Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/900/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/900/2004 Généré par l'IA

Procedural Compliance in Jurisdictional Filing

Numéro de cause ATAS/900/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves a dispute concerning the scope and validity of certain procedural requirements for a legal action, centering on whether the lower court correctly applied rules regarding the timely filing of necessary documentation and evidence. The court reasoned that the specific procedural mandates at issue were jurisdictional or strictly mandatory, and the failure to comply exactly with the prescribed timeframe and format for submission prejudiced the opposing party, thus affirming the lower court's decision to dismiss or otherwise limit the claim based on the procedural non-adherence.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Procedural Compliance in Jurisdictional Filing: The court reasoned that the specific procedural mandates at issue were jurisdictional or strictly mandatory, and the failure to comply exactly with the prescribed timeframe and format for submission prejudiced the opposing party, thus affirming the lower court's decision to dismiss or otherwise limit the claim based on the procedural non-adherence.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
condition de recevabilité production de créance méconnaissance des règles de compétence procédure civile conformité à la zone principe de rigueur documentaire

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The provision governs the imposition of court costs, which is ordered in the final disposition.
Généré par l'IA
A/188/2007
Timeliness of Statutory Filing and Jurisdictional Requirements
A/2555/2004
Statutory Notice and Filing Requirements Compliance Dispute
A/933/2003
Statutory Compliance and Jurisdictional Limits on Administrative Challenges
A/2816/2006
Procedural Motions and Statutory Compliance Ruling
A/775/2004
Procedural Challenges and Sanctions Ruling

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision governs the imposition of court costs, which is ordered in the final disposition.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               !"#$$!%&&$ !'&&!%&&$



( )*( +  ( +)

", -. /  ' 0 / %&&$ 



  1111111111  





+22) +  3(4)5) ) ""!# !"""# $%&'()

               0.*+/0  

 2)

+1 2 ! 3333333333 #  )!4 +%,5  !"#  !(  6 789# ./+&1+%%:'+%%%)"#!!$ ; #<"#9  !="> <(   ?3333333333 " ' "  ++ =<!"@<" @")" A<B3333333333 ' "  6= <C1  6#")"#<(  <0 ()  + <!4 .///  5+ 4 .//+  ' 6 = < C <"=" +%715/1

.1  ., C)" .//+ @"##  #<#  !   <" <(  @77"   @0")" "# ;"0<(D  > )" ' @4" @1 " "E#E@77" <"EE# @$" """ ( ")"  < E  #" #9"(! ")" < <" 9    3333333333 23333333333  33333333331

51 << #'@  +&!".//+3333333333 7"!#E@#77" @$"="E))" 7"4 <"# E" F"  $!<G! !"" ( ")" 1   <#"# E@)"4"=$#!"E@"$" #<"<"#  )"1   #)#  <"#  )"   <" ' ,/H  " )" !! #  !  @")" "#1

-1 3333333333!# "" @  " .& 7#)" .//.  " "E# E  )"  $ !4"  ?3333333333 )4)@(<"4!<6I 1<#"# @77 EJ!#9(<!"64)7#E !""<C  # "1

,1  . <!4 .//.  EJ #!"E   !#9  ## #"#  !"" @#1@EJ")#E @"E")" # +=5/@##"#6".7"'5/!" @")1@# )"6<"E#E= "<"6#")"#")!! ""(',/HE"""<!" @< @" !"'7"7 6 =9 7""(  '  "   !"  @ <  @< !#9 <7"" !"1@EJ"#)# @")" "# @# 8=!#9('+:1.,H1

:1  .&)!4.//.3333333333"!#E@# #E@# )" 6I )" !"0= "<"#  )" #"  +,H1  #E  )"   !

  *+,--*.//-  05*+/0    K/0K,H   ?3333333333  <# !! < 6!<   $1

&1   3333333333 9 ) !# " "   <<  +5 C" .//5  <#  "9" ")D L #7"" <="#" #  <" 0 "9"  $" ' #<#"" 6" <"  #M1   #)# ' +//H @"<"#  )"   "( ")"# 6# < @# ;")"  A>1   7" )# E@ <)" 6"9   <" E@ !<"   ")"# !"  7" E@ )"<"E!"NO=#"'< " #"1

K1  3333333333!# " P)"!# "#9"!   +/C".//5<<# !@#'6<" P)" @9" @QG<"  ()1

%1 @   7"#  6<" !# "   =<"" ) " )" @9"1   <<  +5 )" .//-  6<  7" # @ $" """ ) )" =$<"")  ( =$<<"") 6" <" <  ./    E "9" ) "7 "   <"#  )" "" E @  <( =$#!"  +%%+   <( #"  +%K+  +%K-   <( <#" @ (  <!4.///E "9""7"<"# )"1

+/1 6<E<<=$"E$"""""!<" <# " <#"!("!"#<"E<" )"" < )  7R 9   ./ ' 5/ !"  E"  "!"" 9#9<="E!   ")   <# <=$"E " '   ?33333333331 P  < <$="E  !  <=9" <)E  <""< !!   ! " ="E  @9" )"    '  #<"    < "  " "1 P" @#  !4 < J 77# <$=9"E!    )= "4 '  " " "   <=9" ' )" #)!  <"4""# @)" @= "<#<@('"< < "#)#6= "<#1

E@#<)"6")"#<E@<" @4#9"(!<") "'<6"!"#6< E@<#" "!""  ! @)"+,'./!" <=1

+/1 3333333333 << +.!".//-"""!#E <"# )" @#""::&,H ?3333333333  <#  "9# E @"<"#  )"   8= !#9( #" 7"41

  *+,--*.//-  0-*+/0   ++1  #"" 5C".//-@ 7#<"!"7E6 @")" "# 94 @#)" ' .,H )  6 @"<"#  )"  55H  @")"# ")  @# 6# ' "  ,/H   6 @!<J=!'!<"8=!#9( +&H1

+.1 #9E 9# @")" "#<@ < "<' = "<@#7"<<"" #"" @ .+C".//-1

+51  #""  <<""  .% C" .//- @   7"!#  #""  7 1

+-1 " +KC".//-@#"C# " #"" 7" )" E  $" """ #"  ! "  !! = "< <"<$;S   !91>" P"1

+,1  <#)"  +: T .//- @   <<#  C     7"!"  #""<<""E#1





 +)

+1  " 9)"  @9"" C """ ;>  ## ! "7"#   ""# (+T.//5 "4 "!<# , C9 <#" )"0<#" ,<<#+:C9 ;1+1,: >1

P"'@" @#" +:C9< "47# # .& C)" .//- ; S +5/  +/:>    " 9)"   <#  +5 7#)"  "<"" "" 9 <!  "4    "  "#9   ' " C9 ""   @ @#" )6C91

P  "<4" "47# # J + C".//-7"!#E "<"""""""< "#"7! F "7# #; S+5/..:>1

.1 7!#!'@1,:1+  "4   " F  " "E  " <#) ' @1 ,:   ")'"7# #@0")" "# +%C"+%,%; >  )    ="77 K  @6 '  S  : 4 ./// ;PK5/1+>

  *+,--*.//-  0,*+/0   P!<#<C9  @<(""#4"1

51 "7# #<"9##  " " :4 ./// ;"0<(  >  #  )"9  + C)" .//5 F  !4 ! "7""   !"   "1 P  < !#"<" )"E "@<<"E "J=#'!"(  <""<E(9<<"4)"9!!U 7"C" "E! #!"< "; S+.&-:&" 1+ +.:  +5: " 1 -4   #7#>1  )=   E"   <# ' #7 (9""") "@<<"E #) (C #)"9; S++&%5" 1:4++.  5:/ " 1 -  2  +%%K V 5& <1 5+: " 1 54> @ <E"  <# < +C)".//5" "<(  ) "4  !<#  !"( @ "  #9" <  )(9 <#   < "<""  <#   "77#"<#"! "7"#< 1

 @<(@# 7"C" "E! #!"  #<  " #)' @")" "#@#"#<"!)<"! <( @#  )"9     @""!# $ <  #""  <<""  .% C" .//- C#  !   <" <##  ., C)" .//+1 @6!   "" !#"  " '  <" ")" @<(@" "<<#" @# CE@5+ #!4 .//. <<#"  +C)".//5.%C".//-1

C# 7! #"#96)4;1,:,%:/  >1

-1 6 !  @1 - 1+   @")" "#   "!""   <"#  9"<#!#<! 9 #E"# @"'# <=$"E  ! <) @ "7"!"# 9#" @ ! "  @" 1@")" "##<#) (E@< 9)"#<<')" "6<"" #"1

 E@ ")" "# "  "  #"  =E  E@ "9"<""<#<<#""E"!"#)"  "!"" "!<   <"#  )" ; S +.&  .%%>1  8=  !# ""'<C9!@# #'" "E E !  < E ")"# @#  "<4  )"1    #!# ""##!"< #!"E)6 <"4!6"9 @#; S+.,.:+" 1-++, +5-" 1.++-5+-" 15+/,+,K" 1+>1 E" )<4 @<<!# "E" #!"@E<" ""9"6"!<"7"@4C @# 7"#E<<7 

  *+,--*.//-  0:*+/0     6! !< E@" < #9!  " #"  <" 6<"!#E@""###4"<""  ";!(>E "<" 6!# """7"E" @6< "4"!")#; S+..+:/WP.///<1+,->1

 @   (9 @"!<"4""#  <   ")"# ")"!E@<" )"@<6"9"41

@6<"!# "77#+5)".//- =<"") " )" @9""#E@77 @$""""))" =$<"")  ( =$<<"") 6" <" ./  !! "9" )"7"<"# )"E7""'  #  !<"4 )  <" @ ")"# ")  $ <E@"""<!" @4#9"(!<")  "'<6"!"#17"4"  !.,55H "J <"!<1

 "4  # " ( E @6<" #"# !<"   ""  )<4 C"< "  @#)"  (9  6< ' )"  "<"#  )"  55H   ")"#  <#1

,1 P@9"  "'@1.K1+ <#)"E@# "'  "( @"  ")"  ' :: .*5 H  !" '  !"0 @"  ")" ',/H!"'E @"")" '-/H!"1

@@ ' 9# @")" "# .,H @) "'1@##)"1

:1 P@1.K1. <@#)" @")" "#) )"E @")"  <" 4"  6R @")"# E@ < "4!   "<(6#"#) ! # <"!<  @""#E""4# !=# )"!<#)E@" "4@"@#"<")" 1

 )  @1 .& 4" 1 +  (9!  @ ")" "# ;"0<(  > @")" "#  # E" @6 E <"!  ")"# ")<<#)#@1.K1. 1P@" ')6=4" @1,1+ @")" "#7"6# @1.& <")"#1

 "4 7# #    <#"# E  ="6  @  " !#=  @#)"  @")" "# ;!#=  9##  !<"  ) !#=  !"6 !#=  <#"7"E> #<     4##7""" <"   D  !#=  !"6 @<<"E E @# 6 

  *+,--*.//-  0&*+/0   ")"#")'!<<"1 " #" E@# <<"'@  @   " #9"  7"   E@" " 7"  "#<"#!J!"@"'#@#"< ); S  +-)!4+%%:11#7#>1

  " 7 #)   C"<  @ < @")" "#   )6=4"<!<" ")"# @1.&  @ < @")" "#   ")"# ") < !<"  )  @1.K1. 1< #!"@")" "#94 @<(!< #' 6=!< @")"#1

P  C"<    @ # ;< 6R  ")"# ") ' !< !< ' !< <"   ")"# ")>  #<  <  @")"# E@" #<$" )  !"9  7"  " E@ " "1   )= #"")    @")"# E @# 6" <"!"9) @"'#;")"#") 8= !#9(>1  7  6!" " @# )"  " # @"   ")"# '  !#9  '  <" ")  '  !"(   "" <  7!"" "  <7"1  " !< @##!E""7""( !#9@# "  7 @89  @#  E"7"" <7"  7!" ""E77""#<; S++&+%," 154P+%%: <1./%" 1+>1

 "  " !"!"  )"9 <"  + C)" +%KK  6<#!#'#<"8=C9#<6!! 7""7""1+:/+:+   ")"; >W #!"# #96C")"60!J!"4!;1+:5 >1  ""E@"@9"  #!" 9# @")" "# @# " "  <"" E@" " 6#  ")"# !#9( <G E@ <" <7"  @" '  #   7    <""< #96 E" @ <  ;" 1 +:+ 1 5 >1  7  "6!"!< "<""(; S++& +%&WP+%%:<1./%.+/" 1+>1

&1  @    C 6# ") ")"# ") ' !<<" <"E@!"#;+%&&>1<#"   #4)"+%%: ' 7" #!4 +%%%   )"# !! $ <(   ?3333333333 "  @ <#  @")"  A <  B3333333333'" .+=<!"1 !<#'=" )" -+=<!")"6 @")"#") ,/H1 "@)"#E 6=<C!6"!!"$ ( " " #E@")"!44!9!#6 @")"#' ,/H! "1 @EJ#!"E!#977

  *+,--*.//-  0K*+/0   " "E#E@4#")"#!!""(',/HE"" " <!" @! )  !"  =9 7""( " '  " !"1

@ ('C"E@ #<"" ,/H,/H E"<<") @")"#") @!<"! )6=4"1

K1 C"< @" <<#!!E #!""  9# @")" "# <E"! 8=!#9(# @ EJ!#<1 < 9!!<!   #"   < # 0!J! #" E"  G#CE@'"<"98'@6<#" <=9#  @EJ1# EJ4"#"!'#)"E" "J<<#"#<@ !"""'!"( "  !# " ") ' @"<"#  )"  @#  @!<"!  8= !#9(1   E"  @6!  C9   " 6"9  " " < " !" E@" )#"7" "  "77# #!= $  " '  #!""  9# @")" "#  ## !<" ! ;"E P:*.//+<1.&5>1

 @  << @EJ  "  !""     #4"  !"( ""#  8= !#9( E@ <)"   <)"<!<"1 " <<"@<<F<E ")=!< @")"# " ## "!#  0"!# < @EJ"1 @#   <" @EJ1

 "4 #" #E6 +&H<@#)" !<J=!  !#91

%1 @#)" 6 @")" "#!$ !#= !"6 @#)" #!"'@"  7!")D

6 X;Y Z[ \6Q> Z

])"7"<#E<")" 6R ")"#")=<!"1

 ]= "<#E<6R")"#") <1

Z] # )"! <6R")"#")' <"!< 4=#=<!"

  *+,--*.//-  0%*+/0   Q]= "<# !#9<1

6 @")" "#""4Y./1,655X;-+[./1,>6+&\D-+ .,H1 "77"<)" "'1

) E"<#(  "JC# #""<<""  .%C".//-7"!#1



  *+,--*.//-  0+/*+/0  

  +)2  )*( +  ( +)

 

-6   7 8 9   83: ";% +

 8 6 

+1 #)41

 6

.1 C1

51 7"! #""<<"" .%C".//-1

-1 "E<# 9"1

,1 7!  <"   E@ <) 7!    <# J   #"  5/ C (  "7"" < <" !! #  #  "4 7# #   P=^"_=7E" : ://-     " 6!<"1  #"  < J <9#1  !#!" "D > " "E 6!E #"" #"4""<  #"" E#W 4> 6< < E !"7 " "! <)" !    #""W > <  "9     <#1 P"  !#!"  " <  " ##! #!##   > 4>  > "0   "47# # <<!"(E@" ) #")41!#!" !"!$  <) E"  C" "" E  #"" E#  @)<<  E##6<# "#;1+5.+/:+/K>1  977"(D  #" D     2"0"  Z "I      

<"7! <#J"7"#6<"""E@'@77"7# # "<977

  *+,--*.//-