Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/847/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/847/2007 Généré par l'IA

Preclusive Effect of Prior Judgments

Numéro de cause ATAS/847/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court considered several assertions regarding the validity of prior judgments, specifically addressing challenges to the jurisdiction and binding effect of earlier rulings concerning the present parties and issues. The court reasoned that the prior judgments, relating to the same underlying subject matter and involving the same parties or their privies, were final and conclusive as to the matters determined therein, thus establishing the applicable law through the doctrines of claim and issue preclusion. Therefore, the court affirmed the rulings that upheld the preclusive effect of the antecedent determinations, binding the litigants to the established legal conclusions.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Preclusive Effect of Prior Judgments: The court reasoned that the prior judgments, relating to the same underlying subject matter and involving the same parties or their privies, were final and conclusive as to the matters determined therein, thus establishing the applicable law through the doctrines of claim and issue preclusion. Therefore, the court affirmed the rulings that upheld the preclusive effect of the antecedent determinations, binding the litigants to the established legal conclusions.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
effets des arrêts en appréciation de validité effets des arrêts préjudiciels fixation de compétence présomption notion de décision validité de la détention provisoire

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/1066/2006
Finality of Prior Judgments in Subsequent Litigation
A/3497/2006
Effect of Prior Judgments on Current Liabilities
A/4391/2005
Application of Res Judicata to Prior Judgments
A/2135/2005
Appellant's Liability and Issue Preclusion on Prior Finding Validity
A/2046/2003
Issue Preclusion in Prior Litigation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

            !!"#$$%  !&%#$$%



'( () ) ) ' () 

*+  ,  - ./ #$$% 



 !"  # $!%& !  '"&  !("&  )&#  * 

 ! !"  

&

+   $ +  "/    , * &  &# ( '-. 

      

                   

  406  

) 0

17 89!& 12'!:455;(// (&&'    <&9= %" '%&!&!& !"1.33 &   "  1.34 > ("&& !"  &  ?1 "!: 1.2?7 *& @  89!&  '  %& &  '& &A&& %&9A@& >B

A!%&"%9&&"! %C + & %"'D%/     & "&"E ++ C'%!&&E&&@ &  '<120110455;= &%%"&"%!&" F E#"%E!&"A<%-:& 3  ! =7

47 1;!4556 : " (>G&   E>& & %&9  ' 7  !  >  89!&  ' 12'!:455; > "&& %&9&  &   E"&  * / >  %&9  ' % G& E"&"7  (%%   !    % &  !& &  & >  '  %"'D ("'&  12 '!: 455; @ 144(22; /7  !   "9!& % &  % &/" /!  89!&  ''& &>(9 && %&9  1 H& 455- '  & &7   /& ' >   (&  ( % & @ (  %:  >  89!&  "&" &/" @ &&%&:& /!>((&/&'& " & >( & &"  /  %& D& ""  @ && &&&  " ( 7

?7 &9" %  :  "  +     I$  +   , *  ** I I*  J* /!" %   14 8& 4556 >  !&& %&9: ("'& @ 144(22;/712'!:455;7

;7    . 8& 4556  &&&& 9 !& 9" %  ! "&"% &&/&>((%%%@ 89!&  '%&9&%&9 !&& >"7

-7 *"&"9 "@897

) '

17 (&74- /" ":%9 %"'D%/ '''&&' &" 16 "!:1..?<+=&"'9 18'4555C9%"   '7>8&&

    0122304556 ?06  

% K %&& &@%&9<&7144&14?   '# = 89   '!%"&& (&76?71 /" " %"'D %/  4- 8 1.24 <= & @ C'  : &  %1H&455? &%C>(//  "&"&!<&71;4 =E"& (//%&9:  "  "%&& "&!"%89  '7

47 *(&744+<'&'9 %18'4555=  '  %&&  & > &  !9 & %&9" /!"!& E&714414?1;1&1;4 L&7?@- +(%%>& %9!&&@&/"<71=7F>8&%&&  &@%&9% @ //"&%&& &9!&"  '  : %9 E&& "'&!&  !!&  ' &  %&& &9!&" ' :%9E&&"'&!& !!&  !9</7&74;+=78& @  %&&  & & @ ('  : %9 E&&  !!&     !9  &"G&   !!&  ' < + 142  4?5L +14.;;;=7

?7 (% (: >& (E>& 89!&  ' >"&" %&:%&97

=*(9&  89!&"&9'& "/"@   /" "   & && %'" 12 ! 1.26 <=7 *  &74- ""&9C&*B 7   !%"&  &&" 8    !&&'  (&&  > ""&" "&& "L :7   " (& % %&:        & "/&'L 7((D% !&/ / (&746>%">  ( " "&9C & G& /"   & !/&!&!%&:'( %:7

 ( " &"9!&G&/"%&"&:&B 7 >(("&"&""9C!& &  !  & " F:&!>((&%" "/  / "' :7 >  "  "&"    '&  %% / !&E && @  %&   &  %"  &!!& >  &%&(%%:&" /'!D

    0122304556 ;06  

7 >(&9&!G!%&&!G!:8& "8@"&"& & *D "8@"&"89">(%"" !!&"&"89" "&& &%&&>&& C "!% &  7

(&7 4.  "/&  %"     " "&9C !!&B A >G&     E"&   " @ (&&" !%"&&  & M  " "&9C & '>"7   !%9"B 7 (E%" &!%C&&&F&>  " :7 ( &&&& &&& >  " (& % %&:   >(& "/&'& 7  89!&% "/& ( !&//"&:&>  "/&  "&" &" "9C!& & >(    %:&"  /'!D

>( " "&9C & '>" @ && %": (&&"  %& &&#!G!<&74.7?=7

:=  %%&&   :  "  && @ && %"8    * 89!&  ' 12'!: 455;% (// (&& '    7  : /" "   < + =  /!">(%8 &%&/9 /&""'" % (&7 4. 7 ?  & && #!G! @ && %"8    *  '%"@("&9< +3*7;?20455; 2 8455-L/7"9!&*4554%7?.6=7

 '&   '"/ >    89!& "&9 & !%&:'( %:<&74671=7 &%( "&& & @  %& !%"&'  &  <% E!% ( 'D&  %&9  %&& @  & %&" @   ' N*455;%7;1?O=7

;7  K%C  %& & '  %&9 % !&"   '  ! 7  '&  %  "%E & &/" '& & & /! &&(%%: (G&!%"&"7 %&   !   (%% @    89!& %&97 / (&&&  %"'D "  /!"  &C ":  %&97  ">&  D    )&  89!&  ' & (E"&%&97

    0122304556 -06  

-7 *  !& % &  %&& > % &  !9 %  !  ("C' @ +7 144(22;7#7   !  & @  E#"%  !&& +731(;;47#7

37 /!"!& @  8%  %  8 "&!& %  %&9 8>(!!& &/& %&& &  !8& '":""/ &&%&& &@ &"G&!%& !&& #7 &"G&&"&E!!!"9(&714 ( %"'D%/'''&&' &"  12 ' 1.2; < 4=    &E "9!&  # & %" < +%:"?3054 128&455?=7

67  !  "&& !"  &9  % @ %"&  >&  '!&&>& H%&G&'"%C &(G& !%& %"'D7

/!"!& @ (     : &  % <  L &7 2 & E =  & %%!&  C9!&   1;52061 & -6;064 > (%%>& @  "&"    @  %"'D %/ :9&7  %% / !&E  >  & / " # ("9&"  &&!&&(E%&& %&&&!!&#%&% %:C! %& %>   (& % !& & >(  &&  %& !%&  %!&  &    && 7  '!&%C %&& :%9  "%& "/&/  *<&7-71&7+=:&'F>>&&7

 //&  C9!&  P 1;52061 & &  '!&  %C > (">>&&*&8&&@(:9& (&&!!:  (   (  <&7 15 7 4=7   "& >  %& :9&   %&&  & & G& "%"   %    !%&  : %97

 && & &"  '9  1 8 4556 @ ("F" ( " && >@!%& (&"'9 (  7 &>(&  &  "%& "/&/> "&!"9!&&%%:'!&7 *  % " (& % 8&& @ ( :9& ( && !!: (<%' &G&%%&"%(&""=%&& & &" @  / (>& ( 9!&  D  &8  %:&" ('!&%C7

"!'!&%C %&:9& %&& : %9& !@ : &>("&>&&" "/&'!&  * & >(  & % 8&& @ ( % :9& ( && !!:  (   ( 7 !! && %' "9&'  %'  #

    0122304556 306  

8&&!&@(% (&& ( ( & //@ %%&7 "&&(&@(E#"  "!& /Q'!::>( (& % 8&&  % &  &&&& (8&&!&   # 8&&!& "! % (&&" !%"&&  (&& M  (& "&: </7 &   %"'D %/ P .3 "! % (// /" "  12 "!:4553=7

 (%C  &  9&  (// &   %%& >  !   >&&"  *  &  ?1 8& 1..2 "8@7 * "%& "&& &"184556 &@>&& "& (  & &"'9(%% @>!&&>& H& '"%C7

27  "!!&   %Q  %"  "&& 9&& <&7 6? 7 4  & 2.R71 %"  !&&' 14%&!:1.2-=7



    0122304556 606  

  1 0  () ) ) ' () 

17 '&  +     I$  +         *  ** I I*  J*@&/"  !%& !! +731(;;47#@   /'   !   >  &"G& !%&    "& C1.'!:455;8>(!!& &/&7

47 KD !&&> :7

?7 &>%" &9&&7

;7 /!  %&   >K %'& /!  &  %"& G&   "  ?5 8 C  &/& %C  : /" " <*FSTF/>3355;  =%' !&C  & %:/!"!&E&724 /" " :/" " 16 8 455- < +=L  !"!   &  >   !&/ & !D %'&%&9& & ! &L & G&  "  : /" " % ' %&  % ' "&> E  &  (&7 ;4  +7  %"& G& &  %C  %  &'>"!!!D %' '&G&8&@('7 9//C  " &B         ++ U*  U 

%/! %"&G&&&/"E%&>K@K///" " %9//

    0122304556