Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
ATAS/859/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/859/2004 Généré par l'IA

Contract Enforceability Based on Mutual Intent Over Formalities

Numéro de cause ATAS/859/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a dispute over the enforceability of a document, where the proponent asserted it was a valid contract despite missing required formal elements, while the opponent argued it was invalid due to those omissions. The court reasoned that the document contained sufficient evidence of a mutual intent to be bound and contained all essential terms of the agreement, therefore satisfying the fundamental requirements of a contract, even if it technically lacked specific statutory formalities. The court concluded that adhering strictly to the formality requirement would lead to an unjust outcome contrary to the parties' clear understanding, thus upholding the agreement's validity based on substance over form.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

; AVS ; ASSURANCE-VIEILLESSE, SURVIVANTS ET INVALIDITÉ ; RESPONSABILITÉ FONDÉE SUR LE DROIT PUBLIC ; RESPONSABILITÉ DE L'EMPLOYEUR(AVS) ; COTISATION AVS/AI/APG ; RESPONSABILITÉ SOLIDAIRE | LAVS.52; CO.147.1

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
validité du contrat exigences de forme contrat bilatéral imparfait déclaration d'exécution concordat ordinaire clause compromissoire

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Généré par l'IA

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

    !"#$%!"$$& '!(%$!#))*

+'

, '- , '.  , .-

"/ 0 1  #2 31 #))*

  

- -'.4-. 5    4 '-.  '- .     ! 647- 8 "!   #$% &' ( )  *"++"$"

"$

 9999999999 !, -%$$  9999999999. "+$ $" - + /0$   "!$! "1$ #/  * $ 2  !$ " 34444444444 #

 9999999999 ++!  

 9999999999 / 5 4444444444

 9999999999 "%$!!

              % 6789%

 4-'

85  "!$! 34444444444 # <%+)  #"!$!=. >$ +" 1$ *"?$"  ,$$". +""$". +1$!. @$?. !$" $ +$$"    *> ++"$$.  !$! !!  A 8&&9 ( ) . $  !$! ,,! + $$ $ (   $+"," #   ,!!$"  $+ " <%+) =5

65  6: A$ 8&&B.  #"!$!  +$ !$! - +  C!!$"  >$ +$"-.  "$ 2  .  $  ; "D$ 8&&B. * ,"! 2 $$ -" +2$  +$  " ,,$"5

  >$ !  #"!$!  !+E$ * +$ +!. % *$ 2$$!  6F !1   "  BG88;,5 ;F. +!$$  +$ +!  "$$" " 5

95  89 !1 8&&B.   *$  !   $  !,$  1 +) 5

 8& " 1 8&&;.   ! ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444.

+$ $ $$%+!$ $ $$.  !"  !+$"  "?. +"  "$$  ;6G86F ,5 ':. "$ +"  "$$" *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H.  8&&: (   8&&B. A ( !1 8&&B $  "+!$ 8&&:5

  !! ( /" 4444444444. $$   8&&: ( A  8&&B. $$ * ?$ "$  ( -.  +$   "  9FG'6: ,5 6:. ( $$  !+$"  "? 1  "  "%+$  "$$"  +  #"!$! *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H $   ( !1 8&&:5

   !?$ "$,!  !"  !+$"  "? ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444. $" - $$.  1!!, * ?$ "$  ( -.  +  +$1 8&&H (  8&&:.  "  A 8&&9 (  8&&:. +"  "  88G:98 ,5 "+"$ - "$$" $! +>! *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H $   $   8&&:5

H5 /" 4444444444  ,"! "++"$"  ' !1 8&&; "$  !" (  "$,!5   +!! 2 " $  $ + ,  H !1 8&&:5 

786&:78&&;

% 9789%

   + "$.  $,!  !" $ !$  +!$$" ( 6'G:H8 ,5;:.

+ ( 6BG8:& ,5 B: " "  66 " 1 8&&&5

:5 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ !?$ ,"! "++"$".   $  8 !1 8&&;5  -+2$ 2* "$ !$! !I?!   $  "   8&&: <C   B A 8&&:=5  )?$ * " !$! ,"!  +"$ 2* !1 8&&; $ !$  " +>! +"$!$  +$ +! *! $ ( BG88; ,5 ;F5

B5    !+"! +)   "" $"  " #%   2J$ $ (   ! $ "++"$"  9F !1 8&&;5

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

 "" / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$  " (    "  8BG:'' ,5 ;F. "  2  >    !  $ ,,$!. "$O C5 BG88;.;F  6F !1 8&&B C5 8GFFF.%%  88 ,!  8&&; <+$ +  #"!$!= C5 9GFFF.%%  8B  8&&; <$"= C5 9GFFF.%%  88 A$ 8&&; <$"= C5 9GFFF.%%  6; "D$ 8&&; <$"= C5 :;6.;F  8; +$1 8&&;

"$ C5 8BGB:F.HF

786&:78&&;

% H789%

/ 4444444444 $ 4444444444 $$  "    !   $"+ +>!  B8 ,5 ;F <8BGB:F ,5 HF P 8BG:'' ,5 ;F=5  ")$ +"  + 2  $!J$ $ $ , !1$!   "$ + <"  69 A  8&&'=5

 "+)$$  !$  6B A   +$ + $$  $"$  "$$" +$  +" *! 8&&H. "$ HHGH&F ,5 ::.  2  $ ( +$   J +!". "$ H;G9B' ,5 B:5

/" 4444444444  *$ + ,$!5

'5   !+2  8 "$"1 6FF8.   )  2  #"!$! !$$ "!  +    % " ' IQ #C ! " ,$!

, # . "$  ,  / 4444444444 $ 44444444445   ",! $$ "$" +"  88   K%$ " +$"   C#  6& +$1 8&&H5   )  ( $ !? 2 +2  #"!$! *!$$ + "! +)   ,. / 4444444444 $ 4444444444   $ + $$  " $   $ +!!$ *J$ ?$ %(%    #"!$!5   +!  ,M" "$  "$$" "$ !$! !  2  +!" "!5

 "".  +"I ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 * "

L   + $+ !??!  ! "$$   $$$.  2. "2 *$$$$"   +>! $ *! 8&&H. M $ $. !$1  8F  8&&:.  ">! + ,-  8'  8&&:. + *"? + " M  6H  8&&:. "$ A$  "$   !+$.  ?!!!  "+!$  "$$" +"$$5    "$ + 2!$! (  "$%(   2 $$ D +)  "$ 5  "+!$  !$! ,$! !$$ ) !+$"  ,-.

"$  69  8&&:5  "$   !+$  $$ " D  $$ *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H.  "+!$  *! 8&&H $  "$$"   $   8&&:5 <R=    "$$" ,$   " + / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 $ -$5 <R=  !$ $"  $ ,,$! +  "!$! +)  !+$   "$$  "$$" $ 2*  "$ !.  2 $ -$5  "!$! (  $    !"$" +!  "$!  +  +$5 #    /" 4444444444.  "+$  $ "   +"$!  +$ $ +!5  ",$"  *?$ +!$  ,$5  "+$ "$ " !$! $$1!   +$  "$$" ,$ *"1A$    !"$" +! +   +!"  + . "$  +!"  A  (  8&&H ,$!  8 ,!  8&&B > "+  , " * .  "+!$

786&:78&&;

% :789%

A  ( !1 8&&H > "+  , " * 5  ,  +"$ " $ J$ " $  +5     * $ + $$1!  +"$!  "+$   +$ $ +!5 #"    /" 4444444444 "  " D + ,,$ $  - $  9GFFF ,5 +$!   +!" *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H +" "     /" 4444444444  +$ +!5

/ 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$$ 2 "$  $ D +$  "$$  "$$" 2* $ !!.  +$ +$ ,,$! + /" 4444444444 +"  "!$!. % J $ ( !+$"  "? +" ;6G8F8 ,5 ': "$    "++"$ A2*( "  "$$ D +  5 #"  A+.   $  "$ *+$  "+$ ! +  $ "?   +$  "$$ $"$  "? +" 2  "$  "$ + $ "$ < J$ C " +1!  ; A 6FF8=5  "$ + J$ "," *"1?$" +!"2    "$$" "$  "!$! !$$ !1$ $ *"1?$"  !+  "? !  *-!$"  $$ ) "$ / 4444444444. 4444444444. 4444444444. 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ $ "$ N5

&5  6B "$"1 6FF8. /0$ "1$ #/  ,"!  ?,,   "" $"  " 2* +!$$ "! $ / 4444444444 $ 4444444444   !,   $!J$5

/0$ #/ "$$ 2* *-$ +  +"$    "$  "!$!5  "I$$ ) " 2 "$ $+! % , 2* ",  " !$! +>! $%$+ +  "!$! %J5

8F5  8B A  6FF6.    ,"!  "" $"  " 2 /" 4444444444 $  "$  "  +  +$ +" *2$$  " D5

885  A?$  89 +$1 6FF6. "$,! ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444  66 A  6FF9 $ ( /" 4444444444  86 ,!  6FF9.

 "" $"  " #%   "! (     !  "++"$" ,"! +  - + ( "  88G:98 ,5 $ +  $") ( "  6BG8:& ,5 B:5

865 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444. +!$! + /0$ "1$ #/.

"$ !+"!  "  "$ $$, +)  1 ,!!   % C  6H ,!  6FF95

786&:78&&;

% B789%

895  J$  : ,!  6FFH.  C    ". !  A?$ $+ $ $"!   - + A?5

 C   ,,$ "!! 2* ++$$ ( *$ $". * +$.

* $   $$   #"!$!. 2 * $ + ,$ "++"$" (  !" ( - "$,!. "$ / 4444444444 $ 4444444444. $ *$ +$.  "$$ 2 "$$  $ !$! ! +  #"!$! " + /" 4444444444.  $ *-  2   +$  $ + !  "? 1 +  5

   !$! $ *",,  1  !5

8H5 $"?! + %.    +!! 2  "  "?. "+$ $  $ ,,$! + /" 4444444444 $  , 2 *,,  +"$  $ ,$!      +"!  " $.

*! $.  '   6FFH. ( &G&9H ,5 6:5

8:5  "  H  6FFH.  1  ++!   / 4444444444 $ 44444444445 -% "$  !$!  $! (  !$5

/" 4444444444  *$ + ,$!5 /" 4444444444   I. + "  8; "D$ 6FFH.  !! 2

L  8&&B.  "$$ D ( * # !$$ +! ( ;FGFFF ,5 $ A* $+  +> +"? $ $$ " , 2  $ $$  "$ + 2!$!5  / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ !"!   8&&:.  " 2 !$$  !$$ ,! (  " $"$ !! + * # $  "$$ 2 A* ! <+  BFGFFF ,5= "$  +"$!  !  +  " (  A" / 4444444444 $ 4444444444  "$ + "! +  2$ D ( * #. +2  "$$" ( * #  $  $ *$$ "$ !$! $)$ !?! N5

8B5  !+".    "?! 2*  +" $ + $$  +"$"  /" 44444444445

  +"$  !"+$  "? $$ D. !$$ +!! 2 /" 4444444444  $ "1$ )  !1$ 8&&;  ?$  +$ - ,  !?  +$  "$$" $ +! <,5 "  ' +$1 6FFH=5

8;5  !$  /" 4444444444 $    "$ !$! "2! ( $"$  +$. $ ( /" 44444444445

786&:78&&;

% ;789%

/ 4444444444 $ 4444444444 *"$ + !?5

/" 4444444444  $ ( +! 2* " $  !$! *!$1 - $1-. * +"  +!" $ 2 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 !$$ $$ $  " +"  +!"  $ <,5 "  6' +$1 6FFH=5

$ ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444.  +$?$ !?$ $  . "!$ 2  "  &G&9H ,5 6: "  !$! 2$ / 4444444444. 4444444444 $ 44444444445

 .-'

8:  " ? "  *"?$" A <=  !$! ",! $  $$!.

)  8 "D$ 6FF9.  1 $"   ". "+"!  :

A?. "$  +!$ $  %+!$. : ++!$ $ 8B A?  <$5 8 $5  $ :B =5

#$ ( *$"  *!$"  8B A? . +  1 ,!!  6; A  6FFH < C 89F  8FB=.   " ? "  "+$!.  89 ,! .  +"$" $$" ?$ +$$$  1 $"   "  !?   ( $" A? $$. .  *$$$  *!$"  " - A? 5

#$$$   "  "$ +1.  1 ,!! .   J$  8 A$ 6FFH. ",! 2  +"$" $$" "$$$  "$"  + $" $ !$$ ",".  "0$.  "$ ,!! < C 89F  66B=5

","!$ ( G$5 :B  5 8 $5  I58 .  1 $"   " "0$  $ 2  "$$$" +!  ( *$ :B  2 "$ $  (  " ,!!  *%  $   $  6F !1 8&HB5

# "+!$ +" A?   *+) $  !$15

786&:78&&;

% '789%

65  " ,!!   +$ ?!!  "$   "  B "$"1 6FFF < = $ $!  ?  8 A  6FF9 $0$  ",$"  "1 +"$" !?   "  * #% 5   *+) $ $"$," !? +  +"$"  ? A2* 98 !1 6FF6.  !?  ++ " 2  )? ++1 "$   ?  "$ "S  ,$ A2$ !$$  "$ +"$ < C 86;  HB;.

"5 8 T 868  9BB=5

655 - $  G$ '6. ! 8  )?$  G%  $   $  98 "$"1 8&H; < # $  98 !1 6FF6=.  "$    !+$" G "?  +$ "2    "+$"   ,$ + " +  !"  !+$"   ! G ! ( "+$  "$ "S    "  "? $.  $"$ . ( G-+$" G !  2  ( "+$  ,$ "?15

"$$ (  $  $$ +"$".  G?$  G" G !  +!+$" ( "! G",, <,5 C 886  '. "5 HT  8&'B +5 H&9=5 "2  "$ !  G $ +1 " +  " +! (  !  ++$"  + "? !.  ! $ ++1 <$ '6.

! 6  #=5

6515  1 ,!!   < C =  +"!  ++ 2G   "+$"  U"  "?U     +"$" +!$!. ( +$  "$ "S  "$ "0$.  > +J$$ G$$$" 2G" $  "$ G$$ G $  $$ "+$   +$2. 2  "$   +$$$ +  "   "$$".  +"$ A$,  "1?$"  !+  "? < C 88B  ;:. "5 91T 889  8'8. "5 6T 886  '. "5 H. 8:'T 8F'  :6. "5 :T  8&'9. +5 8F'=5  ,$ !$$ $ "  "$$ 2G G>  U "$ " + $ +",$.  ( $1U <,5  O U#I1$1?  V"@ . 6) !5 +5 886=.

G"S !$  +$   !   5

655    ,$ "  ""$ + 1" G$,.   G + !$ "  "?  "$ $ "S  +$ "$  $1  $1$" $  "+$ , !$1 + G,,  ,$ "  2$. " (  $ ( 2  M"$  $  !,$  15  ,,$.  2 1$  +$   ,$ "   +"! ""$ $ $ $$  $"  "?%$!J$ .  ?!!. "  +$2  $1-. !A( ,,$ "  "?.  "$ "S  ""$"  !  $ "$,!. " (  "S G!$$ 

786&:78&&;

% &789%

""$" $ G $ "$ !$! !+"! $ + $ J$ "$!5  "$% (.  ! $. "  $ J$  ?!!.    "0$ G!$$  $,.  ""$"   ! $    +"11 <,5 C 88B  8B8 "5 HT 88B  ;:. " 91 W  8&&F. +5 H8:. C 889  8'6 "5 6   !,5 W  8&';. +5 BF;=5

655 #"  A+.  "? $ !+$!   "2  "$$"   + $ + J$ +M. +"  "$, A2 "  ,$ < C 889  6:'. "5 9T  8&''. +5 89;T  8F&  &6. "5 & $  J$ $!T  8&'9. +5 H;;=5 "2  "$$" $ +>!  "  G" 1$!  G+"> <+" "=.  "? $ !+$!    "$ "S  !  "$$" "$ !" 1. G$%(%  "$ "S.  !? ( G" 1$!  G+">.  "$$"  + $ + J$ +M "  +"! " < C 886  8:;. "5 6T /  . #IXQI #"Q I?I$. " . +5 B&=5

 +"! "  ++$"  "$$" )   )? ++1     $ 8H $  $  #5 #" G$5 8:. 5 8  #.  "$$" " ! +) "$" "$ +M  ! + "  +"$. ( " 2G  +$ J$ "+!    $ !I5  "$$" "$.  )? ?!!. " ! + "   !?$ "$  !1$ " (  +"$ + "  ,$ <,5 $ 8:. ! 6  #T $5 H9 =5

"  +"$ + "  .  ! 2 G + !$! +>!

$!?$   +"$   !$" M"$  $  !,$  1 !,$, +)  % 2 $ ,"!   !$$   !$" % (  ,,!  G$  !,$  1 +" " +) . 2 $ ,"!  G$$"  G",, % +"  "$$ +>!. G$%(% +"  "$$  " !" $ <,5 $ 8H&. ! 8 T   "$ +" $$.

,$ $ ""$.  "$" A2 ".  8&':. +5 66H=5  +$   2G $  !,$  1 !,$, +)  "$ ! !  !$" +!15 .  +")% 1   $ $  !,$  1 !,$,. "2G 2 2  1 1 ,"$ $)$ !,$ <$ 88:. ! 8  $"   G$ 8H& T C 889  6:'. "5 9 =.  8&''. +5 89;T   "+5 $5 +? 8;&. 66H=5

95  *+).   *$  !   $  !,$  1 +)   $  89 !1 8&&B5 *$ (  "$%( 2*   2* 1$  "?5

786&:78&&;

% 8F789%

H5  " $"  !+$"  "? "$,!  8& " 1 8&&;.    +$!  !  +!+$" *  )  "  "? +!  ( *$ '6. 5 8  #5  "++"$" ,"!  8 !1 8&&; + / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ !$! !+"!  $+ $ <$5 '6 5 6  #=5  2J$  9F !1 8&&;  !$! +!$! +     ! !?  $$ A" ( "+$ $ "++"$".  "$ 2* $  1 (  ," <$5 '6 5 9  #=5

 C .  " J$  : ,!  6FFH.  !  A?$   "" $"  "  89 +$1 6FF6 $   ">!    1  !. ","!$ ( *$ 9 5 9   "  8H " 1 6FF6 ",$  "  *"?$" A <=5

:5 - $  G$5 :6  # <$  98 !1 6FF6=. G+"> "$ "   "? 2G  !  "$  ++$" $$"$ " + !?? ? 5    ++ 2 G$5 :6  # $  +"$" +! < 8&'& +5 88;=5

B5  *+).  "? 1 +   "$$.  "$   !"  !+$"  "?.   +$   !  "$$"  "  *" 1$!   #"!$! +"  "$$ $"$  ;6G86F ,5 ':. +!$$  "$$" +$ #%  $! +>! +  #"!$!. > "+  ,  +"$.  "$" $  $!J$ "$". +"  +!" *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H.  8&&: (   8&&B. A ( !1 8&&B $  "+!$ +" *! 8&&:5

;5  *+). " *-$$  ?$  ". /" 4444444444  !$! $$  +$1 8&&H (  8&&: $ /" 4444444444  A 8&&9 (  8&&:5   $ ) " $1$ $" -  2$!

*"?   "!$! ">.  2*  "$$$  $ + < C 'B  6;8 $ &9  66=5

'5 *!$$  !! ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 2* "  88G:98 ,5. "$  "$$" *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H $   $   8&&:5

 ++$   +$  ,$ 2 /" 4444444444  ,,$!  $ +)   . ( $ ? 2  " D *!)   '   6FFH ( &G&9H ,5 6:5

786&:78&&;

% 88789%

"2 + +" "$ ! 1  "?.   !+"$ "$ <# 8&&9 +5 86F=5  ++ +2 2  *  "+"1 " +> $"$ " +$  +!A 1 +  .  +!$$"  $$ )  !$ *$$5   $ ,,$! + /" 4444444444 "$% !$! +"$!  !$"  "$$  "? 2 $ $$  &G&9H ,5 6:5  $ ,,$! +)  '

  6FFH "$   !I!$ -  !$ <,5 $   *C #   ++$"  "$$" I,, BF8F=5

*$ ( A$ $$ 2   * $ ! ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444  1"$  "? 1 2* $$ 2* +"$   +!" $! (  8&&:. $ ( 2  "$ ! *J$ $$5

#"  !"+$ !$1 +  . /" 4444444444 *$ 2$$!   "  BBG8FF ,5  $"$. 2    ( +>  +"$!  +$ +!.

 "$ 2 $$   "$$" #. +$ +">. +" 6G696 ,5 F:.

 "$$" %IE?. +$ +">.  B:H ,5 ;:. + &6 ,5 ':

+"  , $$,. ;9F ,5 +"  $-  "$" $ BG66H ,5 BF +"  $!J$ "$". "$  $"$  &G&9H ,5 6:5

&5  "$ ) $ 2  "  6;G;H8 ,5 &F. +!$$  $  /" 4444444444 +$!   $"$  "$$" #.

+$ +">. !+ 1$  "  88G:98 ,5 "$  +$  !$$ !!   !"  8& " 1 8&&;5

8F5 #"  I,, ;F;&  $   *C #   ++$"  "$$"  * #%  $ .   +" +  "$$ "+$  "?  " * +"! +$.  +")  " "$ $"  !1$ "  $  "1A$ $ " $ J$ >!  E5 #  $$ $ +$$ 1"!.  +")  $  "1A$ +"  "$$ +>!5

885    ,"  $$ $  +" "! 2 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 $$ "$ +"1 +"  "  "?. "$ +" &G&9H ,5 6:5 +$. $$ $   ,$  *$ 2 +  $  *$5 8H; 5 8 5   $$.   ).

  "S  $$ "$ $ +" +"1 "    *$5 :6  # +"  "$$ ,,!$5  * ) 2* *+).    !$ + ( / 4444444444. 4444444444 $ 4444444444  +$  J "$$.  ( A$ $$. +2  $ +$, *$$  +"$$ +   J +!"5

786&:78&&;

% 86789%

. "  A+  1 ,!!.  *>  "$! 2 A2*( "  "$$ " - D +  !1$. "2 * *- $ $    ! * +$$" 2 !+ *"1?$" " < C 8FB  6:H. $   # K. Y$ # K  $    . $ ?!!  "$  "1?$". " . 6) !5 +5 6F&.

Z 6HFB $ 6HF;=5  $ "$"   $     "!$  *J$  C  : ,!  6FFH. " 2  "$ *!$$ +2!      "? 1 +   2 +"  +$  %5

865  >    ++ 2 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ !$!

II! +   +" !+  "? !$$  "%+$  "$$"  +" "$"1 ( !1 8&&H $  $   8&&:5  !$ *  !  "+$  8B "$"1 8&&B !$1 +   2  "$$ D *! $. $"$ "+. ( &G&:8 ,5 9: +"  " *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H5  - !" $!  8   $ 8  8&&:.    $ !! (  #"!$!  +$  "$$  9GHB9 ,5 B: +" I  "   $   8&&:5  2 "  $"$  8BG';' ,5 BF $! +>!5

895 "!$ 2  $ ,,$! + /" 4444444444  $  ++ J$ !+$  +"$!   +  !  2   +$ +!.  ++0$.   " ( +"! (   + +!. 2  "$$ D  " $$ + / 44444444444 $ 4444444444 * +$. 2 + /" 4444444444 *$ +$. $ ?$ !+! +  $ ,,$! +  . (  " BBG8FF ,5  $"$5

C" ) " $  "$$ 2  2J$   !  "++"$" ,"! + / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 $    "1A$  "$, 2  "? 1 +  . $     2  !$$ +2!.  !$! !+!5

786&:78&&;

% 89789%

  .'-4  '- , '.  , .-



3;   <  =   >3 "2# .

  ; 

85 !     !  "++"$" ,"! + / 4444444444 $ 4444444444  15

 ;

65 "$$ 2* $    "1A$5

95 "   (  ( I  !,  "  'FF ,5. ( $$  +$+$" (  , $ !+

H5 ,"  +$   2G + $ ," " "$  +!$ J$   !  9F A" )  "$,$" + + "! !  1 ,!!  . #IXQI",2 B. BFFH   .  $" -+5  !  +$ J$ +""?!5  !" "$ O = 2 -$$ 2 !"  "$ ! "1$   $ +   !" $$2!T 1= -+" +" 2 "$,  $ +" "  $$ $ !"T = +"$  ?$ "   " +!$$5 #  !"  "$$ +  $" !!$ !!! " $$ = 1= $ = %.  1 ,!!    +" + $  $)   " 2G   !  15  !"  " $" "  ">  + . 2 "$ A"$.  2  !" $$2! $ G "++  2   !$! -+!!  "$ <$5 896. 8FB $ 8F' =5

 ?,,) O  !$ O

/%"  [ " Y   

 "+ ","  +!$ J$ $ "$,! - +$  2G( G,, ,!!   " +  ?,,

786&:78&&;