Contract Enforceability Based on Mutual Intent Over Formalities
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case concerns a dispute over the enforceability of a document, where the proponent asserted it was a valid contract despite missing required formal elements, while the opponent argued it was invalid due to those omissions. The court reasoned that the document contained sufficient evidence of a mutual intent to be bound and contained all essential terms of the agreement, therefore satisfying the fundamental requirements of a contract, even if it technically lacked specific statutory formalities. The court concluded that adhering strictly to the formality requirement would lead to an unjust outcome contrary to the parties' clear understanding, thus upholding the agreement's validity based on substance over form.
Regeste Legislator
Officiel; AVS ; ASSURANCE-VIEILLESSE, SURVIVANTS ET INVALIDITÉ ; RESPONSABILITÉ FONDÉE SUR LE DROIT PUBLIC ; RESPONSABILITÉ DE L'EMPLOYEUR(AVS) ; COTISATION AVS/AI/APG ; RESPONSABILITÉ SOLIDAIRE | LAVS.52; CO.147.1
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay court costs.
Texte complet
!"#$%!"$$& '!(%$!#))*
+'
, '- , '. , .-
"/ 0 1 #2 31 #))*
- -'.4-. 5 4 '-. '- . ! 647- 8 "! #$% &' ( ) *"++"$"
"$
9999999999 !, -%$$ 9999999999. "+$ $" - + /0$ "!$! "1$ #/ * $ 2 !$ " 34444444444 #
9999999999 ++!
9999999999 / 5 4444444444
9999999999 "%$!!
% 6789%
4-'
85 "!$! 34444444444 # <%+) #"!$!=. >$ +" 1$ *"?$" ,$$". +""$". +1$!. @$?. !$" $ +$$" *> ++"$$. !$! !! A 8&&9 ( ) . $ !$! ,,! + $$ $ ( $+"," # ,!!$" $+ " <%+) =5
65 6: A$ 8&&B. #"!$! +$ !$! - + C!!$" >$ +$"-. "$ 2 . $ ; "D$ 8&&B. * ,"! 2 $$ -" +2$ +$ " ,,$"5
>$ ! #"!$! !+E$ * +$ +!. % *$ 2$$! 6F !1 " BG88;,5 ;F. +!$$ +$ +! "$$" " 5
95 89 !1 8&&B. *$ ! $ !,$ 1 +) 5
8& " 1 8&&;. ! ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444.
+$ $ $$%+!$ $ $$. !" !+$" "?. +" "$$ ;6G86F ,5 ':. "$ +" "$$" *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H. 8&&: ( 8&&B. A ( !1 8&&B $ "+!$ 8&&:5
!! ( /" 4444444444. $$ 8&&: ( A 8&&B. $$ * ?$ "$ ( -. +$ " 9FG'6: ,5 6:. ( $$ !+$" "? 1 " "%+$ "$$" + #"!$! *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H $ ( !1 8&&:5
!?$ "$,! !" !+$" "? ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444. $" - $$. 1!!, * ?$ "$ ( -. + +$1 8&&H ( 8&&:. " A 8&&9 ( 8&&:. +" " 88G:98 ,5 "+"$ - "$$" $! +>! *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H $ $ 8&&:5
H5 /" 4444444444 ,"! "++"$" ' !1 8&&; "$ !" ( "$,!5 +!! 2 " $ $ + , H !1 8&&:5
786&:78&&;
% 9789%
+ "$. $,! !" $ !$ +!$$" ( 6'G:H8 ,5;:.
+ ( 6BG8:& ,5 B: " " 66 " 1 8&&&5
:5 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ !?$ ,"! "++"$". $ 8 !1 8&&;5 -+2$ 2* "$ !$! !I?! $ " 8&&: <C B A 8&&:=5 )?$ * " !$! ,"! +"$ 2* !1 8&&; $ !$ " +>! +"$!$ +$ +! *! $ ( BG88; ,5 ;F5
B5 !+"! +) "" $" " #% 2J$ $ ( ! $ "++"$" 9F !1 8&&;5
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
"" / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ " ( " 8BG:'' ,5 ;F. " 2 > ! $ ,,$!. "$O C5 BG88;.;F 6F !1 8&&B C5 8GFFF.%% 88 ,! 8&&; <+$ + #"!$!= C5 9GFFF.%% 8B 8&&; <$"= C5 9GFFF.%% 88 A$ 8&&; <$"= C5 9GFFF.%% 6; "D$ 8&&; <$"= C5 :;6.;F 8; +$1 8&&;
"$ C5 8BGB:F.HF
786&:78&&;
% H789%
/ 4444444444 $ 4444444444 $$ " ! $"+ +>! B8 ,5 ;F <8BGB:F ,5 HF P 8BG:'' ,5 ;F=5 ")$ +" + 2 $!J$ $ $ , !1$! "$ + <" 69 A 8&&'=5
"+)$$ !$ 6B A +$ + $$ $"$ "$$" +$ +" *! 8&&H. "$ HHGH&F ,5 ::. 2 $ ( +$ J +!". "$ H;G9B' ,5 B:5
/" 4444444444 *$ + ,$!5
'5 !+2 8 "$"1 6FF8. ) 2 #"!$! !$$ "! + % " ' IQ #C ! " ,$!
, # . "$ , / 4444444444 $ 44444444445 ",! $$ "$" +" 88 K%$ " +$" C# 6& +$1 8&&H5 ) ( $ !? 2 +2 #"!$! *!$$ + "! +) ,. / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 $ + $$ " $ $ +!!$ *J$ ?$ %(% #"!$!5 +! ,M" "$ "$$" "$ !$! ! 2 +!" "!5
"". +"I ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 * "
L + $+ !??! ! "$$ $$$. 2. "2 *$$$$" +>! $ *! 8&&H. M $ $. !$1 8F 8&&:. ">! + ,- 8' 8&&:. + *"? + " M 6H 8&&:. "$ A$ "$ !+$. ?!!! "+!$ "$$" +"$$5 "$ + 2!$! ( "$%( 2 $$ D +) "$ 5 "+!$ !$! ,$! !$$ ) !+$" ,-.
"$ 69 8&&:5 "$ !+$ $$ " D $$ *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H. "+!$ *! 8&&H $ "$$" $ 8&&:5 <R= "$$" ,$ " + / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 $ -$5 <R= !$ $" $ ,,$! + "!$! +) !+$ "$$ "$$" $ 2* "$ !. 2 $ -$5 "!$! ( $ !"$" +! "$! + +$5 # /" 4444444444. "+$ $ " +"$! +$ $ +!5 ",$" *?$ +!$ ,$5 "+$ "$ " !$! $$1! +$ "$$" ,$ *"1A$ !"$" +! + +!" + . "$ +!" A ( 8&&H ,$! 8 ,! 8&&B > "+ , " * . "+!$
786&:78&&;
% :789%
A ( !1 8&&H > "+ , " * 5 , +"$ " $ J$ " $ +5 * $ + $$1! +"$! "+$ +$ $ +!5 #" /" 4444444444 " " D + ,,$ $ - $ 9GFFF ,5 +$! +!" *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H +" " /" 4444444444 +$ +!5
/ 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$$ 2 "$ $ D +$ "$$ "$$" 2* $ !!. +$ +$ ,,$! + /" 4444444444 +" "!$!. % J $ ( !+$" "? +" ;6G8F8 ,5 ': "$ "++"$ A2*( " "$$ D + 5 #" A+. $ "$ *+$ "+$ ! + $ "? +$ "$$ $"$ "? +" 2 "$ "$ + $ "$ < J$ C " +1! ; A 6FF8=5 "$ + J$ "," *"1?$" +!"2 "$$" "$ "!$! !$$ !1$ $ *"1?$" !+ "? ! *-!$" $$ ) "$ / 4444444444. 4444444444. 4444444444. 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ $ "$ N5
&5 6B "$"1 6FF8. /0$ "1$ #/ ,"! ?,, "" $" " 2* +!$$ "! $ / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 !, $!J$5
/0$ #/ "$$ 2* *-$ + +"$ "$ "!$!5 "I$$ ) " 2 "$ $+! % , 2* ", " !$! +>! $%$+ + "!$! %J5
8F5 8B A 6FF6. ,"! "" $" " 2 /" 4444444444 $ "$ " + +$ +" *2$$ " D5
885 A?$ 89 +$1 6FF6. "$,! ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 66 A 6FF9 $ ( /" 4444444444 86 ,! 6FF9.
"" $" " #% "! ( ! "++"$" ,"! + - + ( " 88G:98 ,5 $ + $") ( " 6BG8:& ,5 B:5
865 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444. +!$! + /0$ "1$ #/.
"$ !+"! " "$ $$, +) 1 ,!! % C 6H ,! 6FF95
786&:78&&;
% B789%
895 J$ : ,! 6FFH. C ". ! A?$ $+ $ $"! - + A?5
C ,,$ "!! 2* ++$$ ( *$ $". * +$.
* $ $$ #"!$!. 2 * $ + ,$ "++"$" ( !" ( - "$,!. "$ / 4444444444 $ 4444444444. $ *$ +$. "$$ 2 "$$ $ !$! ! + #"!$! " + /" 4444444444. $ *- 2 +$ $ + ! "? 1 + 5
!$! $ *",, 1 !5
8H5 $"?! + %. +!! 2 " "?. "+$ $ $ ,,$! + /" 4444444444 $ , 2 *,, +"$ $ ,$! +"! " $.
*! $. ' 6FFH. ( &G&9H ,5 6:5
8:5 " H 6FFH. 1 ++! / 4444444444 $ 44444444445 -% "$ !$! $! ( !$5
/" 4444444444 *$ + ,$!5 /" 4444444444 I. + " 8; "D$ 6FFH. !! 2
L 8&&B. "$$ D ( * # !$$ +! ( ;FGFFF ,5 $ A* $+ +> +"? $ $$ " , 2 $ $$ "$ + 2!$!5 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ !"! 8&&:. " 2 !$$ !$$ ,! ( " $"$ !! + * # $ "$$ 2 A* ! <+ BFGFFF ,5= "$ +"$! ! + " ( A" / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ + "! + 2$ D ( * #. +2 "$$" ( * # $ $ *$$ "$ !$! $)$ !?! N5
8B5 !+". "?! 2* +" $ + $$ +"$" /" 44444444445
+"$ !"+$ "? $$ D. !$$ +!! 2 /" 4444444444 $ "1$ ) !1$ 8&&; ?$ +$ - , !? +$ "$$" $ +! <,5 " ' +$1 6FFH=5
8;5 !$ /" 4444444444 $ "$ !$! "2! ( $"$ +$. $ ( /" 44444444445
786&:78&&;
% ;789%
/ 4444444444 $ 4444444444 *"$ + !?5
/" 4444444444 $ ( +! 2* " $ !$! *!$1 - $1-. * +" +!" $ 2 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 !$$ $$ $ " +" +!" $ <,5 " 6' +$1 6FFH=5
$ ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444. +$?$ !?$ $ . "!$ 2 " &G&9H ,5 6: " !$! 2$ / 4444444444. 4444444444 $ 44444444445
.-'
8: " ? " *"?$" A <= !$! ",! $ $$!.
) 8 "D$ 6FF9. 1 $" ". "+"! :
A?. "$ +!$ $ %+!$. : ++!$ $ 8B A? <$5 8 $5 $ :B =5
#$ ( *$" *!$" 8B A? . + 1 ,!! 6; A 6FFH < C 89F 8FB=. " ? " "+$!. 89 ,! . +"$" $$" ?$ +$$$ 1 $" " !? ( $" A? $$. . *$$$ *!$" " - A? 5
#$$$ " "$ +1. 1 ,!! . J$ 8 A$ 6FFH. ",! 2 +"$" $$" "$$$ "$" + $" $ !$$ ",". "0$. "$ ,!! < C 89F 66B=5
","!$ ( G$5 :B 5 8 $5 I58 . 1 $" " "0$ $ 2 "$$$" +! ( *$ :B 2 "$ $ ( " ,!! *% $ $ 6F !1 8&HB5
# "+!$ +" A? *+) $ !$15
786&:78&&;
% '789%
65 " ,!! +$ ?!! "$ " B "$"1 6FFF < = $ $! ? 8 A 6FF9 $0$ ",$" "1 +"$" !? " * #% 5 *+) $ $"$," !? + +"$" ? A2* 98 !1 6FF6. !? ++ " 2 )? ++1 "$ ? "$ "S ,$ A2$ !$$ "$ +"$ < C 86; HB;.
"5 8 T 868 9BB=5
655 - $ G$ '6. ! 8 )?$ G% $ $ 98 "$"1 8&H; < # $ 98 !1 6FF6=. "$ !+$" G "? +$ "2 "+$" ,$ + " + !" !+$" ! G ! ( "+$ "$ "S " "? $. $"$ . ( G-+$" G ! 2 ( "+$ ,$ "?15
"$$ ( $ $$ +"$". G?$ G" G ! +!+$" ( "! G",, <,5 C 886 '. "5 HT 8&'B +5 H&9=5 "2 "$ ! G $ +1 " + " +! ( ! ++$" + "? !. ! $ ++1 <$ '6.
! 6 #=5
6515 1 ,!! < C = +"! ++ 2G "+$" U" "?U +"$" +!$!. ( +$ "$ "S "$ "0$. > +J$$ G$$$" 2G" $ "$ G$$ G $ $$ "+$ +$2. 2 "$ +$$$ + " "$$". +"$ A$, "1?$" !+ "? < C 88B ;:. "5 91T 889 8'8. "5 6T 886 '. "5 H. 8:'T 8F' :6. "5 :T 8&'9. +5 8F'=5 ,$ !$$ $ " "$$ 2G G> U "$ " + $ +",$. ( $1U <,5 O U#I1$1? V"@ . 6) !5 +5 886=.
G"S !$ +$ ! 5
655 ,$ " ""$ + 1" G$,. G + !$ " "? "$ $ "S +$ "$ $1 $1$" $ "+$ , !$1 + G,, ,$ " 2$. " ( $ ( 2 M"$ $ !,$ 15 ,,$. 2 1$ +$ ,$ " +"! ""$ $ $ $$ $" "?%$!J$ . ?!!. " +$2 $1-. !A( ,,$ " "?. "$ "S ""$" ! $ "$,!. " ( "S G!$$
786&:78&&;
% &789%
""$" $ G $ "$ !$! !+"! $ + $ J$ "$!5 "$% (. ! $. " $ J$ ?!!. "0$ G!$$ $,. ""$" ! $ +"11 <,5 C 88B 8B8 "5 HT 88B ;:. " 91 W 8&&F. +5 H8:. C 889 8'6 "5 6 !,5 W 8&';. +5 BF;=5
655 #" A+. "? $ !+$! "2 "$$" + $ + J$ +M. +" "$, A2 " ,$ < C 889 6:'. "5 9T 8&''. +5 89;T 8F& &6. "5 & $ J$ $!T 8&'9. +5 H;;=5 "2 "$$" $ +>! " G" 1$! G+"> <+" "=. "? $ !+$! "$ "S ! "$$" "$ !" 1. G$%(% "$ "S. !? ( G" 1$! G+">. "$$" + $ + J$ +M " +"! " < C 886 8:;. "5 6T / . #IXQI #"Q I?I$. " . +5 B&=5
+"! " ++$" "$$" ) )? ++1 $ 8H $ $ #5 #" G$5 8:. 5 8 #. "$$" " ! +) "$" "$ +M ! + " +"$. ( " 2G +$ J$ "+! $ !I5 "$$" "$. )? ?!!. " ! + " !?$ "$ !1$ " ( +"$ + " ,$ <,5 $ 8:. ! 6 #T $5 H9 =5
" +"$ + " . ! 2 G + !$! +>!
$!?$ +"$ !$" M"$ $ !,$ 1 !,$, +) % 2 $ ,"! !$$ !$" % ( ,,! G$ !,$ 1 +" " +) . 2 $ ,"! G$$" G",, % +" "$$ +>!. G$%(% +" "$$ " !" $ <,5 $ 8H&. ! 8 T "$ +" $$.
,$ $ ""$. "$" A2 ". 8&':. +5 66H=5 +$ 2G $ !,$ 1 !,$, +) "$ ! ! !$" +!15 . +")% 1 $ $ !,$ 1 !,$,. "2G 2 2 1 1 ,"$ $)$ !,$ <$ 88:. ! 8 $" G$ 8H& T C 889 6:'. "5 9 =. 8&''. +5 89;T "+5 $5 +? 8;&. 66H=5
95 *+). *$ ! $ !,$ 1 +) $ 89 !1 8&&B5 *$ ( "$%( 2* 2* 1$ "?5
786&:78&&;
% 8F789%
H5 " $" !+$" "? "$,! 8& " 1 8&&;. +$! ! +!+$" * ) " "? +! ( *$ '6. 5 8 #5 "++"$" ,"! 8 !1 8&&; + / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ !$! !+"! $+ $ <$5 '6 5 6 #=5 2J$ 9F !1 8&&; !$! +!$! + ! !? $$ A" ( "+$ $ "++"$". "$ 2* $ 1 ( ," <$5 '6 5 9 #=5
C . " J$ : ,! 6FFH. ! A?$ "" $" " 89 +$1 6FF6 $ ">! 1 !. ","!$ ( *$ 9 5 9 " 8H " 1 6FF6 ",$ " *"?$" A <=5
:5 - $ G$5 :6 # <$ 98 !1 6FF6=. G+"> "$ " "? 2G ! "$ ++$" $$"$ " + !?? ? 5 ++ 2 G$5 :6 # $ +"$" +! < 8&'& +5 88;=5
B5 *+). "? 1 + "$$. "$ !" !+$" "?. +$ ! "$$" " *" 1$! #"!$! +" "$$ $"$ ;6G86F ,5 ':. +!$$ "$$" +$ #% $! +>! + #"!$!. > "+ , +"$. "$" $ $!J$ "$". +" +!" *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H. 8&&: ( 8&&B. A ( !1 8&&B $ "+!$ +" *! 8&&:5
;5 *+). " *-$$ ?$ ". /" 4444444444 !$! $$ +$1 8&&H ( 8&&: $ /" 4444444444 A 8&&9 ( 8&&:5 $ ) " $1$ $" - 2$!
*"? "!$! ">. 2* "$$$ $ + < C 'B 6;8 $ &9 66=5
'5 *!$$ !! ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 2* " 88G:98 ,5. "$ "$$" *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H $ $ 8&&:5
++$ +$ ,$ 2 /" 4444444444 ,,$! $ +) . ( $ ? 2 " D *!) ' 6FFH ( &G&9H ,5 6:5
786&:78&&;
% 88789%
"2 + +" "$ ! 1 "?. !+"$ "$ <# 8&&9 +5 86F=5 ++ +2 2 * "+"1 " +> $"$ " +$ +!A 1 + . +!$$" $$ ) !$ *$$5 $ ,,$! + /" 4444444444 "$% !$! +"$! !$" "$$ "? 2 $ $$ &G&9H ,5 6:5 $ ,,$! +) '
6FFH "$ !I!$ - !$ <,5 $ *C # ++$" "$$" I,, BF8F=5
*$ ( A$ $$ 2 * $ ! ( / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 1"$ "? 1 2* $$ 2* +"$ +!" $! ( 8&&:. $ ( 2 "$ ! *J$ $$5
#" !"+$ !$1 + . /" 4444444444 *$ 2$$! " BBG8FF ,5 $"$. 2 ( +> +"$! +$ +!.
"$ 2 $$ "$$" #. +$ +">. +" 6G696 ,5 F:.
"$$" %IE?. +$ +">. B:H ,5 ;:. + &6 ,5 ':
+" , $$,. ;9F ,5 +" $- "$" $ BG66H ,5 BF +" $!J$ "$". "$ $"$ &G&9H ,5 6:5
&5 "$ ) $ 2 " 6;G;H8 ,5 &F. +!$$ $ /" 4444444444 +$! $"$ "$$" #.
+$ +">. !+ 1$ " 88G:98 ,5 "$ +$ !$$ !! !" 8& " 1 8&&;5
8F5 #" I,, ;F;& $ *C # ++$" "$$" * #% $ . +" + "$$ "+$ "? " * +"! +$. +") " "$ $" !1$ " $ "1A$ $ " $ J$ >! E5 # $$ $ +$$ 1"!. +") $ "1A$ +" "$$ +>!5
885 ," $$ $ +" "! 2 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 $$ "$ +"1 +" " "?. "$ +" &G&9H ,5 6:5 +$. $$ $ ,$ *$ 2 + $ *$5 8H; 5 8 5 $$. ).
"S $$ "$ $ +" +"1 " *$5 :6 # +" "$$ ,,!$5 * ) 2* *+). !$ + ( / 4444444444. 4444444444 $ 4444444444 +$ J "$$. ( A$ $$. +2 $ +$, *$$ +"$$ + J +!"5
786&:78&&;
% 86789%
. " A+ 1 ,!!. *> "$! 2 A2*( " "$$ " - D + !1$. "2 * *- $ $ ! * +$$" 2 !+ *"1?$" " < C 8FB 6:H. $ # K. Y$ # K $ . $ ?!! "$ "1?$". " . 6) !5 +5 6F&.
Z 6HFB $ 6HF;=5 $ "$" $ "!$ *J$ C : ,! 6FFH. " 2 "$ *!$$ +2! "? 1 + 2 +" +$ %5
865 > ++ 2 / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 "$ !$!
II! + +" !+ "? !$$ "%+$ "$$" +" "$"1 ( !1 8&&H $ $ 8&&:5 !$ * ! "+$ 8B "$"1 8&&B !$1 + 2 "$$ D *! $. $"$ "+. ( &G&:8 ,5 9: +" " *"$"1 ( !1 8&&H5 - !" $! 8 $ 8 8&&:. $ !! ( #"!$! +$ "$$ 9GHB9 ,5 B: +" I " $ 8&&:5 2 " $"$ 8BG';' ,5 BF $! +>!5
895 "!$ 2 $ ,,$! + /" 4444444444 $ ++ J$ !+$ +"$! + ! 2 +$ +!. ++0$. " ( +"! ( + +!. 2 "$$ D " $$ + / 44444444444 $ 4444444444 * +$. 2 + /" 4444444444 *$ +$. $ ?$ !+! + $ ,,$! + . ( " BBG8FF ,5 $"$5
C" ) " $ "$$ 2 2J$ ! "++"$" ,"! + / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 $ "1A$ "$, 2 "? 1 + . $ 2 !$$ +2!. !$! !+!5
786&:78&&;
% 89789%
.'-4 '- , '. , .-
3; < = >3 "2# .
;
85 ! ! "++"$" ,"! + / 4444444444 $ 4444444444 15
;
65 "$$ 2* $ "1A$5
95 " ( ( I !, " 'FF ,5. ( $$ +$+$" ( , $ !+
H5 ," +$ 2G + $ ," " "$ +!$ J$ ! 9F A" ) "$,$" + + "! ! 1 ,!! . #IXQI",2 B. BFFH . $" -+5 ! +$ J$ +""?!5 !" "$ O = 2 -$$ 2 !" "$ ! "1$ $ + !" $$2!T 1= -+" +" 2 "$, $ +" " $$ $ !"T = +"$ ?$ " " +!$$5 # !" "$$ + $" !!$ !!! " $$ = 1= $ = %. 1 ,!! +" + $ $) " 2G ! 15 !" " $" " "> + . 2 "$ A"$. 2 !" $$2! $ G "++ 2 !$! -+!! "$ <$5 896. 8FB $ 8F' =5
?,,) O !$ O
/%" [ " Y
"+ "," +!$ J$ $ "$,! - +$ 2G( G,, ,!! " + ?,,
786&:78&&;