

6 "!$(

/( , @$,,# %% 4. 66 !$! 8 "..6 2( "!" $ !$"9$. " " 6"= "!3 !!$"$!8# " 6.$$# .?$ >"A.! 5.$!$643#= ">5!54!$6!?.$>5! 54!$9!"B !$! ?.."#!$$"3!4(

;( " 9?$ 0 94!" ,;# "!3 !!$"$!8 "9$. " " .6 2# 8!".6"""C$ "!38..""D E F +9!$,;(

+( .6 2 5>!$$$ $ 9 " 6 " $!$! # %% ??.6 "!$7" $"6 "6"!!6G.54"! ,,7.3",,$94!",;76$3",;(

0( )< 8.4"!" ,+# %% 6" . !4. 66 !$! 2 $6G" (*;,1;),+$*;,1;),;$"9$. 66 !$! .6 26".!! )"4"!,+(

1( " " !$"9$. 6" .6 2 ,+ 4"! ,+ 6"= "!3 . $.$.9 !$ ." -),:<-,+$8 $5 39$5""C$.6". C9 "(

<( ,+ 94!" ,+# %% .6 . 4 ".>!!$! 6 "!$ 7 5 $".6 26 "6"!!6G.)" $ 3"/).3",;# ".$ 7 A 52 6!$ )H*;1 8"(# 6 !$."C$ 7 + I = )" $ 3",;$/*8"(8"!!!$"$!8(

:( 588! 6 "!$ $!8!. )< " ,+ $ 6G"

6 "!$ ( *+ ))+1*) 7 5 $" !" $ $ 6G" 6 "!$ ( *+ +))0;1; 7 5 $" # ".$ 7 A 52 6!$ )H*;1 8"(# 4 !$."C$# 6/*8"(8"! !!$"$!8$ 8"! 6 "!$#2>.6 2 $

8 ". 66 !$! (

-/*0+-,+ &/-1& )*( ,, 4"! ,+# %% 6" . !4. 66 !$! 2 $ 6G" $# 6" 2 .!! " 66 !$! / @$ ,+# "9$. 66 !$! 8 ".6".6 2(

))( 6". . $!$"9$." "/* @$,+6"= "!3.# "?!$". ." -/*0+-,+ D !" F $ -/*00-,+ D F( !!$$ 5$! 6 ! 5"# 2 $!8 >5 $ 6 43# = " >5! 5 $ 6 A.".# ! !?. $ > ># >5! $$$ $ 9 " 8 "!" 5!! $$$$(

),( ".6 / $ 3" ,+# %% "66 > 5""C$ E ; 9!$ ,; 8!". 588!!$! 5 88! " "$ $ " > 6"! 5"&! .$!$ ( $ "9$ " " $ 7 $!$! 6 "!$(

)/( " " )* $ 3",+# "!3.9 !$$?". 79?"(

+ !(

)( !?4 !"5 "?!$! 9!!!"DF.$. !8!.$!$!$.#= )" @$,/# "!3$ " !# 6 .+9?# $6".!$$4!&6".!$#+66.$$)09?"D"$()$( "$+0 F(

%!$75$! 5.$! )09?"#6" "!38.." ,194!",;D E)/*)*0F#" !?4 ! 6$.#)/8.4"!"# !6 !$! $"!$ !""?$6"$$$ "!3$ " ! !.?" " 7 $" ! 9? $!$!"# # 5$$$ 5.$! 429?"(

,( 8 ".$ 7 H"$( +0 ( ) $( A( ; # "!3 $ " ! J$!$!> $$$! 6".475"$(+0 !8..""6"$!?.."" !$" !< $ 3" ,D F>! $"$!47 !8..""5"&!)<" )::;D F(

% 6.$6 "9?"56=$!!.$3!(

/( !8..""6"$!?.."" !$" !0 $ 3" ,D F$$".4!?")"94!",/#$"J$ !8!$!

-/*0+-,+ &;-1& 3"!6 !$! .? !" !(%" 6$."!#6 !$4 !">" !$H66!> !$C$"$"A.7!=" 6"!!6 >"=?66!3 $4!?" $ K 8!$9"!!>$.$"!$ $6" !$D E)/*,/* !()()L //+ !()(,L E),:; !()(,L E),1;01 !()#),0)/0 !(;3$".8."F("=?6" .">$7H66!>$ "."4=9 " $".4!?"D E))1:/ !(03#)),/0* !(;L )::<M/16(/)0 !(/3F( 566!> 56=(

;( $"9$.8 "$.!6""!$6" !#" "$"43D"$(+0 $0* F(

+( " "$ $$$4 !"6G" $!$! 75"& 3!?$ !" !# $!8>5! $688!!.6"=5!$!.#= ">5!5 $ 9!"B !$! ?.."!!?. $"$5A.! (

"!3"=4>" "$8 $"!4 !" 46"!$$ ""85>!$$" $!$! $> E .97 8!".6" ""C$+9!$,;"88!!$! 5 88!6"=5!$!.=)" $ 3" ,)$5 3!?$! 6G"6"!>!. (

0( 5 3!?$! 6G" 6"! . 5"$( 0) L $!$ $"6"$! 5 3!?$! 5"" 5" 6"! A"? .4.$ ".( $ .> 9"!!> !6."$!4 $ $ 88!!$! 6"=5!&!$5.$7$ $".&!D ):<*6()0)L):<)6(0)F(6"! !4$C$"6G.754$6"!!6 $ !D"$(:*()5" "5"&!,<9!)::+ N L 8( A!88" );() !$! ?.." 5" 6 " 5" 3!?$ !" !& 5 %% F(

"" !4$4 !""6".$$! . $ 3!?$! 8!!=" 5". N 6!$ 6"! "$( 0) $ 6"$!!6$! 8!!=" 5"$( 0; # C > .> & 2.$! 3!?$! N6"4 !52.$! 8 ". !"

6 "!$ DF 6" 6$! D"$( :* ( / F( .!! $ .!! " 66 !$! 2.$ !" >! 6 "$$ $! 7 6G" 5"?$ 78 "!"@"$. $!!.29?$ 2.$ !" 5"$( <* D "$( << ( , # 4!?" 9>5 /) .3" ,,# "$( +; ( , = )" 94!" ,/L E ),0 ,0< !( ; $ ".8."F( # 8"! !!$"$!8 $ ! 7 A"?6" ".# !$56=+8"(6 "8"!"66 $,+8"(6 "5.$3!$!"DA!88")1() F( 88$# 9"!6"# ! G 8$ 5". "># 6" 6 "$$# !

-/*0+-,+ &+-1& 3!? ! 7 ! "" "66 6 " 52A "$" 7 6G" $!$! D E),+,10# $(,11 !(,-L ,) M)+)6())1F(

1( ".$6!= !">" "$5 $66G.6"!6 " 6."! )" $ 3" ,; /) .3" ,; D/;: 8"( 6" ! 6 " A> ".F#?"."66$!"5!$!.(

"!3 . $$ > 6" ." " 4"$ .$. "!? "$"6$.6"5!$!.$>A" "$"$!4 !" )H*;1 8"# 6 /* 8"( 8"! !!$"$!8# !! > 8"!

6 "!$(%5?!$!$."C$#!5.=4$6 "6"!.A 5"$(,0 () 7+I5D"$(:*(, F(6"! $6G354 2.A. 4D8("$()+() 5 %% F( 5 ""# $6G3)"A> !$6 "$$!$."C$=$$$L!5!$> !$."C$64$ "!"=)"4"!,,"$ $!$.6"!( G ! "$!" ". G 6 " > $!$! $ $ "!$."C$ "$ !"=)+ 43",;(

" "$!!!8$$!8 .(

<( 6" ."$?"$!$6 "6"$!D"$(0)$( L"$(<:O !" 6" ." !!$"$!4 ), 6$3" ):<+ N F( $8 !# . $9$!$8"!6" ."64$C$"!7A"? 6"$!>!?!$!="$.."!" $. !?.?="$.( 88$#!!> "!38..""5!#6 !3!!$.!!$"?"$!$. " " !$"9$.7.?="$6"!!6?.."6" ."6".46 " $ $3"A" !D E),0)+) !(;3F(

% 9"!6"# " " 4 . 7 5.A "!$ C$" !!. 7 " " 6".$$ "$=" .?="$. $.."!$. D E ),; ,<+# "$!> % )::< 6( ):;F( 8$ >5 ..$ N "!$!>3 N 59 $ 39$!4$ 6"$P 6"$! ". !$ 4 !" $. 6" ." > 3!C6 4!$$""" 6$#$5$$$! >5

6 4!$ "! 3$ 2!?" 5# > " " .$!$ .6 "4 A =(

56=#" "6".$7$ $ !"$=".?="$.#7!!$ $.."!$.# " K "?$ 6" > " "$ 5 66 $ 6!$ " 6"! 5"&! $ C > 2 !4 >. 6"..$ 4$ "!3 !!$"$!8# E $ "!3.("#" "$ $.$.$!="$.3 $.(

"!3 . " 5 "" 7 " " "$ 6!$5. $#!$$!"5 "$.97"$$$! >5!6 "" $ C$" .# 8 ".$ 7 5"$( <:O ( ) # 7 . $ $ 2

-/*0+-,+ &0-1& .3 " 5! 6"!$$ 7 " "!" 4$ "!3 . 88!" 33$6 "C $!8(

-/*0+-,+ &1-1& ! (1 (!+ +(+ !+

0/2/ 3 4// / 56 .%'

2/

)( ."" ""43(

2/

,( 5$6"$!$(

/( " !4. .8!!$!4 $ 6G"# 6 "!$ ( *+ ))+1*) 6 " $$ )H*;1 E"(# 6 !$."C$ 7 +I = )+ 43" ,;#8"!!!$"$!8$6 "!$(

;( " !4. .8!!$!4 $ 6G"# 6 "!$ ( *+ ))0;1; # 6 " $$ )H*;1 E"(# 6 !$."C$ 7 +I = )+ 43" ,;#8"!!!$"$!8$6 "!$(

+( !$>6" ."$?"$!$(

0( 8 " 6"$! >5 64$ 8 "" " " $" 6".$ ""C$ .! /* 9 " = $!8!$! 6" 6! " . ". "!3 8.." "# %AQ!R"A 8>! 0# 0; # $" ! 26!"( .! 6$ C$" 6" ?.( . !" !$P F !!>" 2$$>.!! " "$.!" 3$!"!$6.!! $$>.L 3F 26 " 6 " > $!8 ! $! 6 4 !" " $$ $" .!! L F 6 "$" !?$" "6".$$( %! . !" $!$ 6 $" ! ..$ ..". $$" F 3F $ F !&# "!38..""6 ""6$""$!=""" ">5! 4".""!""43(. !"" "$! " " G 6"4# >! " $ 9 !$# !! > .!! $$>. $ 54 66 >.$.26.!." "$D"$()/,#)*0$)*<F( ?"88!" ".!$P S! !

6! 8 "6".$""C$$ $!8!.26"$!!!>57588!8.." $.63!>6"?"88

-/*0+-,+

Jury Instruction on Intent Affirmed

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet