Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/867/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/867/2005 Généré par l'IA

Statutory Notice and Filing Requirements Compliance Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/867/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves multiple appeals concerning the application of a statute pertaining to certain rights, with the court frequently examining the timing and nature of a required notice or filing across various factual scenarios, including disputes over the statute of limitations for asserting those rights and whether certain procedural prerequisites were met. The court reasoned that the statute in question established clear temporal requirements for asserting the rights, and strict compliance with these requirements, particularly regarding notice periods and filing deadlines relative to specific triggering events, was necessary to preserve the claimed entitlement; where the claimant failed to adhere to these mandatory procedural stipulations, the resulting claim was correctly dismissed or barred by the relevant time limitations.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Notice and Filing Requirements Compliance Dispute: The court reasoned that the statute in question established clear temporal requirements for asserting the rights, and strict compliance with these requirements, particularly regarding notice periods and filing deadlines relative to specific triggering events, was necessary to preserve the claimed entitlement; where the claimant failed to adhere to these mandatory procedural stipulations, the resulting claim was correctly dismissed or barred by the relevant time limitations.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
délais légaux moment du dépôt condition de recevabilité délai de résiliation délai de prescription respect des délais

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited for the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1937/2005
Statutory Deadline Compliance for Legal Filing
A/3818/2006
Statutory Compliance in Timeliness and Sufficiency of Filings
A/933/2003
Statutory Compliance and Jurisdictional Limits on Administrative Challenges
A/1681/2006
Statutory Deadline Adherence in Document Filing
A/188/2007
Timeliness of Statutory Filing and Jurisdictional Requirements

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited for the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

   

"#$$$"#%%& "'()"#%%$



* +!* ,  * ,+

- . /  // 0. #%%$

  

 !!!!!!!!!!" #$% & '(" $ $)* ) +* *   ,  - *# #.  %* #$

*

      / ,,  0  "   *$% # 1 23 & '(

           !  

0 549 0

 1+

:;  !!!!!!!!!!" %  :2<8"  *(% #) :29< )' # -*) =!!!!!!!!!! ,  .*% # $>(" ?.- 8 $ :222" #* & .   % ** *(*% *("  $*@ .- @@* # $A*B B(;

5;   #%)%  #$# (* & -* #- * * # $ )@ )' # -@@ * # -0(#*% C0)' - D  56 ($A :222;

, $%# ***"  *  E,"  @$%  #B* # $A*B BF * #  $A %** ***;   #.% .  )** )%**  )*% ** # *( #  *(*% # $>( *  *$% .  *( # B * #)*% &  %** # *%;

G; -%  %*% $  A%%@ #- *B #-A(* )@ # *1) ,  # :8 ?(  :8 ( 5775" )B%  :< ? 5775;

 ))* %*A & - #  )$' )* # *B"  ))* . -% )* H* %#)*% #  * %$. $  ** .-( #- C$* & -%*A" (* # $FD  $)1%  #*$* & ) *$) * (  #$* $$$ # <7I  )* ))$*  C( # *  )* #A*D" # # *(*% %B' * J B';

 *B  %*% )B% & $0*$) ) #  $%#; ,  )1FB . (* -%"  1 *  #%) %*;   ))* # 5: ? 5775  * (%  $%* #  %** * # $A F% #  *# C) *@ ) #* . ) *(D;  )A # *B   ))% # * -% # @@*@;

8; -%  %*% $ &  K)* #    :7 $ 5778;

 * !!!!!!!!!!" F$*B"  #B*.% # $AB F.   $A %** ***  G * #)*F $*0 %*B%; , "  )*% # *(  ** . $>( #  AL*$* *  *  ($AA$* # $' #%@*(" $ $)'* ) # *(K %B" )** .. $** @*" C) # $($* %)%**@  )*0&0@K" ) # $($*  K* #   $A" ) # $F &  #*D;

 * !!!!!!!!!!" )1F*"  (%  *A $*@$ #@@%%"  %)# #%)@ $1  1#$ $*. *  )*% & ** )@0B@;

4566645778

0 G49 0

-%  %B$* %*% K$% )  * !!!!!!!!!! * !!!!!!!!!!" )F*$B;  * **% . M N  !!!!!!!!!! )%*  *% ( B% #  # 57I & #* * :7I & BF; -K$ .  $*  %(#  $ )$* #-K).  @* ( *' %#*;

-F1)$%*) @* . )%*  )** -K). )  )* # A #-*% ( )B( A*%; -K$ # @# #-> $* # *' #* ) $"  %.   @* (" * -)* *$B)F. #  $ * $ C D;

 ( .. )**% # -%(* . #  @* ( #  !!!!!!!!!!;  @$* .* & -%(* # #%@* ( * ) )%;  A #-*% ( * #%A*%  :22<" *  !!!!!!!!!! * #%)%  )$ # #*  1  ( K "   #  # F. * #  *A (;  * )* .  )** -* ?$   &  %(* )F*$B. )  * * ( #*  @* * #@@$* $)*A (  *(*% .*# $;  "  !!!!!!!!!!  -* ?$ )* # *A ( &  $%# ***" .  * *' %B'$* #) 5777" * . - (  #' **  59 O* 577G;  $A %B$* .  )A'$ ( -* )  # %.   *(*% )@ $$ $>(" K% ?.- :222;

 K$ . %% &  ? @$*  *% ( A% # #K P*%" (  $ *% ( B% # 7;G Q 7;8 )  * 7;G ) ;  F$) ( $)*%% $**  A #  A*% $1 # :7R *K"  )* ) -;

 *$ #  (*B*"  * .- * ( #-B B. * )AA FJ  )**" $H$   )*)*  B.  )* H* K *%B.$*;  )%(1  *P # -%(* # K $ S;

 $ # K)*  @$* *  #B* # *A $*@$ #@@%%" * %*%  # $*" ( -K* #- A** B.  ( F$*B. C $A %**D;   ))% N # * *$*  #B* # $?* # 1$)*P$  %( .  %** # -K$ # *P )F*$B. *  %** # -.H*   #%$** # % $** S;   @K%  -%**  )*% # *( & :77I #  *(*% #)*% C$** F$*B.D" %** )%% )  .- %#* # 56I #  )*% #* # $ :222  *@* # $%# ***; 

4566645778

0 849 0

6;   ))* # 9 ? 5778"  ( # %#)** )@ # -   )%#% &  $) # (   @#*    # -K)* #   *  &  *K #-(#*% # :5":I;

<;  #% # :9 ? 5778" -   ?*%  #$# # )**"  *K #-(#*% * -%** ) @@* ) ?*@ -* # )**;

3;  #%  ))* # :5 ($A 5778"   @$%  #%;

9; -*%%" )%*% ) +*   ,"  *?*%   :6 #%$A 5778 * #* #%  ))*;  **  (  F1)*F%*. #-(# # 67/73< @; * ) - ;  #' & * %B# . 0 - ) * $)* # # F#) #*  @@" .- -#. ) . *1) #-*(*%  )* K *  )F #-( )  #%*  )#%* # :7I $*;

  ))% .- )%*  @* F#)  ( # -*% (" .- * .$* (B *  )* #  (%F *$A;   # * B% .  K)* %(*  ))%*  @* #-(*B* $)%$*  ( )F*$B.;   ?* &    *@* %*A )  * !!!!!!!!!!  3 #%$A 5778" K *$ #.  @@ #- *' $)** %#* #  *% ( ( * $)$%*.; -% 'B  * H* * #- B( % #0 $A (#*" & * B .  # *B , "  $+* #-* (* @K%  )*% %# # *( & <7I;  *  & -* #- * *' #-(#*%;

2;   )%( # 59 ?( 5776" -   ))% # ?*  " # )  $* #  #%  ))* * # ** -K* #- $*@ # %( )*% & #* #%" *  #%B#* $)** # -*% (;

:7; (*% &  #%*$" -% -%* #  . -  ) #-BB(*"

 .  *A )F*$B. (* #%?& %*% **% #  # # -K)*   * .  * !!!!!!!!!! (* *% #  ))* # 3 #%$A 5778 . -*% ( -%** . # 7"G  $K$$  ( A  G7 ?( 5775 #%?&;

::; -   . # ,( $%# %B  Q , %$  ( $%#;

 %* #  * # * ,!!!!!!!!!! #*% # 9 $ 5776 .- * $)A # #%@ ( )% & . $$* -BB(* -* )#* *  : ?* 577G" #* & . -K)* #    %*% %*A *  3 #%$A 5778" #* & .  * !!!!!!!!!!  )%#% &  K$;

4566645778

0 649 0

  # :7 $ 5776" -    **% .  ** )F*$B. * )  K)* #    $ 5778 -%** ) #*. &  **% )  * !!!!!!!!!!  #%$A 5778;    %. )*% & # .  $#@* (%  #%$A 5778 )(* **  $*@ # %( )*% &  #%  ))*;

:5; -%  . -#* # * !!!!!!!!!! C@;  # 9 ( 5776D;

(.% )  A # % )  3 ? 5776"  * !!!!!!!!!!

)#*  @* )* # B# #@@*% &  A% *  ))% .- -(* K$% -% .  G7 ?( 5775 * : #%$A 5778;   @$% .- ?( 5775 -*% ( -%(* & G7 & 87I * -%** . # :7I  #%$A 5778; , "  B A 0)F*$B. * % * ) )*'$*  K$ ) )%$%* # #$ ) -%(* # F$) ( C@;  # :2 $ 5776D;

:G;  G7 $ 5776" -  1* )  #  # * !!!!!!!!!! * )' ( & ( *B%  , %$"  #%% H* #-# (  K$ )F*$B. $)%$*" ?** .-N   #-%#  F% (% )  ,"  * K$ #(*  )$ # #%*$  #* # ( # -BB(* # *  )*% K  # -K)*   %% & @ 577G S;

:8   # -  # G7 $ 5776 * -( $%# K% # 56 $ 5776 * %*% *$ & -%" #*  $#* -* #%*$%  53 ? 5776 $$ * M N   B$* #% )  * !!!!!!!!!!"  * $@*$* . -*% ( #  !!!!!!!!!!  -%(* .-& G7 & 87I  $ # ?( 5775" *  -%** ) .-& :7I  #%$A 5778; - )  # $* # $  & (* ** # 2 ? 5776 -$A #  %%$*" #- )*" * . -K)* )#) @@*%  :7 $ 5778 (* #%?&  ( *' @A #  !!!!!!!!!! #-* )*;  %** * $B% -%(#  $A . -@@ *  ** ?#-F ** $1 ) *# *$*  )%#;    * # * ,!!!!!!!!!! # 56 $ 5776 K% & (* # "

0  )  A*% # ** #*$*  * !!!!!!!!!!;

CTD  @@*"  * !!!!!!!!!!  #%?& #.% # $'  * # # *$ .  @@* #- # -$) # -BB(* # -%** # *% #  !!!!!!!!!! *  )*  * ; CTD '   !!!!!!!!!!  )* . )* #  K)* #%?& #% #  # #   * #   .-  ); ,A#$* * $$  -(* #%?&

4566645778

0 <49 0

@*   *$)" $ $#* * -#* # * !!!!!!!!!! S;

:6;    %*% $$.% & -  *    %*% B#% & ?B;

 ,+

:;   B(  -B* ?# CD  %*% $#@% *  **%"

#'  : O* 577G"  A * #  " $)% # 6 ?B" #*  )%#* *  (0)%#*" 6 ))%* * :< ?B  C*; : *;  * 6< D;

5; ,* & -* # -%* # :< ?B " )  A @%#% 

53 ?( 5778 C :G7  :7<D"  #  B(  #)*%"  :G @%("  #)* ** B* )$*  A * #   # %B   & * ?B **" " #

G; @$%$* & /*; 6<  ; : *;  F; 5 "  A * #   +*  * . # *** )%( & -*;

6< #   @%#% # < *A 5777   )* B%% # #* #   2 D . * *( &    -0(#*% # :2 ? :262 C D; , $)%* ) ?B #  #-)' *  %*A;

G;   @%#%   )* B%% # #* #   # < *A 5777 C D * *%  (B  : ?( 577G" *+*  $#@* # $A #)* %B #  #$ #  ; ,  ) $*%"  )* # ( . #* /)). #* H* *F% &  $' # ))  .  'B ))A *   (B  $$* U  @* ?#.$* #%*$*  * )#* C :G7  G59 #; 5;5 * 5;G V :53  8<3 #; :" :5<  :G< #; 8A *  %@%D;

 (F"   .   )%#" * & #%@* # 'B ** *"  ( #* /)).  %( #'  ? #  *%  (B C ::3  2G #; <A" ::5  G<7 #; 8V   :229 W G3 );

G:< #; GAD; /* ).  )%# )#*  : ?( 577G  *#* )'  #* #(*  *A * $)%**  $*' #/  * %B )  ( 'B # )%# * #   * )  #)* # )%# * #  #@@%*  )% $#@% )   ;

8;  " *?*%  *$) *" * (A C* 6< * <7  D;

4566645778

0 349 0

6;  *B )*   .* # (  -%"  A%%@ #- #$0* #-(#*%" )%*   *   %F%*" #) .#"  BB(* #  %** # *%;

*$* K %B* # *"  * !!!!!!!!!!  @* )* #    A # %  :2 $ 5776"  ) #  # #- )) *%%)F. # * ,!!!!!!!!!!" $ &  * #  (* ) -# )%( )  3 ? 5776;   "  * !!!!!!!!!! BB' .- B A 0)F*$B. * @@*% * ) )*'$*  K$ ) )%$%* # #$ ) -%(* # F$) (;

 -))+* )  #$* % # )%# &  #*" #'  .-   - # @ %** #  *** * #  (;

-K$ )%% )$ & -%(# # #%*$ - 1     BB(* #) -K)* %% )    * # %)# K #* %$ )  )F*$B #  " . (* # * *  #B* N  %( .  %** # -K$ # *P )F*$B. CT;;D  #%$** # % $** S;   ?*@ #'  # (1   & -  @ . 0 )'#  $)%$* #-** %;

4566645778

0 949 0

  ,+1  +!* ,  * ,+



203   4  5   67 /(# ,8

  3 

:; %   (A;

 3

5; -#$* )*$* #   # #%*;

G; (   & -*$% ) $)%$* #-**   # #%* * ( #%;

8; #$ -*$% & (  *  #$*% # :/777 @; & ** # #%);

6; @$  )* #  .- )(* @$  *  )%* H* #  #% # G7 ? #'  *@* ) ) $$#% #%  A @%#% # " ,FXJF@. <" <778   "  * K$);  #%  )* H* )B%;  $%$ #* M D #. K*$* . #%  * #% A*   * ) #  #% .%V AD K) ) . $*@  *$ )( #$#  * #%V D )*  B*   #  )%**; ,  $%$  ** )  * %%$* %$%%   D AD * D 0#"  A @%#% #   ) ) *  $*'    .- #( #% (A;  $%$ #  $*   $1 # )(" . * ?*"  .  #% .% * -()) # .   %*% K)%#%  * C*; :G5" :7< * :79 D;

 B@@'  )%#*

0  Y  Z   

 ) @$ # )%* H* * *@% K )*  .-& -@@ @%#% #   )  B@@ 

4566645778